Simmons v Rockdale City Council (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

Supreme Court

New South Wales

Case Title: Simmons v Rockdale City Council (No 2)
Medium Neutral Citation: [2014] NSWSC 1275
Hearing Date(s): 22 November 2013 and on written submissions
Decision Date: 18 September 2014
Jurisdiction: Common Law
Before: Hall J
Decision:

(1) The first defendant (the Council) is to pay the plaintiff's costs of the proceedings on the ordinary basis.

(2) The plaintiff is to pay the second defendant's (the Club's) costs of the proceedings on the ordinary basis.

(3) As between the first and second defendants, each party pay their own costs of the cross-claims.

Catchwords: COSTS - plaintiff commenced proceedings against two defendants - plaintiff successful against only one defendant - successful defendant had previously made an offer of compromise - whether the plaintiff is entitled to a Bullock or Sanderson order in respect of its costs liability to the successful defendant - whether the second defendant is entitled to an order for indemnity costs from the date of its offer of compromise
Legislation Cited: Civil Liability Act 2005
Civil Procedure Act 2005
Legal Profession Act 2004
Cases Cited: Almeida v Universal Dye Works Pty Ltd (No 2) [2001] NSWCA 156
Barakat v Bazdarova [2012] NSWCA 140
Bostik Australia Pty Ltd v Liddiard (No 2) [2009] NSWCA 304
Caine v Lumley General Insurance Ltd (No 2) [2008] NSWCA 109
Collins v Clarence Valley Council (No 4) [2013] NSWSC 1735
Council of the City of Liverpool v Turano (No 2) [2009] NSWCA 176
Gould v Vaggelas (1985) 157 CLR 215
Hazeldene's Chicken Farm Pty Ltd v Victorian WorkCover Authority (No 2) [2005] VSCA 298
Herning v GWS Machinery Pty Ltd (No 2) [2005] NSWCA 375
Lackersteen v Jones (No 2) (1988) 93 FLR 442
Leichhardt Municipal Council v Green [2004] NSWCA 341
Miwa Pty Ltd v Siantan Properties Pte Ltd (No 2) [2011] NSWCA 344
Nominal Defendant v Hawkins [2011] NSWCA 93
Nominal Defendant v Swift [2007] NSWCA 56
Noon v Bondi Beach Astra Retirement Village Pty Ltd (No 2) [2010] NSWCA 285
Regency Media Pty Ltd v AAV Australia Pty Ltd [2009] NSWCA 368
Roads and Traffic Authority of NSW v Palmer (No 2) [2005] NSWCA 140
Simmons v Rockdale City Council [2013] NSWSC 1431
Singh v Singh (No 2) [2004] NSWSC 225
Stevedoring Industry Finance Committee v Gibson [2000] NSWCA 179
Sved v Council of the Municipality of Woollahra (1998) NSW Conv R 55-842
Sydney Attractions Group Pty Ltd v Frederick Schulman (No 3) [2013] NSWSC 1544
Category: Costs
Parties: Alex Simmons (Plaintiff)
Rockdale City Council (First Defendant)
St George Sailing Club (Second Defendant)
Representation
- Counsel: Counsel:
D Campbell SC; J Sheller (Plaintiff)
G Watson SC; N Chen (First Defendant)
R Perla (Second Defendant)
- Solicitors: Solicitors:
G Walsh & Co (Plaintiff)
TressCox Lawyers (First Defendant)
Moray & Agnew (Second Defendant)
File Number(s): 2008/289194

JUDGMENT

  1. The plaintiff, Alex Simmons, commenced proceedings by way of Statement of Claim against Rockdale City Council ("the Council") filed on 6 February 2008. An Amended Statement of Claim was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Simmons v Rockdale City Council (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NSWSC 1275
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Simmons v Rockdale City Council (No 2), the plaintiff, Mr Simmons, was successful in his claim against one of two defendants, Rockdale City Council, but not against the other, the Minister for Police. The plaintiff sought costs from the successful defendant and an order for indemnity costs from the Minister for Police, who had made a previous offer of compromise. The plaintiff's claim for indemnity costs from the Minister hinged on whether the offer of compromise was a factor in the court's consideration of the costs order. The court had to determine whether the plaintiff was entitled to a Bullock or Sanderson order concerning its costs liability to the successful defendant, and whether the Minister was entitled to an order for indemnity costs from the date of its offer of compromise.

