Madritsch Kg v Thales Australia Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Madritsch KG & Anor v Thales Australia Limited [2021] QSC 262

PARTIES:

MADRITSCH KG

(first plaintiff/first respondent)

NIOA NOMINEES PTY LTD (AS TRUSTEE FOR THE BILL NIOA FAMILY TRUST)
(second plaintiff/second respondent)
v
THALES AUSTRALIA LIMITED
ACN 008 642 751

(defendant/applicant)

FILE NO:

BS 9497 of 2017

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application (Commercial List)

DELIVERED ON:

12 October 2021 (ex tempore)

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

12 October 2021

JUDGE:

Bradley J

ORDER:

The Order of the Court is that:

1.   The parties are to confer and submit to the Associate to Bradley J either any agreed or any competing directions proposed for the next stage of the proceeding by 4:00 pm on 21 October 2021.

2.   The application filed 7 September 2021 is otherwise dismissed.

3.   Costs are reserved, to be agreed or, if necessary, determined at a time convenient to the court. 

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – COURT SUPERVISION – ADJOURNMENT – where the parties sought and the court ordered separate trials to determine questions of liability independent to those of quantum – where the liability trial was heard and determined – where the defendant has appealed the decision on liability – where the defendant has applied for an “adjournment” of the question of the quantification of loss and damage or any enquiry into an account of profits until after the determination of the appeal – where the defendant contends it will incur considerable costs absent a grant of the relief sought – where the plaintiffs seek to progress their claim to final judgment without delay – whether the possible costs disadvantage the defendant may endue outweighs the certain further delay in the determination of the plaintiffs’ claim

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld), r 5, r 221, r 366, r 367, r 374

Aquaculture Corporation v New Zealand Green Mussel Co Ltd & Ors (1985) 5 IPR 353, considered
Birla Mt Gordon Pty Ltd v Miccon Hire Pty Ltd [2013] QCA 363, cited
Cook's Construction Pty Ltd v Stork Food Systems Australasia Pty Ltd [2008] 2 Qd R 453, [2008] QCA 322, considered
Croney v Nand [1999] 2 Qd R 342, [1998] QCA 367, cited
Day v Humphrey & Ors [2017] QCA 104, followed
Dr Martens Australia Pty Ltd v Bata Shoe Company of Australia Pty Ltd
(1997) 75 FCR 230, cited
Gerhardt v Brisbane City Council [2016] QCA 272, cited
Goodman Fielder Pte Ltd v Conga Foods Pty Ltd (2021) 157 IPR 468; [2021] FCA 307 , considered
Klerck & Ors v Sierocki & Anor [2014] QCA 355, cited
Origin Energy LPG Ltd v Bestcare Foods Ltd [2012] NSWCA 322, considered
RLA Polymers Pty Ltd v Nexus Adhesives (2011) 280 ALR 125, [2011] FCA 423, considered
White v Brunton [1984] QB 570, considered
Young v Gold Coast City Council [2015] QCA 45, cited

COUNSEL:

SR Cooper QC, with H…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Madritsch Kg v Thales Australia Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QSC 262
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The parties to the proceeding Madritsch Kg v Thales Australia Limited are Madritsch KG and Nioa Nominees Pty Ltd, who are the plaintiffs, and Thales Australia Limited, who is the defendant. The proceeding involves a claim for damages for breach of contract, compensation for contravention of s 18 of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL), and equitable compensation for breach of a duty of confidence or alternatively an account of profits. The claim relates to the manufacture of a firearm sold to the Commonwealth for use by the Australian Defence Force. The defendant has appealed the decision on liability, and has applied for an adjournment of the question of the quantification of loss and damage or any enquiry into an account of profits until after the determination of the appeal.

The central legal issue the court had to decide was whether the possible costs disadvantage the defendant may endure outweighs the certain further delay in the determination of the plaintiffs’ claim. The defendant argued that it would incur considerable costs absent a grant of the relief sought, and the plaintiffs sought to progress their claim to final judgment without delay. The court had to weigh the considerations of granting an adjournment against the principles of finality and the entitlement of the successful party in litigation to the fruits of their judgment.

The court found that the application was in substance for an order barring the progress of the proceeding in the trial division towards a trial, including preventing further disclosure, exchange of witnesses’ summaries, and orders for expert reports, pending the outcome of the appeal. The court rejected the application, holding that an order that imposes a halt on a proceeding is a stay in nature and effect, if not in name. The court held that the nomenclature was of less importance than the substance and that the considerations that judgments of the Trial Division should not be treated as merely provisional, and that a successful party in litigation is entitled to the fruits of its judgment, outweighed the possible costs disadvantage to the defendant. The court held that the application did not arise in the situation the subject of the decisions in Cook's Construction Pty Ltd v Stork Food Systems Australasia Pty Ltd, Croney v Nand, and Day v Humphrey, which concerned the prevention of an order that might be made by the appellate court being rendered nugatory. The court held that no such issue arose here and that there was no order that needed to be stayed because it might be enforced before the appeal was determined.

The final orders of the court were that the parties were to confer and submit to the Associate to Bradley J either any agreed or any competing directions proposed for the next stage of the proceeding by 4:00 pm on 21 October 2021, the application filed 7 September 2021 was dismissed, and costs were reserved to be agreed or, if necessary, determined at a time convenient to the court.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Order of the Court is that:

1. The parties are to confer and submit to the Associate to Bradley J either any agreed or any competing directions proposed for the next stage of the proceeding by 4:00 pm on 21 October 2021.

