Catchwords MIGRATION – refusal of Class XA (subclass 866) Protection Visa – citizen of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia – criminal record in Australia – attempted rape – sexual assault – 1951 Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees – s 36(1C) of Migration Act 1958 (Cth) –Applicant has been convicted by final judgment of a particularly serious crime – whether Applicant is a danger to the Australian community – non-exhaustive factors considered –Tribunal is satisfied Applicant is a danger to the Australian community – disentitling provision at s 36(1C)(b) of the Act enlivened – decision under review affirmed
Secondary Materials Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees, opened for signature 28 July 1951, 189 UNTS 137 (entered into force 22 April 1954) as amended by the Protocol Relating to the Status of Refugees, opened for signature 31 January 1967, 606 UNTS 267 (entered into force 4 October 1967) (together “the Refugee Convention”)
Sentencing Advisory Council (Vic), ‘Imprisonment’ (Web Page, updated 7 May 2024) align="left">REASONS FOR DECISION
Senior Member A. Nikolic
INTRODUCTION
The Applicant has asked the Tribunal to review the Respondent’s decision to refuse his application for a Protection (subclass 866) Visa (‘Protection Visa’).
The hearing was held by videoconference at the Tribunal’s Melbourne Registry on 2 September 2025. The Asylum Seeker Resource Centre (‘ASRC
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read SDCX and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (Migration... and more:
The parties in this case are a citizen of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, referred to as the Applicant, and the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship, referred to as the Respondent. The Applicant applied for a Class XA (subclass 866) Protection Visa, which was refused by a delegate of the Respondent. The Applicant sought a review of this decision by the Tribunal. The central issue before the Tribunal was whether the Applicant, who has been convicted by final judgment of a particularly serious crime and has a history of criminal conduct, poses a danger to the Australian community. This determination was crucial under section 36(1C)(b) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth), which disentitles a person to a Protection Visa if they meet these criteria.
The Tribunal considered various factors in its decision, including the Applicant’s criminal history, his mental health conditions, and his potential for rehabilitation. The Applicant has a significant history of criminal activity in Australia, including offenses of attempted rape and sexual assault. These crimes were committed while the Applicant was under the influence of alcohol, highlighting a pattern of violence when intoxicated. The Tribunal also noted the Applicant's multiple diagnoses of mental health conditions, including PTSD, Alcohol Dependence Disorder, Obsessive Compulsive Disorder, and Major Depressive Disorder. Despite these conditions, the Tribunal found that the Applicant's history of recidivism and the severity of his crimes indicated a high risk of future violence. Consequently, the Tribunal concluded that the Applicant is a danger to the Australian community, affirming the visa refusal decision.
The Tribunal's reasoning was grounded in the statutory concept of what constitutes a 'danger' to the community, focusing on the probability and consequence of harm. The Applicant's extensive criminal history, coupled with his failure to rehabilitate despite multiple opportunities, led the Tribunal to conclude that he poses a significant risk of causing serious physical or sexual harm. Given these findings, the Tribunal upheld the decision to refuse the Applicant's Protection Visa application under section 36(1C)(b) of the Migration Act.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
For the following reasons, the Tribunal affirms the reviewable decision. BACKGROUND FACTS The Applicant is a 44-year-old citizen of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (‘Saudi Arabia’) and one of five children.[2] His mother, siblings, and other relatives continue to live overseas.[3] [2] Exhibit R2, 4.[3] Exhibit R1, 210. The Applicant’s extensive overseas travel includes completion of tertiary study in the United States of America (‘USA’).[4] He first arrived in Australia on a Tourist Visa in September 2022.[5] Approximately eight weeks later, on 7 November 2022, he was assisted by the ASRC to lodge a Protection Visa application.[6] He stated that he had not previously applied for refugee status or protection.[7] The Applicant also stated he was convicted of an offence in 2022 while living overseas, for which he received a sentence of ‘18 months’.[8] It was submitted on his behalf that he is unable to access overseas records about this.[9][4] Ibid, 209; Exhibit R2, 25 [9], 27 [28].[5] Exhibit R1, 19.[6] Ibid 38-70.[7] Ibid 47.[8] Exhibit R1, 52.[9] Ibid 207 [11]. The Applicant’s crimes in Australia commenced soon after his arrival and include violence, dishonesty, and breaches of conditional liberty.[10] His most serious offending occurred in 2024 after release from an earlier period of imprisonment. This resulted in convictions that include attempted rape and sexual assault.[11] He was sentenced to 28 months imprisonment for the former and 14 months for the latter.