SULLIVAN and SHIRE OF CARNARVON

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

ACT: BUILDING ACT 2011 (WA)

CITATION:   SULLIVAN and SHIRE OF CARNARVON [2023] WASAT 43

MEMBER:   MS C BARTON, MEMBER

HEARD:   DETERMINED ON THE DOCUMENTS

DELIVERED          :   20 JUNE 2023

FILE NO/S:   DR 91 of 2022

BETWEEN:   GLENDA SULLIVAN

First Applicant

DAVID KEARNEY

Second Applicant

DAVID SADECKY

Third Applicant

BARRY MASON

Fourth Applicant

SHANE AYLMORE

Fifth Applicant

KIM GANE

Sixth Applicant

JOANNE BUZZARD

Seventh Applicant

BRETT CAMPBELL

Eighth Applicant

MICHAEL LEE

Ninth Applicant

CRAIG SMITH

Tenth Applicant

BRETT KILGALLON

Eleventh Applicant

GREG HARPER

Twelfth Applicant

COLIN BARON

Thirteenth Applicant

KAI SHANKS

Fourteenth Applicant

KEITH DUNN

Fifteenth Applicant

PETA BURKETT

Sixteenth Applicant

MICHAEL PARRY

Seventeenth Applicant

MATTHEW LARMAN

Eighteenth Applicant

JULIE CLARKE

Nineteenth Applicant

ELIZABETH ANDERSON

Twentieth Applicant

GAVIN HARRIS

Twenty First Applicant

KELLY JANET MANN

Twenty Second Applicant

BRIAN SNOOK

Twenty Third Applicant

AND

SHIRE OF CARNARVON

Respondent


Catchwords:

Review of decision to make a building order - Demolish and remove building - Whether person occupier of land - Meaning of control or management - Permit authority - Crown reserve - Management order

Legislation:

Building Act 2011 (WA), s 3, s 5, s 6, s 93(1), s 94, s 110(1), s 110(1)(c), s 110(2), s 110(2)(d), s 112(2)(g)(vi), s 113(2)(g)(vi), s 115, s 122(1)(a), Pt 3, Pt 7, Pt 8, Div 5
Building Regulations 2012 (WA), reg 10(2)
Building Services (Complaint Resolution and Administration) Act 2011 (WA), s 3
Interpretation Act 1984 (WA), s 6, s 17, s 44(1),
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 60(2)
State Planning Policy 7.3 - Residential Design Codes Volume 1

Result:

Preliminary issues answered in the affirmative

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

First Applicant : N/A
Second Applicant : N/A
Third Applicant : N/A
Fourth Applicant : N/A
Fifth Applicant : N/A
Sixth Applicant : N/A
Seventh Applicant : N/A
Eighth Applicant : N/A
Ninth Applicant : N/A
Tenth Applicant : N/A
Eleventh Applicant : N/A
Twelfth Applicant : N/A
Thirteenth Applicant : N/A
Fourteenth Applicant : N/A
Fifteenth Applicant : N/A
Sixteenth Applicant : N/A
Seventeenth Applicant : N/A
Eighteenth Applicant : N/A
Nineteenth Applicant : N/A
Twentieth Applicant : N/A
Twenty First Applicant : N/A
Twenty Second Applicant : N/A
Twenty Third Applicant : N/A
Respondent : Mr TL Beckett & Ms M Madvad

Solicitors:

First Applicant : N/A
Second Applicant : N/A
Third Applicant : N/A
Fourth Applicant : N/A
Fifth Applicant : N/A
Sixth Applicant : N/A
Seventh Applicant : N/A
Eighth Applicant : N/A
Ninth Applicant : N/A
Tenth Applicant : N/A
Eleventh Applicant : N/A
Twelfth Applicant : N/A
Thirteenth Applicant : N/A
Fourteenth Applicant : N/A
Fifteenth Applicant : N/A
Sixteenth Applicant : N/A
Seventeenth Applicant : N/A
Eighteenth Applicant : N/A
Nineteenth Applicant : N/A
Twentieth Applicant : N/A
Twenty First Applicant : N/A
Twenty Second Applicant : N/A
Twenty Third Applicant : N/A
Respondent : McLeods

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Australian Leisure and Hospitality Group Pty Ltd v Director of Liquor Licensing [2012] WASC 463

City of Fremantle v Imago…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SULLIVAN and SHIRE OF CARNARVON and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] WASAT 43
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Sullivan and Shire of Carnarvon involved the applicants, Sullivan and another individual, challenging the decision of the respondent, the Shire of Carnarvon, to issue a building order requiring the demolition and removal of certain structures located on a Crown reserve. The applicants argued that they were not "occupiers" of the land as defined in the Building Act and, therefore, the building order was not properly directed to them. The dispute was heard in the State Administrative Tribunal of Western Australia.

