Sheppard v Piryani Pty Ltd t/as Galaxy Autos

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Sheppard v Piryani Pty Ltd t/as Galaxy Autos [2025] QCAT 331

PARTIES:

KARISSA LEONE SHEPPARD

(applicant)

ROBERT ANTHONY SHEPPARD

(applicant)

v

PIRYANI PTY LTD T/AS GALAXY AUTOS 

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

MVL253-23

MATTER TYPE:

Motor vehicle matter

DELIVERED ON:

2 September 2025

HEARING DATE:

21 May 2025; final submissions filed 19 June 2025

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Senior Member Brown

ORDERS:

1.     Karissa Leone Sheppard and Robert Anthony Sheppard must, at their expense, deliver up the Holden Colorado motor vehicle to Piryani Pty Ltd t/as Galaxy Autos within 7 days of the date of these orders.

2.     Piryani Pty Ltd t/as Galaxy Autos must pay to Karissa Leone Sheppard and Robert Anthony Sheppard $30,223.07 within 14 days of the delivery up of the Holden Colorado.

CATCHWORDS:

TRADE AND COMMERCE – COMPETITION, FAIR TRADING AND CONSUMER PROTECTION LEGISLATION – CONSUMER PROTECTION – GUARANTEES, CONDITIONS AND WARRANTIES IN CONSUMER TRANSACTIONS – GUARANTEES, CONDITIONS AND WARRANTIES – Where vehicle advertised as being in mechanically perfect condition prior to purchase – where vehicle engine suffered catastrophic failure and engine required replacement three months after purchase – where respondent refused to allow return of vehicle and to refund purchase price – where worn components in engine would have been present when applicants purchased vehicle – where respondent failed to comply with consumer guarantees under Australian Consumer Law – where failure to comply was a major failure as a reasonable consumer would not have purchased the vehicle if acquainted with the pre-existing defect – where applicants gave notice of their intention to reject the goods within the rejection period – where claims for purchase price, towing fees, loan interest payments and insurance allowed – where costs limited to recovery of prescribed fee

Australian Consumer Law, s 54(2), s 54(3), s 259, s 260, s 262, s 263
Fair Trading Act1989 (Qld), s 50A, s 50C

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 102, s 110, s 111

APS Satellite Pty Ltd (formerly known as “Sky Mesh Pty Ltd”) v Ipstar Australia Pty Ltd [2016] NSWSC 1898

Effem Foods Ltd v Nicholls [2004] NSWCA 332
Ferraro v DBN Holdings Aust Pty Ltd T/As Sports Auto Group [2015] FCA 1127
Hinterland Express Pty Ltd v Inchcape European Automotive Pty Ltd & Anor [2023] QCATA 130
Howarth & Anor v Biscamoss PtyLtd [2022] QCATA 72
Jarmain v Market Direct Group Pty Ltd t/as MDC Camper Trailers & Offroad Caravans [2022] QCAT 375
Knox v Tait Motors Pty Ltd t/as Tait Auto Group [2021] QCATA 87
Medtel Pty Ltd v Courtney (2003) 130 FCR 182
Sazdanoff-Haynes v MLS Wholesales Pty Ltd [2023] QCAT 37

Vautin v BY Winddown, Inc. (formerly Bertram Yachts) (No 4) [2018] FCA 426

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

Self-represented

Respondent:

Self-represented

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. This proceeding involves a dispute about the purchase of a Holden Colorado utility by Mr and Mrs Sheppard from Galaxy Autos. The Sheppards say that approximately three months after purchase the vehicle…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sheppard v Piryani Pty Ltd t/as Galaxy Autos and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] QCAT 331
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Sheppard v Piryani Pty Ltd t/as Galaxy Autos, the applicants, Karissa Leone Sheppard and Robert Anthony Sheppard, sought relief against the respondent, Piryani Pty Ltd trading as Galaxy Autos, for the purchase of a Holden Colorado motor vehicle. The applicants alleged that the vehicle was not of acceptable quality under the Australian Consumer Law (ACL), leading to a catastrophic engine failure shortly after purchase. They sought a refund of the purchase price, towing fees, loan interest payments, and insurance costs. The Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal was tasked with determining whether the vehicle was of acceptable quality at the time of sale and whether the respondent's failure to comply with the consumer guarantees was a major failure.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the Holden Colorado was of acceptable quality at the time of purchase, as defined by the ACL. The Tribunal had to consider the condition of the vehicle at the time of supply, the definition of acceptable quality, and the impact of subsequent events on the condition of the vehicle. The Tribunal also needed to determine whether the respondent's failure to comply with the consumer guarantees constituted a major failure, which would entitle the applicants to a refund of the purchase price.

