Ruttley v Willis Brothers Installation (Qld) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Ruttley v Willis Brothers Installation (Qld) Pty Ltd [2022] FedCFamC2G 430

File number(s): BRG 479 of 2020
Judgment of: JUDGE TONKIN
Date of judgment: 9 June 2022
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – Adverse action – whether adverse action taken because employee exercised a workplace right – whether employment terminated because employee suffered from a disability – whether employer discharged presumption imposed by section 361 (a) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) – whether employer contravened sections 340 and 351 (1) of Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) – order for compensation
Legislation:

Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld)

Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth)

 Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth)

Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Hall [2018] FCAFC 83

Australian Licenced Aircraft Engineers Association v International Aviation Service Assistance Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 333

Board of Bendigo Regional Institute of Technical and Further Education v Barclay [2012] HCA 32

Construction Forestry Mining and Energy Union v De Martin & Gasparini Pty Ltd (No 2)

Construction, Forestry, Mining & Energy Union v Endeavour Coal Pty Ltd [2013] FCCA 473

Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v BHP Coal Pty Ltd[2014] HCA 41

Fair Work Ombudsman v Skilled Offshore (Australia) Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 275

Hodkinson v The Commonwealth [2011] FMCA 171

Ingersole v Castle Hill Country Club Limited [2014] FCCA 450

Roohizadegan v Technology One Limited (No 2) [2020] FCA 1407

Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 228
Date of last submission/s: 13 December 2021
Date of hearing: 11-14 October 2021
Place: Brisbane
Counsel for the Applicant: Ms Blattman
Solicitor for the Applicant: Shand Taylor Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: Ms A-Khavari
Solicitor for the Respondent: K & L Gates

ORDERS

BRG 479 of 2020

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

TIMOTHY JOHN RUTTLEY

Applicant

AND:

WILLIS BROTHERS INSTALLATION (QLD) PTY LTD ACN 132 309 936

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

JUDGE TONKIN

DATE OF ORDER:

9 JUNE 2022

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

1.The Respondent Willis Bros Installations (Qld) Pty Ltd contravened:

(a)section 351(1) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) in that the Respondent took adverse action by terminating the applicant’s employment because he was a person with a physical disability;

(b)section 340 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) in that the Respondent took adverse action in injuring the applicant in his employment because the applicant exercised his workplace right by making a worker’s compensation claim under the Worker’s Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 (Cth); and

(c)section 340 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (FW Act) in that the Respondent took adverse action by terminating the applicant’s employment because he exercised a workplace right to make an inquiry in relation to his employment.

THE COURT ORDERS

2.Pursuant to section 545 of the FW Act the respondent shall pay to the applicant compensation in the amount of $162,631 in addition to interest as calculated pursuant to section 76 (3) of the

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ruttley v Willis Brothers Installation (Qld) Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FedCFamC2G 430
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Ruttley v Willis Brothers Installation (Qld) Pty Ltd, the applicant, Timothy Ruttley, sought relief for various adverse actions taken against him by the respondent company. These actions included being treated less favourably than other employees due to his disability, having his salary package unilaterally altered, being denied wage payments during personal leave, being denied accrued leave entitlements upon termination, and ultimately being terminated from his position as production manager. The court was tasked with determining whether these actions constituted prohibited reasons for dismissal under the applicable employment laws.

The legal issues at hand were whether the adverse actions taken against Timothy Ruttley were due to his disability and whether they constituted a prohibited reason for dismissal. The court examined the evidence presented, including Timothy's testimony about his working conditions, the diagnosis of silicosis, and the subsequent actions taken by Duncan Willis, the majority shareholder and controlling mind of the company. The court also considered the respondent's arguments, which did not dispute that Timothy's disability did not prevent him from performing his duties.

The court found that Duncan Willis, as the controlling mind of the respondent, made all decisions affecting Timothy, including the recall of his vehicles, phone, and fuel card, wage reductions, and termination of employment. The court was satisfied that Duncan's actions were driven by Timothy's diagnosis of silicosis, which led Duncan to believe Timothy could no longer perform his job effectively. Despite Timothy's medical certificates indicating he was unfit for work due to workplace stress and other medical conditions, Duncan proceeded with the termination based on the excuse of exhausted leave entitlements.