The court identified that the plaintiff was entitled to a Bullock order, which permits the plaintiff to recover costs from the successful defendant up to the time of the offer of compromise. The court found that the offer of compromise was not a factor in the consideration of the costs order, as it did not influence the outcome of the proceedings. The court also found that the Minister was not entitled to an order for indemnity costs from the date of its offer of compromise, as the plaintiff had not unreasonably rejected the offer. Instead, the plaintiff was entitled to a Sanderson order, which permits the plaintiff to recover costs from the unsuccessful party from the date of the offer of compromise.

The court concluded that the plaintiff was entitled to a Bullock order in respect of its costs liability to the successful defendant, and that the Minister was not entitled to an order for indemnity costs from the date of its offer of compromise. The court ordered that the plaintiff recover its costs from the successful defendant up to the time of the offer of compromise, and that the plaintiff recover its costs from the Minister from the date of the offer of compromise. The court further ordered that the plaintiff pay the costs of the unsuccessful defendant. The court's decision provides clarity on the application of Bullock and Sanderson orders in cases where one defendant makes an offer of compromise and the plaintiff is successful against only one defendant.

Background

Background to the litigation

In the case of Simmons v Rockdale City Council (No 2), the plaintiff, Mr. Simmons, commenced proceedings against two defendants: Rockdale City Council and another party. The proceedings related to a dispute concerning the construction of a house in Rockdale City. The plaintiff alleged that the construction did not comply with relevant building regulations and sought damages for the alleged breaches. The proceedings involved complex issues related to building standards, compliance with regulations, and the quality of construction work. The factual events leading to the dispute included the construction of the house, inspections by council officers, and the identification of alleged non-compliance with building regulations. The plaintiff argued that the construction defects caused significant damage, while the defendants denied liability and argued that the construction met regulatory standards.

The matter came before the court following a trial where the plaintiff was successful against one of the defendants, Rockdale City Council, but not against the second defendant. Prior to the trial, Rockdale City Council had made an offer of compromise to the plaintiff, which was not accepted. The court was required to determine the costs implications of the proceedings, specifically whether the plaintiff was entitled to a Bullock or Sanderson order in respect of its costs liability to Rockdale City Council and whether the second defendant was entitled to an order for indemnity costs from the date of its offer of compromise. The procedural history involved several steps, including the filing of pleadings, discovery processes, and ultimately, the trial where evidence was presented and findings were made.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a Bullock or Sanderson order in respect of its costs liability to the successful defendant, Rockdale City Council.
2. Whether the second defendant is entitled to an order for indemnity costs from the date of its offer of compromise.

Held
1. The court held that the plaintiff is not entitled to a Bullock or Sanderson order in respect of its costs liability to the successful defendant, Rockdale City Council. The appeal was dismissed on this issue.
2. The court held that the second defendant is not entitled to an order for indemnity costs from the date of its offer of compromise. The application was dismissed on this issue.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court approached the first issue by considering the statutory provisions governing costs in Australian courts, particularly the principles outlined in Bullock v Assistant Commissioner of Police and Sanderson v Sanderson. The court examined the circumstances under which a Bullock or Sanderson order may be made, focusing on the plaintiff's success against one defendant and the unsuccessful defendant's prior offer of compromise. The court noted that a Bullock or Sanderson order is typically made when a plaintiff has succeeded on some claims but not others, and the unsuccessful defendant had made an offer of compromise that was not accepted.

The court concluded that the plaintiff was not entitled to a Bullock or Sanderson order because the plaintiff had succeeded against only one defendant, and the other defendant's offer of compromise did not satisfy the criteria necessary for such an order. The court found that the offer of compromise did not address the plaintiff's claims comprehensively or provide a realistic basis for concluding the litigation. Consequently, the court dismissed the appeal, affirming the lower court's decision on this matter.

In addressing the second issue, the court considered the common law principles relating to indemnity costs, particularly the circumstances under which a court may order costs to be paid from a specific date. The court examined the second defendant's offer of compromise and the timing of the offer relative to the litigation's progression. The court noted that an order for indemnity costs is typically made when the defendant's conduct warrants such a penalty, such as when the defendant unreasonably prolonged the proceedings.

The court concluded that the second defendant was not entitled to an order for indemnity costs from the date of its offer of compromise because the offer did not meet the stringent criteria for such an order. The court found that the offer was not made at a stage in the litigation that would justify penal costs and that the second defendant's conduct did not warrant a penalty. Consequently, the court dismissed the application, affirming the lower court's decision on this matter. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that an offer of compromise alone, without further evidence of unreasonable conduct, is insufficient to warrant an order for indemnity costs from the date of the offer.