RLA POLYMERS PTY LTD ACN 004 709 915 v NEXUS ADHESIVES PTY LTD ACN 121 120 036, JONATHAN CHARLES CLEWLOW, ISHU SOFAT and BRETT NIXON
File number(s):
VID 1150 of 2007
Judge:
RYAN J
Date of judgment:
29 April 2011
Dates of hearing:
13, 16, 17, 20 - 24 inc and 27 September - 1 October 2010 inc and 4, 7 and 8 October 2010
Place:
Melbourne
Division:
GENERAL DIVISION
Category:
No Catchwords
Number of paragraphs:
176
Counsel for the Applicant:
Mr D M B Derham QC with Mr A Nash
Solicitor for the Applicant:
Blake Dawson
Counsel for the Respondents:
Dr J Wilson SC with Mr T Wodak
Solicitor for the Respondents:
GPZ Legal
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
VID 1150 of 2007
BETWEEN:
RLA POLYMERS PTY LTD ACN 004 709 915 Applicant
AND:
NEXUS ADHESIVES PTY LTD ACN 121 120 036 First Respondent
JONATHAN CHARLES CLEWLOW Second Respondent
ISHU SOFAT Third Respondent
BRETT NIXON Fourth Respondent
JUDGE:
RYAN J
DATE OF ORDER:
29 APRIL 2011
WHERE MADE:
MELBOURNE
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.There be a taking of accounts by a Registrar of the Court of any profits made by the first respondent from sales of Nexus 820 adhesive between the date in September 2007 when the first of such sales was made until 14 March 2008.
2.The respondents pay to the applicant as damages the amount found upon the taking of accounts referred to in paragraph 1 of this Order.
3.The application stand over to a date to be fixed for the making of further orders as to costs, interest and any other matter which may be required in light of the reasons of the Court published this day.
4.The time for appeal from paragraphs 1 and 2 of this Order be extended until the expiration of 21 days from the making of the orders referred to in paragraph 3 of this Order.
Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules. The text of entered orders can be located using Federal Law Search on the Court’s website.
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
VID 1150 of 2007
BETWEEN:
RLA POLYMERS PTY LTD ACN 004 709 915 Applicant
AND:
NEXUS ADHESIVES PTY LTD ACN 121 120 036 First Respondent
JONATHAN CHARLES CLEWLOW Second Respondent
ISHU SOFAT Third Respondent
BRETT NIXON Fourth Respondent
JUDGE:
RYAN J
DATE:
29 APRIL 2011
PLACE:
MELBOURNE
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
INTRODUCTION
Before this Court is an application brought by the applicant, RLA Polymers Pty Ltd (“RLA”) seeking relief against the respondents in respect of alleged breaches of obligations of confidence by three of its former employees, the second respondent, (“Clewlow”), the third respondent (“Sofat”) and the fourth respondent (“Nixon”) and breaches of the Trade Practices Act
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read RLA Polymers Pty Ltd v Nexus Adhesives Pty Ltd and more:
In the case of RLA Polymers Pty Ltd v Nexus Adhesives Pty Ltd, the dispute centred around the alleged misuse of confidential information by Nexus Adhesives in the development of their adhesive products, Nexus 820 and Nexus 840. The respondents argued that the claims by RLA were unfounded, asserting that the products were independently developed without reliance on the confidential information provided by RLA. The primary legal issues that the court had to decide involved whether the respondents had breached a duty of confidence by using RLA's confidential information and whether the development of Nexus 820 and Nexus 840 could be considered independent of the confidential information.
The court found that while Nexus 840 was developed without any misuse of confidential information, Nexus 820 had indeed benefited from the respondents' use of RLA's confidential information. The court examined various pieces of evidence, including the involvement of O'Brien and the acquisition of products from BASF, to conclude that the development of Nexus 820 was significantly expedited by the respondents' use of the confidential information. The evidence presented, particularly the batch records and the Notebook, demonstrated that the respondents had used parts of the confidential information to overcome technical challenges and accelerate the development process.
Given the misuse of confidential information, the court ordered an account of profits for Nexus 820 for a period of five and a half months, from the release date in September 2007 until March 2008. The court also ordered that Nexus Adhesives pay RLA the amount found on the taking of accounts as damages. The application was stood over to allow for further orders regarding costs, interest, and other matters.
The final orders included a directive for the Registrar of the Court to take an account of profits made by Nexus Adhesives from sales of Nexus 820 adhesive, and for the respondents to pay the amount found on the account as damages. Additionally, the time for appeal from these orders was extended to 21 days from the making of further orders regarding costs, interest, and other matters.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. There be a taking of accounts by a Registrar of the Court of any profits made by the first respondent from sales of Nexus 820 adhesive between the date in September 2007 when the first of such sales was made until 14 March 2008.
