Roadshow Films Pty Ltd v iiNet Limited (No. 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 94 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Roadshow Films Pty Ltd v iiNet Limited (No. 3) [2010] FCA 24

Citation: Roadshow Films Pty Ltd v iiNet Limited (No. 3) [2010] FCA 24
Parties: Roadshow Films Pty Ltd (ACN 100 746 870) and the parties in attached Schedule I v iiNet Limited (ACN 068 628 937)
File number: NSD 1802 of 2008
Judge: COWDROY J
Date of judgment: 4 February 2010
Catchwords:

INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY – Copyright Authorisation – Internet Service Provider provided internet to subscribers – allegations made to Internet Service Provider that those using its internet service were infringing copyright – whether persons using the internet service of the respondent infringed copyright by making available online, electronically transmitting and making copies of applicants’ films – whether the respondent authorised the infringement which occurred – whether the respondent provided the means of infringement – whether the respondent had the power to prevent the infringements which occurred – whether the respondent sanctioned, approved, countenanced the infringements which occurred – whether s 276 of the Telecommunications Act 1997 (Cth) led to a finding that the respondent did not have the power to prevent infringement

INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY – Copyright Authorisation – whether s 112E of the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) prevented the respondent from being found to have authorised – whether the respondent had knowledge of the infringements which occurred

INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY – ‘Safe Harbour’ Provisions – whether the respondent complied with the provisions of Division 2AA of Part V of the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) – what constitutes a repeat infringer policy – whether respondent had a repeat infringer policy – whether respondent had implemented repeat infringer policy

Legislation: Broadcasting Services Act 1992 (Cth)
Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) ss 10, 14, 22(6), 22(6A), 37, 86, 100A, 101, 101(1A), 104, 112E, 115, 116AA, 116AC, 116AD, 116AE, 116AF, 116AG, 116AH(1), 116AH(2), 116AI, 119(a), 135ZWA
Copyright Amendment (Digital Agenda) Act 2000 (Cth)
Copyright Amendment (Digital Agenda) Bill 1999 (Cth)
Copyright Amendment Regulations 2004 (No. 1) (Cth)
Copyright, Designs and Patent Act 1988 (UK) s 45(1)
Copyright Legislation Amendment Act 2004 (Cth)
Copyright Regulations 1969 (Cth) reg 20B, 20I, 20J, 20K, 20L, 20M, 20X
Criminal Code 1995 (Cth) s 137.2
Digital Millennium Copyright Act 1998 (US) s 202
Telecommunications Act 1997 (Cth) ss 7, 87, 270, 276, 279, 280, 289, 290
Telecommunications (Consumer Protection and Service Standards) Act 1999 (Cth) s 128(5)
Telecommunications (Interception and Access) Act 1979 (Cth)
United States Code (US) Title 17 s 512
US Free Trade Implementation Act 2004 (Cth)
Cases cited: Apand Pty Limited v The Kettle Chip Company Pty Limited (1994) 62 FCR 474 followed
Australasian Performing Right Association Limited v Jain (1990) 26 FCR 53 followed/distinguished
Australasian Performing Right Association Ltd v Metro on George Pty Ltd and Others (2004) 61 IPR 57 followed/distinguished
Australian Tape Manufacturers Association Ltd and Others v The Commonwealth of Australia (1993) 177 CLR 480 followed
Avel Proprietary Limited v Multicoin Amusements Proprietary Limited and Another (1990) 171 CLR 88 followed
C J Redman Constructions Pty Ltd v…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Roadshow Films Pty Ltd v iiNet Limited (No. 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCA 24
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Roadshow Films Pty Ltd v iiNet Limited, the plaintiffs, comprising a number of film production companies, sought to establish liability on the part of the internet service provider, iiNet Limited, for copyright infringements carried out by its customers. The case was heard by the Federal Court of Australia, which was tasked with determining whether iiNet could be held liable for the actions of its customers who used the BitTorrent protocol to share copyrighted material. The central legal issue was whether iiNet could be considered to have authorised the infringements by its customers and if the relevant provisions of the Copyright Act and the Telecommunications Act precluded such liability.

