Strong Wise Limited v Esso Australia Resources Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 54 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Strong Wise Limited v Esso Australia Resources Pty Ltd (No 2)

[2010] FCA 575

Citation: Strong Wise Limited v Esso Australia Resources Pty Ltd (No 2) [2010] FCA 575
Parties: STRONG WISE LIMITED v ESSO AUSTRALIA RESOURCES PTY LTD (ACN 091 829 819), BHP BILLITON PETROLEUM (BASS STRAIT) PTY LTD (ACN 004 228 004) and PERSONS WHO MAY HAVE A CLAIM WITHIN THE MEANING OF ARTICLE 2 OF CONVENTION ON LIMITATION OF LIABILITY FOR MARITIME CLAIMS 1976 (AS AMENDED BY THE 1996 PROTOCOL TO AMEND CONVENTION OF LIMITATION OF LIABILITY FOR MARITIME CLAIMS 1976) AS GIVEN FORCE OF LAW BY THE LIMITATION OF LIABILITY FOR MARITIME CLAIMS ACT (1989) (AS AMENDED) IN RESPECT OF LOSS SUFFERED OR DAMAGE CAUSED BY AN ANCHOR OR ANCHOR CABLE OF THE VESSEL "APL SYDNEY" IN PORT PHILLIP BAY, VICTORIA ON OR ABOUT 13 DECEMBER 2008
File number: VID 1060 of 2008
Judge: RARES J
Date of judgment: 8 June 2010
Catchwords:

HIGH COURT AND FEDERAL COURT – JURISDICTION – STATUTORY INTERPRETATION – whether jurisdiction of Court limited by pleadings in proceedings under s 25 of the Admiralty Act 1988 (Cth), s 9 of the Limitation of Liability for Maritime Claims Act 1989 (Cth) and s 39B(1A)(c) of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) seeking relief under Convention on Limitation of Liability for Maritime Claims 1976 as affected by the 1996 protocol to amend that Convention – shipowner pleaded entitlement to limit liability on only one distinct occasion – defendant pleaded existence of four distinct occasions – Court found existence of two distinct occasions – whether Court has jurisdiction to make orders that shipowner entitled to limit liability for both distinct occasions consistent with its findings

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – PLEADINGS – relief flowing from pleadings – Convention does not deny shipowner the right to limit because number of distinct occasions is misidentified in pleadings – real controversy to be resolved in proceedings is whether shipowner can invoke limitation of liability under Art 10 of the Convention on one or more distinct occasions – Court able to give effect to findings by ordering the constitution of one limitation fund and making a declaration of shipowner’s entitlement to establish a second fund

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – PLEADINGS – orders to prevent multiplicity of proceedings under s 22 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) from shipowner’s failure to plead more than one distinct occasion – Court able to grant relief appropriate to dispose of the controversy litigated – multiplicity of proceedings inevitable consequence of not making orders giving effect to reasons due to shipowner’s failure to plead more than one distinct occasion –refusal to grant relief not consistent with interests of justice

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – PLEADINGS – amendment of pleadings – late application to amend after reasons delivered – power of Court to make amendments of its own motion to determine real questions in controversy – no unqualified duty to permit late addition of any new claim – tactical choices…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Strong Wise Limited v Esso Australia Resources Pty Ltd (No 2... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCA 575
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Strong Wise Limited v Esso Australia Resources Pty Ltd (No 2), the legal dispute arose from a limitation of liability claim under maritime law. The shipowner, Strong Wise Limited, sought to limit its liability by establishing a limitation fund. Esso Australia Resources Pty Ltd and BHP, as claimants, contested the shipowner's attempt to establish a single limitation fund to cover all claims. The case was heard by the Federal Court of Australia, where the primary concern was the allocation of costs between the parties.

