Scott and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read

Scott and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (Migration) [2025] ARTA 997 (4 July 2025)

Applicant/s:  Martin Gilroy Elliot Scott

Respondent:  Minister for Immigration and Citizenship

Tribunal Number:                2025/3135

Tribunal:General Member J Papalia

Place:Perth

Date of decision:                 4 July 2025

Date of written reasons:     9 July 2025

Decision:The Tribunal affirms the reviewable decision.  

Statement made on 09 July 2025 at 4:13pm

........................................................................           

General Member

CATCHWORDS

MIGRATION – visa cancellation – Five year resident return visa – Mandatory cancellation under s 501(3A) of Migration Act 1958 – Where Applicant does not pass the character test –– Using electronic communication to procure child under 16 to engage in sexual activity - whether there is another reason to revoke cancellation – consideration of Direction no. 110 – protection of Australian community – Meaning of ‘The safety of the Australian Community’- Whether cogent reasons to depart from government policy - strength, nature and duration of ties to Australia - best interests of minor children in Australia affected by the decision - expectations of the Australian community – legal consequences of decision – extent of impediments if removed - Applicant is a 63-year-old citizen of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland – Reviewable decision affirmed

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)

Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024 (Cth)

Criminal Procedure Act 2004 (WA)

Criminal Procedure Rules 2005 (WA)

Migration Act 1958 (Cth)

Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth)

CASES

Clive Elliot Jennings & Co Pty Ltd v Western Australian Planning Commission [2002] WASCA 276

Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1979) 2 ALD 60

Erujin Pty Ltd v West Australian Planning Commission [2010] WASC 326

Hinton v Western Australia (2023) 306 A Crim R 23

Mizen v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2025] FCAFC 84

Plaintiff M1/2021 v Minister for Home Affairs (2022) 275 CLR 582

RCLN v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2024] FCA 876

Re CLKQ and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2025] ARTA 231

Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634

Re Kumsuz and Commissioner of Police (unreported, Administrative Decisions Tribunal of New South Wales, 23 March 1999)

Re Mizen and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2023] AATA 3113

RQRP v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] FCA 266

Shi v Migration Agents Registration Authority (2008) 235 CLR 286

Singh v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs (2023) 296 FCR 582

Tanielu v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2014) 225 FCR 424

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Direction no. 110 – Visa refusal and cancellation under section 501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under section 501CA (Cth)

Statement of Reasons

The decision in this matter was made on 4 July 2025 and provided to the parties with a note that written reasons would be provided within a reasonable time.[1] These are those written reasons.

THE APPLICATION

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Scott and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (Migratio... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ARTA 997
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Applicant, a British citizen, challenged the Minister’s decision to refuse to revoke the cancellation of his Five Year Resident Return Visa under s 501CA(4) of the Migration Act 1958. The Applicant’s visa was cancelled on 7 December 2023 because of his sentence and incarceration, pursuant to s 501(3A) of the Migration Act. The Applicant made representations to revoke the cancellation on 18 December 2023, which the Minister refused on 11 April 2025. The Applicant sought review of this decision in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). The primary issue before the Tribunal was whether there were cogent reasons to depart from the government policy, as outlined in Direction no. 110, which provides for the mandatory cancellation of visas for certain criminal offences. The Tribunal had to consider the safety of the Australian community, the meaning of ‘the safety of the Australian community’, and the strength, nature, and duration of the Applicant’s ties to Australia, including the best interests of his minor children.

The Tribunal found that the Applicant did not pass the character test, as he had been convicted of using electronic communication to procure a child under 16 to engage in sexual activity, an offence that warranted the mandatory cancellation of his visa. However, the Tribunal also considered whether there were cogent reasons to depart from the government policy. It examined the Applicant’s ties to Australia, including his long-term residence, employment, and role as a carer for his wife who has significant health issues. The Tribunal also considered the impact of the decision on the Applicant’s minor grandchildren. Ultimately, the Tribunal found that while the Applicant had strong ties to Australia, the nature of his criminal offence was such that it warranted the mandatory cancellation of his visa, and there were no cogent reasons to depart from the government policy. The Tribunal affirmed the Minister’s decision not to revoke the visa cancellation.