[12] His total effective sentence was 2 years and 7 months. He remains imprisoned to the present day.[10] Ibid, 211-213, 218-226. [11] Exhibit R2, 34-42.[12] Ibid 1-2. Correspondence passed between the Respondent and the ASRC in 2023 and 2024 about the Applicant’s protection claims.[13] In 2024 while imprisoned, he attended a video interview with the Respondent, assisted by the ASRC.[14] [13] Ibid 59, 188 [1], 187, 206-207.[14] Ibid 33, 173, 182, 197, 199, 206 [4]. On 3 April 2025, a delegate of the Respondent refused the Protection Visa application. Although the Applicant was found to satisfy the definition of a refugee at s 5H(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (‘the Act’), the delegate found he did not satisfy 36(1C)(b).[15] This is a disentitling provision that is enlivened if a person has been convicted by final judgement of a particularly serious crime and is a danger to the Australian community. [15] Exhibit R1, 15-37. On 28 April 2025, the Applicant asked the Tribunal to review the visa refusal decision.[16][16] Ibid 5. On 21 May 2025, the Tribunal held a case management hearing to issue scheduling orders for hearing dates and submission of documents. The following then occurred:(a)The Tribunal provided the Applicant with contact details for potential sources of pro bono assistance although he advised the ASRC may still represent him. He refused an example of what a Statement of Facts, Issues, and Contentions (‘SFIC’)[17] might contain and said he did not intend to call witnesses or submit further documents.(b)Provision was nevertheless made in scheduling orders for the Applicant to provide any other documents by 18 July 2025 and a response to the Respondent’s materials by 28 August 2025. He subsequently did neither. (c)The Tribunal contacted the Applicant through prison staff on 22 July 2025 to confirm his intentions. An email from the prison on the same day confirmed he did not wish to lodge any further documents.[17] A SFIC is comparable to a pleadings document in a court proceeding. It serves to identify / narrow the issues in dispute and helps ensure both sides are aware of each other’s case. JURISDICTION, THE REFUGEE CONVENTION AND LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
A Hearing Book numbering 934 pages was taken into evidence,[25] as was an 831-page bundle of documents obtained under summons.[26] The Tribunal has considered documents previously lodged on the Applicant’s behalf by the ASRC and other lawyers.[27][25] Exhibit R1.[26] Exhibit R2.[27] Exhibit R1, 10, 20-22, 86-96, 206-210; Exhibit R2, 3-11, 18-30.Oral evidence The Applicant was the only witness. An interpreter in the Arabic language was provided at his request and remained throughout the hearing. He chose, however, to speak in English. Prior to the commencement of his evidence, the Tribunal explained the hearing process, key issues to be decided, and his privilege against self-incrimination. The Tribunal is satisfied he understood this. The Applicant’s oral testimony is summarised as follows:(a)The Applicant gave evidence under affirmation and confirmed previous advice that everything he intends to rely upon is contained in Exhibits R1 and R2.(b)The Applicant referred to difficult personal issues while growing up, including his bisexuality and alcohol abuse. He drank alcohol since his teenage years. His family had money, and his father supported him financially. This enabled the Applicant to travel to nearby Gulf countries to drink alcohol where rules were not as stringent.(c)The Applicant said efforts in Saudi Arabia to address his addictions were ineffective because ‘they don’t believe in psychology much’. He recalled ‘rehab’ on six occasions in Saudi Arabia for up to three months and once in Kuwait. He claimed to have been sober for up to three years. The Applicant considers the treatment he received was insufficient because the facility was mainly for those suffering heroin addiction. He claimed no psychiatrists or psychologists were present but a representative from Narcotics Anonymous (‘NA’) spoke with patients.(d)The Applicant recalled relapses after rehabilitative stays, which led him to conclude that alcohol was not his main problem. He attended NA and Alcoholic Anonymous (‘AA’) meetings in multiple countries since 2005 where some participants were sober ‘for a long time’, got married, and felt ‘serene’. The Applicant said he is ‘not like them’, however, because he ‘can’t stop drinking’. He recalled overseas visits, including to Indonesia and Malaysia where he was assaulted while drunk, had property stolen, and came to police attention. He said police treated him poorly in these countries because they believe Saudi Arabian men only visit ‘to fuck their women’.(e)The Applicant said he completed an undergraduate degree in the USA funded by his father. He recalled drinking heavily but lived his life with greater freedom. Upon return to Saudi Arabia, the Applicant said he felt depressed, which escalated his drinking. He worked for his mother’s business and opened his own store about 15 years ago but became ‘sicker’ and the business failed. He recalled spending time in Somalia and tried new relationships. He also smuggled alcohol when returning from overseas travel. The Applicant said he felt ‘sick…angry...lonely…depressed’. He later opened other stores but claims these failed during the COVID pandemic. The Applicant said he became estranged from his family because of alcoholism and has not spoken with his sisters for about 17 years. He said there has been no contact with his mother since he arrived in Australia in 2022.