Starke v Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Judicial Review)

STARKE v LEGAL PROFESSION CONDUCT COMMISSIONER

[2025] SASC 140

Judgment of the Honourable Justice Stein  

PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - ENDING PROCEEDINGS EARLY - SUMMARY DISPOSAL - SUMMARY JUDGMENT FOR DEFENDANT OR RESPONDENT: STAY OR DISMISSAL OF PROCEEDINGS

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - JUDICIAL REVIEW - REVIEWABLE DECISIONS AND CONDUCT - GENERALLY

The applicant, David Ashley Starke, applied by originating application for judicial review of an alleged decision by the Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner (“Commissioner”) to “abandon the [Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA)] section 77J administrative process and to lay a Charge before the Legal Practitioners’ Disciplinary Tribunal”.

The respondent Commissioner applied for summary dismissal of the application under r 256.5 of the Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA).

Held (granting the interlocutory application for summary dismissal and dismissing the originating application for judicial review):

1.      There is no reasonable basis for judicial review.

Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA) ss 77B, 77D, 77J, 77L, 77M; Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s 557; Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA) rr 143.2, 144.2, 256.5, referred to.
Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Cahill [2010] FCAFC 39; Finlayson v Legal Practitioners Conduct Board (2012) 112 SASR 549; Attorney-General v Kowalski [2014] SASC 1; James Cook University v Ridd (2020) 278 FCR 566; Vansetten v State of South Australia [2020] SASC 158; Adelaide Brighton Cement Ltd v Hallett Concrete Pty Ltd (2020) 137 SASR 117; Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner v Belperio [2024] SASCA 102, considered.

STARKE v LEGAL PROFESSION CONDUCT COMMISSIONER
[2025] SASC 140

Civil: Judicial Review

  1. STEIN J: In June 2024, the Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner (the “Commissioner”),[1] the respondent, laid a charge against Mr Starke, the applicant, in the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal (the “Tribunal”) alleging that Mr Starke engaged in professional misconduct on the basis of alleged failure to comply with conditions placed on Mr Starke’s practising certificate on 21 November 2016.  Mr Starke commenced judicial review proceedings which challenge “the decision to abandon the [Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA)] [s] 77J administrative process and to lay a Charge before the Legal Practitioners’ Disciplinary Tribunal”. The Commissioner applied for summary dismissal of the judicial review application.

    [1]   At the time the investigations involving Mr Starke commenced, Mr Greg May was the Commissioner.  Mr Anthony Keane was thereafter appointed Commissioner.

  2. For the reasons which follow, I have determined to grant the Commissioner’s application and summarily dismiss Mr Starke’s application for judicial review.

    Background

  3. Since 2016, Mr Starke’s practising certificate has been subject to conditions that:

    ·he has funds in his trust account to the credit of the client before the brief is delivered to counsel, which funds are in counsel’s estimate sufficient to cover counsel fees to be incurred; or

    ·he advises the barrister he proposes to brief of the condition on his practising certificate at the time of his first approach to discuss briefing her or him in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Starke v Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] SASC 140
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Starke v Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner involves Mr. Starke, who was subject to specific conditions on his practising certificate, and the Commissioner, who investigated a complaint against Mr. Starke for failing to pay counsel fees and for not advising counsel of the conditions on his certificate. Mr. Starke sought judicial review of the Commissioner's decision, arguing that his conduct should be characterised as unsatisfactory professional conduct rather than professional misconduct. The Commissioner applied for summary dismissal of Mr. Starke’s application for judicial review.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Commissioner had made a decision of the character alleged by Mr. Starke. The court had to determine whether Mr. Starke had identified a reviewable decision and if the Commissioner's correspondence constituted a decision that could be subject to judicial review. The court also had to consider whether the Commissioner's characterisation of Mr. Starke's conduct as professional misconduct was lawful and whether there were any grounds for judicial review of the Commissioner's decision.

The court found that the Commissioner did indeed make a decision of the character alleged by Mr. Starke. The Commissioner's correspondence clearly refuted Mr. Starke's characterisation of his conduct as unsatisfactory professional conduct and maintained that it amounted to professional misconduct. The court held that the Commissioner's decision was reviewable, as it was a decision that affected Mr. Starke's legal rights and obligations. However, the court granted the Commissioner's application for summary dismissal, finding that Mr. Starke's arguments did not establish an arguable case for judicial review.