No further orders were made by the Tribunal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The Tribunal took oral evidence from the Applicant, his wife, sister, and oldest son. BACKGROUND The Applicant is a fitter and turner by trade.[14] He and his wife met in Glasgow, and they married there in March 1983.[15] The pair emigrated to Australia shortly thereafter because they had extended family already resident here.[16] [14] Evidence on 23 June 2025. [15] Exhibit 1, p 138. [16] See Exhibit 1, p 120. The Applicant’s first son, D (41), was born in Perth in 1984.[17] [17] See Exhibit 1, p 79 [7]. The Applicant commenced his State employment in September 1985.[18] [18] See Exhibit 1, p 79 [8]. The Applicant’s second son, B (38), was born in Kalgoorlie in 1987.[19] [19] See Exhibit 1, p 79 [9]. The family moved to Albany in or around 1989.[20] During this period, the Applicant’s sister also emigrated to Australia.[21][20] See Exhibit 1, p 80 [10]. [21] Ibid. In or around 2004/2005, the Applicant’s wife was diagnosed with a rare neurological condition called transverse myelitis.[22] This condition causes long-standing deficits, and the wife otherwise suffers from bilateral trigeminal neuralgia (pain on both sides of the face), hypertension, cholesterol, osteoarthritis and diabetes.[23] The Applicant has generally been his wife’s carer since.[24] He was previously in receipt of some form of carer benefits prior to his incarceration.[25] However, the wife has more recently been in receipt of a disability support pension (DSP), including at the single rate.[26] [22] See Exhibit 1, pp 80 [11], 135-136. [23] See Exhibit 1, pp 128, 135.[24] See Exhibit 1, p 132 [4]. [25] See Exhibit 1, p 80 [11]. [26] Evidence on 23 June 2025; Exhibit 1, p 137. The Applicant and his wife have been separated for some time, but they continued to live together (until the Applicant’s incarceration and immigration detention) primarily because of the wife’s need for ongoing support and care.[27][27] See Exhibit 1, p 270. It was an agreed fact that the Applicant’s wife booked a flight to the UK on the morning of 24 January 2023, and that she departed from Perth (with the Applicant taking her to the airport by road) on 26 January 2023. She returned to Australia on 22 February 2023. The Applicant was charged with the criminal offences on or about 21 February 2023. He gave an indicated plea of guilty in April 2023, formally pleaded guilty on 4 May 2023 and was ultimately committed for sentence in the District Court.[28] He was on bail in Albany until his sentencing in Perth on 2 November 2023.[29] During the Tribunal hearing, it became apparent that there was an issue with the District Court’s records from the sentencing (discussed further below in the context of the character test). [28] See Exhibit 1, p 245. [29] See Exhibit 1, pp 249-282. The Applicant was released on a parole order on 30 September 2024.[30] He has been detained under s 189(1) of the Migration Act at Yongah Hill Immigration Detention Centre since. [30] See Exhibit 1, pp 110-111. The Applicant’s oldest son has a daughter, M (8).[31] She resides in Perth, with her mother (who is estranged from D, since M’s infancy).[32] D moved from Perth to Albany at some stage between 2022 and 2024, ostensibly to care for his mother from at least April 2024.[33] During this period, he had another partner and child. However, for reasons that do not need to be stated, this relationship ended, and it was agreed by the parties that the second child will not be affected by this decision. [31] See Exhibit 1, p 130. [32] Evidence on 23 June 2025. [33] See Exhibit 1, p 358 [5]; cf Exhibit 1, pp 60, 80 [14], 98 [3].