[28][28] Ibid 41.(f)The Applicant said one of the reasons he applied for ‘asylum’ in Australia was to access ‘medical rights’. He found life here was ‘triple or four times’ the cost of Gulf countries and recalled his money ran out fast. He referred to homelessness and feeling disconnected from those who were healthy and working, which caused him to be ‘angry’. He recalled being banned from a ‘gambling place’.(g)The Applicant claimed that conditions suffered since childhood ‘make [him] drink’. In 2024 he was diagnosed with Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (‘PTSD’), Alcohol Dependence Disorder (‘ADD’), Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (‘OCD’), and Major Depressive Disorder (MDD’). The diagnosing psychologist was commissioned by counsel in one of his criminal proceedings.[29] The Applicant said this was the first time he became aware of his ‘illness’.(h)The Applicant recalled ‘many’ efforts in Australia to address his alcoholism. This included an Odyssey House placement about 8 months after arrival. The Tribunal notes this was Court-ordered after his May 2023 convictions for recklessly causing injury, throwing a missile to endanger a person, aggravated assault of a female, and other crimes.[30] He also sought placements at several hospitals. The Applicant described support received in Australia as ‘beautiful’ and claimed to have been sober for six-months after the Odyssey House program. He considers the support he has received is insufficient because he relapsed. The Applicant said medications made ‘sleep a lot’ and he was limited to charitable support because of no funds.(i)The Applicant said the Salvation Army, refugee support groups and others gave him food and accommodation. He attributed failed to maintain stable accommodation as resulting from his mental health conditions. The Applicant related a story about two elderly Australian women in their 70s ‘just like [his] mum’, who took him into their home after a period of ‘rehab’ and provided accommodation and food. Both women later took out intervention orders (‘IVO’) against him, the last of which only ceased in April 2025.[31] The Applicant explained their support was conditional on sobriety and not bringing trouble to their home. He relapsed, however, stole alcohol from nearby stores, and was found by police drinking it at their residence. The Applicant claimed, without corroboration, that these women will still do anything for him. The Applicant also recalled an occasion while sober, when he met grandparents with a grandchild in a restaurant. They gave him $50 for food, a blanket and other support. He relapsed and spent the $50 on alcohol.(j)In terms of his crimes, the Applicant claimed he never stole from or hurt individuals ‘on the streets’. Without alcohol, however, he felt like he was ‘going to die’, so he stole from shops. He referred to a retail group in Australia as: ‘a rich company that makes billions’, stating: ‘You don’t harm a rich company by taking…alcohol or food’. (k)The Applicant said he felt ‘sick’ for a lot of his stay in Australia but became ‘very sick’ around the time he received a ‘120-day sentence’. The Tribunal inferred this was a reference to an aggregate 136-day sentence received in April 2024 for two counts of assaulting an emergency worker on duty, two counts of committing an indictable offence on bail, two counts of contravening bail, and three counts of theft.[32](l)At the time of the attempted rape and sexual assault, the Applicant said he had only been out of prison for ‘14 days’ during which he was ‘stealing alcohol and drinking’. Following arrest, he could not believe what police alleged until he saw the video of him attacking a lone young female shopworker. He claimed to have no memory of this and recalled thinking: ‘why am I always struggling – always sick’. The Applicant said he feels sorry for the victim and if this had happened to his sister, he would want the perpetrator imprisoned and ‘kicked out’. (m)The Applicant referred to rehabilitative efforts in prison. He also agreed during cross-examination that he returned positive tests for Buprenorphine,[33] claiming ‘everybody uses it – it’s everywhere’. When asked why he used it, the Applicant did not know. When pressed, he said it’s because he is an ‘alcoholic… a drug addict’. He claimed to have used Buprenorphine ‘four or five times’, most recently in May 2025. The Applicant also accepted the accuracy of custodial reports about him running up drug debts and receiving threats from inmates.(n)When asked about potential sources of support in Australia, the Applicant said an organisation called Muslim Connect and ‘some Somali guys’ said they would assist with accommodation. To qualify for some support, however, he needs ‘to be on Centrelink’. There is no statement from Muslim Connect or the men he referred to. When asked how he would provide for himself, the Applicant said he wants to qualify for Centrelink and intends calling his mother in Saudi Arabia, who previously sent him money. She is almost 80 years’ old now and he does not know if she can help.