LAW and TOWN OF VINCENT

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read
JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
STREAM : DEVELOPMENT & RESOURCES
ACT : TOWN PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT
1928 (WA)
CITATION : LAW and TOWN OF VINCENT [2006] WASAT 263
(S)
MEMBER : MR D R PARRY (SENIOR MEMBER)
HEARD : DETERMINED ON THE DOCUMENTS
DELIVERED : 1 SEPTEMBER 2006
SUPPLEMENTARY
DECISION : 28 SEPTEMBER 2007
FILE NO/S : DR 123 of 2006
BETWEEN : SHIOK MOON LAW

Applicant

AND

TOWN OF VINCENT

Respondent

Catchwords:

Costs - Assessment of reasonable costs - Apportionment of costs for one out of four review matters determined together - Professional costs and disbursements including archival search in relation to planning approvals - Local government direction - Direction required immediate cessation of use of most of building as shop and storage - Direction set aside - Unreasonable conduct by local government in issuing direction which precipitated proceedings and in proceedings - Unreasonable failure by local government to undertake search of approvals in relation to the land

[2006] WASAT 263 (S)

Legislation: 

State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 9(b), s 60(2)
Legal Practitioners (Supreme Court) (Contentious Business) Determination
2004 (WA)
Legal Practitioners (Supreme Court) (Contentious Business) Report and
Determination 2006 (WA)

Town Planning and Development Act 1928 (WA), s 10(2)

Result:

Reasonable professional costs and disbursements of the application for review of the direction under s 10(2) of the Town Planning and Development Act 1928 (WA), including reasonable professional costs and disbursements of undertaking a search of the archives of the City of Perth in relation to approvals granted in respect of the property, is assessed at $7814.04

Category: B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant : Ms LE Rowley
Respondent : Ms BK Callanan

Solicitors:

Applicant : Deacons
Respondent : Williams Handcock

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

J & P Metals Pty Ltd and Shire of Dardanup [2006] WASAT 282 (S)

Morea Architects and Town of Vincent; Law and Town of Vincent [2006]

WASAT 263; (2006) 44 SR (WA) 301

[2006] WASAT 263 (S)

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:

Summary of Tribunal's decision

1              The Tribunal made an order, in proceedings for review of a direction

requiring the cessation of use of premises as a shop, that the local government pay the applicant's reasonable professional costs and disbursements of the review. The review was one of four reviews that were determined by the Tribunal together. The parties were unable to agree on the amount of costs and disbursements payable under the order.

  1. The Tribunal assessed reasonable costs and disbursements attributable to the use review on the following basis:

• costs and disbursements that appear to relate exclusively to this review were fully included using the relevant Supreme Court scale by analogy;
• costs and disbursements that appear to relate exclusively to another review were fully excluded;
• costs and disbursements that appear to relate to the review generally were apportioned on the basis of the approximate proportion of the Tribunal's reasons for decision attributable to the use review using the relevant Supreme Court scale by analogy;…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read LAW and TOWN OF VINCENT and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] WASAT 263 (S)
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Law and Town of Vincent, the applicant, Shiok Moon Law, sought review of a direction issued by the Town of Vincent requiring the cessation of use of her property as a shop and storage area. The State Administrative Tribunal determined the matter and set aside the direction, finding it unreasonable. The applicant subsequently applied for an order that the Town pay her costs and disbursements related to the review proceedings. The Town contested the amount of the costs and disbursements claimed by the applicant, leading to a supplementary decision by the Tribunal regarding the assessment of costs.

The legal issues before the Tribunal were the determination of the reasonable professional costs and disbursements attributable to the applicant's review of the direction, and the apportionment of costs where the review was conducted together with other related matters. The Tribunal had to balance the importance and complexity of the proceedings with the need to minimise costs to the parties, given its generally no-costs jurisdiction.

The Tribunal assessed the costs based on several factors. It considered the proportion of the reasons for decision that related to the review of the use direction, which was approximately 20% of the total reasons. The Tribunal also took into account the complexity and importance of the review, the amount of time and effort required, and the scales applicable to Supreme Court work as an appropriate analogy. After reviewing the itemised invoices provided by the applicant's solicitors and architect, the Tribunal concluded that a fair assessment of costs would include certain items in full, exclude others, apportion some items at 20%, and include a reasonable amount for the preparation of further itemised invoices. The Tribunal determined that the reasonable professional costs and disbursements attributable to the review of the use direction, including the archival search, amounted to $7814.04.

The Tribunal made an order that the Town of Vincent pay the applicant's reasonable professional costs and disbursements of the review of the use direction, including the archival search, in the amount of $7814.04. This amount was based on the Tribunal's assessment of the costs and disbursements in light of the nature of the proceedings, their complexity and importance, and the time and effort required.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 1 September 2006, the State Administrative Tribunal determined applications for review brought by Morea Architects and Ms Shiok Moon Law (Ms Law) concerning the use and physical development of a retail building at Nos 412–414 Fitzgerald Street, North Perth. The Town of Vincent had issued directions requiring the cessation of shop and storage use of the building and the removal of signage displayed on the building. Ms Law sought review of the use direction and the signage direction. The Tribunal set aside the use direction, finding that use of the site as a shop and ancillary storage did not require development approval under the local planning scheme. The Tribunal affirmed the signage direction, because the local planning scheme required development approval for the signage, which had not been obtained. The Tribunal made an order that the Town pay Ms Law's reasonable professional costs and disbursements of the application for review of the use direction, including her reasonable professional costs and disbursements of an archival search. The parties could not agree on the amount of costs and disbursements payable by the Town, and the Tribunal was required to assess the reasonable costs and disbursements.

