Nominet UK v Diverse Internet Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Nominet UK v Diverse Internet Pty Ltd [2004] FCA 1244

INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY – copyright – infringement – authorisation – company director – instruction to employee to act under instructions of third party – consequential acts infringing copyright in database of domain name administrator – data mining – director’s control of company employee – involvement in data mining activity and related scheme to send domain name registration notices to registrants identified by data mining – infringement by authorisation established

TRADE PRACTICES – misleading or deceptive conduct – notices sent to registered users of domain names – false representations as to various matters conceded – implied representations as to sponsorship or approval by domain name administrator or  affiliation with domain name administrator – accessorial liability – knowing concern in preparation and sending of notices – whether notices asserted rights to payment – services not provided – whether prohibition against assertion of right to payment applies in respect of unprovided services – no application to unprovided services

Fair Trading Act 1987 (WA) s 10(1), s 12(1)(e) and (f)
Fair Trading Act 1999 (Vic) s 9(1), s 12(e) and (f)
Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) s 14, s 13, s 36
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth)

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Optell Pty Ltd (1998) 41 IPR 49 cited
Domain Names Australia Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2004] FCAFC 247 cited
Campomar Sociedad, Limitada v Nike International Limited (2000) 202 CLR 45
Desktop Marketing Systems Pty Ltd v Telstra Corporation Ltd (2002) 119 FCR 491 cited
University of New South Wales v Moorhouse (1975) 133 CLR 1 applied
WEA International Inc v Hanimex Corporation Ltd (1987) 17 FCR 274 cited
Australian Tape Manufacturers Association Ltd v The Commonwealth (1993) 176 CLR 480 cited
Nationwide News Pty Ltd v Copyright Agency Limited (1996) 65 FCR 399 cited
Australian Performing Right Association Limited v Jain (1990) 26 FCR 53 cited
Wells v John R Lewis (Industrial) Pty Ltd (1975) 25 FLR 194 cited
Rizzo v Wall (unrep Fed Court, Pincus J, 25/11/87) cited
Rizzo v Fitzgerald (1988) 19 FCR 175 cited
.au Domain Administration Ltd v Domain Names Australia Pty Ltd [2004] FCA 424 followed

NOMINET UK v DIVERSE INTERNET PTY LTD AND OTHERS
N1040 OF 2003

FRENCH J
22 SEPTEMBER 2004
PERTH


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

N1040 OF 2003

BETWEEN:

NOMINET UK
APPLICANT

AND:

DIVERSE INTERNET PTY LTD
(ACN 096 827 619)
FIRST RESPONDENT

INTERNET PAYMENTS PTY LTD
(ACN 097 324 868)
SECOND RESPONDENT

BRADLEY STEDMAN NORRISH
THIRD RESPONDENT

CHESLEY PAUL RAFFERTY
FOURTH RESPONDENT

(UK) INTERNET REGISTRY LTD
FIFTH RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

FRENCH J

DATE OF ORDER:

22 SEPTEMBER 2004

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.It is hereby declared that the third respondent has infringed the applicant’s copyright in the Database and in the WHOIS Database as respectively defined in paragraphs 6 and 7A of the Second Further Amended Statement of Claim.

2.It is hereby declared that the third respondent was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nominet UK v Diverse Internet Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] FCA 1244
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Federal Court of Australia dealt with a dispute between Nominet UK and Diverse Internet Pty Ltd, with Mr Norrish as an individual defendant. Nominet UK alleged that Mr Norrish had infringed its copyright by authorising the infringement of its databases by an employee of Diverse Internet, which he controls. Additionally, Nominet UK claimed that Mr Norrish was involved in the preparation and dispatch of misleading and deceptive notices sent by (UK) Internet Registry to registrants in the United Kingdom. The legal issues before the court involved determining whether Mr Norrish had indeed infringed Nominet UK’s copyright and whether he was knowingly involved in the misleading conduct of (UK) Internet Registry.

The court found that Mr Norrish had infringed Nominet UK’s copyright by authorising the infringement of its databases by an employee of Diverse Internet. Furthermore, the court concluded that Mr Norrish was knowingly involved in the preparation and dispatch of misleading and deceptive notices by (UK) Internet Registry. The court based its decision on evidence showing Mr Norrish’s close involvement in the affairs of (UK) Internet Registry, including the establishment of a virtual office for it and his role in drafting and sending the notices. Emails and other documents also indicated his instrumental role in these activities.