The central legal issues addressed by the court involved the principles governing costs in maritime limitation actions and whether the shipowner should bear the costs of establishing a limitation fund. Esso and BHP argued that the shipowner should bear the costs unless they unreasonably raised issues, citing precedents from James Patrick 60 CLR and Newcastle Port Corporation v Pevitt. Conversely, Strong Wise Limited contended that since they had succeeded in substance by proving the need for a single limitation fund, they should be awarded costs.

The court examined various authorities and precedents, including Barameda Enterprises Pty Ltd v O’Connor, The Capitan San Luis, and Marsden on Collisions at Sea, to determine the appropriate practice regarding costs in limitation actions. The Full Court of the Supreme Court of Queensland had previously opined that no special practice should apply in such cases under the Brussels Convention. However, the Federal Court held that it had a broad discretion to award costs under s 43(2) of the Federal Court of Australia Act. The court reasoned that it was sensible for a shipowner, who benefits from establishing a limitation fund, to bear the costs of proving their entitlement and setting up the fund, especially considering the requirements of the Admiralty Rules. Therefore, the court decided that the shipowner should bear the costs of the proceedings related to establishing the limitation fund.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On the other hand, Esso and BHP argued that the usual practice is that a shipowner should pay the costs in a limitation action unless the other party unreasonably raised an issue. They relied on James Patrick 60 CLR at 677-678, and Newcastle Port Corporation v Pevitt (2003) 58 NSWLR 584 at 560 [49] per Palmer J. In any event, they contended that they had succeeded in substance and were entitled to an order for costs. This was because, they said, the shipowner had failed in its principal claim that one limitation fund should be established to meet all claims.COSTS - CONSIDERATION The Full Court of the Supreme Court of Queensland considered, in obiter dicta, that no special practice as to costs should apply in limitation actions under the Brussels Convention: Barameda Enterprises Pty Ltd v O’Connor [1988] 1 Qd R 359 at 371 per Kelly SPJ with whom Macrossan J agreed at 378 as did McPherson J in separate reasons at 391-392. In The Capitan San Luis [1994] QB 465 at 472G-473B, Clarke J said that under the Convention ordinarily the shipowner only has to prove that the claim falls within Art 2 in order to establish his right to limit liability. If the other party resists the shipowner’s claim, his Lordship held that costs should follow the event. The learned editors of Marsden on Collisions at Sea (13th ed) at [16-19] expressed the view that the Convention had made a radical change in the principles concerning limitation of liability. They argued that the shift in the burden of proof meant that limitation was now a legal right rather than a privilege. However, they did not discuss who should bear the initial costs of the shipowner establishing an uncontested right to limit. The parties did not refer to any other case that had decided this issue. In Pevitt 58 NSWLR at 560 [49] Palmer J proceeded on the agreement of the parties that in James Patrick 60 CLR at 677-678 Dixon J had stated the law. However, Palmer J was not referred to Barameda [1988] 1 Qd R 359. This Court has a general and unfettered discretion to award costs under s 43(2) of the Federal Court of Australia Act: see Probiotec Ltd v University of Melbourne (2008) 166 FCR 30 at 42-44 [45]-[50] where I discussed the principles under that section, with the agreement of Finn and Besanko JJ at 32 [1], 51 [82]. There is considerable commonsense in a rule of practice that, ordinarily, a shipowner seeking to limit his liability ought pay at least the other side’s costs of the issue of establishing a prima facie case to its entitlement and of the constitution of a limitation fund. A shipowner must serve at least one named defendant with his initiating process seeking to invoke his right to limitation of liability by dint of r 61(1) of the Admiralty Rules. Thus, the Rules require the person served at least to consider his, her or its position in relation to the shipowner’s claim. The costs of that process and the prima facie proof of the claim should not be forced on the person that the Rules require be served. After all, the costs of establishing the entitlement and fund enure to the benefit of the shipowner against, not only the particular opponent but, as in effect a fund in rem: cp James Patrick 60 CLR at 675. It may be unfair that the costs of the shipowner to prove its claim to limit liability be made to fall on only one of potentially several persons with claims under Art 2 of the Convention.