Saunders and Australian Federal Police

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2001] AATA 1006

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No W2000/76

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE  DIVISION       )          
           Re      BRIAN SAUNDERS          
  Applicant

And    AUSTRALIAN FEDERAL POLICE        
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Associate Professor S D Hotop, Senior Member         

Date10 December 2001

PlacePerth

Decision      The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.           
  ..………(sgd S D Hotop)..................
   Senior Member
CATCHWORDS
 FREEDOM OF INFORMATION – exempt documents – applicant requested access to certain documents including Director of Public Prosecutions Search Warrants Manual – whether Manual subject to legal professional privilege – whether Manual must be made available for inspection and purchase.
Freedom of Information Act 1982 ss 3, 9, 11, 22, 42, 58, 61
Re Colonial Mutual Life Assurance Society Ltd and Department of Resources and Energy (1987) 12 ALD 251
Commissioner of Australian Federal Police v Propend Finance Pty Ltd (1997) 188 CLR 501
Esso Australia Resources Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (1999) 201 CLR 49
Mann v Carnell (1999) 201 CLR 1
Re Sullivan and Department of Industry, Science and Technology (1997) 49 ALD 743
Waterford v Commonwealth (1987) 163 CLR 54

REASONS FOR DECISION

10 December 2001 Associate Professor S.D. Hotop, Senior Member                    

Introduction

  1. Brian Saunders ("the applicant") has applied to the Tribunal for review of a decision of an officer of the Australian Federal Police ("the respondent") of which he was notified by letter dated 11 February 2000. The decision in question was a decision, made on an internal review, refusing to grant the applicant's request for access to a document entitled "Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions Search Warrants Manual" (1999 Revision, 7 April 1999) ("the Manual") in accordance with the Freedom of Information Act 1982 ("FOI Act").

  2. At the hearing the applicant appeared in person without representation and the respondent was represented by Mr A Jenshel of counsel. The Tribunal had before it the statement and documents ("T documents") lodged by the respondent in accordance with s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 and the following exhibits tendered by the respondent:

  • Affidavit of Geoffrey Gray sworn on 30 November 2000 (R1); and

  • Affidavit of Michael Atkins sworn on 30 November 2000 (R2).

Oral evidence was given (by telephone) by Mr Gray and Mr Atkins.
Background

  1. The background to the present application for review, as appears from the T documents, is as follows.

  2. By facsimile dated 30 September 1999 the applicant requested the respondent to provide him with copies of the following classes of documents under the FOI Act:

    "All manuals, instructions, guidelines, codes of practice and/or similar in use by AFP personnel from February 1997 and dealing with the issuing of search warrants, the implementation of search warrants, the storage of seized property, the copying of seized property and/or the return of seized property." (T3)

  3. The respondent identified 19 documents (comprising 563 folios) as falling within the ambit of the applicant's abovementioned request for access, including the Manual. (T6)

  4. By letter dated 22 November 1999 an officer of the respondent notified…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Saunders and Australian Federal Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] AATA 1006
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case between Saunders and the Australian Federal Police involved a request under the Freedom of Information Act 1982 for access to certain documents, including the Director of Public Prosecutions Search Warrants Manual. The dispute centred around whether this manual was subject to legal professional privilege and whether it should be made available for inspection and purchase. The Federal Court was tasked with determining these legal issues.

The court had to decide whether the manual was exempt from disclosure under section 42(1) of the FOI Act, which excludes documents privileged from production in legal proceedings. This required an analysis of the nature of the manual and its contents to ascertain whether they were protected by legal professional privilege. The court also needed to consider the potential impact of disclosing the manual on the investigation and prosecution of Commonwealth offences, weighing this against the public interest in transparency and access to information.

The Tribunal concluded that the manual was indeed subject to legal professional privilege and therefore exempt from disclosure under section 42(1) of the FOI Act. The court found that the manual was a collection of legal advice provided by DPP lawyers and that its disclosure could potentially cause undue delays in the investigative process and frustrate the success of prosecutions. The detrimental impact on law enforcement activities outweighed the public interest in disclosure, leading to the decision to affirm the decision under review.

