JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
STREAM: DEVELOPMENT & RESOURCES
ACT: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)
CITATION: ROBERTSON and SHIRE OF MURRAY [2009] WASAT 171
MEMBER: MR D R PARRY (SENIOR MEMBER)
HEARD: DETERMINED ON THE DOCUMENTS
DELIVERED : 4 SEPTEMBER 2009
FILE NO/S: DR 348 of 2008
BETWEEN: PETER JOHN ROBERTSON
YVONNE ROBERTSON
ApplicantsAND
SHIRE OF MURRAY
Respondent
Catchwords:
Town planning - Development application - Motorcycle track - Special use equestrian-based zone - Whether proposed development requires development approval - Whether motorcycle track is 'development' - Whether motorcycle track is a 'work' - Whether riding motorcycles on motorcycle track is incidental or ancillary to residential or equestrian use - Whether requirement for development approval is obviated by authorisation under the Control of Vehicles (Off-road Areas) Act 1978 (WA) - Whether proposed development is capable of approval under local planning scheme - Local planning scheme states land 'may only be used for training, trotting and stabling of horses and associated activities including residential' - Whether there is power to approve proposed development despite non-compliance with provision - Whether provision is a 'standard or requirement' prescribed under local planning scheme - Amenity - Noise - Whether requirement in reg 7 of Environmental Protection (Noise) Regulations 1997 (WA) that noise should not exceed assigned levels at nearest affected premises does not apply because of reg 14 of Environmental Protection (Noise) Regulations 1997 (WA) - Whether a motorcycle is 'specified equipment' - Whether the land is 'residential premises' - Whether motorcycle would be used in a reasonable manner - Whether noise would unreasonably interfere with amenity - Whether proposed development is consistent with zoning - Local government direction - Direction to remove motorcycle track and to restore land - Whether direction too broad - Direction to cease use of motorcycle track
Legislation:
Control of Vehicles (Off-road Areas) Act 1978 (WA), s 6, s 6(1), s 45, s 47, s 47(1)
Environmental Protection Act 1986 (WA), s 3(1)
Environmental Protection (Noise) Regulations 1997 (WA), reg 2(1), reg 3, reg 7, reg 8, reg 9, reg 14, reg 14(2), Sch 1 Pt C
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 214, s 214(2), s 214(3), s 252(1), s 255(1)
Shire of Murray Town Planning Scheme No 4, cl 1.7, cl 3.1.2, cl 3.5(c), cl 6.6, cl 13.3.1, Sch V, Appendix 1
Result:
Application for review dismissed
Development approval for construction and use of a motorcycle track at No 64 (Lot 21) Greenlands Road, Pinjarra refused
Direction to remove motorcycle track and to restore the land at No 64 (Lot 21) Greenlands Road, Pinjarra confirmed but varied to enable removal and restoration to be completed by 4 December 2009
Direction to cease use of motorcycle track at No 64 (Lot 21) Greenlands Road, Pinjarra confirmed
Category: A
Representation:
Counsel:
Applicants: Mr S Steenhof
Respondent: Mr C Slarke
Solicitors:
Applicants: Cornerstone Legal
Respondent: McLeods
Case(s) referred to in decision(s):
Australian Racing Drivers' Club Limited v Baulkham Hills Shire Council (1981) 2 APA 127
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read ROBERTSON and SHIRE OF MURRAY and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] WASAT 171
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The WCAT examined whether the proposed motorcycle track was a 'development' or a 'work' that required approval under the local planning scheme. The court held that the use of the land for regular and specific motorcycle training and testing, particularly for competition purposes, was a separate and distinct use from residential purposes. Therefore, the proposed use did not constitute an incidental or ancillary activity to the residential use of the land. Furthermore, the court noted that riding off-road motorcycles on the track was not exempt from development approval under the Control of Vehicles (Off-road Areas) Act 1978 (WA). The court found that the regular use of the land for professional training and testing purposes, such as for motorcycle competitions, was not incidental or ancillary to residential use. Consequently, the proposed development required approval under the local planning scheme.
In its decision, the WCAT emphasised that the noise impacts of riding motorcycles on a track within close proximity to common boundaries in an equestrian-zoned locality were inconsistent with reasonable amenity expectations of nearby residents. The Tribunal found that the proposed use of the land for motorcycle training and testing, for up to 10 hours a week, including four hours on weekends, would unreasonably interfere with the amenity of neighbouring properties. The court also concluded that the proposed development was not consistent with the zoning of the land and was therefore not capable of approval under the local planning scheme. The WCAT upheld the Shire's direction to remove the motorcycle track and restore the land, as well as to cease use of the motorcycle track, finding that the direction was not too broad.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
It is recognised that:Rural areas generate a variety of 'externalities' - mainly noise and dust emissions. One cannot expect to reside in such a zone and necessarily expect a quiet and serene rural environment. (Marley-Duncan v Corporation of the Town of Gawler [2003] SAERDC 28 at [21])and'People … who choose to live beyond the urban fringe should do so in the knowledge that they may have to live with a less pleasant environment than they may have originally expected. (Australian Racing Drivers' Club Limited v Baulkham Hills Shire Council (1981) 2 APA 127 at 130). However, the noise impacts of riding motorcycles on a track with a significant length and, for large parts, within just a few metres of common boundaries, in a locality zoned and generally developed for equestrian purposes, for up to 10 hours a week, including up to four hours on weekends, is plainly inconsistent with reasonable amenity expectations of residents in the locality. As the Tribunal found in relation to a similar proposal in a similar location in Townsend and Shire of Donnybrook/Balingup [2005] WASAT 276 at [70]:Reflecting the activity that produced it, the noise here is not, in the Tribunal's view, comparable to the 'usual' but largely transient and intermittent sounds that one might be exposed to in a rural residential area. A further reason why the proposed use is not incidental or ancillary to the residential use of the site is, to quote Mr Peake's evidence:The purpose of the track is to provide for the regular and specific motorcycle training and testing needs of the owner's son for competition purposes. Such needs are more akin to a use in its own right than that which would generally be expected in an incidental domestic situation; As Mr Robertson said in evidence, his son Liam Robertson would use the proposed modified motorcycle track for testing, tuning and running in motorbikes, prior to competing in motorcycle events throughout Australia. The regular use of land for the purposes of one's profession, occupation or calling, including training for motorcycle competitions, is not incidental or ancillary to residential use, even if one also resides on the land. The use is not consequent on, nor naturally attaching, appertaining or relating to the residential use, but rather is a separate and distinct use. Mr and Mrs Robertson relied on s 6, s 45 and s 47 of the Control of Vehicles (Off-road Areas) Act 1978 (WA) (Off-road Vehicles Act) in support of their argument that the riding of off-road motorcycles on the proposed modified motorcycle track does not require the Shire's approval. Section 6(1) of the Off‑road Vehicles Act creates an offence for a person to drive or use an off-road vehicle otherwise than on private land by consent or on land comprised within a permitted area, with certain exceptions. Section 45 of the Off-road Vehicles Act permits a local government to make local laws for the purposes of that Act. Section 47(1) of the Off-road Vehicles Act authorises the Governor, by notice published in the Government Gazette, to revoke or amend a local law or local planning scheme which, in the opinion of the Governor, is 'repugnant to or inconsistent with the provisions of this Act … insofar as it is so repugnant or inconsistent …'.