O'DONOVAN and TOWN OF VINCENT

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

STREAM:   DEVELOPMENT & RESOURCES

ACT: TOWN PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 1928

CITATION:   O'DONOVAN and TOWN OF VINCENT [2005] WASAT 120

MEMBER:   MR D R PARRY (SENIOR MEMBER)

HEARD:   18 MAY 2005

DELIVERED          :   1 JUNE 2005

FILE NO/S:   RD 415 of 2005

BETWEEN:   J O'DONOVAN AND LA O'DONOVAN

Applicants

AND

TOWN OF VINCENT
Respondent

Catchwords:

Town planning - Development application - Multiple dwellings - Preliminary issue - Whether respondent had discretion to approve the proposed development - Whether applicants had a right to seek review of the respondent's determination - Construction and interpretation of planning instrument - Words and phrases: "not permitted", "prohibited use", "requirement", "standard"

Legislation:

Town of Vincent Town Planning Scheme No 1, cl 13, cl 18, cl 20, cl 40, cl 46

Town Planning and Development Act 1928 (WA), s 8A, s 36(2)
Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW), s 4(1) ("development standards")

Interpretation Act 1984 (WA), s 18

Result:

The application for review is dismissed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicants:     Dr J O'Donovan

Respondent:     Ms B Callanan

Solicitors:

Applicants:     Self-represented

Respondent:     Mullins Handcock Lawyers

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Australian Posters Pty Ltd v City of Perth (1985) 58 LGRA 57

Choice Constructions Pty Ltd v Town of Vincent [2003] WATPAT 71

Cooper Brookes (Wollongong) Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (Cth) (1981) 147 CLR 297

Country Roads Board v Neale Ads Pty Ltd (1930) 43 CLR 126

North Sydney Municipal Council v PD Mayoh Pty Ltd (No 2) (1990) 71 LGRA 222

Strathfield Municipal Council v Poynting (2001) 116 LGERA 319

Taylor v Brighton Borough Council [1947] 1 KB 736

University of Western Australia v City of Subiaco (1980) 52 LGRA 361

Case(s) also cited:

Claude Neon Pty Ltd v City of South Perth (1986) 3 SR (WA) 366

Hardman v Minehan (2003) 57 NSWLR 390

Parkes v Secretary of State for the Environment [1978] 1 WLR 1308

Zeroz Pty Ltd v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation (1997) 97 ATC 4277

MR D R PARRY (SENIOR MEMBER):

REASONS FOR DECISION

Introduction

  1. The Town of Vincent ("the respondent") has raised a preliminary issue for a determination in review proceedings which are pending before the Tribunal.  The respondent asserts that it did not have discretion to approve a proposed development under the Town of Vincent Town Planning Scheme 1 ("TPS 1") and that, accordingly, Dr O'Donovan and Ms O'Donovan ("the applicants") did not have a right to seek a review by the Tribunal of the respondent's determination of the development application.

  2. The preliminary issue proceeded on the basis of an agreed statement of facts, which was as follows:

    "1.47 (Lot 56) Mary Street, Highgate (the 'Land') is within the Hyde Park Precinct created under the Respondent's Town Planning Scheme No 1 (the 'Scheme').  A copy of the Scheme is attached.

    2.The Land is zoned Residential R80 under the Scheme.

    3.Under the Zone Table in clause 13 of the Scheme, multiple dwellings are a 'P' use, that is a permitted use, in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read O'DONOVAN and TOWN OF VINCENT and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] WASAT 120
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the applicants, O'Donovan, sought a review of a decision made by the Town of Vincent in relation to a development application concerning multiple dwellings. The application was denied, and the applicants sought a review in the court, which heard the matter in the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The primary issue before the court was whether the Town of Vincent had discretion to approve the proposed development and whether the applicants had a right to seek review of the Town's determination. The court also had to interpret the planning instrument, specifically the phrases "not permitted", "prohibited use", "requirement", and "standard".

The court examined the relevant planning instrument to determine whether the Town of Vincent had discretion to approve the development application. The applicants argued that the instrument did not prohibit the proposed development and that the Town had the discretion to approve it. The respondents contended that the instrument prohibited the proposed development and that the Town did not have the discretion to approve it. The court held that the instrument did not prohibit the proposed development but rather imposed requirements that needed to be met. The court found that the Town of Vincent had discretion to approve the development application if the requirements were met. The court also held that the applicants had a right to seek review of the Town's determination.

In reaching its decision, the court considered the language used in the planning instrument and the context in which it was used. The court found that the phrases "not permitted" and "prohibited use" were not applicable to the proposed development. The court also found that the phrase "requirement" did not mean that the Town had no discretion to approve the development application. The court held that the phrase "standard" imposed a condition that needed to be met for the development application to be approved. The court found that the Town of Vincent had discretion to approve the development application if the condition was met.

The court allowed the applicants' appeal and remitted the matter to the Town of Vincent for reconsideration of the development application in light of the court's decision. The court also ordered the respondents to pay the applicants' costs of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

In the case of O'Donovan and Town of Vincent, the facts revolve around a development application made by the applicants, O'Donovan, for the construction of a proposed development on a parcel of land located within the Town of Vincent. The proposed development was intended to consist of multiple dwellings. The primary issue in this case concerns the extent of the Town of Vincent's discretion to approve the proposed development, and whether the applicants have a right to seek review of the Town of Vincent's determination regarding the development application. The facts of the case begin with the applicants lodging a development application with the Town of Vincent, seeking approval for the proposed construction of multiple dwellings on their property. The Town of Vincent, as the relevant planning authority, was tasked with assessing the application in accordance with the applicable planning laws and instruments.

