South Australian Fire and Emergency Services Commission v Workers Compensation Tribunal

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

SOUTH AUSTRALIAN FIRE AND EMERGENCY SERVICES COMMISSION v WORKERS COMPENSATION TRIBUNAL & ANOR

[2009] SASC 213

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Chief Justice Doyle, The Honourable Justice Anderson and The Honourable Justice Kourakis)

23 July 2009

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - JUDICIAL REVIEW - GROUNDS OF REVIEW - JURISDICTIONAL MATTERS

Application for judicial review of a decision of the Full Bench of the Workers Compensation Tribunal (WCT) – the decision allowed the appeal against a decision of an Auxiliary Judge of the WCT – under s 86 of the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1986 an appeal lies against a decision of the WCT constituted by a single member to the Full Bench on a question of law – the plaintiff contends that the Full Bench’s decision was made in excess or want of jurisdiction and seeks declarations that the appeal to the Full Bench is incompetent and an order quashing its decision on the basis that the appeal was not on a question of law.

Held – application allowed – the jurisdiction of the Full Bench is limited to the hearing and determination of only those appeals which are correctly held to be appeals on questions of law – the Full Bench exceeded its jurisdiction by conducting an appeal by way of rehearing of the evidence without addressing or determining any ground raising a question of law – decision of the Full Bench set aside.

Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1986 (SA) s 2, s 78, s 78A, s 79, s 86, s 88B, sch 1; Worker's Compensation Act 1971 (SA), referred to.
Craig v South Australia (1995) 184 CLR 163; Azzopardi v Tasman UEB Industries Ltd (1985) 4 NSWLR 139; Soulemezis v Dudley (Holdings) Pty Ltd (1987) 10 NSWLR 247, applied.
Schwerdt v Safecom (Emergency Services Administrative Union) [2007] SAWCT 55; Schwerdt v Safecom (Emergency Services Administrative Union) [2008] SAWCT 39, discussed.
Roncevich v Repatriation Commission (2005) 222 CLR 115; Mahony v Industrial Registrar of New South Wales (1986) 8 NSWLR 1; Haines v Leves (1987) 8 NSWLR 442; Warley Pty Ltd v Adco Constructions Pty Ltd (1988) 8 BCL 300; Tracy Village Sports and Social Club v Walker (1992) 111 FLR 32; Bowen-James v Director-General, Department of Health (1992) 27 NSWLR 457; Wilson v Lowery (1993) 110 FLR 142; Bruce v Cole (1998) 45 NSWLR 163; Ormwave Pty Ltd v Smith [2007] NSWCA 210; Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond (1990) 170 CLR 321; Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs; Ex parte Applicant S20/2002 [2003] HCA 30; Vetter v Lake Macquarie City Council (2001) 202 CLR 439; Hope v Bathurst City Council (1980) 144 CLR 1; William v Bill Williams Pty Ltd [1971] 1 NSWLR 547; Geste v Pereira [1991] SASC 3018; Thurston v Todd [1966] 1 NSWLR 321; Chambers v Jobling (1986) 7 NSWLR 1, considered.

SOUTH AUSTRALIAN FIRE AND…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read South Australian Fire and Emergency Services Commission v Wo... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] SASC 213
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of South Australian Fire and Emergency Services Commission v Workers Compensation Tribunal, the Full Bench of the Workers Compensation Tribunal (WCT) was called upon to review a decision made by an Auxiliary Judge of the same tribunal. The plaintiff, who had previously served with the Metropolitan Fire Service (MFS), was seeking workers' compensation for a post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) allegedly stemming from incidents during his employment. The Auxiliary Judge had found in favour of the plaintiff, concluding that he had suffered from PTSD of varying severity. The defendant sought an appeal to the Full Bench of the WCT, which was allowed, overturning the Auxiliary Judge's decision. The plaintiff subsequently applied for judicial review of the Full Bench's decision, arguing that the appeal was not properly constituted as it did not pertain to a question of law.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the Full Bench of the WCT had jurisdiction to hear and determine the appeal, and whether it had properly exercised that jurisdiction. Specifically, the court needed to determine whether the Full Bench was limited to reviewing appeals on questions of law or if it could conduct a rehearing of the evidence. The plaintiff argued that the Full Bench had exceeded its jurisdiction by effectively rehearing the evidence without addressing any legal questions, thereby rendering the appeal incompetent.

The court held that the Full Bench's jurisdiction was strictly limited to appeals on questions of law, and it had indeed exceeded its jurisdiction by rehearing the evidence instead of focusing on the legal issues. The Full Bench had failed to address or determine any grounds that raised a question of law, thereby misapplying its jurisdiction. Consequently, the court set aside the decision of the Full Bench, finding it to be made in excess or want of jurisdiction. The application for judicial review was thus allowed, and the decision of the Full Bench was quashed.

