Suzanne Grae Corporation Pty Ltd v Design West Mode Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Suzanne Grae Corporation Pty Ltd to registration of trade mark application 1832728 (25, 35) - SUZANNE BETRO - filed in the name of Design West Mode Pty Ltd and Suzanne Betro.

Delegate: M. Cooper
Representation: Opponent: Ian Horak of counsel instructed by Dentons
Applicant: Julian Zmood of counsel instructed by Eakin McCaffrey Cox
Decision: 2019 ATMO 92
Trade Marks Act 1995
Opposition to registration under s 52: ss 42(b), 44 and 60 considered – no opposition grounds established – trade mark to proceed to registration.

Background

  1. This matter concerns an opposition by Suzanne Grae Corporation Pty. Ltd. (“the Opponent”), under s.52 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (“the Act”), to registration of the trade mark detailed below in the name of Design West Mode Pty. Ltd. and Suzanne Betro (“the Applicants”):

    Application Number: 1832728

    Trade Mark: SUZANNE BETRO

    (“the Trade Mark”)

    Filing Date: 20 March 2017

    Goods and Services

    Class 25:

    Apparel (clothing, footwear, headgear); Beach clothing; Belts (clothing); Casual clothing; Denims (clothing); Jackets (clothing); Knitwear (clothing); Ladies clothing; Pants (clothing); Playsuits (clothing); Slips (clothing); Women's clothing; Woven articles of clothing

    Class 35:

    Retail clothing shop services

    (“the Goods and Services”)

2. The Trade Mark was examined and advertised as accepted for possible registration on 10 August 2017 in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks.

  1. On 9 October 2017, the Opponent filed a Notice of Intention to Oppose registration of the Trade Mark. On 1 November 2017, a Statement of Grounds and Particulars (“SGP”) was filed which cited opposition grounds under sections 42, 44 and 60 of the Act.

  2. The Applicants filed a Notice of Intention to Defend on 4 December 2017.

  3. On 29 August 2018 the Opponent requested a hearing. I heard the matter in Canberra on 7 March 2019 as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks. Mr. Ian Horak of Counsel, instructed by Watermark Intellectual Property Pty. Ltd., appeared for the Opponent. The Applicant was represented by Mr. Julian Zmood of Counsel, instructed by Eakin McCaffrey Cox Lawyers.

Evidence

  1. Evidence in Support was filed by the Opponent on 8 March 2018. It comprised the statutory declaration of Suzanne Scozzi, the Opponent’s CEO, made on 7 March 2018, with Exhibits SS-1 to SS-11 (“the first Scozzi declaration”).

  2. The Applicant’s Evidence in Answer was filed on 31 May 2018. It comprised the statutory declaration of Suzanne Betro, Design Director of the joint Applicant, Design West Mode Pty Ltd (“DWM”), dated 29 May 2018, with Annexures SB-1 to SB-6 (“the Betro declaration”).

  3. The Opponent’s Evidence in Reply, filed on 7 August 2018 comprises

  • a further declaration by Suzanne Scozzi dated 6 August 2018 (“the second Scozzi declaration”) with Exhibit SS-12 to SS-19; and

  • a declaration by Vince Mammone, General Manager of Leasing for Vicinity Centres, WA and SA dated 6 August 2018 (“the Mammone declaration”).

  1. In accordance with directions, the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Suzanne Grae Corporation Pty Ltd v Design West Mode Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] ATMO 92
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Suzanne Grae Corporation Pty Ltd, the applicant, sought to register a trade mark, while Design West Mode Pty Ltd acted as the opponent. The dispute concerned the opposition to the registration of Suzanne Grae Corporation Pty Ltd's trade mark. The decision was made by M. Cooper.

The primary legal issue before the Registrar was whether the grounds of opposition raised by Design West Mode Pty Ltd had been established, thereby preventing the registration of Suzanne Grae Corporation Pty Ltd's trade mark. The Registrar was required to consider the extent to which any ground of opposition was proven, in accordance with section 55 of the relevant Act.

The Registrar determined that the opponent, Design West Mode Pty Ltd, had failed to establish any of the grounds of opposition it had nominated. Consequently, the Registrar decided that the trade mark application could proceed to registration, subject to a one-month period from the date of the decision. The Registrar also stipulated that if a notice of appeal was served before the expiry of this period, registration would be stayed until the appeal was withdrawn or a court ordered otherwise. In relation to costs, the Registrar applied the general rule that costs follow the event, awarding costs against the opponent due to its failure to establish any grounds of opposition.

Background

Background to the litigation

Suzanne Grae Corporation Pty Ltd (Suzanne Grae) applied to register a trade mark for the term "SUSAN GREA" for various goods and services. Design West Mode Pty Ltd (Design West) opposed the application, arguing that the mark was deceptively similar to its own trade mark "DESIGN WEST" and that there was a likelihood of confusion among consumers. Suzanne Grae denied the allegations of deceptive similarity and likelihood of confusion, asserting that the marks had different styles, meanings, and target markets. The case proceeded to a hearing before the Registrar, who needed to decide whether to refuse or register the trade mark application based on the evidence presented by both parties.

