Thales Australia Limited v Madritsch KG

Link copied
Case Copied 66 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Thales Australia Limited v Madritsch KG & Anor [2022] QCA 205

PARTIES:

THALES AUSTRALIA LIMITED
ACN 008 642 751
(appellant)
v
MADRITSCH KG
(first respondent)
NIOA NOMINEES PTY LIMITED
ACN 010 108 086
AS TRUSTEE FOR THE BILL NIOA FAMILY TRUST

(second respondent)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 9591 of 2021
SC No 9497 of 2017

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

General Civil Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:


Supreme Court at Brisbane – [2021] QSC 170 (Bradley J)

DELIVERED ON:

21 October 2022

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATES:

24 & 25 March 2022

JUDGES:

Morrison and Mullins JJA and Freeburn J

ORDER:

The appeal be dismissed, with costs.

CATCHWORDS:

INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY – CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION – USE OF INFORMATION – where the respondent’s case at first instance was entirely circumstantial – where the court was required to draw inferences from the available evidence – whether the primary judge undertook a mechanical comparison of probabilities independent of any evidence supporting a belief in their reality – whether the primary judge reversed the onus of proof

APPEAL – APPEAL GENERAL PRINCIPLES – PROOF AND EVIDENCE – ERROR OF FACT – where the trial judge found that it was more likely than not that Thales identified the lower torque exerted by the automatic firing lever spring when they observed the Madritsch Solution – where the primary judge found that Thales gave no plausible explanation for Mr Steele’s decision to significantly reduce the automatic firing lever spring force in the first automatic firing lever spring design – where the primary judge found that Thales used the information about the auto fire lever spring force in the Madritsch Solution to avoid an independent design sequence – where the primary judge found that Mr Steele had no experience, particularly with torsion springs – whether the primary judge made factual errors

INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY – CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION – OBLIGATION OF CONFIDENTIALITY – whether Madritsch/Nioa failed to identify with sufficient specificity the information which they alleged was confidential and misused – whether Madritsch/Nioa failed to specify how that information was misused

INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY – CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION – OBLIGATION OF CONFIDENTIALITY – where the Madritsch Solution was provided to personnel of the Austrian Armed Forces on three separate occasions for testing purposes – where the appellant contends that any confidentiality of the Madritsch Solution was lost as a consequence – whether the Madritsch Solution lost its character of confidentiality – whether information previously disclosed to a limited public is deemed to enter the public domain

TRADE AND COMMERCE – COMPETITION, FAIR TRADING AND CONSUMER PROTECTION LEGISLATION – CONSUMER PROTECTION – MISLEADING OR DECEPTIVE CONDUCT OR FALSE REPRESENTATIONS – MISLEADING OR DECEPTIVE CONDUCT GENERALLY – where Madritsch/Nioa calculated losses as estimates of the licence fees and royalty rates that Madritsch/Nioa had sought in the draft licence agreement – where the trial was run as a split trial – where the first instance trial was concerned with the issue of liability and a later trial would eventuate to address damages –…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Thales Australia Limited v Madritsch KG and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] QCA 205
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Thales Australia Limited appealed against the decision of the Federal Court of Australia in relation to an action for breach of confidence and misleading or deceptive conduct. The respondents, Madritsch KG and Nioa GmbH (collectively referred to as Madritsch), were an Austrian company that developed a solution to a defect in a gas piston operated automatic assault rifle, known as the Bolt Unlocking Problem. The primary judge found that Thales, an Australian defence contractor, had access to confidential information about the Madritsch Solution and used it to avoid an independent design sequence. The primary judge also found that Thales misled Madritsch into believing that it had a continuing interest or intention to enter into a licence arrangement for the Madritsch Solution. Thales argued that the primary judge erred in fact and law in making these findings.

The court considered whether the primary judge undertook a mechanical comparison of probabilities independent of any evidence supporting a belief in their reality, and whether the primary judge reversed the onus of proof. The court also considered whether Madritsch failed to identify with sufficient specificity the information which they alleged was confidential and misused, and whether Madritsch failed to specify how that information was misused. The court found that the primary judge did not err in fact or law in making the findings, and that the appeal should be dismissed with costs.

The primary judge's approach to the evidence was not mechanical, but rather a careful evaluation of the evidence having regard to the capacity of each party to adduce the evidence. The primary judge was satisfied that the available credible evidence was sufficient to discharge Madritsch's onus of proof in relation to the misuse of confidential information. The primary judge also found that Madritsch had identified with sufficient specificity the information which they alleged was confidential and misused, and that Thales had misled Madritsch into believing that it had a continuing interest or intention to enter into a licence arrangement for the Madritsch Solution. These findings were supported by the evidence and were not erroneous.

In conclusion, the court found that the appeal should be dismissed, with costs. The primary judge's findings in relation to the misuse of confidential information and misleading or deceptive conduct were supported by the evidence and were not erroneous. The primary judge's approach to the evidence was careful and appropriate, and there was no reversal of the onus of proof. The appeal was dismissed, with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