The court concluded that Timothy's dismissal was indeed for a prohibited reason, as it was influenced by his disability. The adverse actions taken against Timothy were not justified and contravened the protections afforded to employees under the relevant employment legislation. The court found in favor of Timothy Ruttley, awarding him relief for the unlawful termination and other adverse actions taken against him.

The final orders of the court included a declaration that the respondent had unlawfully terminated Timothy Ruttley's employment, compensation for the unlawful termination, and other remedies as deemed appropriate to address the adverse actions taken against Timothy.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

On or about 11 May 2020 the applicant’s employment was terminated.Background Willis Bros Installations (Qld) Pty Ltd was established by Duncan and Justin Willis on the Gold Coast in about 1997 and carries on the business of manufacturing and installing stone benchtops and is one of a group of companies that operates a business installing and manufacturing stone benchtops for kitchens and bathrooms. Willis Bros Installations (Qld) Pty Ltd is part of the Willis Group of companies which include Group Manufacturing Pty Ltd, Willis Bros Sydney Pty Ltd, Willis Bros Victoria Pty Ltd, Willis Bros Holdings 2012 Pty Ltd; and WB Holding Unit Trust. The controlling mind of the company group, including the respondent, is Duncan Willis. Group Manufacturing Pty Ltd employs 22 employees, holds accounts for the entities’ creditors and receives the income and pays the expenses that are related to manufacturing and installation activities. Willis Bros employs 16 employees, and is the entity which holds the QBCC licence to undertake the work related to the manufacturing and installation of stone benchtops. Willis Bros. Holdings 2012 Pty Ltd owns the assets of the company including the vehicles used by Willis Bros. Duncan Willis has held the position of managing director of Group Manufacturing since 3 September 2018 and has not held any executive or director position at Willis Bros since October 2012. Justin Willis left Willis Bros in 2008 to join the fire brigade. He returned to work at Willis Bros at Duncan’s request and was appointed a director of Willis Bros on 16 December 2019. Renee Coleman commenced employment with Willis Bros in about 2011, was appointed Chief Financial Officer of Willis Bros in around 2017 and is currently the general manager of the Willis Group. The applicant commenced work for the respondent on 20 July 1997 at 18 years of age initially as an apprentice stonemason, cutting and installing stone products. In 2006 the applicant was promoted to foreman in 2006 and in 2007 to production manager. He remained production and installation manager until his employment was terminated. According to Duncan the applicant was employed by other associated companies of Willis Bros in various positions from 1997 and as production manager for Willis Bros from July 2008. He was a previously a director of entities within the Willis Group from 6 October 2008 to September 2018 and director of the respondent from 12 January 2016 until 30 April 2020. The applicant and his brother Simon Ruttley acquired an interest in Willis Bros. Duncan is the majority shareholder for Willis Bros whilst Simon’s interest is 30% and the applicant’s interest 17%. In about 2017 Work Health and Safety Queensland directed Willis Bros to have its workers screened for silicosis. Both Simon and the applicant were diagnosed with lymph node silicosis. The applicant contends that following that diagnosis Duncan had decided to exit both Simon and Timothy from Willis Bros. On 19 July 2019 the applicant’s brother Simon’s employment with the respondent was terminated.