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

In its first deportation case, the inaugural President of the AAT (Brennan J) posed four questions:There are four related but distinct issues which may arise in any application to review a decision to order deportation under s 13(a) of the Migration Act 1958. First, is it a case where the Minister may order deportation under s 13(a)? Second, if the Minister has a policy which governs or affects his exercise of the power, is that policy consistent with the Act? Third, if the Minister has such a policy is any cause shown why the Tribunal ought not to apply that policy either generally or in the particular case? And finally, on the facts of the case and having regard to any policy considerations which ought to be applied, is the Minister’s decision the right or preferable decision?[38](emphasis added)[38] Re Becker and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1977) 1 ALD 158, 161-162 (emphasis added). The Full Court subsequently held in Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1979) 2 ALD 60, 68, that:The question for the determination of the Tribunal is whether [the reviewable decision] was the correct or preferable one on the material before the Tribunal.(emphasis added) In dealing with the remitted decision arising from that decision, Justice Brennan observed in Drake (No 2):The Tribunal’s function, when it undertakes a review of a Minister’s decision to deport, is to form its own judgment of what is the correct or preferable decision in the circumstances of the particular case as revealed in the material before the Tribunal (Drake’s case, supra, at 589). It is discretionary judgment …and ministerial policy may play a part in it.[39][39] Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634, 636. The High Court confirmed the test stated in Drake’s case in Shi v Migration Agents Registration Authority (2008) 235 CLR 286 at [33]-[38], [96]-[98], [116]-[117], [131]-[146]. Specifically, in Shi, Justice Keifel (as her Honour then was) observed:[140] The term "merits review" does not appear in the AAT Act, although it is often used to explain that the function of the Tribunal extends beyond a review for legal error, to a consideration of the facts and circumstances relevant to the decision. The object of the review undertaken by the Tribunal has been said to be to determine what is the "correct or preferable decision". "Preferable" is apt to refer to a decision which involves discretionary considerations. A "correct" decision, in the context of review, might be taken to be one rightly made, in the proper sense. It is, inevitably, a decision by the original decision-maker with which the Tribunal agrees. Smithers J, in Collector of Customs (NSW) v Brian Lawlor Automotive Pty Ltd, said that it is for the Tribunal to determine whether the decision is acceptable, when tested against the requirements of good government. This is because the Tribunal, in essence, is an instrument of government administration.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 7 December 2023, the Applicant’s resident visa was mandatorily cancelled under s 501(3A) of the Migration Act 1958 (Migration Act) because of that sentence and his then incarceration in Western Australia.[10][10] See Exhibit 1, pp 172-178. On 18 December 2023, the Applicant made representations seeking revocation of the cancellation,[11] and, on 11 April 2025, a delegate of the Respondent (Minister) refused to revoke the cancellation under s 501CA(4) of the Migration Act (Non-Revocation Decision).[12] [11] See Exhibit 1, p 22 [3]. [12] Exhibit 1, p 21. The Applicant sought review of the Non-Revocation Decision in this Tribunal. After hearing from the parties, the Tribunal has determined that the correct decision is to affirm the reviewable decision. In other words, and for the following reasons, the Tribunal is not satisfied that there is ‘another reason’ why the visa cancellation should be revoked. THE HEARING AND THE EVIDENCE The Applicant appeared in-person before the Tribunal on 23 June 2025. He was represented by Ms Jasmin Angel of Estrin Saul Lawyers. The Minister was represented by Mr Ashley Burgess of the Australian Government Solicitor’s Office - Perth. The following documents were marked as exhibits:(a)Joint Hearing Bundle, including the parties’ respective Statements of Facts, Issues and Contentions (375 pages) (Exhibit 1); and(b)Amended Certificate of Final Outcome dated 26 June 2025 (Exhibit 2). At the hearing, the Applicant was advised, in simple terms, of his right to invoke the privilege against self-incrimination prior to his giving evidence.[13] He was also provided an opportunity to respond to matters put to him and to provide answers to questions asked by the Tribunal which were directed at relevant considerations under the Direction. [13] See Bainbridge v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2024] FCA 1080, [64]-[65]. The Tribunal took oral evidence from the Applicant, his wife, sister, and oldest son. BACKGROUND The Applicant is a fitter and turner by trade.[14] He and his wife met in Glasgow, and they married there in March 1983.[15] The pair emigrated to Australia shortly thereafter because they had extended family already resident here.[16] [14] Evidence on 23 June 2025. [15] Exhibit 1, p 138. [16] See Exhibit 1, p 120. The Applicant’s first son, D (41), was born in Perth in 1984.[17] [17] See Exhibit 1, p 79 [7]. The Applicant commenced his State employment in September 1985.[18] [18] See Exhibit 1, p 79 [8]. The Applicant’s second son, B (38), was born in Kalgoorlie in 1987.[19] [19] See Exhibit 1, p 79 [9]. The family moved to Albany in or around 1989.[20] During this period, the Applicant’s sister also emigrated to Australia.[21][20] See Exhibit 1, p 80 [10]. [21] Ibid. In or around 2004/2005, the Applicant’s wife was diagnosed with a rare neurological condition called transverse myelitis.[22] This condition causes long-standing deficits, and the wife otherwise suffers from bilateral trigeminal neuralgia (pain on both sides of the face), hypertension, cholesterol, osteoarthritis and diabetes.[23] The Applicant has generally been his wife’s carer since.[24] He was previously in receipt of some form of carer benefits prior to his incarceration.[25] However, the wife has more recently been in receipt of a disability support pension (DSP), including at the single rate.[26] [22] See Exhibit 1, pp 80 [11], 135-136. [23] See Exhibit 1, pp 128, 135.[24] See Exhibit 1, p 132 [4]. [25] See Exhibit 1, p 80 [11]. [26] Evidence on 23 June 2025; Exhibit 1, p 137.