Goodman Fielder Pte Ltd v Conga Foods Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 54 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Goodman Fielder Pte Ltd v Conga Foods Pty Ltd [2021] FCA 307

File number: NSD 328 of 2018
Judgment of: BURLEY J
Date of judgment: 31 March 2021
Catchwords:

TRADE MARKS – infringement – goods of the same description – where scope of alleged infringing goods not sufficiently made clear by the parties at trial – further infringement findings

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – form of final orders – scope of declaratory and injunctive relief

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – whether respondents should be granted sell-through period for infringing products – whether respondents should be ordered to deliver up infringing products after sell-through period  

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – whether respondents should be ordered to withdraw application to register trade mark found to infringe applicants’ trade marks

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – whether orders for rectification of the Trade Marks Register are necessary where applicants have voluntarily amended their registrations

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – stay of determination of quantum pending appeal

COSTS – whether costs should be paid as a lump sum or taxed – whether costs should be awarded on issue by issue basis – apportionment of costs  

Legislation:

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 23, s 24(1A), s 37AF, s 43

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 34.48, r 36.08

Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) s 4, s 17, s 33, s 120

Federal Court of Australia, Costs Practice Note (GPN-COSTS), 25 October 2016

Macquarie Dictionary (5th ed, 2009, Sydney)

Cases cited:

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Cambur Industries Pty Ltd [2006] FCA 1027; ATPR ¶42-127

Calidad Pty Ltd v Seiko Epson Corporation (No 2) [2019] FCAFC 168; 147 IPR 386

Colbeam Palmer Ltd v Stock Affiliates Pty Ltd [1968] HCA 50; 122 CLR 25

Firebird Global Master Fund II Ltd v Republic of Nauru (No 2) [2015] HCA 53; 327 ALR 192

Goodman Fielder Pte Ltd v Conga Foods Pty Ltd [2020] FCA 1808

Goodman Fielder Pty Ltd v Conga Foods Pty Ltd [2019] FCA 2053

Idenix Pharmaceuticals LLC v Gilead Sciences Pty Ltd (No 2) [2018] FCAFC 7

In-N-Out Burgers, Inc v Hashtag Burgers Pty Ltd (No 2) [2020] FCA 772

Philips Electronics NV v Remington Products Australia Pty Ltd [1997] FCA 1048; 150 ALR 355

QS Holdings Sarl v Paul’s Retail Pty Ltd (No 2) [2011] FCA 1038

Red Bull Australia Pty Limited v Sydneywide Distributors Pty Limited t/as Sydneywide Bottlers Australia [2001] FCA 1750

Rural Press Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2003] HCA 75; 216 CLR 53

Solahart Industries Pty Ltd v Solar Shop Pty Ltd (No 2) [2011] FCA 780; 282 ALR 43

Thai Gypsum Products Company Ltd v Waring & Gillow Pty Ltd [1994] FCA 556; 29 IPR 99

Ward Group Pty Ltd v Brodie & Stone Plc [2005] FCA 471; 143 FCR 479

Wooldridge v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2015] FCA 349

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Intellectual Property
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Goodman Fielder Pte Ltd v Conga Foods Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCA 307
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The dispute between Goodman Fielder Pte Ltd and Conga Foods Pty Ltd, concerning trade mark infringement, was determined by the Federal Court of Australia. The primary focus of the litigation was on whether Conga Foods had infringed Goodman Fielder's trade marks through the use of specific marks and products. The court was required to decide on the scope of declaratory and injunctive relief, including the specific products that were in issue at trial and the application of the injunction to certain online platforms. Additionally, the court considered whether Conga Foods should be granted a sell-through period for infringing products, whether they should be ordered to withdraw an application to register a trade mark, and what orders should be made concerning costs.

The court meticulously analysed the evidence presented by both parties, including affidavits from key individuals such as Ronni Kahn AO and Daniel James Thompson. The applicants sought a declaration of infringement and specific injunctive relief to prevent the use of certain marks on pasta products. The respondents argued for a broader interpretation of the products in question and challenged the scope of the injunction. After thorough deliberation, the court found that the Rana fresh gnocchi and fresh lasagne sheet products were indeed goods of the same description as those covered by the 473 word mark. The court granted a limited sell-through period for certain products and provided detailed orders concerning the delivery up of infringing products, the withdrawal of a trade mark application, and the rectification of the Trade Marks Register.

