Rintoul v State of Queensland

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Rintoul v State of Queensland & Ors [2018] QCA 20

PARTIES:

JENETTE RINTOUL
(applicant)
v
STATE OF QUEENSLAND
DOUG QUADRIO
PETER LEMON
(respondents)

FILE NO:

Appeal No 7182 of 2017
QCATA No 270 of 2016

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

Application for Leave Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act

ORIGINATING COURT:

Queensland Civil and Administrative Appeal Tribunal at Brisbane – [2017] QCATA 78

DELIVERED ON:

2 March 2018

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

8 February 2018

JUDGES:

Morrison and Philippides JJA and Applegarth J

ORDER:

Application for leave to appeal refused with costs.

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – APPEAL – LEAVE TO APPEAL – where the applicant complained of unlawful discrimination in a proceeding in the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal – where her claim was dismissed – where the applicant appealed and contended that the hearing before the Tribunal was not conducted with natural justice because she was denied the right to question her most important witness in chief – where the Appeal Tribunal dismissed her appeal – where the applicant seeks leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal – whether the application raises a question of law which warrants the grant of leave

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – APPEAL – PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – QUEENSLAND – POWERS OF COURT – COSTS – where application for leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal dismissed – where the respondent submitted that costs should follow the event – where the applicant argued she should not pay costs due to her personal circumstances and the history of the matter before the Tribunal – whether costs should follow the event

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 3, s 28, s 29, s 95, s 150

Oshlack v Richmond River Council (1998) 193 CLR 72; [1998] HCA 11, followed
Rintoul v State of Queensland & Ors[2015] QCA 79, cited
Terera v Clifford[2017] QCA 181, cited

COUNSEL:

The applicant appeared on her own behalf
M Spry for the respondents

SOLICITORS:

The applicant appeared on her own behalf
Crown Law for the respondents

  1. MORRISON JA:  I agree with the reasons of Applegarth J and the order his Honour proposes.

  2. PHILIPPIDES JA:  I agree with the reasons of Applegarth J and with the order proposed by his Honour.

  3. APPLEGARTH J:  The applicant brought a proceeding in the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal alleging acts of unlawful discrimination in connection with her employment as a supply teacher.  The matter went to a final hearing in November 2015.  After receiving written submissions in early 2016, the Tribunal dismissed her application.[1]  The applicant then appealed and also sought leave to appeal to the Appeal Tribunal.  She alleged:

    (a)the hearing before the Tribunal was procedurally flawed because of a failure to observe natural justice in not giving her a “reasonable opportunity” to examine an important witness, with the result that not “all relevant material” was disclosed to the Tribunal; and

    (b)errors in the factual…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rintoul v State of Queensland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] QCA 20
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Rintoul v State of Queensland, the applicant sought leave to appeal against the dismissal of her claim for unlawful discrimination in proceedings before the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT). The applicant argued that she was denied natural justice because she was not allowed to question her witness in chief before cross-examination. The Appeal Tribunal dismissed the appeal, and the applicant now seeks leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal.

The central legal issue was whether the applicant's application raised a question of law that warranted the grant of leave to appeal. The applicant argued that the Appeal Tribunal erred in concluding that she was not denied natural justice. The applicant also contended that the Appeal Tribunal failed to properly consider her submissions about the alleged procedural irregularity.

The Court found that the Appeal Tribunal's conclusion that the applicant was not denied natural justice was open to it based on the transcript of the hearing. The applicant did not demonstrate what, if anything, Mr Joseph might have said had the hearing taken a different course, or what further questions she would have asked after the conclusion of Mr Joseph’s cross-examination which she did not ask. The Court was not persuaded that there was a reasonable argument that there was an error of law to be corrected in respect of the Appeal Tribunal’s consideration of the natural justice ground. The applicant also failed to show that an appeal was necessary to correct a substantial injustice.

The Court refused the application for leave to appeal and ordered that the applicant pay the costs of the application.

This case highlights the principles governing a grant of leave to appeal and the importance of demonstrating a reasonable argument that there is an error to be corrected, and reasonable prospects of success, in order to warrant a grant of leave. The Court also emphasised that an application for leave to appeal is not the occasion to examine things said at conciliation conferences and mediations, or to characterise the case as something akin to a "David and Goliath battle".