The appeal be dismissed, with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Both weapons are gas piston operated automatic assault rifles. Both weapons suffered from a defect. Even though the weapons were not designed to do so, they were both frequently used with a grenade launcher attachment. When used with that attachment both weapons would fail to fire a round of ammunition immediately after the grenade launcher had been fired. The operator had to stop and ‘re-cock’ the rifle before it could be fired. The defect was described as the ‘Bolt Unlocking Problem’. The present dispute concerns the attempts to solve that problem.PART A: THE FACTS In 2007, Australia’s Defence Materiel Organisation (the DMO) identified and reported on the Bolt Unlocking Problem. Between March and October 2008, the DMO developed a prototype for a possible engineering solution to the Bolt Unlocking Problem in the Austeyr called the Joule Gain Modified Trigger Mechanism (JGCM). In Austria, at about the same time, the first respondent, Madritsch KG (Madritsch), an Austrian company that supplied a grenade launcher attachment for the Bundesheer, was also developing its own solution to the Bolt Unlocking Problem. The solution was in the form of a kit that could be retrofitted to the Steyr AUG. In the litigation this was called the ‘Madritsch Solution’. The development of the Madritsch Solution was explained by the primary judge in some detail.[2] Essentially, between September 2008 and August 2009, Mr Madritsch and Mr Frohnwieser, engineers employed or retained by Madritsch, developed the Madritsch Solution through a series of tests and modifications to design. It did so by means of an extensive series of live fire tests involving high speed cameras and measurement of trigger forces.[2]Reasons at [73] to [88]. By August 2009, the Madritsch Solution had been tested and approved by the Bundesheer. A certificate was issued by the relevant department confirming that the Madritsch Solution kits had been tested and approved in accordance with the procedures in a NATO standard described as ‘NATO AC/225’.[3] The kits were ready to be manufactured by Madritsch for retrofitting to the Steyr AUG.[3]See First Witness Statement of Stefan Madritsch at [48], [63]. In the meantime, in Australia, the JGCM solution took a different trajectory. In October 2008, the DMO engaged Thales to investigate the ‘manufacturability’ of the JGCM solution. Mr Williams, a technical officer with Thales, worked on that project, amongst other work, between October 2008 and late 2009. Mr Williams formed the opinion that the JGCM prototype could not be mass produced unless certain manufacturing issues were resolved. Mr Williams produced a new prototype and drawings, the Hammer Mechanism Assembly No. 1 (HMA1 V1), which largely reproduced the JGCM prototype. Mr Williams produced further revisions, HMA1 V2 and HMA1 V3,[4] in December 2008 and February 2009 respectively. Those versions made modifications to the mounting points, the shape and length of the legs for the hammer springs, and the design of the automatic firing lever (AFL) spring.[5][4]For convenience the various versions are referred to as V1 for version 1, etc.[5]Reasons at [29].

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

And so, the primary judge made clear that, having considered all the evidence, he was satisfied that Thales had not established that the Two Features in HMA1 V6 were developed by Thales’ own efforts. Then, His Honour continued:“[327] Weighing the evidence according to the power or ability of a party to produce it,[89] the available credible evidence, which leads to the conclusion that Mr Eyles directed Mr Steele to include specifications for the AFL spring in V6 that would have the effect of significantly reducing the force exerted by the AFL on the gun lock group and inspired Mr Steele’s decision to use a double torsion spring, is sufficient to discharge the plaintiffs’ onus of proof in this respect. This is so notwithstanding the seriousness of the allegations made in the plaintiffs’ case.” [emphasis added][89]At this point in the reasons a footnote refers the reader to Hampton Court Ltd v Crooks (1957) 97 CLR 367, 371-372 (Dixon CJ). The primary judge’s use of that initial phrase “Weighing the evidence according to the power or ability of a party to produce it” merely shows that His Honour has assessed the evidence having regard to the capacity of that party to adduce the evidence. In this case, of course, Thales had an unimpeded capacity to adduce, and did in fact adduce, a considerable body of evidence which, it contended, showed that HMA1 V6 was the result of the efforts of its own employees. One example is that Thales went into evidence concerning the many aspects of its work on the HMA1 project from February to June 2012.[90] As His Honour recorded, Mr Steele of Thales sought to take responsibility for the lower disengagement force in HMA1 V6 compared with its predecessors.[91] However, that evidence was rather undermined by Mr Steele’s admission that Mr Eyles, Mr Steele’s direct supervisor, spoke to him about the spring forces “still being too high” as well as Mr Steele’s concession that Mr Eyles was involved in the decision to lower the spring force.[92][90]This evidence is discussed by the primary judge at paragraphs [173] to [242] of the reasons.[91]Reasons at [214].[92]Reasons at [217]. Another example of Thales adducing evidence intended to show that the HMA1 V6 was the result of the efforts of its own employees, was Mr Steele’s evidence that he was responsible for the change from a single to a double torsion spring.[93][93]Reasons at [190]. As the primary judge explicitly said, he weighed that evidence. That was an evaluation exercise. His assessment of that evidence acknowledged that it was within Thales’ power to produce that evidence. Thales tendered the evidence it wished to adduce designed to demonstrate that HMA1 V6 was the product of Mr Steele’s labours. Ultimately, the primary judge did not accept significant parts of that evidence. None of that signifies any reversal of the burden of proof. Rather, paragraph [327] of the reasons explicitly:(a)recognised the reality that evidence as to how Thales designed HMA1 V6 was exclusively within Thales’ domain;(b)weighed the evidence bearing in mind that reality;(c)weighed the evidence having regard to the serious nature of the allegations sought to be proved; (d)concluded that the strength of the evidence was insufficient to establish that the HMA1 V6 was the product of Mr Steele’s own independent skill and ingenuity;(e)concluded that it was Mr Eyles’ conduct that had led Mr Steele to incorporate the Two Features into HMA1 V6; and(f)concluded that the strength of that evidence was sufficient to discharge Madritsch/Nioa’s onus of proving the misuse on the balance of probabilities.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For those reasons this ground should fail also.CONCLUSION In my opinion, the appeal should be dismissed, with costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.