Sunlight Nominees Pty Ltd v Zotti and Zotti

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court: Civil)

SUNLIGHT NOMINEES PTY LTD v ZOTTI & ZOTTI

[2019] SASCFC 11

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Justice Vanstone, The Honourable Justice Blue and The Honourable Justice Parker)

8 February 2019

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - ADMISSION OF FRESH EVIDENCE

The appellant, "Sunlight", is a concreting company which concreted a driveway for the respondents. When they refused to pay, Sunlight commenced proceedings in the Magistrates Court for the quoted price. The respondents argued that the work was defective and counterclaimed for damages for the cost of the rectification. The Magistrate held that Sunlight should recover the contract price but awarded the respondents damages on the counterclaim.

On appeal to a single Judge Sunlight sought to introduce fresh evidence on two topics. The single Judge declined to receive the fresh evidence. Sunlight's appeal was dismissed. However the Judge increased the award on the counterclaim.

On appeal to this Court, Sunlight argues that the Judge erred in refusing to admit the fresh evidence and tenders further fresh evidence. Additionally, it argues that the Judge erred in increasing the award on the counterclaim.

Held, per Vanstone J (Parker J concurring, Blue J agreeing in separate reasons): The decision not to receive the fresh evidence was correct.  The appeal is allowed only for the purpose of restoring the Magistrate's award on the counterclaim.

SUNLIGHT NOMINEES PTY LTD v ZOTTI & ZOTTI
[2019] SASCFC 11

Full Court:      Vanstone, Blue and Parker JJ

  1. VANSTONE J:     Sunlight Nominees Pty Ltd (“Sunlight”) is a concreting company.  It is the plaintiff and appellant in the action.  The defendants and respondents, Mr and Mrs Zotti, engaged Sunlight to undertake concreting works on their residential property, for which they were to pay a total of $57,933.  The works were completed.  When the defendants failed to pay, Sunlight sued in the Magistrates Court for the quoted price.  The defendants answered that the works were defective and not in accordance with the contract specifications and they counterclaimed for damages for the cost of the rectification work.

  2. The Magistrate found that Sunlight was entitled to recover the agreed price, but upheld the defendants’ main claim of fundamental breach of contract and awarded $56,600 in damages on the counterclaim.  This left a net award to Sunlight of $1,333.

  3. On appeal to a single Judge of this Court, Sunlight sought to introduce fresh evidence on two separate topics.  The Judge declined to receive that evidence.  The Judge increased the award on the counterclaim to equate to the amount required for the rectification work as given in expert evidence; as opposed to the amount set out in the counterclaim.  The Judge subsequently granted permission to appeal in relation to the refusal to admit the fresh evidence and the level of damages on the counterclaim.

  4. On the appeal to this Court, Sunlight claims that the Judge erred in declining to receive both bodies of fresh evidence and tenders additional fresh evidence.  Sunlight also…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sunlight Nominees Pty Ltd v Zotti and Zotti and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] SASCFC 11
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Sunlight Nominees Pty Ltd appealed to the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia against a decision of a single judge, who had declined to admit fresh evidence tendered by Sunlight and had also increased the damages awarded to the defendants, Mr and Mrs Zotti, on their counterclaim. The dispute concerned the construction of a concrete driveway, with the Zottis alleging the concrete was defective due to not meeting an agreed strength of 25 megapascals (MPa), whereas Sunlight contended the agreed strength was 20MPa.

The primary legal issues before the Full Court were whether the single judge erred in refusing to admit fresh evidence, specifically an affidavit from a truck driver named Nino Calabria, and whether the judge was correct in increasing the damages awarded on the counterclaim. Sunlight sought to introduce Mr Calabria's affidavit, which purported to depose to a conversation overheard between Mr Russo of Sunlight and Mr Zotti, suggesting the agreed concrete strength was 20MPa. The Zottis also sought to tender fresh evidence in response to Sunlight's new affidavits.