Orders

Orders of the court

Application for leave to appeal refused with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The principles governing a grant of leave to appeal are well-established. In short, an applicant for leave to appeal must show:(a)the appeal is necessary to correct a substantial injustice;(b)there is a reasonable argument that there is an error to be corrected.There must be reasonable prospects of success to warrant a grant of leave. Therefore, in deciding whether to grant leave to appeal the Court usually makes some preliminary assessment of the prospects of the proposed appeal.[10][10]Terera v Clifford [2017] QCA 181 at [10].Relevant facts The pre-hearing stage of the proceeding before the Tribunal had a complicated course, and included a successful appeal by the applicant to this Court.[11] Directions were later made about the calling of witnesses and the matter proceeded to a hearing in Cairns. The hearing was set down for three days in anticipation of the applicant and the respondents each calling a number of witnesses. Some prospective witnesses for the applicant were prepared to provide written statements whilst others were not.[11]Rintoul v State of Queensland & Ors [2015] QCA 79. At the commencement of the hearing the applicant outlined the names of the witnesses she proposed to call, and the Member explained that the witnesses would be sworn, that she could ask them questions, that counsel for the respondents would then be given the opportunity to cross-examine and, if need be, the applicant could re-examine them. A number of “housekeeping” matters were discussed. Counsel for the respondents expressed his understanding that in the case of the applicant and those of her witnesses who had provided statements or statutory declarations, that those documents would form their evidence-in-chief. At that stage the Member did not commit to that course, but instead suggested that the applicant commence by giving her evidence and that he would later see how the matter should proceed. Counsel for the respondents at the hearing was concerned that if all of the evidence had to be given orally then the matter would not finish within its allocated three days. The applicant was sworn and adopted the witness statement which formed part of the hearing book. She accepted that the things said in it constituted her evidence. Cross-examination then occurred for a substantial time. At the end of her cross-examination the applicant was invited by the Member to comment on any matters arising out of the cross-examination. She then stood down and was invited to call her first witness, Mr Joseph. He was sworn and his attention directed to a statutory declaration, the contents of which he stated were true and correct. At that point the following exchanges occurred:“MR FARREN: Are we proceeding on the basis of that document, Member, straight to cross-examination?MEMBER: Well, as I understand it, that’s his evidence.MR FARREN: Thank you. Mr Joseph, I understand from - - -MEMBER: Did you want to add something, Mrs Rintoul?MS RINTOUL: No. I just thought I was going to question first. That’s all.MEMBER: Well, no. He’s your witness so you don’t get to cross-examine.MS RINTOUL: Okay.MEMBER: But if there’s something that is in addition to his evidence that you want to lead, I’ll give you permission to do that, but I was of the understanding, from what you told me earlier, that everything that’s contained in the affidavit is his evidence.MS RINTOUL: Yes.MEMBER: All right. Yes, Mr Farren.”Counsel for the Crown then cross-examined Mr Joseph.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