(o)The Applicant said he is fortunate to be in the ‘best country in the world’, will never touch alcohol again, and wants to make a positive contribution. If he receives a visa, work rights and required healthcare support he intends seeking employment in a coffee shop, restaurant, or clothing store. He also wants to be supported by a psychologist who can tell him: ‘take this medication, do this, do that, and everything will be OK’. The Applicant aspires to ‘go somewhere hot’ and referred to the Gold Coast. When asked if he knows anyone there he responded: ‘No’. When asked if Muslim Connect could help with accommodation on the Gold Coast, the Applicant replied: ‘If I get…work rights, I won’t need Muslim Connect’. The Applicant also aspires to open a ‘fashion line’ and a ‘camping rehab’ facility on the Gold Coast. His vision for the latter is that recovering alcoholics and drug addicts can pitch a tent and receive long-term treatment for their needs.(p)The Applicant said the Australian Government recently ‘signed an agreement with Nauru’ and he would relocate there if required support was provided. He is unsure if he would choose to remain there, but does not want to return to Saudi Arabia, stating: ‘I have been everywhere around the world – just find me a place’.[29] Ibid 194 [45].[30] Exhibit R2, 723.[31] Ibid 494.[32] Ibid 32.[33] Buprenorphine is a prescription drug used to treat opioid dependence.DANGER TO THE COMMUNITY
Decision
Reasons for decision
The Applicant has been convicted by final judgement of a particularly serious crime. There are reasonable grounds to consider he poses a high and unacceptable risk of committing further physical or sexual violence that may cause serious harm. He constitutes a danger to the Australian community within the meaning of the Act. DECISION It follows that s 36(1C)(b) of the Act is enlivened and the reviewable decision affirmed.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The statutory concept of what constitutes ‘a danger’ to the community centres on ‘probability and consequence’ of harm.[40] Relevant factors can include past crimes and other conduct, sentences, remorse, rehabilitation, protective factors, and recidivism risk. Commission of a particularly serious crime is the starting point, followed by a prospective analysis to determine if reasonable grounds exist to consider a person poses a danger to the community. Any framework adopted is non-exhaustive, guides assessments about questions of fact, and is not a rigid test nor applied mechanistically. A person is a danger if: (a)the risk of harm they pose exceeds that of ordinary personal interactions; (b)the harm caused if the danger is realised is not inconsequential and is of a physical or psychological nature; and (c)would affect any member of the Australian community.CONSIDERATION: IS THE APPLICANT A DANGER TO THE COMMUNITY[40] DMQ20, [107].Addiction, offences and misconduct The Applicant has a long history of addiction.[41] He reports depression and anxiety for most of his life,[42] persistent alcoholism, and drug use.[43] He referred to judicial punishment overseas and multiple rehabilitative attempts.[44] His evidence is that he has suffered multiple undiagnosed psychological conditions for much of his life, which were first diagnosed in Australia in 2024, and that this is a significant contributory factor to his offending.[45] [41] Exhibit R1, 88 [15], 90 [35], 92 [50], 102-3, 191-2 [28]-[29], [33], 35], 194-6 [43]-[48] [50]-[51] [55], 201 [12] and [19]; Exhibit R2, 21 [34], 25 [13], 28 [29], 232, 724, 738, 740, 761. [42] Exhibit R2, 761.[43] Exhibit R1, 191 [28], 205 [38]; Exhibit R2, 6 [3.11].[44] Exhibit R1, 193 [38].[45] Ibid 21, 188; Exhibit R2, 10, 28 [33]-[34]. During the Applicant’s three-year stay in Australia there are reports of him being a ‘chronic alcoholic’ who ‘drinks to black out most days’ and ‘does crazy things’.[46] To the extent his oral testimony conflicts with convictions, the Tribunal prefers the latter. His guilty pleas constitute admission to and acceptance of all charges.[47] It is also impermissible to impugn the essential basis of court findings.[48] No weight is placed, however, on charges dismissed under s 76 of the Sentencing Act 1991[49] (Vic) or that may be pending.[50][46] Exhibit R1, 99, 192 [31]; Exhibit R2, 495.[47] Maxwell v R (1996) 184 CLR 501, [19].[48] Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Daniele (1981) 61 FLR 354 at 358; Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v SRT (1999) 91 FCR 234 at 244–5; HZCP v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 1803, [102] (Bromberg J).[49] This provides that even if a court is satisfied that a person is guilty of an offence, it can dismiss the charge without recording a conviction.[50] Exhibit R1, 32-34; Exhibit R2, 723. The Applicant’s most serious offences occurred in April 2024. It is sufficient to note he attacked a young female shop assistant who suffered a terrifying ordeal from ‘significant and repeated acts of violence’. He was drunk[51] and his motivation appears to have been sexual gratification. A Victim Impact Statement refers to the victim’s continuing fears, insecurity, and isolation, with adverse impacts on her mental health, ability to work, and relationships.[52] There is no evidence the harm suffered by the victim is other than enduring. [51] Exhibit R2, 19 [9].[52] Exhibit R2, 12-13 [3]-[5].