The court ultimately dismissed Mr. Starke's application for judicial review, holding that there was no basis for the court to interfere with the Commissioner's decision. The court found that the Commissioner had properly considered the matters put forward by Mr. Starke and had acted within his powers in characterising Mr. Starke's conduct as professional misconduct. The court also noted that any issues regarding the characterisation of conduct and penalty would be addressed by the disciplinary tribunal.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons which follow, I have determined to grant the Commissioner’s application and summarily dismiss Mr Starke’s application for judicial review. Background Since 2016, Mr Starke’s practising certificate has been subject to conditions that: ·he has funds in his trust account to the credit of the client before the brief is delivered to counsel, which funds are in counsel’s estimate sufficient to cover counsel fees to be incurred; or·he advises the barrister he proposes to brief of the condition on his practising certificate at the time of his first approach to discuss briefing her or him in a matter, and the barrister agrees with him in writing to wait until a particular date or event, to be identified in writing in the agreement, for payment of his or her counsel fees. On 17 May 2021, the Commissioner[2] wrote to Mr Starke to inform Mr Starke the Commissioner had received a complaint about his conduct. The complaint was received by the Commissioner from counsel retained by Mr Starke (“complainant”). The complainant said she was briefed by Mr Starke on 20 May 2020 to appear at a hearing in the Federal Circuit Court and her account remained unpaid despite requests. The Commissioner informed Mr Starke that the Commissioner was obliged to investigate the complaint and the Commissioner had commenced an investigation. Mr Starke was informed of his right to make submissions and provided with a copy of the complaint. The Commissioner stated that the complainant appeared to allege Mr Starke had failed to pay her account for counsel fees and asked Mr Starke to address in his response whether he had told the complainant he had money in trust from the client to pay her fees or if he had alerted her to the conditions on his practising certificate concerning briefing counsel. [2] A number of different staff members of the Commissioner were responsible for correspondence sent on behalf of the Commissioner. On 17 May 2021, the complainant sent to the Commissioner a letter responding to a letter from him of the same date. The complainant said she could not recall whether Mr Starke told her he had money in trust and there was never any discussion about the conditions on Mr Starke’s practising certificate. On 18 May 2021, in response to a further email from the Commissioner, the complainant said there was no discussion about any deferred payment, she could not recall whether there was a specific discussion about funds in trust, and there was no discussion about any conditions on Mr Starke’s practising certificate. On 13 July 2021, Mr Starke responded by letter to the Commissioner (the “13 July letter”). In that letter, Mr Starke explained that he had retained counsel but when that counsel became unavailable, Mr Starke searched for alternative counsel. The client was a client who had always paid her bills. Mr Starke had no reason to doubt the client would pay counsel fees and she did in fact pay the fees. Mr Starke said that, in the particular circumstances, he did not have time to correspond by letter so he spoke to his client about the likely fees and asked her to put money in trust, the client agreed to brief the complainant and said she would pay the anticipated fees into trust. Mr Starke stated that, as a result of COVID-19 lockdown requirements, everything was done by telephone and there was no time for letters. Mr Starke said that after receiving the complainant’s bill, it was sent to the client via email. The fees were paid into Mr Starke’s office account, not the trust account. Mr Starke could not explain why he missed the fact of payment into the wrong account. Mr Starke then moved office in circumstances set out in the letter. Mr Starke said he was not aware of account reminders until late in the matter and payment was overlooked. In Mr Starke’s response, he accepted there was non-compliance with the “strict wording” of the conditions on his practising certificate but maintained there were significant mitigating factors which he set out in his letter.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Commissioner filed the interlocutory application for summary dismissal pursuant to rr 144.2 and 256.5 on 16 January 2025. The Commissioner sought an extension of time “to the extent required”. The extension of time was agreed by the parties and this Court made an order on 11 February 2025 extending the time to file and serve the interlocutory application nunc pro tunc to 16 January 2025 thus bringing the application within r 256.5.Did the Commissioner make a decision of the character alleged? Judicial review addresses the process by which a reviewable decision was made rather than the merits of such a decision. An applicant must, among other things, identify the decision the subject of the judicial review proceedings. The Commissioner contended that he did not make a decision to the effect alleged in the judicial review application. The success of this argument depended on the application of the legislative provisions and the proper characterisation of the correspondence between Mr Starke and the Commissioner. Mr Starke’s 5 May letter described its purpose as