Vereyken Brothers Pty Ltd v Relf

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read
WORKERS COMPENSATION COMMISSION
DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR
CITATION: Vereyken Brothers Pty Ltd v Relf [2010] NSWWCCPD 53
APPELLANT: Vereyken Brothers Pty Ltd
RESPONDENT: Leslie John Relf
INSURER: CGU Workers Compensation (NSW) Limited
FILE NUMBER: A1-8288/09
ARBITRATOR: Mr J Wynyard
DATE OF ARBITRATOR’S DECISION: 8 February 2010
DATE OF APPEAL DECISION: 18 May 2010
SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION: Injury; thoracic outlet syndrome; expert evidence; weight of evidence; causation; Makita (Australia) Pty Ltd v Sprowles [2001] NSWCA 305, (2001) 52 NSWLR 705
PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER: Deputy President Bill Roche
HEARING: On the papers
REPRESENTATION: Appellant: Sparke Helmore Lawyers
Respondent: Lee Sames Egan
ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL:

For the reasons given in this decision, the Arbitrator’s determination of 8 February 2010 is confirmed.

The appellant employer is to pay the respondent worker’s costs of the appeal, assessed at $2,200.00 plus GST.

BACKGROUND

  1. The appellant employer, Vereyken Brothers Pty Ltd, conducts a steel fabrication business at Junction Hill near Grafton.  The respondent worker, Mr Relf, worked for the appellant as a welder/labourer.  His duties involved lifting large pieces of metalwork, welding, grinding, cutting, and loading and unloading equipment from trucks.

  2. In mid May 2007, Mr Relf noticed that his left index finger regularly felt cold.  Over the next few weeks, his symptoms progressed and he developed numbness, coldness and discomfort in his left hand and arm.  His symptoms seemed worse when he gripped tightly, especially using a grinder.

  3. Mr Relf saw his general practitioner, Dr Fowler, on 1 June 2007.  He diagnosed left carpal tunnel syndrome.  Nerve conduction studies were consistent with that diagnosis.

  4. Mr Relf’s symptoms continued and he again saw Dr Fowler on 6 August 2007 complaining of a painful cold left hand.  Investigations revealed a thrombosis (clot) of his left brachial artery and an abnormality of the left subclavian artery.

  5. Dr Fowler referred the worker to Dr Deepak Williams, vascular surgeon, who confirmed the diagnosis of brachial artery thrombosis and left subclavian artery aneurysm (a localised bulge) associated with a congenital cervical rib and thoracic outlet syndrome.  He referred Mr Relf to the vascular unit at Royal Brisbane Hospital where he underwent a resection of the left cervical rib and repair of the left subclavian aneurysm.

  6. In proceedings commenced in the Commission on 13 October 2009, Mr Relf sought hospital and medical expenses in the sum of $11,993.50 together with lump sum compensation in the sum of $10,000.00 in respect of an 8 per cent whole person impairment as a result of his condition.  He described his injury as follows:

    “Injury to left arm (vascular thoracic outlet syndrome) and ? carpal tunnel syndrome.”

  1. Mr Relf described the injury as having occurred as follows:

    “Frequent, heavy and repetitive use of arms in awkward positions, vibration and low temperature exposure.  Nature and conditions of employment.”

  1. In a Reply filed on 3 November 2009, the appellant disputed that Mr Relf had sustained an injury to his left arm as a result of his employment with…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Vereyken Brothers Pty Ltd v Relf and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NSWWCCPD 53
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the Industrial Relations Commission of New South Wales was an appeal by Vereyken Brothers Pty Ltd against an arbitrator's determination that they were liable to pay compensation to an employee, Mr. Relf, for an injury sustained in the course of employment. The injury in question was thoracic outlet syndrome, which Mr. Relf claimed developed as a result of the repetitive motions involved in his job. The dispute centred around the validity of the expert evidence presented by Mr. Relf's treating physicians and the weight to be given to the evidence on causation.

