MOREA ARCHITECTS and TOWN OF VINCENT [2006] WASAT 263
| STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL | Citation No: | [2006] WASAT 263 | |
| TOWN PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 1928 (WA) | |||
| Case No: | DR:123/2006 | DETERMINED ON THE DOCUMENTS | |
| Coram: | MR D R PARRY (SENIOR MEMBER) | 1/09/06 | |
| 35 | Judgment Part: | 1 of 1 | |
| Result: | DR 123 of 2006 - Application for review allowed in part Development approval granted for alterations to shopfront and rear loading bay Development approval refused for external signage DR 124 of 2006 - Application for review allowed in part Direction set aside in relation to use Direction affirmed in relation to external signage | ||
| B | |||
| PDF Version |
| Parties: | MOREA ARCHITECTS TOWN OF VINCENT SHIOK MOON LAW |
Catchwords: | Town planning – Development application – External signage and alterations to shopfront and rear loading bay of retail building – Signage significantly exceeds total signage area standard under planning policy – Adverse impact on existing and likely future amenity – Whether application of standard is unreasonable or undesirable in the circumstances – Whether signage merely rebadging of former retail signage – Local government direction – Direction requires immediate cessation of use of most of building as a shop and storage and removal of signage – Direction addressed to business name, not applicant personally – Argument of validity – Argument not apposite in administrative review – Distinction between administrative and judicial review – Discretion to give direction – Factors which guide exercise of discretion – Interior building alterations and use of land as shop exempt from requirement for development approval under local planning scheme – Building licence plans approved in 1965 show whole of building as shop and (ancillary) storage – Inference that development approval not required when building erected or was obtained – Whether use of area identified as (ancillary) storage on building licence plans has changed to shop – Direction set aside in relation to use – Direction affirmed in relation to signage – Costs – Exercise of discretion in relation to review proceedings concerning local government direction – Usually each party should pay its own costs – Unreasonable conduct by council in issuing notice which precipitated proceedings and in proceedings – No reasonable basis for issue of notice in relation to use – Unreasonable failure by council to undertake search of approvals in relation to site – Council ordered to pay professional costs and disbursements of application for review in relation to use |
Legislation: | Local Government Act 1995 (WA), s 9.7 Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 214, s 214(1), s 214(2), s 214(3), s 238(3)(a)(i), s 238(4), s 255(1) State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 19(3)(b), s 21, s 27(2), s 60(2), s 87, s 87(2), s 87(3), s 87(4)(b), s 88 State Administrative Tribunal Rules 2004 (WA), r 43 Town of Vincent Town Planning Scheme No 1, cl 10, cl 13, cl 29, cl 32(1), cl 32(2), cl 33, cl 33(a), cl 33(d), cl 33(f), cl 38(5), cl 38(5)(g), cl 38(5)(h) Town Planning and… |
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read MOREA ARCHITECTS and TOWN OF VINCENT and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2006] WASAT 263
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to decide whether the Town of Vincent's application of the signage standard was unreasonable or undesirable in the circumstances, and whether the signage constituted a rebadging of the former retail signage. Additionally, the court needed to determine the validity of the direction given to Chemist Warehouse and whether the council had acted unreasonably in issuing the notice that led to the proceedings. The court also had to consider the distinction between administrative and judicial review and the discretion to give direction.
The court found that the signage significantly exceeded the total signage area standard under the planning policy and had an adverse impact on existing and likely future amenity. However, the court set aside the direction concerning the use of the property as a shop and storage facility, as there was no reasonable basis for the council's issuance of the notice. The court affirmed the direction in relation to the signage, as it found that the signage was not merely a rebadging of the former retail signage. The court ordered the council to pay the professional costs and disbursements of the application for review in relation to the use of the property. The court allowed the application for review in part, granting development approval for the alterations to the shopfront and rear loading bay but refusing approval for the external signage. The court also set aside the direction given to Chemist Warehouse concerning the use of the property as a shop and storage facility and substituted a decision that no direction be given.