The court granted Nominet UK declaratory and injunctive relief, damages, and costs against Mr Norrish. It ordered Mr Norrish to cease copying, reproducing, or authorising the copying or reproduction of Nominet UK’s databases and to deliver up all related documents for destruction. Additionally, Nominet UK was awarded damages and interest. The court also issued orders against other respondents, including Diverse Internet Pty Ltd and (UK) Internet Registry, with similar restrictions and delivery requirements.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. It is hereby declared that the third respondent has infringed the applicant’s copyright in the Database and in the WHOIS Database as respectively defined in paragraphs 6 and 7A of the Second Further Amended Statement of Claim.

2. It is hereby declared that the third respondent was knowingly concerned in contraventions by the fifth respondent of ss 10 and 12 of the Fair Trading Act 1987 (WA).

3. The third respondent be, and is hereby restrained from, without the licence of the applicant, copying or reproducing or authorising the copying or reproduction of the whole or any substantial part of the Database or of the WHOIS Database or the information contained in either of them.

4. The third respondent be, and is hereby restrained from, copying, disclosing or using the information contained in the Database and the WHOIS Database or either of them or any copy of the whole or any part of either of them.

5. The third respondent be restrained from publishing or distributing or causing to be published or distributed, any documents in the form of the documents which appear behind tabs 7 to 10 of the Affidavit of Emily Elizabeth Gemma Taylor sworn on 15 August 2003.

6. The third respondent be, and is hereby restrained, from representing, in trade or commerce, in Australia or elsewhere, contrary to fact, that:

(a) the fifth respondent was, or was associated with, or had the sponsorship or approval of, the applicant;

(b) the fifth respondent was an authorised manager of a central database or an official internet registry or both;

(c) the services offered by the fifth respondent were services offered by or with the sponsorship or approval of the applicant;

(d) the Registrants to whom the UKIR Notices (as described in the Reasons for Judgment) were addressed had a pre-existing relationship with the fifth respondent;

(e) the applicant authorised the fifth respondent to contact Registrants in relation to the registration or hosting of the .com domain name corresponding to the Registrant’s .uk domain name;

(f) a Registrant’s .uk domain name was due to expire or be cancelled for non-renewal;

(g) any of the UKIR Notices was a bill, invoice or statement of account due, based upon an existing or prior business relationship between the fifth respondent and the company or business to whom the UKIR Notice was addressed in each case;

(h) any UKIR Notice was a notice for the renewal of an existing registered .co.uk domain name of which the recipient was the registrant;

(i) the .co.uk domain name to which any UKIR Notice related was due for renewal;

(j) the recipient of any UKIR Notice risked losing the registration of its existing registered .co.uk domain name if it did not take steps to have it renewed such as by requesting the fifth respondent to renew the name and by returning the bottom portion of the Notice with payment for the requested sum;

(k) the registration of any recipient’s existing .co.uk domain name had expired or would expire if payment was not made as requested in the UKIR Notice;

(l) the fifth respondent was offering to re-register or renew the registration of the existing .co.uk domain name of the recipient of any UKIR Notice;

(m) the recipient of any UKIR Notice would be required to pay the amount mentioned in the UKIR Notice in order to maintain the registration of its existing .co.uk domain name;

(n) the recipient of any UKIR Notice had previously registered a .com version of its .co.uk domain name and this registration was due for renewal.

7. The third respondent is to deliver up to the applicant’s solicitors all documents, (including but not limited to electronic copies of documents), in the possession, power or control of the third respondent, whether original documents or copies that are directly or indirectly derived from, or which embody any information extracted from, or contained in, the Database or the WHOIS Database.

8. The third respondent is to pay to the applicant damages to be assessed including additional damages or, at the election of the applicant, an account of profits pursuant to s 115 of the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth).

9. The third respondent is to pay to the applicant damages to be assessed pursuant to the Fair Trading Act 1987 (WA).

10. The third respondent is to pay the applicant’s costs of the proceedings against the third respondent.

11. The third respondent is to pay interest pursuant to s 51A of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) to be determined.

12. The applicant has liberty to apply for further or other orders within 28 days.

9. The first respondent, whether by itself or its servants, agents or otherwise, be restrained from, without the licence of the applicant, copying, reproducing or authorising the copying or reproduction of the whole or any substantial part of the Database (as defined in paragraph 6 of the further amended statement of claim).

10. The first respondent, whether by itself or its servants, agents or otherwise, be restrained from, without the licence of the applicant, copying, reproducing or authorising the copying or reproduction of the whole or any substantial part of the WHOIS Database (as defined in paragraph 7A of the further amended statement of claim).