The Court found that iiNet could not be held liable for the actions of its customers under the Copyright Act, as authorisation of infringement requires more than mere facilitation of the infringement. The Court concluded that iiNet's actions did not amount to authorisation as defined by the Act. Furthermore, the Court held that the Telecommunications Act did not prevent iiNet from acting on the notices issued by the Australian Federation Against Copyright Theft (AFACT). The Court also found that the safe harbour provisions in Division 2AA of Part V of the Copyright Act provided protection for iiNet, as it had adopted a policy of terminating the accounts of repeat infringers, which met the requirements of the safe harbour provisions.

In conclusion, the Court found in favour of iiNet and dismissed the claims brought by the plaintiffs. The Court held that iiNet was not liable for the copyright infringements carried out by its customers, as it had not authorised the infringements and was protected by the safe harbour provisions in the Copyright Act. The Court's decision provides clarity on the issue of internet service providers' liability for the actions of their customers in relation to copyright infringement.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

To assist the consumption and comprehension of this lengthy judgment, it has been divided into a number of parts, each addressing specific issues. To some extent there may be repetition, but this is unavoidable if the various parts of the judgment are to be readily comprehended. Part A [1]-[42] is the current part, the introduction. Part B [43]-[78] provides a succinct explanation of the operation of the internet and of the BitTorrent protocol. A comprehension of both is necessary to understand the subsequent findings. Part C [79]-[252] discusses important evidentiary issues in the proceedings. In Part D [253]-[356] the Court discusses and makes findings on the issue of whether the applicants have been successful in proving that iiNet users infringed their copyright. Part E1 [357]-[507] concerns the pivotal issue of these proceedings, namely whether the respondent can be said to have authorised any infringement by the iiNet users. Part E2 [508]-[555] concerns the specific issue of whether the Telco Act prohibited the respondent from acting on the AFACT Notices. Part E3 [556]-[579] concerns the issue of whether s 112E of the Copyright Act assists the respondent in these proceedings. Part F [580]-[634] concerns the issue whether the respondent can take advantage of the safe harbour provisions in Division 2AA of Part V of the Copyright Act. Finally, in Part G [635]-[636], the Court makes its conclusions. Following the conclusion, there are two schedules attached to the judgment. The first (‘I’) lists the second to thirty-fourth applicants in these proceedings and the second (‘II’) lists the identified films and their owners and/or exclusive licensees.PART B: TECHNICAL BACKGROUND This judgment proceeds into a significant amount of technical detail. In order to better understand the reasons given, a brief technical interlude into the operation of both the internet and the BitTorrent protocol is necessary. The Court will turn first to the internet and then to the BitTorrent protocol. The information in this technical interlude is derived from both the evidence given at trial and certain notorious facts of which the Court takes judicial notice.The internetIP addresses and packets The internet is, in summary, a network of networks of computers. In order for those computers to be able to communicate with each other, they have to be speaking the same language. Protocols facilitate this process. Protocols could be described as languages or, alternatively, sets of rules for computers. If two computers obey these rules, they will be able to understand each other and communicate. The two primary protocols by which communication is effected between computers on the internet are the Internet Protocol (‘IP’), and the Transmission Control Protocol (‘TCP’). TCP is not relevant for these proceedings and will not be discussed further. Data that is sent by means of the IP is ‘packetised’, that is, the data to be communicated is broken up into small packets and then sent by means of the IP. Each packet contains a header (akin to an envelope) containing information identifying the address or location from which the packet is sent and to which the packet is to be sent and other information not presently relevant. The packet itself contains the data which is akin to the letter within an envelope. The IP protocol effects communication between computers by means allocating addresses to the sending and receiving computers and then sending the packets of data from one address to another, in many ways analogous to the mail.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The above explanation and examples are sufficient to enable an understanding of the internet and the BitTorrent protocol for the purpose of these proceedings. With that understanding, the Court will now address the evidence.PART C: THE EVIDENCE There has been an extensive amount of evidence placed before the Court in these proceedings. Evidence was given over ten days of the hearing. There were 30 affidavits read during the proceedings and 151 exhibits were tendered. It is impossible and unnecessary to refer to all the evidence that was placed before the Court. Suffice to say the Court has read and considered all the evidence. Each of the witnesses who have provided evidence will be discussed in the following part of the judgment, as well as the key evidentiary issues arising.Role of AFACT The Australian Federation Against Copyright Theft (‘AFACT’), though not actually an