providing submissions that addressed why, in the circumstances, the better and more appropriate conduct finding was unsatisfactory professional conduct. The letter acknowledged that the Commissioner relied on the 13 July letter and the complainant’s email. The 5 May letter did not dispute that, in May 2020, Mr Starke retained counsel but contended that the Commissioner had failed to take into account the extraordinary circumstances that confronted him at the time. Mr Starke did not dispute the underlying factual matters upon which the Commissioner’s preliminary view was formed, but rather put matters Mr Starke contended should have been considered by the Commissioner. He also asserted unworkability of the conditions on the practising certificate. The 5 May letter also accepted that counsel was not advised of the practising certificate conditions but stated that Mr Starke did not demonstrate any wilful intention and the circumstances were not of Mr Starke’s making. Mr Starke thus did not shy away from the matters conceded by him in the 13 July letter on which the Commissioner relied in forming his preliminary views. The submissions in the 5 May letter were put in support of the position that the better and more appropriate characterisation of Mr Starke’s conduct was unsatisfactory professional conduct. The letter also reiterated that there was unfairness in having two findings in relation to conduct and penalty with respect to the same course of conduct. As set out above, on 15 May 2024, the Commissioner responded to the 5 May letter. The Commissioner maintained his view the conduct was professional misconduct and, having formed the view there was evidence of professional misconduct, the Commissioner was of the view the conduct could adequately be dealt with under s 77J(2). It is thus readily apparent from the correspondence that, having considered the matters set out in the 5 May letter, the Commissioner refuted the characterisation of Mr Starke’s conduct as unsatisfactory professional conduct, maintained his position that the conduct amounted to professional misconduct and informed Mr Starke that he was of the view the conduct could be dealt with under s 77J(2). The Commissioner proposed certain disciplinary action and sought Mr Starke’s consent. The correspondence made clear that if Mr Starke did not consent, it was most likely the Commissioner would then be obliged to lay a charge.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Starke also complained that the Commissioner treated the non-payment of the account and the breach of conditions as separate matters but, on Mr Starke’s position, they arose out of the one course of conduct and, accordingly, should have been dealt with in one determination on misconduct with one penalty. Mr Starke therefore submitted that there is an arguable case on judicial review that he will be disciplined twice for the same course of conduct. Consideration Abuse of process On the basis of the matters put by Mr Starke, I accept the issue of duplication will be addressed in the Tribunal and, accordingly, I do not further consider abuse of process.Rule 256.5 The Commissioner filed the interlocutory application for summary dismissal pursuant to rr 144.2 and 256.5 on 16 January 2025. The Commissioner sought an extension of time “to the extent required”. The extension of time was agreed by the parties and this Court made an order on 11 February 2025 extending the time to file and serve the interlocutory application nunc pro tunc to 16 January 2025 thus bringing the application within r 256.5.Did the Commissioner make a decision of the character alleged? Judicial review addresses the process by which a reviewable decision was made rather than the merits of such a decision. An applicant must, among other things, identify the decision the subject of the judicial review proceedings. The Commissioner contended that he did not make a decision to the effect alleged in the judicial review application. The success of this argument depended on the application of the legislative provisions and the proper characterisation of the correspondence between Mr Starke and the Commissioner. Mr Starke’s 5 May letter described its purpose as providing submissions that addressed why, in the circumstances, the better and more appropriate conduct finding was unsatisfactory professional conduct. The letter acknowledged that the Commissioner relied on the 13 July letter and the complainant’s email. The 5 May letter did not dispute that, in May 2020, Mr Starke retained counsel but contended that the Commissioner had failed to take into account the extraordinary circumstances that confronted him at the time. Mr Starke did not dispute the underlying factual matters upon which the Commissioner’s preliminary view was formed, but rather put matters Mr Starke contended should have been considered by the Commissioner. He also asserted unworkability of the conditions on the practising certificate. The 5 May letter also accepted that counsel was not advised of the practising certificate conditions but stated that Mr Starke did not demonstrate any wilful intention and the circumstances were not of Mr Starke’s making. Mr Starke thus did not shy away from the matters conceded by him in the 13 July letter on which the Commissioner relied in forming his preliminary views. The submissions in the 5 May letter were put in support of the position that the better and more appropriate characterisation of Mr Starke’s conduct was unsatisfactory professional conduct. The letter also reiterated that there was unfairness in having two findings in relation to conduct and penalty with respect to the same course of conduct.