Sands v Channel Seven Adelaide Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Appeal from a Master: Civil)

SANDS v CHANNEL SEVEN ADELAIDE PTY LTD AND AUSTRALIAN BROADCASTING CORPORATION

Judgment of The Honourable Justice White

20 May 2005

DEFAMATION - ACTIONS FOR DEFAMATION - PLEADING - SOUTH AUSTRALIA

First respondent broadcast on television a promotion for a current affairs programme in which it was stated that appellant was a suspect in a murder case - Third party obtained interim injunction preventing broadcast of the programme to which the promotions related - Continuance of injunction argued in District Court - Second respondent broadcast on radio and published in an article on the Internet reports of the District Court proceedings, including a concern expressed by the District Court Judge that the appellant was referred to in the programme as a murder suspect - Appellant sought to amend Statement of Claim - Respondents sought to have struck out paragraphs in Statement of Claim which alleged that the natural and ordinary meaning of the broadcasts and article were that appellant was suspected of murder and that there were reasonable grounds for such suspicion - Master accepted that the broadcasts were not capable of bearing that meaning - Broadcasts of first and second respondents were capable of bearing that meaning - Unnecessary to decide whether words actually bear that meaning at this stage - Consideration of "repetition rule" - Statement of Claim disclosed reasonable causes of action - Pleading not ambiguous - Appeal allowed

Supreme Court Rules 1987 rr 53.01, 46.19, 97.08, referred to.
Chapman v Australian Broadcasting Corporation [2000] SASC 146; (2000) 77 SASR 181; Whelan v John Fairfax & Sons Ltd (1988) 12 NSWLR 148; Stern v Piper [1997] QB 123, applied.
Rakhimov v Australian Broadcasting Corporation [2001] NSWSC 10; Bennett v News Group Newspapers Ltd [2002] EMLR 39, distinguished.
Jackson v John Fairfax & Sons Ltd [1981] 1 NSWLR 36, discussed.
Chakravarti v Advertiser Newspapers Ltd [1998] HCA 37; (1998) 193 CLR 519; Nationwide News Pty Ltd v Chapman [2001] SASC 30; General Steel Industries Inc v Commissioner for Railways (NSW) (1964) 112 CLR 125; Ronci v Nationwide News Pty Ltd [2001] SASC 30; Lim v TVW Enterprises Ltd [2002) WASC 214; Amalgamated Television Services Pty Ltd v Marsden (1998) 43 NSWLR 158; Lewis v Daily Telegraph [1964] AC 234; Shah v Standard Chartered Bank Ltd [1999] QB 241; Chase v News Group Newspapers Ltd [2003] EMLR 11; Jameel v Times Newspapers Ltd [2004] EMLR 31; Lucas-Box v News Group Newspapers Ltd [1986] 1 WLR 147; Polly Peck (Holdings) Plc v Trelford [1986] QB 1000, considered.

SANDS v CHANNEL SEVEN ADELAIDE PTY LTD AND AUSTRALIAN BROADCASTING CORPORATION
[2005] SASC 182

Appeal from a Master

WHITE J:

Introduction

  1. This is an appeal from a decision of a Master by which the Master refused to grant leave to the appellant (the plaintiff in the proceedings below) to amend further the Statement of Claim filed in the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sands v Channel Seven Adelaide Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] SASC 182
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Sands v Channel Seven Adelaide Pty Ltd, the appellant sought to amend his Statement of Claim in a defamation action against Channel Seven and the Australian Broadcasting Corporation (ABC). The respondents argued for a strike-out of certain paragraphs in the Statement of Claim, which alleged defamatory meanings in their broadcasts and publications. The appellant claimed that the broadcasts and articles suggested he was suspected of murder, which he denied. The Master initially dismissed the appellant's application to amend the Statement of Claim and struck out the contested paragraphs, finding they did not disclose a reasonable cause of action. The appellant appealed, arguing that the pleadings were capable of bearing the defamatory meanings and should not have been struck out.

The legal issues before the court involved the proper pleading of defamation claims and the interpretation of the broadcasts and articles in question. The court considered whether the pleadings disclosed a reasonable cause of action and whether they were ambiguous or capable of bearing the defamatory meanings alleged by the appellant. The court also examined the "repetition rule," which considers whether the repetition of defamatory matter without further publication can sustain a defamation claim. The appeal hinged on whether the pleadings were sufficiently clear and capable of bearing the meanings alleged, despite the Master's earlier findings.

The appeal was allowed by the court, which found that the Statement of Claim did disclose reasonable causes of action. The court determined that the pleadings were not ambiguous and that it was unnecessary to decide at that stage whether the words actually bore the defamatory meanings. The court found that the appellant's proposed Amended Statement of Claim was not objectionable and should have been allowed. The appeal court also noted that the repetition rule could be relevant, but this did not affect the outcome regarding the pleadings. The court concluded that the pleadings were not defective and that the Master's decision to strike out the paragraphs and refuse leave to amend was in error.

