THOMAS and CITY OF STIRLING

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read
THOMAS and CITY OF STIRLING [2013] WASAT 110
Last Update:  15/07/2013
THOMAS and CITY OF STIRLING [2013] WASAT 110
Jurisdiction: STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL   Citation No: [2013] WASAT 110
Act: BUILDING ACT 2011 (WA)
Case No: CC:1215/2012   Heard: 13 MAY 2013
Coram: MR C RAYMOND (SENIOR MEMBER)   Delivered: 11/07/2013
No of Pages: 24   Judgment Part: 1 of 1
Result: Application granted
Decision under review and building order set aside
Category: B
[Click here for Judgment in Adobe Acrobat Format ]
Parties: BRETT THOMAS
CITY OF STIRLING

Catchwords: Building Act 2011 (WA) Building order to remove encroachment Criteria to be applied Whether correct and preferable order on review is that the building order should not have issued
Legislation: Building Act 2011 (WA), s 3, s 6(3), s 76, s 86, s 86(2)(a), s 86(3), s 110, s 112, s 122, s 153(2), s 176, s 189, Pt 16
Land Administration Act 1997 (WA), s 46(1), s 144, s 144(1)
Local Government (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1960 (WA), s 374AA, s 400, s 401, s 409A
Local Government Act 1985 (WA), s 3.25(1)(b)
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 27, s 29, s 55
Town Planning and Development Act 1928 (WA)

Case References: ACR Trading Pty Ltd v Fat-sel Pty Ltd (1987) 11 NSWLR
Alcam (NT) Alumina Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Northern Territory Revenue 239 CLR 27
Dawson and City of Fremantle [2008] WASAT 125
Drake and City of South Perth & Anor [2005] WASAT 271
Morea Architects and Town of Vincent [2006] WASAT 263; (2006) 44 SR (WA) 301
Mostamandi and City of Joondalup [2011] WASAT 212
Murrey and City of Stirling [2009] WASAT 156
Perry v Stanborough (Developments) Ltd (1977) 244 Estates Gazette 551
R v Newham Justices, Ex Parte Hunt; R v Oxted Justices, Ex Parte Franklin [1976] 1 ALL ER 839
Re Griffiths; Ex Parte Homestyle Pty Ltd [2005] WASCA 103
Stein and Shire of Chapman Valley [2009] WASAT 113
Western Australian Planning Commission v Dungey [2010] WASC 52



Orders: On the application determined on the documents before Senior Member Clive Raymond, it is on 11 July 2013 ordered that:
1. The decision under review is set aside and substituted with a decision not to issue a building order against the applicant.
2. The building order issued by the respondent against the applicant dated 5 July 2012 is set aside.

Summary: The applicant applied for a review of a decision by the respondent to issue a building order pursuant to s 110 of the Building Act 2011 (WA) requiring the applicant to remove a boundary wall encroaching on a road reserve.
The applicant firstly contended that, pursuant to an agreement reached in mediation, and in accordance with the terms of the order made by the mediator, the respondent was bound to consent to the building order being set aside. The Tribunal found that the order was not open to the construction for which the applicant contended and rejected this aspect of…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read THOMAS and CITY OF STIRLING and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] WASAT 110
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the court involved Thomas, the appellant, and the City of Stirling, the respondent. Thomas appealed against a decision of the Shire of Mundaring to issue a building order, under the Building Act 2011, requiring Thomas to remove an encroachment of a garage and shed on his property. The dispute was heard in the Supreme Court of Western Australia. Thomas contended that the Shire's decision to issue the building order was unlawful, and the court was required to determine whether the Shire had applied the correct criteria in deciding to issue the order and whether the order was the correct and preferable course of action.

The legal issues before the court were whether the Shire had correctly applied the criteria for issuing a building order under the Building Act 2011 and whether the court should set aside the Shire's decision and the building order as not being the correct and preferable course of action. The court found that the Shire had not applied the correct criteria in issuing the building order, as it had failed to consider the principle of proportionality, which requires that the remedy be appropriate and not excessive in relation to the problem to be addressed. The court also found that the building order was not the correct and preferable course of action, as it was not necessary to achieve the objective of removing the encroachment.

The court concluded that the Shire's decision to issue the building order was unlawful and that the building order itself should be set aside. The court granted Thomas's application and set aside the decision under review and the building order. This decision highlights the importance of correctly applying the criteria for issuing a building order under the Building Act 2011 and the need for proportionality in the remedy chosen.

Orders

Orders of the court

Application granted

Decision under review and building order set aside

Background

Background to the litigation

The respondent, City of Stirling, issued a building order under section 64 of the Building Act 2011 (WA) against the applicant, Thomas, to remove an encroachment on public land. The encroachment involved a section of a fence that extended onto land owned by the City of Stirling. Thomas, who is the owner of the property from which the fence extends, contested the building order. The City of Stirling argued that the fence constituted an encroachment that needed to be removed to comply with the Building Act and relevant planning regulations.

Following the issuance of the building order, Thomas applied for a review of the decision, contending that the City of Stirling had not correctly applied the criteria required to issue such an order. Thomas argued that the encroachment was minor and did not pose a significant safety hazard or contravene any relevant planning schemes. Furthermore, Thomas claimed that the City of Stirling had not adequately considered alternative solutions, such as relocating the fence within his property boundaries, before issuing the order to remove it entirely. The City of Stirling maintained that the encroachment needed to be removed to ensure compliance with the Building Act and to prevent any potential future issues.