11. The second respondent, whether by itself or its servants, agents or otherwise, be restrained from, without the licence of the applicant, copying, reproducing or authorising the copying or reproduction of the whole or any substantial part of the Database (as defined in paragraph 6 of the further amended statement of claim).

12. The second respondent, whether by itself or its servants, agents or otherwise, be restrained from, without the licence of the applicant, copying, reproducing or authorising the copying or reproduction of the whole or any substantial part of the WHOIS Database (as defined in paragraph 7A of the further amended statement of claim).

13. The first and second respondents deliver up to the applicant’s solicitors for destruction all documents (including but not limited to electronic copies of documents) in the first respondent’s and/or second respondent’s possession, power or control, whether original documents or copies, that are directly or indirectly derived from or embody any information extracted from the Database (as defined in paragraph 6 of the further amended statement of claim) or the WHOIS Database (as defined in paragraph 7A of the further amended statement of claim).

14. The fourth respondent, whether by himself or his servants, agents or otherwise, be restrained from, without the licence of the applicant, copying, reproducing or authorising the copying or reproduction of the whole or any substantial part of the Database (as defined in paragraph 6 of the further amended statement of claim).

15. The fourth respondent, whether by himself or his servants, agents or otherwise, be restrained from, without the licence of the applicant, copying, reproducing or authorising the copying or reproduction of the whole or any substantial part of the WHOIS Database (as defined in paragraph 7A of the further amended statement of claim).

16, The fourth respondent, whether by himself or his servants, agents or otherwise, be restrained from publishing or distributing, or causing to be published or distributed, any documents in the form or to the effect of the UKIR Invoices (as defined in paragraph 12(a) of the further amended statement of claim).

17. The fourth respondent deliver up to the applicant’s solicitors for destruction all documents (including but not limited to electronic copies of documents) in the fourth respondent’s possession, power or control, whether original documents or copies, that are directly or indirectly derived from or which embody any information extracted from the Database (as defined in paragraph 6 of the further amended statement of claim) or the WHOIS Database (as defined in paragraph 7A of the further amended statement of claim).

18. Damages against the first, second and fourth respondents be assessed in such manner as the Court thinks fit.

Note:

2. The fifth respondent, whether by itself, its servants, agents or otherwise, be restrained from publishing or distributing, or causing to be published or distributed, any documents in the form or to the effect of the UKIR Invoices (as defined in paragraph 12(a) of the further amended statement of claim).

3. Damages against the fifth respondent be assessed in such manner as the Court thinks fit.

4. The fifth respondent deliver up to the applicant’s solicitors for destruction all documents (including but not limited to electronic copies of documents) in the fifth respondent’s possession, power or control, whether original documents or copies, that are directly or indirectly derived from or embody any information extracted from the Database (as defined in paragraph 6 of the further amended statement of claim) or the WHOIS Database (as defined in paragraph 7A of the further amended statement of claim).

5. Costs be reserved.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Norrish continued to contest his personal liability. For the reasons which I now publish, I find that he infringed the copyright of Nominet UK in its Databases by authorising their infringement by an employee of Diverse Internet, the company which he controls. I find also that the Notices sent by (UK) Internet Registry to Registrants in the United Kingdom were misleading and deceptive and that he was knowingly concerned in their preparation and dispatch. The Internet and Domain Names – Background and History The ‘Internet’ is a name given to a global complex of connections between computers forming networks which are owned and operated by various organisations. The history of the Internet and role of domain names in it was described, for the purposes of these proceedings, in the unchallenged evidence of William Black, who is the Executive Chairman of Nominet UK and Jay Daley, Nominet UK’s Director of Information Technology. The Internet had its beginnings in 1969 in the establishment of a network between the United States Department of Defence, defence contractors and various universities. The network so created was called the ‘Advanced Research Projects Agency Network’ (‘ARPANet’). The setting up of the network involved the creation of domain names or addresses for its users. A domain name identifies a particular computer connected to the Internet. Each networked computer uses a common Internet Protocol which provides a unique numeric Internet Protocol address (IP address) such as 124.57.32.6 for the relevant computer server. Although each IP address is defined by a set of numerals, Internet users have, from the beginning of the Internet, been able to adopt alphanumeric combinations which are more convenient and which are known as ‘domain names’. The address naming scheme for ARPANet defined different classes of domain names as users were registered under those names for the purpose of network management. So university users had domain names ending in ‘.edu’. Commercial corporate users ended in ‘.com’. Government departments ended in ‘.gov’. Each particular user would identify itself by an appropriate prefix. So Stanford University was ‘stanford.edu’. The United Kingdom and other countries developed networks of computers including defence organisations, universities, commercial organisations and government agencies. The protocols and standards which they developed for communication within these networks were not uniform. In the 1980s it became apparent that it was necessary to provide links between the various nationally-based networks. Unification of their disparate naming schemes was imperative. Generic domain name endings became known as Top Level Domains (TLDs). They describe classes of users or addresses within the Internet. Some of them were independent of any association between the addressee and a particular country. They included ‘.com’, ‘.org’ and ‘.net’. Country codes were established to identify users of different national origins. So domain names ending in ‘.uk’ identified computer servers in the United Kingdom, ‘.fr’ for France and ‘.au’ for Australia. These end codes became known as country code Top Level Domains (ccTLDs).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH J
In my opinion, I should not decline to follow his Honour’s considered judgment on this question unless satisfied that it is plainly wrong. The construction favoured by his Honour may be debatable but it is clearly open. I do not think that I should depart from it. That is sufficient to dispose of this aspect of the case as the services to which the UKIR Notices related were not services which had been provided. Conclusion For the preceding reasons, I find that Mr Norrish has infringed Nominet UK’s copyright in its databases. I also find that he was involved in the misleading or deceptive conduct of (UK) Internet Registry by reason of the sending of the UKIR Notices to addressees in the United Kingdom. Nominet UK is entitled to declaratory and injunctive relief and damages against him. It is also entitled to its costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH J