The central legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the applicants were "occupiers" of the land on which the structures were located, which would make them subject to the building order. The definition of "occupier" in the Building Act includes "any person who appears to have the control or management of the place." The Tribunal needed to determine if the applicants appeared to have control or management of the land in question, and if the term "place" included the Crown reserve where the structures were situated.

In considering the meaning of "occupier," the Tribunal noted the High Court's approach in SZTAL v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, which emphasised the importance of using statutory terms in their ordinary sense unless the statute itself indicates otherwise. The Tribunal found that the term "place" in the definition of "occupier" should be interpreted in its ordinary sense, which includes a portion of land or property, including a building or structure on that land. The Tribunal also interpreted "appears" in its ordinary sense, meaning to have an appearance or seem. The Tribunal concluded that an "occupier" for the purposes of the Building Act is a person who appears to have a legal right of control or management of the land or premises. However, the Tribunal was not satisfied that the respondent could reasonably have concluded that the applicants appeared to have control or management of the land in question or any part of it.

The Tribunal ordered that the decision of the respondent to issue the building order was not properly directed to the applicants as they were not occupiers of the land. The order was made on the basis that the applicants did not appear to have control or management of the land, and therefore, the building order was not validly directed to them.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

This is consistent with the approach of the High Court in SZTAL v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] HCA 34; (2017) 347 ALR 405 at [94] in which his Honour Edelman J stated, 'where a statute employs a term in its ordinary sense, there can be no warrant for the extension of the meaning beyond its ordinary sense'. I will first consider whether each of the applicants is an 'occupier' of the land on which the shacks are located for the purposes of s 110(2)(d) of the Building Act. Section 110(1) of the Building Act provides that a permit authority may make an order (referred to in the Building Act as a 'building order') in respect of one or more of the following -(a)particular building work;(b)particular demolition work;(c)a particular building or incidental structure, whether completed before or after commencement day. Relevantly, s 110(2)(d) of the Building Act provides that a building order must be in an approved form and must be directed to any one or more of the following persons as is appropriate in the case -…(d)a person who is an owner or occupier of the land on which the particular building or incidental structure is located. The expression 'occupier' is defined in s 94 of the Building Act as follows:occupier, of a place, includes any person who appears to have the control or management of the place. The full meaning of the expression 'place' (as referred to in the above definition of 'occupier') is not defined in the Building Act. However, 'place' is defined in s 94 of the Building Act to include 'a vehicle'. In the Macquarie Dictionary Online, 'place' is defined broadly to include:1.a particular portion of space, of definite or indefinite extent.2.space in general (chiefly in connection with time).3.the portion of space occupied by anything.…21.a building.22.a part of a building.23.a.a residence, dwelling, or house.b.a property (def. 3) comprising land, buildings, residence, etc. Notably, the dictionary meaning of 'place' is consistent with its definition for the purposes of the Building Services (Complaint Resolution and Administration) Act 2011 (WA) (BS(CRA) Act). In the BS(CRA) Act, the expression 'place' means 'any land, building or structure, or part of any land, building or structure'.[3][3] BS(CRA) Act, s 3. Consequently, I find that a 'place' for the purposes of its definition in s 94 of the Building Act is a portion of land or property, including a building, structure or vehicle on that land or property. The expression 'appears' is not defined in the Building Act and, having regard to the context in which it is used, I find that there is no reason why its ordinary meaning should not prevail. Relevantly, the Macquarie Dictionary Online defines the word 'appear' as follows:verb (copular) 1. to have an appearance; seem; look: to appear wise. In Corpus and Shire of Broome (2017) 91 SR (WA) 365; [2017] WASAT 66 (Corpus), the Tribunal concluded that, for the purposes of s 110(2)(d) of the Building Act, an 'occupier' is a person who must have, or appear to have, 'a legal right of control or management of the land or premises so as to be in a position to be capable of complying with the type of directions that may be imposed by a building order'.[4] Ultimately, the Tribunal was not satisfied that the applicant, who sought review of the building order directed at him, was someone who the respondent could reasonably have concluded appeared to have control or management of the land in question or any part of it.[5][4] Corpus at [41].[5] Corpus at [45].