The final orders of the court were that the appeal be allowed, the orders of the Master be set aside, and leave be granted for the appellant to amend his Statement of Claim as proposed. The court directed that the parties proceed with the amended pleadings in the defamation action. The decision underscores the importance of clear and precise pleadings in defamation cases and the potential for successful appeals where the original pleadings are found to be adequate despite initial judicial rulings to the contrary.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an appeal from a decision of a Master by which the Master refused to grant leave to the appellant (the plaintiff in the proceedings below) to amend further the Statement of Claim filed in the action, and, in addition, struck out two paragraphs of the appellant’s Amended Statement of Claim.Background Circumstances The circumstances which I set out below are drawn from the appellant’s allegations contained in the proposed Amended Statement of Claim. I note that they are allegations only at this stage. Channel Seven is a commercial broadcaster of free to air television in South Australia. The Australian Broadcasting Corporation (“the ABC”) is, amongst other things, a radio broadcaster and a publisher of news on its internet site. On Friday, 14 May 2004 and Saturday, 15 May 2004, Channel Seven broadcast promotions for its Today Tonight programme in the following terms:On Today Tonight South Australian Federal MP, her boyfriend and the business trip – disgusted that taxpayer funds have been used – the paper trail and whistle blower – he is a suspect in a murder case.The Channel Seven promotions included pictures of Patricia Draper, a South Australian Member of the Federal Parliament, and of the plaintiff and of one Corinna Marr. Corinna Marr was murdered in South Australia on 4 July 1997. The Amended Statement of Claim alleges that the fact that she was murdered is known to a large number of South Australians, that her picture would have been identified by a large number of South Australians, and that the appellant would have been identified by a large but unidentifiable number of persons who saw the promotions. On Sunday, 16 May 2004, Ms Draper obtained an interim injunction from a District Court Judge preventing Channel Seven from broadcasting the programme which had been the subject of its promotions. On Wednesday, 19 May 2004 there were two hearings before the District Court Judge during which the continuance of the injunction was argued. In a number of its regular radio news broadcasts on Wednesday, 19 May 2004, the ABC reported the proceedings in the District Court including an application by Channel Seven for the injunction to be revoked. The principal focus of each report was the Court’s prohibition of Channel Seven reporting that Ms Draper had travelled overseas with the appellant at the taxpayers’ expense. However, in the course of each report, the ABC reported an expression of concern by the District Court Judge about Channel Seven having mentioned in the promotions that the appellant was a murder suspect. The language used in each report varied but I think one example is sufficient to identify the basis of the appellant’s claim. In its 2.00 pm news bulletin the ABC said:[the Judge] said that he would not have imposed an injunction if the story was just about a travel rort. He said he was concerned Channel Seven referred to Sands as a murder suspect. In addition, in an article on its website on Wednesday, 19 May 2004, the ABC reported the statement by the District Court Judge that he was concerned that Channel Seven had referred to the appellant as a murder suspect.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Master was informed that the plaintiff intended the pleading in sub-paragraphs (a) and (b) of each of paragraphs 7 and 11 of the proposed Amended Statement of Claim to be one conjunctive pleading and not to allege separate imputations.The Decision of the Master The Master accepted the submission of each of Channel Seven and the ABC that their respective publications were not capable of bearing the meaning pleaded by the appellant in paragraphs 7 and 11 of the Amended Statement of Claim or as proposed to be pleaded in the Further Amended Statement of Claim. Accordingly, the Master dismissed the appellant’s application for leave to amend further the Amended Statement of Claim. The Master also ordered paragraphs 7 and 11 of the Amended Statement of Claim filed on 23 July 2004 to be struck out. The effect of the first order of the Master was that the appellant was also refused leave to make the cosmetic changes to which neither defendant had objected. The Master did not rule on an alternative submission made by Channel Seven, which was to the effect that the pleading in paragraph 7 of the Amended Statement of Claim (and in the proposed Further Amended Statement of Claim) should be struck out because of its ambiguity.The Appeal On appeal, the appellant alleges that the Master erred in law in striking out paragraphs 7 and 11 of the Amended Statement of Claim and in dismissing the application for leave to file a Further Amended Statement of Claim. The appellant submits that the Master should, as a matter of law, have found that the defamatory imputations pleaded by him were capable of arising from each of the respective publications of Channel Seven and the ABC. Although Channel Seven had not filed any Notice of Alternative Contention,[1] it argued that the decision to strike out paragraph 7 of the Amended Statement of Claim should be upheld on its alternative ground, namely, its ambiguity.[1] See SCR 97.08.The Legal Principles Each of the strike out applications was made pursuant to SCR 46.18. That Rule permits the Court to strike out the whole or part of a pleading which, amongst other things, discloses no reasonable cause of action or which has a tendency to cause prejudice, embarrassment or delay in the proceedings. Although there is no Rule of Court requiring a plaintiff to plead imputations where only the natural and ordinary meaning of the words published is relied upon, it is the practice in this State to plead the imputations which the plaintiff alleges. I note that in Chapman v Australian Broadcasting Corporation, Lander J, with whom Doyle CJ and Nyland J agreed, held that the effect of Chakravarti v Advertiser Newspapers Ltd[2] was to require a plaintiff to plead the imputations said to arise, whether the imputations arise out of the natural and ordinary meaning of the words or whether they arise by reason of extrinsic facts and circumstances known by the person to whom the publication was made.[3] There is of course, an obligation to plead the imputations and particulars of the facts and matters relied upon for those imputations where the plaintiff alleges that the published words have a defamatory sense in other than their ordinary meaning.[4] In each case, the pleading of the imputation relied upon informs the defendant of the precise imputation alleged by the plaintiff, and assists in the identification by the defendant of the basis, if any, on which the claim can be defended. Thus the issues between the parties may be narrowed.[2] [1998] HCA 37; (1998) 193 CLR 519.[3][2000] SASC 146; (2000) 77 SASR 181 at 189 [56]. See also Nationwide News Pty Ltd v Chapman [2001] SASC 30 at [9] per Doyle CJ (with whom Duggan and Williams JJ agreed).[4] SCR 46.19.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.