Sazdanoff-Haynes v MLS Wholesales Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Sazdanoff-Haynes v MLS Wholesales Pty Ltd  [2023] QCAT 37

PARTIES:

stephen miller sazdanoff-haynes

(applicant)

v

mls wholesales pty ltd 

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

MVL070-21

MATTER TYPE:

Motor vehicle matter

DELIVERED ON:

31 January 2023

HEARING DATE:

21 October 2022

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Member Traves

ORDERS:

1.     MLS Wholesales Pty Ltd must pay the sum of $28 000 to Stephen Miller Sazdanoff-Haynes by 4:00pm on 28 February 2023.

CATCHWORDS:

TRADE AND COMMERCE – COMPETITION, FAIR TRADING AND CONSUMER PROTECTION LEGISLATION – CONSUMER PROTECTION – GUARANTEES, CONDITIONS AND WARRANTIES IN CONSUMER TRANSACTIONS – JURISDICTION -  whether Tribunal has jurisdiction to order a refund by a supplier of goods under the Australian Consumer Law (Qld) where purchase price is $43 000 – whether pre-sale conversation misleading or deceptive or likely to mislead or deceive – whether breach of consumer guarantees – whether breach of sale by description provisions – whether breach of acceptable quality provisions – appropriate remedies

MOTOR DEALERS LEGISLATION – whether breach of statutory warranties – appropriate remedies

Australian Consumer Law (Qld), s 18, s 29, s 54, s 56, s236, s 259, s 260, s 262, s 263

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), Schedule 2
Fair Trading Act 1989 (Qld), s 50, s 50A

Motor Dealers and Chattels Auctioneers Act 2014 (Qld), Schedule 1, s 14, s 15

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Jayco Corporation Pty Ltd [2020] FCA 1672

Collyer v Grays (NSW) Pty Ltd [2022] QCATA 80

Dwyer v Volkswagen Group Australia Pty Ltd t/as Volkswagen Australia [2021] NSWSC 715

Harlingdon & Leinster Enterprises Ltd v Christopher Hull Fine Art [1990] 3 WLR 13.

Howarth v Biscamoss [2022] QCATA 72.

Jarmain v Market Direct Group Pty Ltd [2022] QCAT 375

Minister for Environment and Heritage v Greentree (No 2) [2004] FCA 741
Taylor v Combined Buyers Ltd [1924] NZLR 627
3WJ v Director-General Fair Trading [2003] NSWSC 331.

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

Self-represented

Respondent:

Self-represented

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. Mr Sazdanoff-Haynes (Mr Haynes) bought a second-hand Toyota Troop Carrier from MLS Wholesales Pty Ltd (MLS) over the telephone after seeing an online advertisement for the vehicle on Gumtree. Mr Haynes did not conduct a pre-purchase examination of the vehicle.

  2. Mr Haynes resides in New South Wales and bought the vehicle, which was located in Brisbane, after reading the advertisement and having a conversation with Mr Sitnik, a director of MLS, on the telephone. The vehicle was advertised for sale for $45 000 and sold to Mr Haynes for $43 000.

  3. Mr Haynes claims he was misled prior to purchase as to the history of the vehicle and its condition. He also claims the vehicle does not correspond with its description and is not of acceptable quality, in breach of relevant statutory guarantees.

  4. Mr Haynes’ application for motor vehicle dispute[1] claims, in the alternative:

    (a)Under s 15(1)(d) of the Motor Dealers and Chattel Auctioneers Act 2014 (Qld), Schedule 1:

    (i)      the cost of repairs and losses suffered…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sazdanoff-Haynes v MLS Wholesales Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QCAT 37
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Sazdanoff-Haynes v MLS Wholesales Pty Ltd, the plaintiff, Stephen Miller Sazdanoff-Haynes, sought a refund from the defendant, MLS Wholesales Pty Ltd, for a vehicle purchased by him, alleging it did not meet acceptable quality standards. The case was heard by the Australian Small Business and Family Enterprise Ombudsman (ASBFEO), which has jurisdiction under the Australian Consumer Law (ACL). The plaintiff claimed the vehicle had defects not disclosed at the time of sale, including an electrical fault in the tail/trailer lighting and a short-lived battery. The defendant denied the defects and argued the price of a similar vehicle today would be higher.

The court was required to determine whether the ASBFEO had jurisdiction to order a refund under the ACL. The court also needed to establish whether the vehicle met the statutory guarantee of acceptable quality, as required under the ACL. The court had to examine the evidence regarding the content of the advertisement and the telephone conversation between the parties. The court also had to consider whether the defects alleged by the plaintiff were significant enough to warrant a refund.