Orders
Orders of the court
In proceedings DR 123 of 2006 - 1. The application for review is allowed in part. 2. Development approval is granted for alterations to shopfront and rear loading bay at Lot 2 (Nos 412 - 414) Fitzgerald Street, North Perth in accordance with three sheets of plans drawn by Morea Architects Project Chemist Warehouse Drawing MAO550TP1A (existing conditions ground floor plan), MAO550TP2A (proposed ground floor plan) and MAO550TP3A (existing conditions rear elevation and proposed rear elevation) each dated 13 December 2005. 3. Development approval is refused for external signage at Lot 2 (Nos 412 - 414) Fitzgerald Street, North Perth. In proceedings DR 124 of 2006 - 1. The application for review is allowed in part. 2. The decision of the Town of Vincent to give a direction to Chemist Warehouse dated 24 March 2006 under s 10(2) of the Town Planning and Development Act 1928 (WA) requiring Chemist Warehouse to immediately stop and not recommence the use of the property located at Lot 2 (Nos 412 - 414) Fitzgerald Street, North Perth, Western Australia, being the whole of the land described in Certificate of Title Volume 1511 Folio 11 (property), as a shop and storage for the purposes of a pharmacy business is set aside and a decision is substituted in its place that no direction be given.
Background
Background to the litigation
The Town of Vincent exercised its discretion under section 10(2) of the Town Planning and Development Act 1928 (WA) to give a direction concerning the use of the property. The Town of Vincent claimed that the use of the area identified as storage on the building licence plans had changed to a shop, but this claim was not substantiated. The Town of Vincent's decision to require Chemist Warehouse to stop using the property as a shop and storage was unreasonable and undesirable, particularly as the interior building alterations and use of the land as a shop were exempt from the requirement for development approval under the local planning scheme. Furthermore, the Town of Vincent failed to undertake a reasonable search of the approvals in relation to the site. This unreasonable conduct by the council in issuing the notice and in the proceedings led to an order for the Town of Vincent to pay the professional costs and disbursements of the application for review.
This case pertains to a dispute over a development application involving external signage and alterations to the shopfront and rear loading bay of a retail building located at Lot 2 (Nos 412 - 414) Fitzgerald Street, North Perth. The applicant, Morea Architects, sought review of the decision made by the Town of Vincent, which had issued a direction requiring the cessation of most of the building's use as a shop and storage, and the removal of signage. The application for review was heard in the State Administrative Tribunal of Western Australia. This was not a first-instance hearing but an administrative review of a local government decision. The Town of Vincent had issued the direction under section 10(2) of the Town Planning and Development Act 1928 (WA). The key procedural steps involved in this matter included the initial direction issued by the Town of Vincent, followed by Morea Architects lodging an application for review of that decision with the State Administrative Tribunal. During the proceedings, arguments were presented regarding the validity of the direction, the scope of the Tribunal's discretion in reviewing local government decisions, and the distinction between administrative and judicial review. The Tribunal's decision ultimately set aside the direction concerning the use of the property as a shop and storage, while affirming the direction regarding the removal of the signage. The Tribunal also addressed the issue of costs, finding that the council's unreasonable conduct warranted an order for the council to pay the professional costs and disbursements of the application for review in relation to the use of the property.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the application of the total signage area standard under the planning policy is unreasonable or undesirable in the circumstances, given that the signage significantly exceeds the standard and has an adverse impact on existing and likely future amenity.
2. Whether the signage constitutes merely a rebadging of former retail signage.
3. Whether the local government direction requiring immediate cessation of use of most of the building as a shop and storage and removal of signage is valid, given that the direction is addressed to the business name, not the applicant personally.
4. Whether the distinction between administrative and judicial review applies in this case, and if so, how it affects the argument of validity.
5. What factors guide the exercise of discretion in giving a direction under s 10(2) of the Town Planning and Development Act 1928 (WA).
6. Whether the use of the area identified as (ancillary) storage on the building licence plans has changed to a shop.
7. Whether the direction set aside in relation to use should be affirmed in relation to signage.
8. Whether the council's conduct in issuing the notice that precipitated the proceedings and in the proceedings was unreasonable, and whether there was a reasonable basis for issuing the notice in relation to use.
9. Whether the council's failure to undertake a search of approvals in relation to the site was unreasonable.
10. Whether the council should be ordered to pay professional costs and disbursements of the application for review in relation to use, and whether the usual rule that each party should pay its own costs applies in this case.
Held
1. The application of the total signage area standard under the planning policy is deemed unreasonable or undesirable in the circumstances. The court granted development approval for the signage alterations despite the significant exceedance of the standard and the adverse impact on existing and likely future amenity.
2. The signage does not constitute merely a rebadging of former retail signage. The court found that the signage was not simply a rebranding exercise but involved significant changes.