The Tribunal found that the Holden Colorado was not of acceptable quality at the time of purchase due to pre-existing worn components in the engine, which were likely present when the Sheppards bought the vehicle. The evidence of the independent assessor, Mr Thomas Kovalev, supported the conclusion that the engine failure was due to insufficient servicing and the pre-existing worn components. The Tribunal held that the respondent's failure to comply with the consumer guarantees was a major failure, as a reasonable consumer would not have purchased the vehicle if they had been aware of the pre-existing defects. Consequently, the Tribunal ordered the respondent to refund the purchase price to the applicants and awarded costs limited to the recovery of the prescribed fee.

The Tribunal's final order was that Karissa Leone Sheppard and Robert Anthony Sheppard must deliver up the Holden Colorado motor vehicle to Piryani Pty Ltd t/as Galaxy Autos within seven days of the date of the orders. Piryani Pty Ltd t/as Galaxy Autos must pay to Karissa Leone Sheppard and Robert Anthony Sheppard $30,223.07 within 14 days of the delivery up of the Holden Colorado. This sum includes the purchase price, towing fees, loan interest payments, and insurance costs, as determined by the Tribunal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Karissa Leone Sheppard and Robert Anthony Sheppard must, at their expense, deliver up the Holden Colorado motor vehicle to Piryani Pty Ltd t/as Galaxy Autos within 7 days of the date of these orders.

