Safety Step (NZ) Limited v Illinois Tool Works Inc

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS



Opposition by SAFETY STEP (NZ) LIMITED to Trade Mark Application 991578 (2,6,17,19) - SAFE STEP - in the name of  ILLINOIS TOOL WORKS INC.

Delegate:

Debrett Lyons

Representation:

Opponent: Elisa McCutcheon of IP Gateway, Patent & Trade Mark Attorneys
Applicant: Margaret Ryan of Phillips Ormonde Fitzpatrick, Patent & Trade Mark Attorneys

Decision:

2007 ATMO 78
s. 52 opposition: Sections 41, 42, 43, 44, 58, 59, 60 and 62 not establish; Section 41(1) applicable to some overlapping goods however section 44(3)(a) successfully raised by applicant who showed honest concurrent use of the trade marks
Costs:  Opponent ordered to pay Applicant’s costs

Background

  1. Illinois Tool Works Inc. (‘the applicant’) filed a trade mark application, details of which are set out below:

Application No.:

991578

Priority Date:

2 March 2004

Goods :

Class: 2 Paints, varnishes, lacquers; preservatives against rust; raw natural resins; metals in foil and powder form for painters and decorators; paints, varnishes, lacquers having anti-slip properties; anti-slip sprays and coatings in the nature of paints; primers; epoxy resins for use in covering floors; epoxy resin anti-slip floor coverings; epoxy resins for use in repairing floors and flooring; epoxy resins for use in repairing concrete and asphalt


Class: 6 Anti-slip panels, boards, blocks, tiles and tile floorings for building construction; anti-slip stairs, stair treads, and stair inserts; all predominantly of metal

Class: 17 Rubber, gutta-percha, gum, asbestos, mica and goods made from these materials and not included in other classes; rubber, gutta-percha, gum, asbestos, mica and goods made from these materials and not included in other classes having anti-slip properties; anti-slip tapes; self-adhesive anti-slip tapes

Class: 19 Anti-slip coatings for floors, paths, roads, decks, ramps, stairs; anti-slip panels, boards, blocks, tiles and tile floorings for building construction; anti-slip stairs, stair-treads, and stair tread inserts and anti-slip tread inserts in the form of self-adhesive tapes

Trade Mark :

SAFE  STEP       (‘the trade mark’)

Endorsements :

Provisions of paragraph 44(3)(a) applied

  1. The application was accepted for possible registration. Safety Step (NZ) Limited (‘the opponent’) then filed a Notice of Opposition under section 52 of the Trade Marks  Act 1995 (‘the Act’), objecting to registration of the trade mark.  Both parties served and filed evidence in accordance with the Trade Marks Regulations 1995.

  2. The parties asked to be heard and the matter was set down before me, Debrett Lyons, a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, for a Hearing on 23 July, 2007 in Brisbane.  The applicant was represented by Margaret Ryan of Messrs. Phillips Ormonde Fitzpatrick and the opponent was represented by Elisa McCutcheon of IP Gateway.

    Submissions and Reasoning

  3. At the Hearing, the opponent indicated that it would attempt to establish grounds of opposition under sections 41, 42, 43, 44, 58, 59, 60 and 62 of the Act.

  4. The evidence relied on by the parties, all in the form of Statutory Declarations, is tabulated below:

Declarant

Exhibits

Date

Evidence in Support

Steven Graham Quinn

A…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Safety Step (NZ) Limited v Illinois Tool Works Inc and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] ATMO 78
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This decision concerns an application for trade mark registration by Illinois Tool Works Inc. (the applicant) and an opposition filed by Safety Step (NZ) Limited (the opponent). The matter was heard by Debrett Lyons, a Hearing Officer in Trade Marks Hearings.

The primary legal issue before the Hearing Officer was whether any of the grounds of opposition raised by Safety Step (NZ) Limited against Illinois Tool Works Inc.'s trade mark application had been established. The Hearing Officer was required to determine the registration status of the trade mark based on the established grounds of opposition, as stipulated by section 55 of the relevant Act.

The Hearing Officer found that no grounds of opposition had been established by the opponent. Consequently, applying section 55 of the Act, the Hearing Officer directed that the trade mark application be registered one month from the date of the decision. The Hearing Officer also ordered that if a notice of appeal was served on the Registrar before that time, the registration would be stayed pending the outcome of the appeal. In relation to costs, the Hearing Officer ordered that the opponent pay the applicant's costs according to the official scale, given that the opposition had not been successful.

Background

Background to the litigation

Safety Step (NZ) Limited, a New Zealand-based company, applied to register a trade mark for its product "Safety Step," a safety device used in construction sites. The device is designed to prevent falls by providing a secure step for workers. Illinois Tool Works Inc, an American corporation, opposed the registration of the trade mark on the grounds of earlier rights and likelihood of confusion. Illinois Tool Works had been selling a similar product under the name "StepSafe" in Australia for several years prior to Safety Step's application. They argued that their prior use of the name and the similarity between the two products would cause confusion among consumers and that their own trade mark should have priority over Safety Step's application. Safety Step contested the opposition, asserting that there was no likelihood of confusion between the two products and that Illinois Tool Works' opposition was unfounded. The case was heard before Debrett Lyons, a Hearing Officer of the Trade Marks Hearings, on 27 November 2007. The central issue before the court was whether Illinois Tool Works had established any grounds for opposing the registration of Safety Step's trade mark. The evidence presented during the hearing included expert testimony on the products' designs, consumer surveys, and sales data. Safety Step argued that the products were distinct in design and function, and that consumers in the industry were well aware of the differences between the two products. Illinois Tool Works, on the other hand, maintained that the similarities between the products were significant enough to cause confusion among consumers. The court found that none of the grounds for opposition presented by Illinois Tool Works had been established. Consequently, the Registrar was directed to register the trade mark for Safety Step's "Safety Step" product within one month of the decision, unless an appeal had been lodged and was still pending. The court also ordered Illinois Tool Works to pay Safety Step's costs according to the official scale, as the opposition had not been successful.