3. The local government direction requiring immediate cessation of use of most of the building as a shop and storage and removal of signage is invalid. The court held that the direction is addressed to the business name, not the applicant personally, making the argument of validity not apposite in administrative review.
4. The distinction between administrative and judicial review applies in this case, affecting the argument of validity. The court found that the distinction is relevant and impacts the argument regarding the validity of the direction.
5. The exercise of discretion in giving a direction under s 10(2) of the Town Planning and Development Act 1928 (WA) is guided by factors such as the nature of the use, the impact on amenity, and the compliance with planning policies.
6. The use of the area identified as (ancillary) storage on the building licence plans has not changed to a shop. The court found that the area was originally intended for storage and had not been converted to a shop.
7. The direction set aside in relation to use is affirmed in relation to signage. The court set aside the direction concerning the use of the property as a shop and storage but upheld the direction to remove the signage.
8. The council's conduct in issuing the notice that precipitated the proceedings and in the proceedings was unreasonable, and there was no reasonable basis for issuing the notice in relation to use. The court found the council's actions to be unreasonable and without a reasonable basis.
9. The council's failure to undertake a search of approvals in relation to the site was unreasonable. The court held that the council's failure to verify approvals was unreasonable.
10. The council should be ordered to pay professional costs and disbursements of the application for review in relation to use. The court ruled that the usual rule that each party should pay its own costs does not apply in this case, and ordered the council to pay the costs.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The case of Morea Architects and Town of Vincent presents a multifaceted review of a local government decision regarding a development application and subsequent direction under the Town Planning and Development Act 1928 (WA). The court's reasoning primarily revolves around the application of planning standards, the nature of the signage in question, the validity of a local government direction, and the appropriateness of costs awarded in the proceedings.
The court first addressed whether the application of the total signage area standard under the planning policy was unreasonable or undesirable in the circumstances, given that the signage significantly exceeded the standard and had an adverse impact on existing and likely future amenity. The court considered the nature and extent of the signage and its impact on the amenity of the area, finding that the signage substantially exceeded the standard set forth in the planning policy. However, the court did not find the application of the standard to be unreasonable or undesirable, thus setting aside the direction related to the use of the property as a shop and storage.
The court then examined whether the signage constituted merely a rebadging of former retail signage. The court concluded that the signage in question was not merely a rebadging but rather a new and significant addition that substantially exceeded the permitted signage area, leading to the refusal of development approval for the external signage.
Further, the court addressed the validity of the local government direction requiring immediate cessation of use of most of the building as a shop and storage and the removal of signage. The direction was addressed to the business name, not the applicant personally, leading the court to conclude that the argument of validity was not apposite in the context of administrative review. The court noted that the distinction between administrative and judicial review applied, affecting how the argument of validity was considered.
Regarding the exercise of discretion in giving a direction under s 10(2) of the Town Planning and Development Act 1928 (WA), the court identified several factors that guide this discretion, including the nature and extent of the contravention, the public interest, and the impact on the amenity of the area. The court found that the local government had not appropriately exercised its discretion in this instance, particularly given the significant impact of the signage on the area's amenity.
The court also considered whether the use of the area identified as (ancillary) storage on the building licence plans had changed to a shop. Given the evidence, the court concluded that the use had not changed and thus set aside the direction related to the use of the property as a shop and storage.
In relation to the direction set aside in respect of use but affirmed in respect of signage, the court held that the direction concerning signage was valid and should stand, whereas the direction concerning the use of the property was not valid and should be set aside.
The court examined the council's conduct in issuing the notice that precipitated the proceedings and in the proceedings themselves. It found the council's conduct to be unreasonable, particularly in issuing a notice with no reasonable basis in relation to the use of the property. The court also found the council's failure to undertake a search of approvals in relation to the site to be unreasonable.
Finally, the court addressed the issue of costs, determining that the council should be ordered to pay the professional costs and disbursements of the application for review in relation to use. The court held that the usual rule that each party should pay its own costs did not apply in this case due to the unreasonable conduct of the council.
In summary, the court's reasoning centred on the application of planning standards, the nature of the signage, the validity of the local government direction, the exercise of discretion, and the appropriateness of costs. The binding legal principles established or applied by the decision include the importance of considering the impact of signage on amenity, the distinction between administrative and judicial review in assessing the validity of directions, and the factors guiding the exercise of discretion in administrative decisions. The court's decision to set aside the direction related to the use of the property as a shop and storage and to affirm the direction concerning signage highlights the nuanced approach required in administrative review proceedings.