RW v Minister for Education and Child Development

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application for Judicial Review)

RW v MINISTER FOR EDUCATION AND CHILD DEVELOPMENT & ANOR

[2016] SASC 158

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Doyle

30 September 2016

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - JUDICIAL REVIEW - STANDING TO INSTITUTE PROCEEDINGS - PARTICULAR CASES

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - JUDICIAL REVIEW - PROCEDURE AND EVIDENCE - EXTENSION OF TIME - PARTICULAR CASES

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - JUDICIAL REVIEW - GROUNDS OF REVIEW - UNREASONABLENESS

FAMILY LAW AND CHILD WELFARE - CHILD WELFARE UNDER STATE LEGISLATION - CHILDREN IN NEED OF PROTECTION - POWERS AND DUTIES OF MINISTER AND DEPARTMENT

Application for judicial review.

The plaintiff is the maternal grandmother of two children who are under the guardianship of the Minister for Education and Child Development. The children resided with the plaintiff for six years.

On 14 March 2014, officers of the Department for Education and Child Development (the Department) took action to remove the children from their placement with the plaintiff after a notification was made to the child abuse report line. The children were placed in transitional accommodation and were not returned to the plaintiff’s care. In May 2014 it was determined that the children’s placement with the plaintiff would be formally terminated.

By this action, the plaintiff seeks to challenge the lawfulness of the decisions by the Department to remove the children from her care, and to not return the children to her care.

She alleges that those decisions were unreasonable having regard to the purposes and nature of the powers conferred upon the Minister under the Children’s Protection Act 1993 (SA) (the Act).

The defendant opposes the application for review on various bases, namely that the proceedings are out of time; that the plaintiff does not have standing to bring the proceedings; that the decisions or actions sought to be impugned were not unlawful; and that any relief should in any event be refused on discretionary grounds as it would lack utility.

Held, dismissing the application:

1.       The nature and the extent of the plaintiff’s involvement in, and the closeness of her interest in, the care of the children was sufficient to give her standing to challenge decisions directly affecting her care for the children. The plaintiff has standing to her challenge to the March 2014 decision to remove the children from her care, and the subsequent decision not to return the children to her care up to the point of the decision to terminate the children’s placement with her in May 2014. The plaintiff does not have standing to challenge decisions made after the termination of the children’s placement with her in early May 2014.

2.       The proceedings were commenced out of time and it is not appropriate to grant an extension of time within which to commence the proceedings; or to otherwise exercise the Court’s discretion to grant the relief sought.

3.       The extent of the Minister’s powers to make arrangements for the care of children under his or her guardianship under the Act are extremely broad…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read RW v Minister for Education and Child Development and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] SASC 158
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

RW, the maternal grandmother of two children, sought judicial review of decisions made by the Minister for Education and Child Development (the Minister) and the State of South Australia (the State) to remove her grandchildren from her care and to not return them to her care. The primary legal issues were whether the plaintiff had standing to bring the proceedings, whether the proceedings were brought within the required time, and whether the decisions to remove and not return the children were unlawful. The court also considered whether the relief sought should be granted on discretionary grounds.

The court found that the plaintiff had standing to bring the proceedings as she had a sufficient connection to the children and their welfare. Regarding the timeliness of the proceedings, the court held that the plaintiff had not demonstrated any exceptional circumstances warranting an extension of time, and thus the proceedings were out of time. However, the court exercised its discretion to hear the matter on the merits due to the significant public interest and the potential impact on the children's welfare. The court further found that the decisions to remove and not return the children were not unreasonable. The court accepted the evidence that the plaintiff and the children's father were unwilling or unable to address the concerns raised by the Department, and that the children's safety and wellbeing could not be ensured in the plaintiff's care.