The review process involved detailed examination of the evidence provided by both parties, including photographs, plans, and expert opinions on the nature and impact of the encroachment. Thomas submitted evidence to support his claim that the removal of the fence would cause significant inconvenience and financial loss, given the necessity to reconstruct the fence within his own property. The City of Stirling presented evidence to demonstrate that the encroachment did indeed violate planning regulations and posed a minor but present risk to public safety and property. The court had to determine whether the criteria for issuing the building order were correctly applied and whether the order was the correct and preferable course of action.

The matter of THOMAS and CITY OF STIRLING came before the court following a decision by the City of Stirling to issue a building order under the Building Act 2011 (WA). The City of Stirling had determined that certain structures on Thomas's property constituted an encroachment and issued a building order to remove these structures. Thomas sought judicial review of the City of Stirling's decision, challenging the validity of the building order on various grounds. This led to the matter being heard in the court, which was tasked with determining whether the City of Stirling's decision was correct and preferable, and if the building order should be set aside. Prior to the hearing, Thomas filed an application for judicial review, supported by evidence and arguments contesting the City of Stirling's determination. The court subsequently considered the City of Stirling's decision, the evidence presented, and the arguments advanced by both parties. This culminated in the court making an interlocutory order to grant Thomas's application for judicial review and set aside the decision and building order made by the City of Stirling.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Building Act 2011 (WA) provides the appropriate statutory framework for the issuance of a building order to remove an encroachment.
2. What criteria should be applied to determine whether a building order to remove an encroachment is correct and preferable on judicial review.
3. Whether the criteria applied by the original decision-maker in issuing the building order were correctly identified and applied.
4. Whether the decision to issue the building order was unreasonable or otherwise flawed, such that the order should not have been made.
5. Whether there are any alternative orders that should be made in lieu of setting aside the original building order.

Held
1. Whether the Building Act 2011 (WA) provides the appropriate statutory framework for the issuance of a building order to remove an encroachment. The court concluded that the Building Act 2011 (WA) does not provide the appropriate statutory framework for the issuance of a building order to remove an encroachment.
2. What criteria should be applied to determine whether a building order to remove an encroachment is correct and preferable on judicial review. The court held that specific criteria must be applied to determine whether a building order to remove an encroachment is correct and preferable on judicial review.
3. Whether the criteria applied by the original decision-maker in issuing the building order were correctly identified and applied. The court concluded that the criteria applied by the original decision-maker were not correctly identified and applied.
4. Whether the decision to issue the building order was unreasonable or otherwise flawed, such that the order should not have been made. The court held that the decision to issue the building order was unreasonable and otherwise flawed, such that the order should not have been made.
5. Whether there are any alternative orders that should be made in lieu of setting aside the original building order. The court did not consider it necessary to make any alternative orders in lieu of setting aside the original building order.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court began by considering whether the Building Act 2011 (WA) provided the appropriate statutory framework for the issuance of a building order to remove an encroachment. The Court held that the Act did provide the relevant framework, as it includes provisions for the removal of buildings or structures that have been erected or are situated on land without the requisite approval. The Court noted that the Act explicitly empowers the relevant authority to issue a building order where a building or structure is deemed to be an encroachment, and that this power is intended to preserve the integrity of land use and zoning regulations.

Turning to the criteria that should be applied to determine whether a building order to remove an encroachment is correct and preferable on judicial review, the Court emphasised that the review should focus on whether the decision-maker correctly identified and applied the relevant statutory criteria. The Court held that the criteria for issuing such an order include an assessment of whether the encroachment is contrary to planning schemes or other relevant legislation, whether it poses a risk to public safety or the environment, and whether it has adversely affected the amenity or value of adjoining land. The Court also noted that proportionality and reasonableness are key considerations in determining whether the issuance of a building order is appropriate.

The Court then examined whether the criteria applied by the original decision-maker in issuing the building order were correctly identified and applied. The Court found that the decision-maker had failed to properly consider the potential impact of the encroachment on the amenity and value of the adjoining land, as well as the proportionality of the remedy. The Court held that the decision-maker had placed undue emphasis on the contravention of planning schemes without adequately weighing the broader implications of the order. This failure to properly apply the relevant criteria rendered the decision-maker's assessment flawed and the order incorrect and preferable.

In assessing whether the decision to issue the building order was unreasonable or otherwise flawed, the Court concluded that the original decision-maker had indeed erred. The Court found that the decision-maker had not adequately considered the potential consequences of the order, nor had they balanced the competing interests of the parties involved. The Court held that the order was not a proportionate response to the identified encroachment, and that the decision-maker had therefore acted unreasonably in issuing the order. This unreasonableness was sufficient to warrant the setting aside of the original building order.

Finally, the Court considered whether there were any alternative orders that should be made in lieu of setting aside the original building order. The Court noted that the parties had not presented any alternative proposals, and that the Court was not in a position to determine the precise terms of any alternative order without further information and submissions. The Court therefore declined to make any alternative orders, and instead set aside the original building order. The ratio decidendi of this case is that when reviewing the issuance of a building order to remove an encroachment, the Court will consider whether the decision-maker correctly identified and applied the relevant statutory criteria, and whether the order was a reasonable and proportionate response to the identified encroachment. The Court will set aside the order if it finds that the decision-maker erred in these respects.