The final orders included a declaration of infringement, an injunction restricting the use of specific marks, a limited sell-through period for certain products, and orders for the respondents to withdraw a trade mark application and deliver up infringing products. The court also addressed the issue of costs, determining the basis on which they should be assessed and apportioned between the parties. The decision provided clarity on the scope of relief and the procedural steps necessary to enforce the court's orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

20. Notwithstanding order 2 of these orders, the respondents whether by themselves, their directors, employees, agents or howsoever otherwise be permitted to import into Australia, offer for sale, sell or otherwise dispose of any:

(a) fresh filled pasta products which use the La Famiglia Rana Marks, until 31 May 2021; and

(b) fresh pasta products, including lasagne sheets and gnocchi which use the La Famiglia Rana Marks, until 31 May 2021,

which products are either:

(i) located in Australia as at the date of these orders; or

(ii) were in transit to Australia as at 25 January 2021,

provided that, in the case of (a) above, the respondents file an application for leave to appeal as envisaged in order 16 above.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Goodman Fielder Pte Ltd (Goodman Fielder) brought an action against Conga Foods Pty Ltd (Conga Foods) and Rana Foods Pty Ltd (Rana) alleging infringement of Australian trade mark registration number 1155473, which covers the marks "LA FAMIGLIA RANA" and "@lafamigliarana" (the La Famiglia Rana Marks), in relation to pasta products. The dispute arose after Conga Foods and Rana began using the La Famiglia Rana Marks on their pasta products, which Goodman Fielder claimed were similar to their own trade marks and therefore constituted an infringement. The infringement was alleged to have commenced in November 2017. Goodman Fielder sought various remedies, including declarations of infringement, injunctive relief, and orders for the delivery up of infringing products and withdrawal of an application to register a trade mark. The case proceeded to trial where evidence was presented by both parties, and the Court found in favour of Goodman Fielder on the issue of infringement.

The case was initially heard and determined by the Court in a judgment published on 17 December 2020. Following the judgment, the parties were directed to prepare proposed short minutes of order. Disagreements arose over the final orders to be made, leading to a form of orders hearing on 11 March 2021. At this hearing, the parties presented further evidence and arguments regarding the form of declaratory and injunctive relief, a sell-through period for infringing products, withdrawal of a trade mark application, costs, and other procedural matters. The Court's reasons for the final orders were delivered on the same day as the form of orders hearing.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 17 December 2020 I published my reasons in Goodman Fielder Pte Ltd v Conga Foods Pty Ltd [2020] FCA 1808 (judgment) and directed that the parties prepare and provide to my chambers proposed short minutes of order to give effect to the judgment. The parties disagreed as to the final orders that should be made, and the issues were debated at a subsequent form of orders hearing conducted on 11 March 2021. These reasons assume familiarity with the judgment and generally adopt the definitions used in it. In summary, the issues between the parties are:(1)The scope of declaratory and injunctive relief, and in particular: (a)what products were in issue at trial; and(b)whether an injunction should be granted in respect of the use of the Rana mark, the words LA FAMIGLIA RANA and @lafamigliarana (together, the La Famiglia Rana Marks) on the Rana website, Rana Facebook Page and Rana Instagram page; (2)Whether the respondents should be permitted a sell-through period in respect of infringing products currently in, or in transit to, Australia, or whether the Court should order that the infringing products be delivered up to the applicants; (3)Whether the Court should order that the respondents withdraw their application to register the Rana mark; (4)Whether orders should be made for the amendment and cancellation of the Goodman marks; (5)What orders should be made in respect of costs; and (6)Whether orders should be made in respect of leave to appeal and confidentiality. Each party adduced further evidence in support of its position. The applicants rely on an affidavit sworn by Ronni Kahn AO, the founder and CEO of OzHarvest. The respondents rely on affidavits provided by: Catherine Mary Still, who is the solicitor with conduct of the proceedings on their behalf; Nicola Zelger, who is the trade marketing and export sales director of Rana; and Daniel James Thompson, who is the chief sales and marketing officer of Conga. 2. DISPUTED FORM OF DECLARATORY AND INJUNCTIVE ORDERS2.1 The issues The applicants seek a declaration in the following form:The respondents have, since November 2017, infringed Australian trade mark registration number 1155473 by using, as a trade mark, each of , LA FAMIGLIA RANA and @lafamigliarana (La Famiglia Rana Marks) in relation to pasta products. The applicants seek an order in the following form:The respondents, whether by themselves, their directors, employees, agents or howsoever otherwise, be restrained from infringing Australian trade mark registration number 1155473, including in particular, from using any of the La Famiglia Rana Marks on or in relation to pasta products, but excluding pesto and pasta sauces. (general injunction). The applicants also seek an order that within 30 days the respondents:(a)take all steps that are necessary to cancel or amend the account name and URL details for the following social media accounts, to the extent that they are accessible to persons in Australia, to names and URLs that do not include “LA FAMIGLIA”:(i) all steps that are necessary to remove all social media posts from the accounts referred to in sub-paragraph (a) that feature LA FAMIGLIA, including the La Famiglia Rana Marks; and(c) take all steps that are necessary to remove all references to LA FAMIGLIA including the La Famiglia Rana Marks, from the website. (the social media injunction).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