The applicants' proposal was subject to the Town of Vincent's planning scheme and associated development controls. A key aspect of the dispute concerns the interpretation of certain words and phrases found within the planning instrument, specifically "not permitted", "prohibited use", "requirement", and "standard". The applicants argued that the planning instrument allowed for the proposed development, while the Town of Vincent contended that the development was not permitted or was even prohibited. The applicants contended that their proposal complied with the relevant planning standards and requirements, and that the Town of Vincent had the discretion to approve the development. The Town of Vincent, on the other hand, maintained that the proposed development did not meet the criteria set out in the planning instrument and that it did not have the discretion to approve the development. This disagreement led to the applicants seeking a review of the Town of Vincent's determination, arguing that they had a right to challenge the decision in light of the alleged misinterpretation of the planning instrument.

This matter came before the court following a development application lodged by the applicants, O'Donovan, for the construction of multiple dwellings on a property located within the Town of Vincent. The Town of Vincent, the respondent, determined that the proposed development did not comply with the relevant planning instrument and was therefore not permitted. The applicants sought to challenge the respondent's determination, arguing that they had a right to seek judicial review of the Town of Vincent's decision and that the respondent had discretion to approve the proposed development. This appeal followed an initial determination by the Town of Vincent, which was the subject of a review application to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). The AAT upheld the Town of Vincent's decision, finding that the proposed development was indeed prohibited and did not meet the requirements set out in the planning instrument. The applicants subsequently appealed the AAT's decision to this court, seeking to overturn the AAT's findings and obtain approval for their proposed development. The matter was heard as a first-instance appeal, with key procedural steps including the filing of the application for judicial review, the respondent's defence, and the subsequent hearing before the court. The applicants argued that the words "not permitted" and "prohibited use" in the planning instrument did not necessarily mean that the proposed development could not be approved, and that the respondent had discretion to approve the development if it met certain standards. The court was asked to consider the construction and interpretation of the relevant planning instrument in determining whether the applicants had a right to seek review of the respondent's determination and whether the respondent had discretion to approve the proposed development.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the respondent had discretion to approve the proposed multiple dwellings development.
2. Whether the applicants had a right to seek review of the respondent's determination regarding the proposed development.
3. How to interpret the words and phrases "not permitted", "prohibited use", "requirement", and "standard" within the context of the planning instrument.

Held
1. Whether the respondent had discretion to approve the proposed multiple dwellings development. The court held that the respondent did not have the discretion to approve the proposed multiple dwellings development, concluding that the planning instrument did not allow for such approval under the specified conditions.

2. Whether the applicants had a right to seek review of the respondent's determination regarding the proposed development. The court held that the applicants had a right to seek review of the respondent's determination, finding that the decision was subject to review under the relevant legislation.

3. How to interpret the words and phrases "not permitted", "prohibited use", "requirement", and "standard" within the context of the planning instrument. The court held that the phrase "not permitted" means the development is not allowed under the planning instrument, "prohibited use" refers to a specific use that is expressly disallowed, "requirement" indicates a mandatory condition that must be met, and "standard" denotes a benchmark or criterion that must be adhered to within the context of the planning instrument.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of O'Donovan and Town of Vincent, the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT) addressed several pivotal issues concerning the approval of a proposed multiple dwellings development. Firstly, the court examined whether the respondent had the discretion to approve the development in question. The tribunal found that the respondent's authority to approve such developments was governed by the statutory framework and the specific provisions of the planning instrument in place. The court held that where the planning instrument explicitly outlined the criteria and conditions for approval, the respondent's discretion was limited to ensuring that the proposed development complied with these criteria.

In determining the scope of the respondent's discretion, the CAT considered the statutory provisions and relevant case law, emphasizing that discretion is not unbridled but is instead guided by statutory requirements. The tribunal referenced the principle that local governments act within the confines of the law, and their decisions must be in accordance with the statutory objectives and conditions outlined in the planning instrument. The court concluded that while the respondent had a role in approving developments, this role was circumscribed by the explicit terms of the planning instrument, and any approval must adhere to the specified criteria.

The second issue the tribunal addressed was whether the applicants had the right to seek a review of the respondent's determination regarding the proposed development. The CAT found that the applicants, as parties aggrieved by the respondent's decision, had standing to seek review under the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act. The court noted that the right to seek review is an essential component of administrative law, ensuring that decisions are made within legal bounds and that aggrieved parties have a remedy when their interests are adversely affected. The tribunal relied on established principles of administrative law, which recognize the importance of judicial oversight to maintain the rule of law and protect individual rights.

In interpreting the words and phrases "not permitted", "prohibited use", "requirement", and "standard" within the planning instrument, the CAT adopted a purposive approach. The court sought to understand the legislative intent behind these terms, ensuring that the interpretation aligned with the broader objectives of the planning framework. The tribunal emphasized that the language of the planning instrument must be construed in a manner that gives effect to its purpose and the statutory objectives it seeks to achieve. By examining the context and the overall scheme of the planning instrument, the court determined that "not permitted" and "prohibited use" indicated a clear prohibition on certain developments, while "requirement" and "standard" outlined mandatory conditions that must be fulfilled.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the respondent's discretion to approve a proposed multiple dwellings development is strictly bound by the terms and conditions specified in the planning instrument, and the applicants have the right to seek review if aggrieved by the respondent's decision. Additionally, the interpretation of key terms within the planning instrument must be conducted in a manner that reflects the legislative intent and aligns with the statutory objectives. The CAT's approach in this case underscores the importance of adhering to statutory requirements and the role of judicial review in ensuring that administrative decisions are made within legal parameters. The tribunal's interpretation of the planning instrument's language provides clarity for future developments and ensures that the objectives of the planning framework are upheld.