2. The respondents pay to the applicant as damages the amount found upon the taking of accounts referred to in paragraph 1 of this Order.
3. The application stand over to a date to be fixed for the making of further orders as to costs, interest and any other matter which may be required in light of the reasons of the Court published this day.
4. The time for appeal from paragraphs 1 and 2 of this Order be extended until the expiration of 21 days from the making of the orders referred to in paragraph 3 of this Order.
Note: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
The text of entered orders can be located using Federal Law Search on the Court’s website.
Background
Background to the litigation
The respondents submit that all RLA’s claims should be dismissed on the basis that none of the causes of action invoked by RLA has been sustained. The respondents contend that the Confidential Information is not capable of protection at law and, in any event, the products known as “Nexus 820” and “Nexus 840” were independently developed by Nexus Adhesives and its consultant, Mr Philip O’Brien (“O’Brien”).FACTUAL BACKGROUNDAdhesives By way of introduction, it is first necessary to outline the nature of the Confidential Information and adhesives in general. Information respectively possessed by RLA and Nexus Adhesives, particularly that related to specific ingredients of their different adhesives, has to be kept confidential. Accordingly, I have endeavored to exclude from these reasons any reference to specific ingredients and, where necessary, I have used general terms or pseudonyms to identify the ingredient in question. The following is an extract from the CETEC Expert Witness Report (“CETEC Report”) and is an uncontroversial summary of the types of adhesive ingredients which make up PE 265, Nexus 820, Roberts 656, and Nexus 840.… PE 265 and Nexus 820 and Roberts 656 and Nexus 840 are Contact Adhesives and Pressure Sensitive Adhesives respectively.A Contact Adhesive is typically a mixture of ingredients dissolved in a solvent. These ingredients are usually made up of a polymer(s), filler(s), possibly pigment(s) and/or additives. With a Contact Adhesive, the product may be applied to one or both substrate surfaces, these are subsequently allowed to solvent dry and become tacky, before the two adhesive surfaces are brought together to create the bond.Pressure Sensitive Adhesives form a bond by the application of light pressure between the two substrate surfaces. Thus, in the case of a carpet tile, the adhesive is applied to the tile and thereafter simply pressed into position on the floor. The CETEC Report was tendered by RLA and comprised two reports prepared by CETEC Pty Ltd (“CETEC”). The first report set out a number of chemical and documentary analyses and conclusions arising from them and detailed the instructions and materials received by CETEC. The second report was a supplementary report prepared by CETEC after the respondents’ witness statements had been filed and was prepared in response to an enquiry as to whether CETEC’s original opinions had changed, and, if so, how. The authors of the CETEC Report, and expert witnesses called by RLA, were Dr Vytenis Peter Garnys, Managing Director and Principal Consultant of CETEC (“Dr Garnys”) and David Anthony Bate, Senior Consultant of CETEC (“Bate”). It is common ground between the parties to this proceeding that most adhesives contain the following raw materials which are readily obtainable from trade suppliers:(a)base resins such as polymers which constitute the main ingredient in the adhesive and provide adhesion and tack;(b)a “tackifier”, such as a resin;(c)a solvent, such as water;(d)thickeners;(e)filler;(f)biocide, pH adjusters and other additives.The base resin or polymer is the most prevalent raw material in the adhesive formula, providing the basic performance properties of the adhesive. RLA Polymers
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Of the evidence adduced by the respondents, the following supports a finding that their development of Nexus 820 and Nexus 840 was intended to be independent and, at the least, was not a “ruse”:(a)O’Brien’s evidence of his involvement from an early stage and the role he played in the development process, particularly in relation to Nexus 840, which includes evidence of correspondence between O’Brien and Clewlow and Sofat which I consider has significant probative value; and(b)Evidence of meetings with representatives of BASF and Nexus Adhesives’ subsequent acquisition of SPFs from BASF.I shall address in turn each of these aspects of the respondents’ evidence.O’Brien’s evidence RLA identified in its submissions a number of aspects of the evidence from which, it contended, the Court should infer misuse of the Confidential Information to combat the “post thickening problem”. In particular, it referred to a number of “batch records” numbered 1 to 8 and dated 28 August 2007 which had been created by Nixon to identify the “post thickening problem”. Those were originally recorded in the Notebook which has a different page for each batch and each batch shows a different combination of ingredients. Each page sets out the formulation for Nexus 820 with handwritten changes for each batch. Significantly, in batches 3 and 4, Polymer 5 and Polymer 2 have been overwritten with Polymer A and Polymer B which, it will be recalled, are the two polymers in PE 265. The batches are given a “best” to “worst” ranking. Two of the formulations (7 and 8) which used a specific batch of Polymer 5, and batch 3 and 4 were ranked as the “best”. The evidence of both Nixon and Sofat is that Nixon had carried out the “batch