The Full Court, in allowing the appeal in part, found that the single judge had erred in his assessment of the fresh evidence. While the judge accepted that there was a reasonable explanation for Sunlight's failure to call Mr Calabria at trial and that his evidence was relevant and potentially influential, he ultimately declined to admit it. The Full Court noted that Mr Russo's evidence at trial, which did not mention the presence of a third party during the crucial conversation, was inconsistent with the explanation for not calling Mr Calabria earlier. However, the Court ultimately did not receive Mr Calabria's affidavit or other fresh evidence tendered by Sunlight.

The Court allowed the appeal solely for the purpose of setting aside the single judge's increased award of damages on the counterclaim and restoring the original award made by the Magistrate, which was $56,600. The Court ordered that the fresh evidence tendered by both parties not be received.

Background

Background to the litigation

On the appeal to this Court, Sunlight claims that the Judge erred in declining to receive both bodies of fresh evidence and tenders additional fresh evidence. Sunlight also asserts that the Judge erred in uplifting the damages on the counterclaim. For their part the defendants tender fresh evidence in answer to the new affidavits filed by Sunlight.Background Sunlight, through its sole director, Mr Antonio Russo, has conducted a concreting business for some years. In early 2008 Sunlight provided a quote to the defendants for a concrete driveway to service their house and a large, adjacent, shed. The quotation included reference to the thickness of the concrete (100 millimetres) although not its strength. It was to be reinforced. Subsequently it was agreed that the area to be constructed would be increased to about 490 square metres, charged at the same rate. There were nine pours of concrete in all, the last taking place on 13 May 2008. Following completion the parties fell into dispute. The defendants claimed that the works were defective for several reasons, most importantly because the concrete did not comply with what they claimed was the agreed strength of 25 megapascals (MPa). They sought damages measured by reference to the cost of replacing the entire driveway with the extra strength concrete. As mentioned, the agreement was partly in writing – the written quotation – and partly oral. However no writing bore on the defendants’ claim that the concrete was to be provided at the strength of 25MPa. (The usual strength for a domestic driveway is 20MPa.) Before the single Judge the Magistrate’s credibility findings in relation to this issue were attacked. However the single Judge found that the findings were open to the Magistrate.The tender of fresh evidence Before the single Judge, Sunlight tendered an affidavit purporting to be that of a truck driver who had delivered some of the concrete to the defendants’ home. The affidavit was in the briefest terms. It was the affidavit of one Nino Calabria. He deposed that he was a truck driver with Hanson Construction and Building Materials and that on about 3 May 2017 (sic) he attended the third pour of concrete at the relevant address. He observed Mr Russo speaking with Mr Zotti. He heard Mr Zotti ask to see the cart note whereupon he went to his truck and retrieved it. He handed it to Mr Russo who handed it to Mr Zotti. Mr Calabria said he then overheard an exchange between the two men in the following terms:Zotti:Are all driveways done in 20MPa?Russo:Yes.Russo:Your house foundation is 20MPa. If you want it stronger then you will have to pay for extra labour and materials.Mr Calabria said he then finished pouring the concrete and left the property. Mr Russo also provided an affidavit relevant to this issue. He said, in effect, that before the trial in the Magistrates Court he had approached Hanson Construction to ascertain the name of the driver who had overheard the conversation. However, Hanson Construction refused to provide the name to him. He said that after the trial, by chance, he ran into the truck driver, whom he knew as “Nino”. Mr Calabria told Mr Russo that he remembered the conversation. This was plainly Mr Russo’s explanation for not having called Mr Calabria at the trial.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Following completion the parties fell into dispute. The defendants claimed that the works were defective for several reasons, most importantly because the concrete did not comply with what they claimed was the agreed strength of 25 megapascals (MPa). They sought damages measured by reference to the cost of replacing the entire driveway with the extra strength concrete. As mentioned, the agreement was partly in writing – the written quotation – and partly oral. However no writing bore on the defendants’ claim that the concrete was to be provided at the strength of 25MPa. (The usual strength for a domestic driveway is 20MPa.) Before the single Judge the Magistrate’s credibility findings in relation to this issue were attacked. However the single Judge found that the findings were open to the Magistrate.The tender of fresh evidence Before the single Judge, Sunlight tendered an affidavit purporting to be that of a truck driver who had delivered some of the concrete to the defendants’ home. The affidavit was in the briefest terms. It was the affidavit of one Nino Calabria. He deposed that he was a truck driver with Hanson Construction and Building Materials and that on about 3 May 2017 (sic) he attended the third pour of concrete at the relevant address. He observed Mr Russo speaking with Mr Zotti. He heard Mr Zotti ask to see the cart note whereupon he went to his truck and retrieved