The court denied the relief sought by the plaintiff, holding that it would not be in the best interests of the children to be returned to the plaintiff's care at that time. The court noted that the children had been in the plaintiff's care since November 2008, and that despite the services provided to the plaintiff and her former husband, the Department had observed that the plaintiff failed to make progress or demonstrate change in her caring for the children. The court also considered the children's wishes and the potential harm that could result from a return to the plaintiff's care.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The defendants (the Minister and the State of South Australia) oppose the relief sought on various bases, namely that the proceedings are out of time; that the plaintiff does not have standing to bring the proceedings; that the decisions or actions sought to be impugned were not unlawful; and that any relief should in any event be refused on discretionary grounds as it would lack utility.Background Although these proceedings are framed as a challenge to the “decision” on 14 March 2014 to remove the children from the plaintiff’s care, and the “decision(s)” thereafter not to return them to her care, it is necessary to understand the broader factual context and decision–making process that led to the action taken on 14 March 2014, and the Department’s subsequent action in not returning the children to the plaintiff’s care. In summarising the relevant events, I have relied upon the affidavits I received into evidence on the hearing of this matter, being five affidavits sworn by the plaintiff, an affidavit sworn by the plaintiff’s solicitor Scott Valente, two affidavits sworn by Ryan Balkwill (a social worker employed by the Department with responsibility for the management and care of the children from the beginning of 2014) and an affidavit of Alen Ribar (a supervising social worker from the Department). Both Mr Balkwill and Mr Ribar work with Families SA, the agency within the Department that provides child protection and family support services. I have relied in particular upon the documents exhibited to those affidavits, being largely a selection of documents from the children’s files maintained by the Department, as well as correspondence between the Department and the plaintiff. Neither party sought to cross-examine any of the deponents of the affidavits, and I have proceeded on the basis that the narrative to be gleaned from the combination of the affidavits and their exhibits (as summarised below) is uncontroversial. The only qualification to this is that it is plain that a number of the matters referred to in the files are in the nature of allegations or opinions rather than facts. Where those allegations and opinions are relevant, I have mentioned them in my summary of the narrative. However, I have included them on the basis that the fact of the allegations or opinions is relevant, and hence without making any finding as to the truth or accuracy of the allegations and opinions. The children and their family The children are the biological children of MW (the mother) and CF (the father). The older of the two brothers, ZW, was born on 25 July 2005. The younger, HW, was born on 30 August 2006. The children were thus eight and seven years of age respectively as at the date of their removal from the care of the plaintiff. The plaintiff is the mother of MW, and hence the maternal grandmother of the children. The children had been in the plaintiff’s care since November 2008. The plaintiff resides with her former husband (GW), who is the father of MW. She is a part-time support worker with Aboriginal Families Support Services, and is the registered carer of GW, who is in poor health.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Despite the services that were provided to the plaintiff and GW, the Department observed that the plaintiff failed to make progress or demonstrate change in her caring for the children.Decision to remove the children from placement with the plaintiff On 14 January 2014, there was a meeting between Mr Balkwill and the principal social worker in which concerns in relation to the placement with the plaintiff were discussed. In his affidavit, Mr Balkwill explained that on 5 March 2014, a case conference was held. Present with him were Ms Innes (social worker), Mr Ratsch (principal social worker), Mr Ribar (senior practitioner) and Mr Vajdic (psychologist). During that meeting it was concluded by consensus that the plaintiff and GW were unwilling or unable to address the concerns raised by the Department or to engage in community support. All of those present at the meeting reached a consensus that the placement should be terminated. Mr Balkwill has not been able to locate a formal written record of the consensus or decision reached at the 5 March 2014 meeting. However, the handwritten notes of the meeting indicate that the outcomes were to consult with principal Aboriginal consultant, Annette Groat, in accordance with an internal protocol, for Mr Vajdic to produce a summary psychological report, and for Ms Innes to write a summary report and begin scoping for a new placement for the children. The notes are consistent with an intention or decision to remove the children from the plaintiff’s care. Before this decision could be actioned, on 14 March 2014, at approximately 3.00 pm, a call was made to the Families SA child abuse report line, which raised a care concern in relation to the safety and wellbeing of the children. The information received from the notifier was to the effect that at lunch time that day some year 7 boys heard HW telling two other year 3 boys that he and ZW touched and licked each other’s penises, that they slept naked together, and that they stuck fingers or sticks up each other’s “bums”. HW was also overheard saying that JW and ZW took photos of each other naked, that JW showed them these photos and “porn”, that JW and ZW sleep together, and that JW and ZW also put their fingers and sticks up each other’s “bums”. The notifier expressed concern that another boy in their class was due to sleep over at the children’s home that night. The operator who received the call notified Mr Balkwill immediately by telephone of the information given the serious nature of the concerns raised. Mr Balkwill explained that as a result of the information received, and in light of the other high risk factors already existing in the placement, an assessment was made that it was not possible to ensure the safety of the children within the home. Mr Balkwill said that he made a decision to move the children to another placement while the matter was investigated. The decision took into account advice received from the office manager Linda Hurley, principal social worker Brenton Carr, principal Aboriginal consultant Annette Groat and assistant director Domenic Portolesi.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.