applicant in these proceedings, has nonetheless played a central role in the collection of evidence on behalf of the applicants for this trial. AFACT is an organisation set up for the purposes of benefiting its members. Those members apparently include all of the applicants (or at least certain affiliate companies of each of the applicants) and other companies engaged in the film production industry. The exact nature of the relationship between the applicants and AFACT is not clear. Mr Gane, the Executive Director of AFACT, suggested that there was no formal membership process by which one can become a member of AFACT, whether by application or agreement. Village Roadshow was an exception. What is clear is that the members of AFACT provide its budget and decide on its business plan, that is, what investigations and activities it will undertake. The Motion Picture Association (‘MPA’) and the Motion Picture Association of America (‘MPAA’) have a membership of the major American film studios. They are not associated with AFACT by any formal written agreement. However, AFACT does report to the regional branch office of the MPA which is based in Singapore. In respect of operations in the Asian region, the Singapore office of the MPA prepares a business plan or budget for AFACT which is approved by the Los Angeles head office of the MPA. The Court considers that AFACT is, for relevant purposes, the local ‘franchise’ of the MPA, though with specific additional interaction with Australian entities that are not part of the MPA, such as Village Roadshow and related entities. Nevertheless, it has not been established that AFACT is an agent of the applicants; rather, its position vis-à-vis the applicants is a loose arrangement to provide certain services for the applicants.AFACT witness – Aaron Guy Herps Mr Herps is the Manager of Digital Affairs of AFACT. Mr Herps has provided evidence of copyright infringing acts of iiNet users. He has sworn four affidavits in these proceedings. The Court accepts the evidence of Mr Herps and no challenge was made to any aspect of it by the respondent.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Otherwise the applicants join issue with the Defence. It should be noted that the filing of the Amended Defence did not require the filing of an Amended Reply.Structure of judgment The Court is mindful of the substantial length of this judgment. However, given the length of the trial (some 20 days), the length and detail of the closing submissions (over 800 pages, excluding hundreds of pages of tables, graphs and spreadsheets), and the obvious importance of these proceedings to the law of copyright both in this country and possibly overseas, the Court believes that all submissions made and arguments raised ought to be decided to give certainty and finality to the litigation (pending any appeal). To assist the consumption and comprehension of this lengthy judgment, it has been divided into a number of parts, each addressing specific issues. To some extent there may be repetition, but this is unavoidable if the various parts of the judgment are to be readily comprehended. Part A [1]-[42] is the current part, the introduction. Part B [43]-[78] provides a succinct explanation of the operation of the internet and of the BitTorrent protocol. A comprehension of both is necessary to understand the subsequent findings. Part C [79]-[252] discusses important evidentiary issues in the proceedings. In Part D [253]-[356] the Court discusses and makes findings on the issue of whether the applicants have been successful in proving that iiNet users infringed their copyright. Part E1 [357]-[507] concerns the pivotal issue of these proceedings, namely whether the respondent can be said to have authorised any infringement by the iiNet users. Part E2 [508]-[555] concerns the specific issue of whether the Telco Act prohibited the respondent from acting on the AFACT Notices. Part E3 [556]-[579] concerns the issue of whether s 112E of the Copyright Act assists the respondent in these proceedings. Part F [580]-[634] concerns the issue whether the respondent can take advantage of the safe harbour provisions in Division 2AA of Part V of the Copyright Act. Finally, in Part G [635]-[636], the Court makes its conclusions. Following the conclusion, there are two schedules attached to the judgment. The first (‘I’) lists the second to thirty-fourth applicants in these proceedings and the second (‘II’) lists the identified films and their owners and/or exclusive licensees.PART B: TECHNICAL BACKGROUND This judgment proceeds into a significant amount of technical detail. In order to better understand the reasons given, a brief technical interlude into the operation of both the internet and the BitTorrent protocol is necessary. The Court will turn first to the internet and then to the BitTorrent protocol. The information in this technical interlude is derived from both the evidence given at trial and certain notorious facts of which the Court takes judicial notice.The internetIP addresses and packets The internet is, in summary, a network of networks of computers. In order for those computers to be able to communicate with each other, they have to be speaking the same language. Protocols facilitate this process. Protocols could be described as languages or, alternatively, sets of rules for computers. If two computers obey these rules, they will be able to understand each other and communicate. The two primary protocols by which communication is effected between computers on the internet are the Internet Protocol (‘IP’), and the Transmission Control Protocol (‘TCP’). TCP is not relevant for these proceedings and will not be discussed further.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.