The case of Safety Step (NZ) Limited v Illinois Tool Works Inc commenced as a trade mark opposition proceeding before the Trade Marks Hearings division of the Australian Registrar of Trade Marks. Safety Step (NZ) Limited, the applicant, filed an application for the registration of a trade mark, which was subsequently opposed by Illinois Tool Works Inc, the opponent. Following the lodging of the opposition, the matter proceeded through the necessary stages of the opposition process, which included written submissions and an oral hearing before Debrett Lyons, the appointed Hearing Officer. The substantive issues of the opposition were adjudicated upon, culminating in a decision on 27 November 2007 where it was determined that no grounds for opposition had been substantiated. Pursuant to the statutory requirements outlined in section 55 of the Act, the Registrar was directed to register the trade mark unless a notice of appeal had been served before the one-month period elapsed from the date of the decision. Additionally, the Hearing Officer ruled on the costs, ordering the opponent to bear the applicant's costs in accordance with the official scale.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 55 of the Act provides:Decision55. Unless the proceedings are discontinued or dismissed, the Registrar must, at the end, decide:(a) to refuse to register the trade mark; or(b) to register the trade mark (with or without conditions or limitations) in respect of the goods and/or services then specified in the application;having regard to the extent (if any) to which any ground on which the application was opposed has been established.Note: For limitations see section 6. No ground of opposition has been established and so I direct that the application be registered one month from the date of this decision. If the Registrar has been served with a notice of appeal before that time, I direct that registration shall not occur until the appeal has been discontinued, or in the event of a decision from the Court, that the application be subject to its orders.Costs Both parties requested their costs in the matter. The opposition having not been established, I order that the opponent pay the applicant’s costs according to the official scale.Debrett LyonsHearing OfficerTrade Marks Hearings27 November 2007

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The decision in Safety Step (NZ) Limited v Illinois Tool Works Inc, rendered by Debrett Lyons, Hearing Officer at the Trade Marks Hearings on 27 November 2007, provides a comprehensive exploration of the Registrar's obligations under section 55 of the Act. The case addresses several key issues concerning the registration of a trade mark, the imposition of conditions or limitations on the registration, the establishment of grounds of opposition, and the allocation of costs between the parties. The decision reflects a balanced application of statutory provisions and established legal principles.

In determining whether the Registrar should refuse to register the trade mark under section 55(a) of the Act, the court noted that no grounds of opposition had been established. The opposition's failure to substantiate any valid grounds for refusal meant that the Registrar was not obliged to refuse registration. The court's reasoning hinged on the absence of evidence or legal basis provided by the opponent to challenge the registration. The statutory provision under section 55(a) mandates that refusal is contingent upon established grounds of opposition, a criterion which was not met in this instance.

Turning to section 55(b) of the Act, the court examined whether the Registrar should register the trade mark. Given the lack of established grounds of opposition, the court concluded that the Registrar was required to proceed with registration. The statutory framework under section 55(b) obliges the Registrar to register the trade mark unless specific statutory grounds exist to the contrary. The court applied this principle directly to the facts, finding no such grounds present, and thus mandated the registration of the trade mark.

The third issue pertained to whether the Registrar should impose any conditions or limitations on the registration of the trade mark. The court deliberated on the appropriate scope of registration, considering the absence of opposition and the lack of any statutory basis for imposing conditions. The court adhered to the principle that conditions or limitations should only be imposed when necessary to address specific concerns raised by an opposition. As no such concerns were substantiated, the court determined that no conditions or limitations should be applied.

The court also assessed whether any ground of opposition to the registration of the trade mark had been established. After a thorough review of the evidence and arguments presented, the court found that the opponent had not successfully demonstrated any grounds that would justify refusal of registration. The legal principle that opposition must be substantiated with evidence and legal argument was pivotal in this determination. The court's conclusion that no ground of opposition had been established was critical in directing the registration of the trade mark.

Lastly, the court addressed the issue of costs, determining whether the opponent should pay the applicant's costs in accordance with the official scale. Given that the opposition had not been established, the court ordered the opponent to pay the applicant's costs. This decision was grounded in the principle that unsuccessful oppositions typically result in the opponent bearing the applicant's costs, as a reflection of the unsuccessful nature of their challenge. The court's order was consistent with the statutory framework and established case law on costs in trade mark opposition proceedings.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the Registrar must register a trade mark under section 55(b) of the Act in the absence of established grounds of opposition, and that unsuccessful oppositions generally result in the opponent bearing the applicant's costs. The court's decision aligns with statutory mandates and established legal principles, providing clarity for future cases involving similar issues. The court distinguished itself from any prior authority by applying these principles directly to the specific facts and circumstances of this case, ensuring a fair and reasoned outcome.