it. He handed it to Mr Russo who handed it to Mr Zotti. Mr Calabria said he then overheard an exchange between the two men in the following terms:Zotti:Are all driveways done in 20MPa?Russo:Yes.Russo:Your house foundation is 20MPa. If you want it stronger then you will have to pay for extra labour and materials.Mr Calabria said he then finished pouring the concrete and left the property. Mr Russo also provided an affidavit relevant to this issue. He said, in effect, that before the trial in the Magistrates Court he had approached Hanson Construction to ascertain the name of the driver who had overheard the conversation. However, Hanson Construction refused to provide the name to him. He said that after the trial, by chance, he ran into the truck driver, whom he knew as “Nino”. Mr Calabria told Mr Russo that he remembered the conversation. This was plainly Mr Russo’s explanation for not having called Mr Calabria at the trial. Perhaps generously, the single Judge accepted that there was a reasonable explanation for Sunlight’s failure to call Mr Calabria at the trial. He also accepted that the evidence was relevant and would have been capable of influencing the Magistrate’s consideration of whether or not the agreement was for a concrete strength of 25MPa. However, his Honour went on:[85]However, I cannot be satisfied without more that the evidence would, or even would likely, have had an important influence on the case. First, while the evidence, if accepted, would tend to support the plaintiff’s case, it does not in fact square with the evidence of either Mr Zotti or Mr Russo. Secondly, and more significantly, the evidence from Mr Calabria relates to a short conversation that he overhead almost 10 years ago. It cannot be said that the evidence is inherently likely to be reliable and of significant weight. In any event, its reliability and weight could only be assessed after hearing cross-examination of Mr Calabria, and perhaps also additional evidence from Mr Zotti and Mr Russo. This would likely require that the matter be remitted to the Magistrates Court for rehearing given its interrelationship with the issues of credit that arose in the case. Further, in the circumstances of a civil or commercial dispute of the nature and limited dollar significance of the present case, and which relates to events that occurred almost 10 years ago, the public interest in the finality of litigation looms large.The Judge declined to receive Mr Calabria’s affidavit.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In my view there is some force in Sunlight’s argument on this ground. The Magistrate was in the best position to assess damages and to take into account that the trial proceeded on the basis of amounts given in the pleadings. Without descending into the level of detail presented before the Magistrate, I am persuaded that it would be appropriate to restore her Honour’s award on the counterclaim.Conclusion I would allow the appeal only for the limited purpose of setting aside the Judge’s award of damages on the counterclaim and restoring the award made by the Magistrate. In relation to the affidavits filed I would make the following orders:1.FDN 24 is not received;2.FDN 25 is not received;3.FDN 28 is not received;In relation to the appeal itself I would order:4.The appeal is allowed to the extent of setting aside the Judge’s award of damages on the counterclaim and restoring the Magistrate’s order, namely an amount of $56,600.BLUE J: The background, issues and contentions are summarised in the reasons for judgment of Vanstone J. I agree with the disposition of the appeal proposed by Vanstone J but for somewhat different reasons.The appeal grounds The notice of appeal is unfortunately drafted in that it ostensibly sets out two different sets of appeal grounds, one comprising eight grounds and the other comprising three grounds. However, on the hearing before the single Judge of the application for permission to appeal and again before this Court, the appellant (Sunlight) said that the three grounds are the grounds of appeal and the eight “grounds” are merely particulars thereof. The appeal was conducted on this basis. Accordingly I refer in these reasons to the three grounds as the grounds of appeal. For the sake of clarity I refer to the eight “grounds” as sub-grounds. The first three sub-grounds are particulars of ground 1, the next three sub-grounds are particulars of ground 2 and the last two sub-grounds are particulars of ground 3. Grounds 2 and 3 complain of the exercise by the single Judge of the discretion not to admit new evidence on appeal (relating to the affidavit of Mr Calabria and to evidence concerning development approval). If one or both of grounds 2 and 3 is successful and new evidence is admitted on appeal, Sunlight challenges the Magistrate’s finding concerning the 25 MPa alleged term of the contract on the basis of the new evidence. However, Sunlight does not challenge that finding on the evidence that was before the Magistrate. Ground 1 complains of the allowance by the single Judge of the cross appeal by the Zottis which increased the quantum of the counterclaim by $8,400 from $56,600 to $65,000. However, during the hearing of the appeal, due to the unfortunate drafting of the notice of appeal, a question arose as to whether ground 1 extends beyond the allowance of the cross appeal to the quantum of the counterclaim allowed by the Magistrate. It is convenient to address the fresh evidence grounds (2 and 3) first, followed by ground 1 insofar as it complains of the allowance of the cross appeal, followed by the question whether ground 1 extends more generally to the quantum of the counterclaim.The admission of fresh evidence on appeal