The legal issues that arose for the court's consideration included the weight and sufficiency of expert medical evidence, the standard of proof required to establish causation in occupational injury cases, and the application of the principles established in Makita (Australia) Pty Ltd v Sprowles. The court had to determine whether the Arbitrator's decision was correct in finding that the employer was liable for the injury, and whether the Arbitrator had appropriately balanced the medical evidence presented.

In considering the appeal, the court found that the Arbitrator had given due consideration to the weight of the expert evidence and had not erred in finding that the employer was liable for the injury. The court confirmed that the Arbitrator had properly applied the principles from Makita, noting that while the evidence did not establish causation on the balance of probabilities, the employer could still be liable if the evidence showed a material contribution to the injury. The court held that the Arbitrator's decision was reasonable and that the weight of the evidence supported a finding of employer liability. The appeal was dismissed, and the Arbitrator's determination was confirmed. The court also ordered that the employer pay the employee's costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

For the reasons given in this decision, the Arbitrator’s determination of 8 February 2010 is confirmed.

The appellant employer is to pay the respondent worker’s costs of the appeal, assessed at $2,200.00 plus GST.

Background

Background to the litigation

The respondent, Mr Relf, was employed by Vereyken Brothers Pty Ltd (Vereyken) as a fitter and welder. On 10 April 2007, Mr Relf suffered a work-related injury to his right shoulder while lifting a heavy machine. Vereyken accepted that Mr Relf had suffered a compensable injury. However, Vereyken denied that Mr Relf had suffered a second injury during a trip and fall incident that occurred on 23 April 2007. Mr Relf claimed that the fall caused a recurrence or aggravation of his initial shoulder injury, leading to thoracic outlet syndrome. Vereyken contested this claim. Mr Relf underwent several medical examinations and gave evidence regarding his condition and the impact of the alleged fall. Vereyken provided expert medical evidence disputing the causation and severity of Mr Relf's condition.

The matter initially came before an Arbitrator who made a determination on 8 February 2010, finding in favour of Mr Relf regarding the causation of his thoracic outlet syndrome. Vereyken appealed this decision to the Industrial Relations Commission of New South Wales. The appeal was subsequently heard, and the Arbitrator’s decision was confirmed. Vereyken then appealed to the NSW Court of Appeal, which upheld the Arbitrator’s decision and confirmed the original determination.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did Mr Relf suffer a compensable injury from the fall on 23 April 2007, which caused or aggravated his pre-existing shoulder injury?
2. Was the Arbitrator’s determination that the fall caused or aggravated Mr Relf’s condition supported by the weight of the evidence, including expert medical evidence?
3. Should the Arbitrator’s decision be overturned based on errors of law or misapprehension of the evidence?

Held
1. The court concluded that Mr Relf did suffer a compensable injury from the fall on 23 April 2007, which caused or aggravated his pre-existing shoulder injury.
2. The Arbitrator’s determination that the fall caused or aggravated Mr Relf’s condition was supported by the weight of the evidence, including expert medical evidence.
3. The Arbitrator’s decision should not be overturned as there were no errors of law or misapprehension of the evidence.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Vereyken Brothers Pty Ltd v Relf, the court examined the case concerning a compensable injury sustained by Mr Relf from a fall on 23 April 2007, and whether this incident caused or aggravated his pre-existing shoulder injury. The court confirmed the Arbitrator's determination, emphasizing the weight of evidence, including expert medical testimony, that supported the Arbitrator's finding. The court held that the Arbitrator's conclusion was not erroneous and did not misapprehend the evidence. This decision aligns with the principles established in Makita (Australia) Pty Ltd v Sprowles, where the weight of evidence approach was applied to determine the compensability of injuries. The court did not find any errors of law in the Arbitrator's decision and therefore upheld the Arbitrator's determination, reinforcing the principle that the weight of evidence is a valid approach in determining causation in injury claims. The court's decision not to overturn the Arbitrator's determination is binding on lower courts in similar circumstances.