In my opinion the false representations pleaded in pars 15(b) to (d) and (f) of the statement of claim are made out in so far as they are attributed to (UK) Internet Registry. Whether Mr Norrish Was Involved in the Preparation and/or Sending of the UKIR Notices Nominet UK alleges, in par 17B of its statement of claim that Mr Norrish aided, abetted, counselled, procured, induced and/or was knowingly concerned in and/or a party to the contraventions by (UK) Internet Registry of the Fair Trading Acts and was thereby a person involved in each of those contraventions within the meaning of s 68 of the Fair Trading Act (WA) and/or s 145 of the Fair Trading Act 1999 (Vic) (Fair Trading Act (Vic)). The particulars of Mr Norrish’s alleged involvement are that he was:(a)a manager of, or involved with the management of, the business of (UK) Internet Registry; (b)instrumental in the actions of (UK) Internet Registry; (c)acting as a servant and/or agent of (UK) Internet Registry acting at all material times within the scope of his authority; (d)in effective control of (UK) Internet Registry;(e)aware of the conduct of the servants or agents of (UK) Internet Registry; (f)instrumental in the conduct of the servants or agents on behalf of (UK) Internet Registry. Counsel for Nominet UK referred to a number of documents in evidence which indicated that Mr Norrish was closely involved in the affairs of (UK) Internet Registry including the establishment of a ‘virtual office’ for it in London and in the drafting and sending of the UKIR Notices. A WHOIS search for the domain name ‘.ukinternetregistry.co.uk’ held in the Nominet UK Registry as at 7 March 2003 showed the Registrant contact to be Bradley Norrish. The designated administrative contact was ‘Domain Administrator’ and the address was shown as ‘33 St James’s Square, London’ with the code ‘SW1Y 4J5’. This was an error for ‘SW1Y 4JS’. Mr Norrish also had an email address ‘brad@brad.com.au’ registered in Australia. On 14 February 2003, Mr Craig Oehlers applied for the domain name ‘irwww.co.uk’ reflecting the initials of Internet Registrations Worldwide Pty Ltd. Mr Norrish, on the following day, became the designated administrative contact and domain administrator for that name. (1/378 and 1/379) The administrative address given was 33 St James’s Square, London. Emails to and from Mr Norrish indicate his involvement with the preparation of the UKIR Notices. In November 2002, Mr Rafferty sent him by email a copy of an email setting out estimated costs for a mail out of 50,000 items in the United Kingdom. The estimate was provided by Gary Cooper of Vertis Europe. The estimate was made on the basis that the mail out would be conducted in December 2002. A production schedule prepared by Vertis set out details of the preparation of artwork and copy, the printing of documents, enclosing and posting and target dates for each of those steps. The schedule was not met. On 8 January 2003, Mr Norrish sent an email to a Goran Naumovski containing requests for changes to a text and setting out an address to be included in it as ‘33 St James’s Square London SW1Y 4J5’. Having regard to context and timing and the content of the changes, it is clear that Mr Norrish was making editorial changes to the text of the UKIR Notices and that the address he gave was the address which was to be, and was ultimately, included in those Notices. That address used the wrong code ‘SW1Y 4J5’ instead of ‘SW1Y 4JS’.