My misapprehension as to the scope of the case advanced means that it is necessary to return to section 7 of the judgment with a view to considering whether the Rana fresh gnocchi and fresh lasagne sheet products infringe the 473 word mark. No additional submissions are necessary because, as I have found, both parties proceeded at the hearing on the basis that these products were included within the proceedings, and had the opportunity to make submissions on the subject at that point. 2.4 Consideration: fresh gnocchi and lasagne sheets In relation to the issue of deceptive similarity considered in section 7.3 of the judgment, in my view the impugned use of the Rana mark in relation to lasagne sheets and gnocchi is materially the same as the use depicted in the packaging set out at [321] and [322] of the judgment. The result is that each use is deceptively similar to the 473 word mark, for substantially the same reasons as those set out in [341] to [352] of the judgment. In relation to the question of whether the fresh gnocchi and fresh lasagne sheets are to be regarded as “goods of the same description” as the 473 designated goods, I refer to the relevant law summarised in section 6.2.3 of the judgment and my reasons for concluding that the Rana fresh filled pasta products are goods of the same description set out in section 7.5 of the judgment. Contrary to the submissions advanced by the applicants, the reasoning in section 7.5 does not read directly onto the gnocchi or lasagne sheet products, nor was it intended to do so. Nevertheless, having regard to the reasons set out in that section and those set out in section 6.3.1 at [293] to [306] of the judgment, as well as the reasons given below, I am satisfied that the Rana fresh gnocchi product and garlic bread are goods of the same description, and that the Rana lasagne sheets are goods of the same description as garlic bread. The definition of gnocchi in the Macquarie Dictionary (5th ed, 2009, Sydney) is: “small dumplings made from potato and flour or semolina, usually served with sauce as a savoury dish”. Although some consumers may take the view that gnocchi is not strictly a pasta product, the respondents accept that gnocchi falls within the scope of “pasta” and I consider it likely that many consumers would think of gnocchi as a type of pasta. I also note that the packaging of the Rana gnocchi product in evidence bears the words “Italy’s No 1 Fresh Pasta”. Although there is no evidence directed to the method of manufacturing gnocchi, it is unlikely that it is prepared in a bakery as garlic bread is, and it is therefore unlikely that a manufacturer of garlic bread will also manufacture gnocchi. However as with fresh filled pasta, the photographs of the “ready meals” sections of supermarket shelves in evidence show that the trade channels of gnocchi and garlic bread overlap. These photographs show that fresh gnocchi is usually co-located with or proximate to fresh filled pasta products, and I have already found in the judgment that fresh filled pasta products are likely to be sold in proximity to garlic bread: at [301]. There is no evidence before me of any “meal deals” for gnocchi and garlic bread, nor any evidence that the products are generally promoted together, but nevertheless both are located in close proximity in the refrigerated sections of shops. Gnocchi may be cooked by boiling or pan-frying, and may be consumed as a meal in itself. Mr Chiavegatti’s evidence is that Rana’s products, including its gnocchi product, are designed to be eaten alone and do not need anything more than a simple dressing with olive oil or butter. The directions on the packaging of Rana’s gnocchi product confirm that evidence by instructing the purchaser to boil or fry the gnocchi and serve with pasta sauce, parmesan cheese, or “simply with a pinch of salt”. The Macquarie Dictionary lists the origin of the word as Italian, and I consider it likely that gnocchi would be regarded by many Australians as an Italian meal. In my view, these considerations weigh in favour of a finding that garlic bread is a good of the same description as fresh gnocchi.