Ms Law claimed $21 257.52 in costs for both the use direction and the signage direction. The Town rejected the claim and requested the Tribunal to assess the reasonable costs and disbursements. Ms Law subsequently provided itemised invoices claiming $24 198.21 for the use direction only. The Town filed submissions in relation to the costs assessment, contending that the amount claimed was excessive. The Tribunal assessed Ms Law's reasonable professional costs and disbursements of the use direction, including the archival search, at $7814.04. The Tribunal found that apportionments of two-thirds and 77% of the total costs and disbursements were both excessive and unreasonable, having regard to the scope of the proceedings and the issues for determination. The Tribunal considered that approximately 20% of its substantive determination of the proceedings was attributable to the use direction. The Tribunal also found that 19 hours was excessive and unreasonable for the preparation of the further itemised invoices, and that eight hours would be a reasonable period for this work.

The case of LAW and TOWN OF VINCENT came before the State Administrative Tribunal of Western Australia in the Development and Resources stream. On 1 September 2006, the Tribunal determined applications for review brought by Morea Architects and Shiok Moon Law concerning decisions made by the Town of Vincent regarding the use and physical development of a retail building. The proceedings were determined together entirely on the documents pursuant to the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA). The applications sought review of the deemed refusal of a development application for signage and building works, and directions given by the Town which required the cessation of shop and storage use of the building and the removal of signage displayed on the building. The Tribunal set aside the direction requiring the cessation of use of most of the building as a shop and storage, finding that such use did not require development approval under the local planning scheme. The Tribunal also affirmed the direction for the removal of signage, as development approval was required for the signage and had not been obtained. Following the Tribunal's determination, Shiok Moon Law applied for an order that the Town pay costs for her expenses, loss, inconvenience, and embarrassment occasioned by the issue of the use and signage directions. The Tribunal ordered that the Town pay Shiok Moon Law's reasonable professional costs and disbursements of the application for review of the use direction, including her reasonable professional costs and disbursements of undertaking a search of the archives of the City of Perth in relation to approvals granted in respect of the property. As the parties were unable to agree on the amount of costs and disbursements payable, the matter proceeded to a costs assessment hearing.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What is the appropriate analogy for assessing costs in proceedings before the State Administrative Tribunal?
2. What proportion of the applicant's total professional costs and disbursements is reasonably attributable to the use direction, including the archival search?
3. What is a reasonable amount for the preparation of further itemised invoices requested by the Town?
4. Are there any other costs and disbursements that should be included or excluded from the assessment of the applicant's costs?
5. What is the total amount of costs and disbursements that the respondent should pay to the applicant?

Held
1. What is the appropriate analogy for assessing costs in proceedings before the State Administrative Tribunal?
The appropriate analogy for assessing costs in proceedings before the State Administrative Tribunal is to legal work which is subject to the Legal Practitioners (Supreme Court) (Contentious Business) Determination 2004 (WA) and the Legal Practitioners (Supreme Court) (Contentious Business) Report and Determination 2006 (WA).

2. What proportion of the applicant's total professional costs and disbursements is reasonably attributable to the use direction, including the archival search?
The Tribunal determined that approximately 20% of the applicant's total professional costs and disbursements is reasonably attributable to the use direction, including the archival search.

3. What is a reasonable amount for the preparation of further itemised invoices requested by the Town?
The Tribunal considered that eight hours would be a reasonable period for the preparation of the further itemised invoices, using the relevant Supreme Court scale for a clerk.

4. Are there any other costs and disbursements that should be included or excluded from the assessment of the applicant's costs?
The Tribunal determined that costs and disbursements that appear to relate exclusively to the review of the use direction, including the archival search, should be fully included in the assessment. Costs and disbursements that appear to relate exclusively to the development application or review concerning the development application should be excluded from the assessment. Half the costs and disbursements that appear to relate to the applicant's application for costs should be included in the assessment. Twenty percent of the costs and disbursements that appear to relate to the conduct of the proceedings generally should be attributed to the review of the use direction, including the archival search.

5. What is the total amount of costs and disbursements that the respondent should pay to the applicant?
The respondent should pay the applicant's costs and disbursements assessed at $7814.04 in accordance with Order 5 made on 1 September 2006.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal's reasoning in assessing the costs in the proceedings before it was grounded in the principles of proportionality and reasonableness, consistent with its general objectives of minimising costs to the parties. The court considered the analogy for assessing costs, determining that Supreme Court scales for contentious business were most appropriate due to the complexity and importance of the proceedings. In apportionment of costs for the use direction, the court applied a pragmatic approach, assessing costs based on the proportion of the Tribunal's reasons attributable to the use direction, which was determined to be approximately 20%. The court rejected the applicant's initial claims of two-thirds and 77% apportionment as excessive. For the archival search, the court included costs and disbursements that related exclusively to the search, and apportioned other costs based on relevance to the proceedings generally. Regarding the preparation of further itemised invoices, the court found that eight hours was a reasonable amount of time, rather than the 19 hours claimed by the applicant's solicitors. The total amount of costs and disbursements the respondent should pay to the applicant was assessed at $7814.04. The ratio decidendi of this case is that in assessing costs in proceedings before the State Administrative Tribunal, the court will apply a pragmatic approach, using an appropriate analogy and considering the nature, complexity, and importance of the proceedings to ensure proportionality between the matter and the associated costs.