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Counsel argued that in this case removal and replacement of the entire driveway was not an appropriate remedy, first because the installed product was capable of withstanding the stresses said to be intended for it and which Mr Zotti’s most recent affidavit established continued to be its intended use, and second that, in any event, the intended use foreshadowed at trial was not permitted as a matter of law. It was put that the defendants have had the use of the driveway for some 10 years without paying for it and, as a result of the orders made by the Magistrate, were to retain that benefit.Consideration I deal first with the issue of the fresh evidence emanating from Mr Calabria. The Judge gave two reasons why he was not satisfied that the evidence would have had an important influence on the case. Although he did not elaborate, I consider that there was more to his Honour’s observation that Mr Calabria’s statement did not sit well with Mr Russo’s evidence than merely whether the conversation occurred on the occasion of the first or third pour. When he described the relevant conversation at trial, Mr Russo gave the following evidence:Q …at any time did you receive a complaint from Mr or Mrs Zotti… About the strength of the steel that you were using.ANo, on the first day he asked to see the docket, the part note docket from the concrete which I handed him and he had a look at it, he did query the – he said, ‘I thought you quoted for 25MPa’ I said ‘No, I didn’t, it’s 20MPa which is the standard driveway’.…QDid they ever say to you at any time that they wanted 25MPa.ANo, when he had all of that cart note he said ‘I thought you were using 25MPa’. I said ‘No, it’s all 20MPa, that’s what I quoted for. But if you wanted to go 25 you’ve got to pay the difference in the concrete’ and he left it at that. I never heard from him, you know, he was coming out every day, we were greeting each other, you know, for we did eight or nine calls there, you know, and it never come up again.QSo you had a discussion about a cart note.AYeah.QWhen did that discussion take place.AOn the first pour.At no time during his evidence did Mr Russo assert that a truck driver or anyone else was present during this conversation. That is curious since Mr Russo’s affidavit of 24 August 2017 deposes to his having made efforts, before the trial, to obtain the name of the truck driver who handed the docket to the defendant and who overheard the conversation. In his affidavit Mr Russo deposed to having telephoned Hanson Construction, Mr Calabria’s employer, for the purpose of obtaining the driver’s name and having been told that the information would not be provided because of privacy laws. He then deposed that it was only after the trial and because of a chance meeting with the driver that he was able to raise the issue with him. If it were in Mr Russo’s mind that a third person was present at the time of his conversation with Mr Zotti and indeed that the third person had handed over the cart note at his request, then one would have expected him to say so in his evidence before the Magistrate.