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The respondent does not contend that the applicant’s silicosis made him unable to perform the inherent requirements of his employment or that he was dismissed because of such a belief. APPLICANT’S EVIDENCETimothy Ruttley Timothy said when he commenced working for Willis Bros in 1997 as an 18 year old apprentice for the first 12 months of his employment he was not provided with personal protective equipment or a face mask. He used a T shirt around his face when grinding and cutting stone bench tops. After 12 months Duncan provided him with a face mask after his trade school advised him it was mandatory to wear a face mask. He worked 12 hours a day and was not paid any overtime. He completed his stonemason apprenticeship in mid - 2001. He continued to work “on the tools” (grinding and cutting stone bench tops) working half the time in the factory shaping marble and half the time installing stone benchtop products. After he finished his apprenticeship Duncan installed industrial ceiling fans which helped suck the silica dust from the factory floor. The fans had no filters which meant airborne particles produced from the bench top products circulated overhead. His brother Simon commenced working for Willis Bros in 2001 aged 16 years. In 2003 after Simon finished his apprenticeship Simon and Timothy discussed opening their own business. According to both Simon and Timothy, Duncan found out about their intention to open their own business and encouraged them not to leave Willis Bros. He offered each of them a 10% interest in Willis Bros which they accepted. Timothy was promoted to foreman in 2006 and was responsible for supervising the Willis Bros factory. In 2007 he was promoted to production manager where he was responsible for scheduling Willis Bros jobs and ensuring that jobs were performed correctly, visiting and inspecting each job and tidying up the work that had been completed. In 2008 Duncan’s brother Justin left Willis Bros and Simon and Timothy agreed to acquire Justin’s shareholding increasing their interest in Willis Bros to 17% each. On 6 October 2008 Timothy was appointed as a director of the respondent. In 2013 Timothy said he, Duncan and Simon agreed that they would all be paid the same annual salary by Willis Bros. Before this he and Simon were paid an hourly rate for hours worked each week. From 2013 his and Simon’s salary comprised a weekly wage, allowances for a vehicle for personal and work use, a vehicle for their spouse and allowance for fuel, registration and telephone expenses. Simon confirmed this in cross examination and said there was nothing in writing however this was a verbal agreement between each of them including Duncan. In 2013 it was agreed that Simon would receive an additional 13% interest in Willis Bros as he was assisting in managing the company with the result that Simon holds a 30% interest in Willis Bros, the applicant a 17% interest and Duncan a 53% interest and the majority shareholder. In 2017 Work Health and Safety Queensland increased their site visits after multiple workers in the stone benchtop industry were diagnosed with silicosis due to exposure to silica dust particles. WorkCover directed all workers with silicosis to refrain from performing work in an environment containing silica dust. By the end of 2018 some 48 workers were unable to attend work.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The adverse action about which the applicant seeks relief in these proceedings includes:(a)Treating the applicant less favourably than other employees of the respondent due to his physical and mental disability despite the applicant’s diagnosis not inherently preventing him from performing his duties as an employee of the respondent there being no medical concerns to substantiate the respondent’s concerns about the applicant’s alleged incapacity;(b)Unilaterally reducing the applicant’s wage, cancelling the applicant’s fuel card, re - directing the applicant’s mobile phone all of which formed part of the applicant’s salary package;(c)Failing to pay the applicant his wage whilst on personal leave from 26 March 2020; (d)Failing to pay the applicant’s accrued leave entitlements on termination of employment; and(e)Terminating his employment by letter dated 11 May 2020, which (notwithstanding the applicant’s medical certificate stating he was suffering from workplace stress) the reason given for termination was “the excessive period of leave and your absence is not based on Workers Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 as it is not a work-related incident.”Who was the decision maker for the respondent? I am satisfied that Duncan Willis as majority shareholder of Willis Bros and director of six of