2. Piryani Pty Ltd t/as Galaxy Autos must pay to Karissa Leone Sheppard and Robert Anthony Sheppard $30,223.07 within 14 days of the delivery up of the Holden Colorado.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr Piryani’s evidence is that after the Colorado broke down he spoke with Mrs Sheppard and advised her that the dealer warranty had expired but that Galaxy Autos would fit a replacement engine at no cost if the Sheppards provided the engine. Mr Piryani agrees that Mrs Sheppard sought a refund of the purchase price paid. Mr Piryani says that when the Colorado was sold to Mr Sheppard the vehicle had travelled 150,930 kilometres and the service sticker on the vehicle windscreen noted that the next service was due at 150,000 kilometres. Mr Piryani says that the Sheppards failed to have the vehicle serviced after purchase. He says that having the 150,000 km service carried out was not an obligation imposed on Galaxy Autos and was the responsibility of the Sheppards. Mr Piryani says that the service history of the Colorado was available and known to Mr Sheppard. Mr Piryani agreed that the vehicle was described by Galaxy Autos in the online listing as being in perfect mechanical condition. Mr Piryani says that the fact Mr Sheppard continued to drive the Colorado for 7,000 kilometres past the scheduled service interval could have contributed to the engine failure. The evidence of the independent assessor Mr Thomas Kovalev inspected the Colorado and provided a report.[1] In the report Mr Kovalev says:[1]Report dated 23 April 2024. (a)The engine of the Colorado failed 3 months and 13 days after purchase by Mr Sheppard during which time the vehicle had travelled 6,079 kilometres;(b)No service records for the vehicle were available until 90,000 kilometres;(c)The 105,000 kilometre service was carried out at 2,312 kilometres over the recommended interval;(d)The 120,000 kilometre service was not carried out;(e)The 135,000 kilometre service was carried out at 7,394 kilometres over the recommended interval;(f)The 150,000 kilometre service had not been carried out; Mr Kovalev’s oral evidence at the hearing was that the worn componentry in the engine leading to the ultimate engine failure would have been present when Mr Sheppard purchased the Colorado. Mr Kovalev characterised the engine failure as catastrophic and said that the type of engine failure experienced by the vehicle was not normal for that particular type of motor. I found both the Sheppards and Mr Piryani to be witnesses doing their best to recall events truthfully and accurately. Where the evidence of the parties diverges, I prefer the evidence of the Sheppards who had carefully documented the relevant events and had a more detailed recollection of events, particularly Mrs Sheppard. ConsiderationWas the Colorado of acceptable quality? The Sheppards’ claim may be understood as being one arising out of a major failure by Galaxy Autos to comply with the consumer warranties contained in the Australian Consumer Law and particularly the warranty that goods are of acceptable quality. Section 50A of the Fair Trading Act1989 (Qld) vests the Tribunal with jurisdiction in relation to motor vehicles in respect of certain actions under the Australian Consumer Law (‘ACL’). The ACL is schedule 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act2010 (Cth).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I found both the Sheppards and Mr Piryani to be witnesses doing their best to recall events truthfully and accurately. Where the evidence of the parties diverges, I prefer the evidence of the Sheppards who had carefully documented the relevant events and had a more detailed recollection of events, particularly Mrs Sheppard. ConsiderationWas the Colorado of acceptable quality? The Sheppards’ claim may be understood as being one arising out of a major failure by Galaxy Autos to comply with the consumer warranties contained in the Australian Consumer Law and particularly the warranty that goods are of acceptable quality. Section 50A of the Fair Trading Act1989 (Qld) vests the Tribunal with jurisdiction in relation to motor vehicles in respect of certain actions under the Australian Consumer Law (‘ACL’). The ACL is schedule 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act2010 (Cth). Section 54(1) of the ACL provides that, where a person supplies goods in trade or commerce, the goods are guaranteed to be of ‘acceptable quality’. The time at which goods are to be of acceptable quality is the time at which the goods are supplied to the consumer.[2] Information available after the time of supply may be taken into account in deciding whether the goods were of acceptable quality at the time of supply.[3] Where the supplier claims that the failure arose after the goods were supplied, the onus is on the supplier to prove that this is the case.[4] Section 54 is not a guarantee of perfection.[5] [2]Medtel Pty Ltd v Courtney (2003) 130 FCR 182. [3]Ibid. [4]Effem Foods Ltd v Nicholls [2004] NSWCA 332.[5]Knox v Tait Motors Pty Ltd t/as Tait Auto Group [2021] QCATA 87. It is not contentious that the Colorado is within the meaning of ‘goods’ for the purposes of the relevant provisions of the ACL. Nor is it contentious that Galaxy Autos was a ‘supplier’. Section 54(2) and s 54(3) of the ACL provide:(2) Goods are of acceptable quality if they are as: (a)fit for all the purposes for which goods of that kind are commonly supplied; and (b) acceptable in appearance and finish; and (c) free from defects; and (d)safe; and (e) durable; as a reasonable consumer fully acquainted with the state and condition of the goods (including any hidden defects of the goods), would regard as acceptable having regard to the matters in subsection (3). (3) The matters for the purposes of subsection (2) are: (a) the nature of the goods; and(b) the price of the goods (if relevant); and (c)any statements made about the goods on any packaging or label on the goods; and (d)any representation made about the goods by the supplier or manufacturer of the goods; and (e) any other relevant circumstances relating to the supply of the goods. Mr Kovalev is an assessor appointed pursuant to the provisions of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld) (‘QCAT Act’).[6] Mr Kovalev has given expert evidence in the proceeding.[7] I accept the evidence of Mr Kovalev. I find that:[6]QCAT Act, s 110.[7]Ibid, s 111(1)(a).(a)The Colorado’s engine failed on 17 August 2023;(b)At the time the engine failed Mr Sheppard had driven the vehicle 6,079 kilometres since purchase just over three months prior;(c)Service records for the vehicle, only available after 90,000 kilometres, indicate that:(i) the 105,000 kilometre service was carried out at 2,312 kilometres over the recommended interval;(ii) the 120,000 kilometre service was not carried out;(iii) the 135,000 kilometre service was carried out at 7,394 kilometres over the recommended interval;(iv) the 150,000 kilometre service had not been carried out;(d)The likely cause of the engine failure was one or more of the big end bearings failing which caused the connecting rod to seize on the crankshaft and or cause the connecting rod to fracture;(e)The type of failure would be deemed premature and was likely due to insufficient servicing, specifically the lack of regular oil changes;(f)The engine oil’s lubricating and viscosity were likely compromised considering the vehicle had travelled 7,708 kilometres over the recommended service interval, contributing to the engine failure;(g)A further contributing factor to the engine failure would likely be the history of irregular oil changes which accelerated engine wear; (h)If the vehicle had undergone regular oil changes in accordance with the manufacturer’s recommendations for all prior service intervals, with only the last service overdue by 7,708 kilometres, the engine would not have failed;(i)the worn componentry in the engine leading to the ultimate engine failure was present when Mr Sheppard purchased the Colorado;(j)the fact the Sheppards did not undertake the 150,000 kilometre scheduled service after purchase and before the engine failure did not cause or contribute to the engine failure in circumstances where, had the worn componentry not been present at the time of purchase, the failure to undertake the service of itself would not have resulted in the failure of the engine; (k)The engine failure may be characterised as catastrophic and the type of engine failure experienced by the Colorado was not normal for that particular type of motor.