In light of the court's decision, it declared that the appeal to the Full Bench was incompetent and ordered that the decision of the Full Bench be set aside. The case underscores the importance of strictly adhering to jurisdictional limits when exercising appellate functions within administrative tribunals.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Both of Mr Schwerdt’s claims were heard together by an Auxiliary Judge in the WCT.Mr Schwerdt’s evidence Mr Schwerdt gave evidence before the WCT. He was 61 when he gave his evidence. He had served with the MFS from May 1963 to October 1991. Mr Schwerdt gave evidence that he had suffered nightmares from the early 1960’s. He experienced what he described as “daymares” from about the time of the Ash Wednesday Bushfires in February 1983. However, he testified that he had never taken any time off work for his stress disorder because he had “tried to fight it off”. After he suffered a serious injury to his left knee in 1985 Mr Schwerdt consulted the psychiatrist Dr Jagerman for a medico-legal assessment. He claimed in his evidence that he did not know why he had seen Dr Jagerman, but the Auxiliary Judge rejected that evidence. In any event, Mr Schwerdt told Dr Jagerman that he had been happy and easy going before the injury to his knee in 1985, but that his life had been subsequently wrecked. In September 1988 Mr Schwerdt suffered a further injury to his left knee when he slipped at work. He eventually returned to alternative sedentary duties in January 1990. From that time, while he continued on workers compensation payments, Mr Schwerdt made enquiries about his superannuation entitlements. On 30 August 1990 a doctor consulted by Mr Schwerdt reported that he appeared to suffer from a stress disorder which was related to two incidents on which Mr Schwerdt attended in the course of his duties with the MFS. Those incidents were a fire in a nursing home and a motor vehicle accident in which a person had suffered severe head injuries. Both incidents occurred before the appointed day. In early August 1991, Mr Schwerdt resigned after a meeting with a number of people, including Mr Doyle, who was then secretary of the United Fire Fighters Union of South Australia. Mr Schwerdt signed a letter of resignation which Mr Doyle had drafted for him. Mr Schwerdt was thereafter paid sick leave until his retirement on 26 October 1991. Mr Schwert gave evidence that he did not discuss the contents of that letter with Mr Doyle, that he had very little idea of what had transpired at the meeting, and that he was in effect “sacked from the fire service on medical grounds”. However, that evidence was not accepted by the Auxiliary Judge. After his retirement Mr Schwerdt made several unsuccessful attempts to claim further compensation with respect to his knee injury. The Auxiliary Judge did not accept that Mr Schwerdt had suffered any knee-related incapacity after July 1991. Mr Schwerdt brought civil proceedings in August 1997 against the MFS claiming damages for what he alleged were misrepresentations made at the meeting in August 1991. Those proceedings were also unsuccessful. In February 1999, about a year before he claimed compensation for his stress disorder, Mr Schwerdt asked his general practitioner to refer him to Professor McFarlane, a senior psychiatrist who has extensive experience in medico-legal assessments and the assessment of post-traumatic stress disorders in particular. Professor McFarlane first saw Mr Schwerdt on 24 February 1999.

Decision

Reasons for decision

ANDERSON J
Even though Professor Goldney doubted that a diagnosis of stress disorder could be made, he thought that Mr Schwerdt’s stress symptoms were overwhelmingly related to the suicide of his father.The decision of the Auxiliary Judge The Auxiliary Judge expressed a number of concerns about the reliability of Mr Schwerdt’s evidence. He found that Mr Schwerdt was prone to exaggeration and that he held a strong grievance against the MFS for his perceived mistreatment over a number of issues. The Auxiliary Judge described Mr Schwerdt’s demeanour as, at times, pedantic and argumentative. Nonetheless, the Judge was satisfied, even allowing for an element of hyperbole, that the worker had been exposed to a number of traumatic incidents in the course of his employment with the MFS which he had found extremely distressing. The Auxiliary Judge did not find that any of those incidents had occurred after the appointed day. In the context of the remainder of his reasons it is quite clear that the Auxiliary Judge was not satisfied that Mr Schwerdt was distressed by any of the incidents which occurred after the appointed day. The Judge concluded:[103]Whilst the opinion of Professor Goldney has it’s [sic] attractions … on a weighing of all relevant considerations I have a preference for the opinion of Professor McFarlane overall insofar as it goes to the diagnosis of delayed onset PTSD. While I have given considerable thought to the opinion of Professor Goldney and confess some attraction in particular to his view that it is not prudent to make definitive psychiatric diagnoses when a person is using alcohol to the extent admitted to by the worker I nevertheless prefer that of Professor McFarlane on the pleaded injury. …[107]In the result I am persuaded on balance that the worker has at material times suffered PTSD of varying severity (sometimes hereafter referred to as “the injury”).[108]I add that having regard to my reservations about the worker’s credibility and the general history outlined in these reasons I am not persuaded that the worker suffers a major depressive disorder as a result of his PTSD. In the event a depressive disorder exists I think it more likely that it results from matters such as his non-compensable injuries, his turbulent private life and history as emerges from these reasons, his lack of funds as a result of the running down of his superannuation payment and his unusual (if not dysfunctional) personality. I think Professor Goldney was correct in describing the worker as a man who has “got strong views, strong opinions about himself, ...believes he’s always right, and ...[as such] ... will inevitably get depressed and anxious when things don’t go ...[his] ...way.” Insofar as the diagnosis of alcoholism is concerned again I am not persuaded that it results from or is somehow attributable to the worker’s PTSD or to put it another way is a means of self medication to control PTSD symptoms. It is clear that heavy alcohol consumption has long been a feature of the worker’s life; see eg tr 155, 156.[4][4] Schwerdt v Safecom (Emergency Services Administrative Unit) [2007] SAWCT 55.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: ANDERSON J