the companies that comprised the Willis Group, Willis Bros also being part of the Willis Group was the controlling mind of the respondent. He requested Justin Willis return to work for Willis Bros and prepared a company resolution as majority shareholder appointing Justin a director of Willis Bros on 16 December 2019 in circumstances where Timothy (who remained a director) refused to provide his consent. I am satisfied that Duncan made all the decisions for Willis Bros including recalling the vehicles, mobile phone and fuel card, reducing his wages, ceasing to pay Timothy any entitlements from March 2020 and terminating his employment on 11 May 2020. Each of those decisions impacted adversely on Timothy. I am satisfied that Renee had full knowledge of those decisions and acted under Duncan’s authority. I find that Justin who had recently returned to work with Willis Bros after a 10 year absence acted with Duncan’s authority in terminating Timothy’s employment contrary to his assertion that he alone made that decision. Events leading to termination The events leading to termination are discussed at length above and may be summarised as follows:(a)On 20 November 2018 Timothy was diagnosed with lymph node silicosis. Duncan formed a view that he would not be able to continue as production and installation manager for Willis Bros due to his physical disability. Persons diagnosed with silicosis were unable to complete stone masonry work and were not to be exposed to silica dust. Simon who was also diagnosed with silicosis had his employment terminated in July 2019. He had refused to transfer his interest in Willis Bros to Duncan.(b)In January 2019 Timothy made a workers compensation claim and WorkCover accepted the claim for compensation in relation to his silicosis diagnosis. (c)In September 2019 Duncan attempted to obtain the QBCC nominee supervisor licence which was rejected. He became increasingly aggressive and intimidating towards Timothy but at that stage needed Timothy to continue to operate the production and installation side of the business.(d)Sometime in November 2019 Duncan requested Justin return to work for Willis Bros. He had the requisite stone masonry qualifications and he obtained a QBCC nominee supervisor licence. At that point Timothy was no longer needed to continue to operate the production and installation side of the business. Justin was appointed a director of Willis Bros on 16 December 2019.(e)In December 2019 Duncan made an offer to buy out Timothy’s interest in Willis Bros which was not accepted. Duncan acted on his intention to terminate Timothy’s employment on the basis that he remained a liability to the business because he was diagnosed with silicosis. (f)On 14 January 2020 Duncan recalled Timothy’s two vehicles, diverted his phone and cancelled his fuel card leaving Timothy, his wife and children without a vehicle. (g)Timothy forwarded the respondent a medical certificate which stated he was suffering from workplace stress from 14 January 2020 to 14 February 2020 and would be unfit for work.(h)On 13 February 2020 Timothy forwarded the respondent a medical certificate which stated he was suffering from a medical condition between 13 February 2020 and 28 April 2020 and would be unfit for work.(i)Whilst Timothy was on personal (sick) leave on 21 February 2020 Duncan ceased paying Timothy his QBCC allowance reducing the amount Timothy received in wages.(j)On 16 March 2020 Duncan ceased paying Timothy his wages (or personal leave entitlements) notwithstanding Timothy had provided a medical certificate indicating he was unfit to work until 20 May 2020.(k)On 6 and 9 April and 21 April 2020 Duncan ignored Timothy’s request when he made an inquiry about his personal and annual leave entitlements.(l)On 6 April 2020 Duncan moved a resolution to remove Timothy as director of Willis Bros.(m)On 28 April 2020 Timothy forwarded the respondent a medical certificate which stated he was suffering from a medical condition between 28 April 2020 and 30 May 2020 and would be unfit for work.(n)On 30 April 2020 Timothy was removed as a director of Willis Bros. (o)On 11 May 2020 Duncan terminated Timothy’s employment on the basis that he had exhausted his leave entitlements. Was Timothy dismissed for a prohibited reason