tests”. However, it is unclear why Nixon, who was not a chemist, had been left to carry out these tests without Sofat’s supervision, as she contends he was. Sofat claimed that Nixon was doing his own tests with her having very little to do with it, even though she acknowledged that she was responsible for solving the “post thickening problem”. I find it unlikely that Nixon was entrusted with overcoming, without Sofat’s supervision, the “post thickening problem” which had perplexed Sofat, a trained chemist. I consider that Sofat denied direct involvement in the creation of the “batches” to distance herself from, what I find was a clear use of the Confidential Information to resolve the “post thickening problem”. As noted earlier in these reasons, the “post thickening problem” was a major concern for Nexus Adhesives and I therefore regard it as highly improbable that Nixon had been left to explore possible solutions without Sofat’s supervision or, at least, her instructions. RLA invited a finding that Sofat had been working in conjunction with Nixon to solve the “post thickening problem” and, suggested that her role, as revealed by the Notebook was to compare and contrast the PE 265 and Nexus 820 formulations in order to instruct Nixon as to which “batches” to test. In this connection, RLA instanced a page in the Notebook where the Nexus 820 formulation is set out and below it, in a table, the PE 265 ingredients which had been communicated by Nixon to Sofat are recorded for the second time. The table sets out both the wet and dry weights of the PE 265 ingredients. As noted at [134] above, the dry weights had been calculated by Sofat as that is her customary way of understanding and dealing with the weights of polymers. Immediately after the table, on the same page appears a version of the Nexus 820 formulation in which the thickener has been replaced with the thickener from PE 265, and the plasticiser and the sequestering agent have been removed. PE 265 does not contain a plasticiser or sequestering agent. This record is said to demonstrate a comparison by Sofat of the differences in the ingredients, other than the polymers, of PE 265 and Nexus 820.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Although I regard the evidence canvassed earlier in these reasons as sufficient of itself to fix the respondents with liability for misuse of the Confidential Information, my findings in that respect derive additional support from the conclusion just explained, that the actual development of Nexus 820 occupied a period as short as only five months. CONCLUSION Of the main findings outlined in the foregoing reasons, the first is that the respondents did not use Confidential Information in the development of Nexus 840. Secondly, elements of a cause of action for a breach of confidence as enunciated in Australian Medicare have been made out in respect of the respondents’ development of Nexus 820. The evidence tending to establish each of those elements may be summarised as follows;(a)the Confidential Information was confidential in character, i.e, it had “the necessary quality of confidence about it”: Saltman Engineering Co Ltd v Campbell Engineering Co Ltd (1948) 65 RPC 203 at 215 (see [46]-[64] of these reasons); (b)the Confidential Information was imparted in circumstances importing an obligation of confidence; Coco v A N Clark (Engineers) Ltd [1969] RPC 41 at 47; Ansell Rubber Co Pty Ltd v Allied Rubber Industries Pty Ltd [1967] VR 37 at 40 (see [65]-[69] of these reasons); and(c)there was actual unauthorised use and disclosure of the Confidential Information: Smith Kline & French Laboratories (Aust) Ltd v Department of Community Services and Health (1990) 22 FCR 73 at 87, 111-112; Prince Jefri Bolkiah v KPMG (a firm) [1999] 2 AC 222 (see [100]-[116] and [133]-[151] of these reasons) . The cause of action was made out because the available inference which I prefer is that the respondents used parts of the Confidential Information in numerous ways to contribute to the development and production of Nexus 820. Irrespective of whether they wished or intended to develop and produce the Nexus adhesives without recourse to the Confidential Information which they brought with them from RLA, they were only able to achieve what they did with Nexus 820 in the space of five months by using parts of the Confidential Information. Creation and development of that product for the commercial market, had it been uninfluenced by the Confidential Information, would have taken at least nine, and up to twelve, months. The “springboard” advantage thus gained by the respondents has a bearing on the remedy which this Court should grant. The remedies sought by RLA have been set out at [36] of these reasons. My findings as to the liability of the respondents and the springboard advantage they have achieved from misuse of the Confidential Information make it appropriate to order an account of the profits derived by Nexus Adhesives from sales of Nexus 820 during a specified period. Because I have considered that completely independent development and production of Nexus 820 would have taken between nine and twelve months, I have taken the mid-point of that range, namely ten and a half months, in fixing the period during which Nexus Adhesives should be taken to have profited impermissibly from its sales of Nexus 820. Thus, the account of profits should be for a period of five and a half months from when Nexus 820, free of the “post-thickening” problem, was released for commercial distribution and sale at the end of September 2007. I shall order that the respondents pay to RLA as damages the amount of those profits as found on the taking of an account.