The court found that the ASBFEO had jurisdiction to order a refund under the ACL. The court noted that the legislation intended to protect consumers and provide remedies when goods did not meet acceptable quality standards. The court found that the vehicle did not meet the statutory guarantee of acceptable quality due to the defects alleged by the plaintiff. The court also found that the defects were significant enough to warrant a refund. The court ordered the defendant to pay the plaintiff a refund of $28,000.

MLS Wholesales Pty Ltd must pay the sum of $28,000 to Stephen Miller Sazdanoff-Haynes by 4:00pm on 28 February 2023. The court did not consider the claim under the Motor Dealers and Chattel Auctioneers Act 2014 (Qld) as the plaintiff had been successful in his claim under the ACL.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

MLS denied the vehicle had the defects complained of at the time of sale and submitted that the price of the equivalent vehicle today would be higher than the price Mr Haynes paid. Background On 25 June 2020 Mr Haynes read the online advertisement for sale of the vehicle posted by MLS on Gumtree. The parties were unable to produce the advertisement at the hearing. There is a dispute as to the content of the advertisement. MLS said the advertisement of the vehicle would have said ‘military model’ 2011/12 Toyota Landcruiser. Mr Haynes gave evidence that the ad said “military Troopcarrier”. On 26 June 2020 at around 9:00am Mr Haynes telephoned MLS regarding the vehicle and spoke to Mr Sitnik, a director of MLS. The content of that telephone conversation is also in dispute. I deal with this further below. The parties negotiated a reduced price of $43 000 for the vehicle (a reduction of $2 000) on the basis Mr Haynes was a resident of New South Wales and would have to pay transport and registration costs in New South Wales. If Mr Haynes had been resident in Queensland the usual practice would have been for MLS to pay for the car to obtain a roadworthy certificate and registration. At 9:13am, immediately after the telephone conversation, Mr Haynes emailed MLS accepting the offer and stating:We just spoke on the phone about the Toyota Troopcarrier.Here is the ad just in case: [link provided]As we discussed I’m happy to buy it immediately for $43k. I’ve really been looking for a Troopy with the third door!I’ve attached a copy of my driver’s license, let me know what the next steps are.ThanksStephen Haynes At 9:47am MLS emailed a PPSR Search certificate and a Tax Invoice for $43 000. The PPSR certificate dated 26 June 2020 stated the vehicle’s Queensland registration expired on 1 June 2020. The invoice described the vehicle as follows:12/2011 Toyota Landcruiser Troopcarrier 4x4 White Wagon Manual 8-cyls (Diesel). At 12:47pm the $43 000 was electronically transferred to MLS. On 18 July 2020, one day after receiving the vehicle, Mr Haynes obtained a ‘blue slip’ for the vehicle (an equivalent of a roadworthy certificate) and the vehicle was registered in New South Wales. Mr Haynes paid $2 091 for stamp duty, blue slip and registration. On 20 July 2020 Mr Haynes emailed MLS stating that while he was “happy with it overall” he was disappointed the vehicle was not in roadworthy condition as indicated in the advertisement. Mr Haynes referred to the following defects: an electrical fault in the tail/trailer lighting in the main harness; and the battery having a short lifespan, being 2 days. On 21 July 2020 MLS replied:…The advertised price was $45 000 with RWC & Registration. The car was sold to you at $43 000 without RWC & Registration and not inspected by yourself. The battery was replaced prior to it going out to you…You can post back to us if you like and we can get it replaced under warranty?As for the wiring issue, this is something we do not look into or test sorry.The car was also serviced prior to you receiving (Oil & Oil Filters).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

There is no sensible reason why the legislation would not, in the circumstances, intend the Tribunal to have jurisdiction to order a refund; and every reason to infer the legislature intended the Tribunal to have that jurisdiction. The matters above, in my view, support the view that the Tribunal has jurisdiction to make an order requiring a refund to be paid.Conclusion Given Mr Haynes has been successful in his claim under s 259(3) of the ACL due to the failure to comply with the statutory guarantee as to acceptable quality, I do not propose to consider the claim under the Motor Dealers and Chattel Auctioneers Act 2014 (Qld). Accordingly, I order:MLS Wholesales Pty Ltd must pay the sum of $28 000 to Stephen Miller Sazdanoff-Haynes by 4:00pm on 28 February 2023.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.