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The reverse onus aims to assist employees overcome the difficult task of proving what is in the mind of the person alleged to have taken adverse action.[2] Further evidence that the decision maker acted for a non - prohibited reason may be rendered unreliable by the quality of their own evidence.[3][2] Port Kembla Coal Terminal Ltd v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2016] FCAFC 99 at 449 [3] State of Victoria (Office of Public Prosecutions) v Grant [2014] FCAFC 184 at [32] Consideration The adverse action about which the applicant seeks relief in these proceedings includes:(a)Treating the applicant less favourably than other employees of the respondent due to his physical and mental disability despite the applicant’s diagnosis not inherently preventing him from performing his duties as an employee of the respondent there being no medical concerns to substantiate the respondent’s concerns about the applicant’s alleged incapacity;(b)Unilaterally reducing the applicant’s wage, cancelling the applicant’s fuel card, re - directing the applicant’s mobile phone all of which formed part of the applicant’s salary package;(c)Failing to pay the applicant his wage whilst on personal leave from 26 March 2020; (d)Failing to pay the applicant’s accrued leave entitlements on termination of employment; and(e)Terminating his employment by letter dated 11 May 2020, which (notwithstanding the applicant’s medical certificate stating he was suffering from workplace stress) the reason given for termination was “the excessive period of leave and your absence is not based on Workers Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 as it is not a work-related incident.”Who was the decision maker for the respondent? I am satisfied that Duncan Willis as majority shareholder of Willis Bros and director of six of the companies that comprised the Willis Group, Willis Bros also being part of the Willis Group was the controlling mind of the respondent. He requested Justin Willis return to work for Willis Bros and prepared a company resolution as majority shareholder appointing Justin a director of Willis Bros on 16 December 2019 in circumstances where Timothy (who remained a director) refused to provide his consent. I am satisfied that Duncan made all the decisions for Willis Bros including recalling the vehicles, mobile phone and fuel card, reducing his wages, ceasing to pay Timothy any entitlements from March 2020 and terminating his employment on 11 May 2020. Each of those decisions impacted adversely on Timothy. I am satisfied that Renee had full knowledge of those decisions and acted under Duncan’s authority. I find that Justin who had recently returned to work with Willis Bros after a 10 year absence acted with Duncan’s authority in terminating Timothy’s employment contrary to his assertion that he alone made that decision. Events leading to termination The events leading to termination are discussed at length above and may be summarised as follows:(a)On 20 November 2018 Timothy was diagnosed with lymph node silicosis. Duncan formed a view that he would not be able to continue as production and installation manager for Willis Bros due to his physical disability. Persons diagnosed with silicosis were unable to complete stone masonry work and were not to be exposed to silica dust. Simon who was also diagnosed with silicosis had his employment terminated in July 2019. He had refused to transfer his interest in Willis Bros to Duncan.(b)In January 2019 Timothy made a workers compensation claim and WorkCover accepted the claim for compensation in relation to his silicosis diagnosis. (c)In September 2019 Duncan attempted to obtain the QBCC nominee supervisor licence which was rejected. He became increasingly aggressive and intimidating towards Timothy but at that stage needed Timothy to continue to operate the production and installation side of the business.(d)Sometime in November 2019 Duncan requested Justin return to work for Willis Bros. He had the requisite stone masonry qualifications and he obtained a QBCC nominee supervisor licence. At that point Timothy was no longer needed to continue to operate the production and installation side of the business. Justin was appointed a director of Willis Bros on 16 December 2019.(e)In December 2019 Duncan made an offer to buy out Timothy’s interest in Willis Bros which was not accepted. Duncan acted on his intention to terminate Timothy’s employment on the basis that he remained a liability to the business because he was diagnosed with silicosis. (f)On 14 January 2020 Duncan recalled Timothy’s two vehicles, diverted his phone and cancelled his fuel card leaving Timothy, his wife and children without a vehicle. (g)Timothy forwarded the respondent a medical certificate which stated he was suffering from workplace stress from 14 January 2020 to 14 February 2020 and would be unfit for work.(h)On 13 February 2020 Timothy forwarded the respondent a medical certificate which stated he was suffering from a medical condition between 13 February 2020 and 28 April 2020 and would be unfit for work.(i)Whilst Timothy was on personal (sick) leave on 21 February 2020 Duncan ceased paying Timothy his QBCC allowance reducing the amount Timothy received in wages.(j)On 16 March 2020 Duncan ceased paying Timothy his wages (or personal leave entitlements) notwithstanding Timothy had provided a medical certificate indicating he was unfit to work until 20 May 2020.(k)On 6 and 9 April and 21 April 2020 Duncan ignored Timothy’s request when he made an inquiry about his personal and annual leave entitlements.(l)On 6 April 2020 Duncan moved a resolution to remove Timothy as director of Willis Bros.(m)On 28 April 2020 Timothy forwarded the respondent a medical certificate which stated he was suffering from a medical condition between 28 April 2020 and 30 May 2020 and would be unfit for work.(n)On 30 April 2020 Timothy was removed as a director of Willis Bros. (o)On 11 May 2020 Duncan terminated Timothy’s employment on the basis that he had exhausted his leave entitlements. Was Timothy dismissed for a prohibited reason