After the cross-examination concluded the Member asked the applicant:“MEMBER: Do you want to ask any further questions of Mr Joseph about what’s been – what he’s been asked about so far?”The applicant indicated that she did. She then examined Mr Joseph and a number of her questions were not confined strictly to specific matters which had been raised in cross-examination. Having done so, the Member then asked the applicant:“Do you have any more questions?”to which the applicant responded, “Not particularly”.The Appeal Tribunal’s consideration of the alleged denial of natural justice associated with the evidence of Mr Joseph The Appeal Tribunal considered the course of the proceeding. Having done so, it concluded that the transcript did not substantiate the applicant’s proposition that she was denied the opportunity to question Mr Joseph. In addition, the applicant’s arguments before the Appeal Tribunal were said to not demonstrate what, if anything, Mr Joseph might have said or which could have been led from him if the applicant had in fact been denied the opportunity to question him. In that context, the Appeal Tribunal noted that Mr Joseph had supported the applicant’s case without compulsion and that she had had some limited role in the preparation of his statutory declaration. She had an opportunity to include in that declaration any material that she thought was relevant. The Appeal Tribunal added that, to the extent that “it missed out anything that she thought was relevant, she could have included it in a supplementary declaration, or indicated to the Member that she wished to adduce some oral evidence to supplement the declaration”.[12][12]Rintoul v State of Queensland & Ors [2017] QCATA 78 at [21].Did the Appeal Tribunal err in law? The Appeal Tribunal considered the relevant principles and provisions, including s 95(1) of the QCAT Act which requires the Tribunal to allow a party to a proceeding “a reasonable opportunity to: (a) call or give evidence; (b) examine, cross-examine and re-examine witnesses; and (c) make submissions to the Tribunal.”[13] The applicant does not submit that the Appeal Tribunal adopted an erroneous principle or misconstrued the relevant provisions.[13]QCAT Act, s 95(1). The applicant’s essential complaint to this Court is that the Appeal Tribunal did not accept her argument that she was denied natural justice because she was denied the right to question Mr Joseph before he was cross-examined. However, the Appeal Tribunal’s conclusion that the applicant was not denied natural justice was a conclusion that was open to it on the basis of its analysis of the transcript of the hearing before the Tribunal Member. The applicant has failed to establish that the Appeal Tribunal erred in law.Does the application otherwise raise a question of law which warrants the grant of leave to appeal? The application does not raise any substantial issue about the proper interpretation of the relevant provisions of the Act.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In oral submissions to this Court the applicant said that she wanted to ask Mr Joseph about a photograph she kept on her desk, and that she overlooked asking him about that matter. She explained to this Court that she had not spoken to Mr Joseph very much before the final hearing and, in retrospect, should have asked him to provide another statutory declaration in addition to the one which was prepared in 2013. However, before this Court she still could not say what Mr Joseph would have said in any such statutory declaration about the photograph or about anything else.Conclusion on natural justice argument I am not persuaded that there is a reasonable argument that there is an error of law to be corrected in respect of the Appeal Tribunal’s consideration of the natural justice ground. In addition, the applicant has not shown that an appeal is necessary to correct a substantial injustice. The applicant before the Appeal Tribunal did not demonstrate what, if anything, Mr Joseph might have said had the hearing taken a different course. The applicant did not identify to the Appeal Tribunal what further questions she would have asked after the conclusion of Mr Joseph’s cross-examination which she did not ask. The Appeal Tribunal was correct to conclude that the applicant did not demonstrate to it that she lost an opportunity to lead evidence which would have been relevant to her case before the Tribunal.Other matters The application for leave to appeal and the applicant’s submissions raise matters about the conduct of Crown Law in defending the respondents, and about QCAT in dealing with the proceeding, including:(a)applications by the respondents to strike out the proceeding;(b)delays in the matter coming on for a final hearing;(c)things allegedly said by one of the respondents at the conciliation conference in the Anti-Discrimination Commission of Queensland in March 2013;(d)the conduct of the mediation by QCAT; and(e)the decision of a Senior Member of QCAT at a directions hearing in 2015 about the witnesses to whom notices to appear would issue (the applicant wished to examine, among others, the former Minister for Education).The applicant asks this Court to “‘unpack’ and examine this complex case and examine the conduct of the parties due to its precedent value and in the interests of upholding principals (sic) of ‘natural justice’”. It is not the function of this Court in an application for leave to appeal from a decision of the Appeal Tribunal to exercise some general supervisory jurisdiction over QCAT. The application for leave to appeal to this Court is not the occasion to examine things said at conciliation conferences and mediations, or to characterise the case, as the applicant does, as something akin to a “David and Goliath battle” that has consumed almost five years of her life and cost a great amount of taxpayers’ money. After a substantial delay this matter proceeded to a hearing on the merits. It is noteworthy that the applicant says that she re-read the transcript of the hearing several times before she detected the alleged procedural irregularity in not being given the opportunity to ask Mr Joseph additional questions “in chief”. This level of scrutiny by the applicant in a search for procedural error suggests that the Tribunal Member acted fairly towards the applicant in the conduct of the hearing and provided the applicant with appropriate assistance as a self-represented litigant.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.