2. The application filed 7 September 2021 is otherwise dismissed.

3. Costs are reserved, to be agreed or, if necessary, determined at a time convenient to the court.

Background

Background to the litigation

Written submissions were filed for the applicant-defendant and for the respondent-plaintiffs. These were supplemented by oral submissions made in today’s hearing. After a short adjournment, the court resumed. No further oral submissions were made. The court refused an adjournment. Reasons for the decision were given ex tempore. The paragraph above and those following comprise an edited version of those reasons. Background This proceeding has a history. Most of the events relevant to the claim occurred between 14 September 2011 and 11 June 2012. The plaintiffs, Madritsch KG and Nioa Nominees Pty Ltd, filed their claim on 14 September 2017. In it, the plaintiffs seek damages for breach of contract, compensation or other relief for contravention of s 18 of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL), and equitable compensation for breach of a duty of confidence or alternatively an account of profits. Each of these claims relates to the manufacture by the defendant of a firearm that is sold to the Commonwealth for use by the Australian Defence Force. It is convenient to refer to the weapon as the F90, although it may not be common ground that only this model of rifle is the subject of the claim. It seems the proceeding fell into a bit of a hole between about July 2018 and October 2019. From the latter time, it was managed on the caseflow managed list. On 20 April 2020, the parties asked the court to make an order for “the question of the quantification of the loss and damage claimed by the plaintiffs or the enquiry into an account of profits” to be heard and determined “separately from and after all questions of liability” have been determined in the proceeding. The parties sought this order on the papers without an oral hearing. Written submissions were filed as well as affidavit evidence from the defendant’s solicitor, Mr Fairbairn, about the time and cost likely to be involved in the preparation and hearing of the parties’ cases on the quantification of damages or an account of profit. At that time, Mr Fairbairn gave evidence on information from Mr Evenden, who was then the Director of the Soldier Weapon Systems and OME Australia departments in the Land and Air Systems Global Business Unit of the defendant. According to Mr Evenden’s information, the defendant “does not maintain accounting records by which a net profit per F90 product produced or sold could be determined.” (This evidence is repeated in Mr Fairbairn’s second affidavit affirmed for the hearing of this application. He elaborates: “Thales would need to engage an expert forensic accountant to determine the gross and net profit from the F90.” Extraordinary as it may seem, the defendant’s evidence before the court, then and now, and the submissions it has instructed its counsel to make today are to the effect that this public company, which manufactures and sells the F90 rifle to the Commonwealth, does not maintain accounting records by which a net profit per F90 produced or sold could be determined.)

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Although described as an adjournment, the application is in substance for an order barring the progress of the proceeding in the trial division towards a trial, including preventing further disclosure, exchange of witnesses’ summaries and orders for expert reports, pending the outcome of the appeal. It is therefore unlike, and broader than, a stay of enforcement of a particular order or judgment. It would prevent the plaintiffs from progressing their claim to a final determination, while the order is in place. An order that imposes a halt on a proceeding is a stay in nature and effect, if not in name. The nomenclature is of less importance than the substance. Some considerations that may be relevant to granting the relief sought The situation before the court is not that which was before the Court of Appeal in Cook's Construction Pty Ltd v Stork Food Systems Australasia Pty Ltd.[5] However, some of the considerations there would appear to be appropriate reference points. At [12], Keane JA explained: “The decision of this Court in Berry v Green suggests that it is not necessary for an applicant for a stay pending appeal to show ‘special or exceptional circumstances’ which warrant the grant of the stay. Nevertheless, it will not be appropriate to grant a stay unless a sufficient basis is shown to outweigh the considerations that judgments of the Trial Division should not be treated as merely provisional, and that a successful party in litigation is entitled to the fruits of its judgment. Generally speaking, courts should not be disposed to delay the enforcement of court orders. The fundamental justification for staying judicial orders pending appeal is to ensure that the orders which might ultimately be made by the courts are fully effective: the power to grant a stay should not be exercised merely because immediate compliance with orders of the court is inconvenient for the party which has been unsuccessful in the litigation.” [footnotes omitted][5][2008] 2 Qd R 453. The Court of Appeal has accepted as correct the test that the applicant bears the onus of showing that it is an “appropriate” case for a stay to be granted.[6] This was more recently confirmed by Morrison JA in Day v Humphrey:“An applicant for a stay must demonstrate some reason why a judgment should not be given immediate effect. The test applicable on an application to stay a judgment pending an appeal is simply expressed as being whether the case is an appropriate one for a stay.”[7][6]Croney v Nand [1999] 2 Qd R 342 at [33] (Keane JA), citing Williams v Chesterman App 74/1992 Court of Appeal, 23 June 1992 (unreported).[7][2017] QCA 104 at [5]. His Honour cited Croney v Nand. As noted, this application does not arise in the situation the subject of those decisions. The typical ground for a stay pending appeal is to prevent an order that might be made by the appellate court being rendered nugatory. As Mr Thompson identified, by reference to the reasons of Gotterson JA in Gerhardt v Brisbane City Council[8] and Young v Gold Coast City Council,[9] no such issue arises here. There is no order that needs to be stayed because it might be enforced before the appeal is determined.[8][2016] QCA 272.[9][2015] QCA 45.