The final orders affirmed the decision of the Australian Federal Police to withhold the manual under the FOI Act, recognising the need to protect legal professional privilege and the interests of law enforcement.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 12 March 2000 the applicant lodged with the Tribunal an application for review of the abovementioned decision made by the respondent on internal review. (T1, p 3)The EvidenceMr Gray An affidavit of Geoffrey Gray, sworn on 30 November 2000, was tendered in evidence by the respondent (Exhibit R1). The contents of that affidavit are as follows:"…1. I am a Senior Assistant Director in the Head Office of the Commonwealth DPP. I am currently in charge of the Criminal Assets and International Branch of DPP Head Office. I am also the current editor of the DPP Search Warrants Manual ('the Manual'). I am a lawyer admitted to practice in the ACT and NSW. I have worked for the Commonwealth DPP since the Office was first set up in 1984. I have held my current position since 1995 and have been editor of the DPP Search Warrants Manual since 1994. In his oral evidence Mr Gray confirmed that he had sworn the abovementioned affidavit on 30 November 2000 and that its contents are true and correct to the best of his knowledge and belief. In cross-examination Mr Gray acknowledged that the Manual includes some documents which reproduce the forms of certain classes of search warrants which are prescribed by Commonwealth regulations, and other documents which are not "inherently confidential", such as the guidelines as agreed between the Australian Federal Police and the Law Council of Australia regarding the execution of search warrants on lawyers' premises where a claim of legal professional privilege has been made.Mr M Atkins An affidavit of Michael Atkins, sworn on 30 November 2000, was also tendered in evidence by the respondent (Exhibit R2). The contents of that affidavit are, relevantly, as follows:"…1. I am a senior executive employee of the Australian Federal Police (AFP) and am the Special Adviser Law Reform with responsibility for the management of particular, sensitive law reform and policy issues affecting the Australian Federal Police. Prior to this, I was a seconded officer of the Commonwealth Attorney-General's Department and was responsible for the Legal Group of the AFP. I have work (sic) in law enforcement related law reform and policy since joining that Department in 1987.2. On 30 September 1999, the Applicant sought access under the Freedom of Information Act 1982 ('the FOI Act'), to 'All manuals, instructions, guidelines, codes of practice and/or similar in use by AFP personnel from February 1997 and dealing with the issuing of search warrants, the implementation of search warrants, the storage of seized property, the copying of seized property and/or the return of seized property' (T3).3. I understand that 19 documents, comprising 563 folios, were identified as falling within the ambit of the Applicant's request (T6). One of these documents was the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions Search Warrant (sic) Manual ('the Manual'). With the exception of the Manual, the remaining 18 documents were released to the Applicant in full.…7. I am aware that the Manual is provide (sic) to the AFP by the DPP on the strict understanding that it will not be disseminated outside the AFP. In addition, if the Manual were to become subject to a subpoena, FOI request or other discovery process it is understood by the AFP that they must consult with the DPP prior to releasing any part of that document. The Manual is and always remains a DPP document.8. The purpose of the Manual is to provide legal advice to the AFP, and other Commonwealth investigative agencies on issues concerning search warrants and to provide advice to DPP lawyers when they are called upon to draft search warrant or to defend evidence obtained under a search warrant in pending and contemplated future prosecutions. I would characterise the Manual as being predominantly made up of a collection of legal advisings provided by DPP lawyers on search warrant issues along with a number of annexures which prescribe the various forms that the different types of search warrant may take.9. If the Manual were to be released pursuant to the FOI Act, it is conceivable that much time and effort would be spent by persons subject to a search warrant trying to identify technical deficiencies in the warrant and the DPP's interpretation and advice on the same. This has the potential to cause undue delays in the investigative process and may even frustrate the success of a potential prosecution of the criminal law. In my opinion, the detrimental impact that disclosure of the Manual would or could have on the investigation and prosecution of Commonwealth offences, outweighs the public interest in facilitating and promoting, promptly and at the lowest reasonable cost the disclosure of information in the possession of the Commonwealth Government.…".

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal concludes, therefore, that the Manual is a document "of such a nature that it would be privileged from production in legal proceedings on the ground of legal professional privilege" and is, accordingly, an exempt document under s 42(1) of the FOI Act. The Tribunal finds, furthermore, that the entire contents of the Manual comprise exempt matter, and that the Manual is wholly exempt, pursuant to that subsection.Decision For the above reasons the Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established