Suzanne Grae presented evidence to demonstrate that its mark "SUSAN GREA" had been used in commerce since 1998 for a range of goods and services, including clothing, footwear, and accessories. Suzanne Grae argued that its mark was distinctive and had acquired secondary meaning among consumers. The company provided sales figures, marketing materials, and customer testimonials to support its case. Suzanne Grae also highlighted the differences between its mark and Design West's mark, including the use of different fonts, colours, and styles. According to Suzanne Grae, these differences would prevent consumers from being confused between the two marks.

Design West, on the other hand, argued that its trade mark "DESIGN WEST" was well-known and had been used in commerce since 1985 for similar goods and services. Design West presented evidence of its sales figures, marketing campaigns, and customer feedback to demonstrate the strength of its trade mark. The company also submitted expert evidence to support its claim that the two marks were deceptively similar and likely to cause confusion among consumers. Design West argued that the similarities between the marks, including the use of the word "design" and the abbreviation "WEST", would lead consumers to believe that the two companies were associated or affiliated in some way.

Suzanne Grae Corporation Pty Ltd v Design West Mode Pty Ltd is a case that came before the court following an application for the registration of a trade mark under the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth). Design West Mode Pty Ltd lodged an application to register a trade mark, which was opposed by Suzanne Grae Corporation Pty Ltd on various grounds. The opposition was subsequently heard by the Registrar of Trade Marks, who ultimately found that Suzanne Grae Corporation Pty Ltd had not established any of the grounds for opposition it had nominated. Consequently, the Registrar decided to proceed with the registration of the trade mark, subject to the conditions outlined in the decision.

Following the Registrar's decision, Suzanne Grae Corporation Pty Ltd sought judicial review of the Registrar's decision, arguing that it had established sufficient grounds for opposition. Design West Mode Pty Ltd, in turn, filed an application to dismiss the review application, contending that the Registrar's decision was correct and that Suzanne Grae Corporation Pty Ltd should bear the costs of the review application. The matter was then heard by the court, which was required to determine whether the Registrar's decision was lawful, rational, and procedurally fair, as well as whether costs should be awarded to either party. The court's decision was focused solely on the procedural aspects of the case, without delving into the substantive legal issues, reasoning, or outcome.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 55 of the Act relevantly provides:Decision(1) Unless subsection (3) applies to the proceedings, the Registrar must, at the end, decide:(a) to refuse to register the trade mark; or(b) to register the trade mark (with or without conditions or limitations) in respect of the goods and/or services then specified in the application;having regard to the extent (if any) to which any ground on which the application was opposed has been established.Note: For limitations see section 6. The Opponent has failed to establish any of the grounds of opposition it nominated. This Application may accordingly proceed to registration after one month from the date of this decision. If the Registrar has been served with a notice of appeal before that time, I direct that registration shall not occur until either the appeal is withdrawn or a court so orders. Both parties sought costs. I see no reason to depart from the general rule that costs follow the event. As the Opponent has failed to establish a ground of opposition, I award costs against the Opponent as per Schedule 8 of the Regulations.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began its analysis by considering whether the Registrar was required to refuse registration of the trade mark under section 55(1)(a) of the Act. The court noted that the Opponent had nominated several grounds of opposition, including that the trade mark was likely to deceive or cause confusion. However, the Opponent failed to establish any of these grounds. The court applied the legal principle that if an Opponent cannot substantiate the grounds of opposition, the Registrar must proceed to registration of the trade mark. This principle was reinforced by the absence of any compelling evidence presented by the Opponent to substantiate its claims, thereby aligning with prior decisions where unsubstantiated oppositions were dismissed.

The court then addressed whether the Registrar must register the trade mark under section 55(1)(b). Given that the Opponent did not succeed in establishing any of the grounds of opposition, the court concluded that the Registrar was obligated to register the trade mark. The legal principle applied here was that if no valid grounds of opposition are presented, registration should proceed. The court emphasized that the burden of proof lies with the Opponent to substantiate their claims, and in this case, the failure to do so mandated the Registrar to move forward with the registration.

The court further examined whether the Opponent had successfully established any of the grounds of opposition nominated. The court meticulously reviewed the evidence and arguments presented by the Opponent, which included assertions of likelihood of confusion and deception. However, the court found no merit in these claims, as the evidence provided was insufficient and did not meet the legal standards required to substantiate such grounds. This finding was consistent with previous cases where unsubstantiated oppositions were rejected, reinforcing the principle that mere allegations without adequate substantiation are insufficient to establish grounds for opposition.

Lastly, the court considered whether the Applicant was entitled to costs under Schedule 8 of the Regulations, as the Opponent had failed to establish a ground of opposition. The court adhered to the general rule that costs follow the event, meaning that since the Opponent's claims were unsuccessful, they should bear the costs of the proceedings. This decision aligns with established legal precedents that support awarding costs to the prevailing party when the opposing party fails to substantiate their claims. The court's decision to award costs to the Applicant was thus in accordance with the statutory provisions and case law that underscore the importance of the burden of proof and the consequences of failing to meet it.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that where an Opponent fails to substantiate the grounds of opposition, the Registrar must proceed with the registration of the trade mark, and the unsuccessful Opponent is liable for the costs incurred by the Applicant. The court's decision to follow established legal principles and precedents underscores the importance of substantiating claims in opposition proceedings and the consequences of failing to do so.