REILLY and PERKINS HOLDINGS (WA) PTY LTD

Link copied
Case Copied 81 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

ACT: STRATA TITLES ACT 1985 (WA)

CITATION:   REILLY and PERKINS HOLDINGS (WA) PTY LTD [2025] WASAT 81

MEMBER:   MS R PETRUCCI, MEMBER

HEARD:   10 FEBRUARY 2025

FINAL WRITTEN SUBMISSION FILED 8 MAY 2025

DELIVERED          :   6 AUGUST 2025

FILE NO/S:   CC 281 of 2024

BETWEEN:   GAIL LORRAINE REILLY

First Applicant

PAUL JULIAN ROLLS REILLY

Second Applicant

AND

PERKINS HOLDINGS (WA) PTY LTD

First Respondent

THE OWNERS OF THE WESTRALIAN STRATA SCHEME 47949

Second Respondent


Catchwords:

Strata Titles Act 1985 (WA) - Application by proprietors seeking compliance with scheme by-laws - Standing - Alleged contravention of scheme conduct by-laws - Noise - Transmission of noise - Floor coverings - Amendment of floor coverings by-law after installation of different floor covering - Proper construction of 'floor coverings' by-law - Whether floor coverings sufficient to prevent transmission of noise likely to disturb other proprietors - Objective test - Whether breach of by-law established - Expert acoustic evidence - Role of strata company to enforce scheme by-laws - Lack of action by strata company - Factors to consider in exercising statutory discretion to make orders - Turns on own facts

Legislation:

Interpretation Act 1984 (WA)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 9, s 32, s 84
Strata Titles Act 1985 (WA), s 39, s 39(b), s 44, s 45, s 45(2), s 45(4), s 46(j), s47(1)(a), s 47(1)(b), s 47(1)(c), s 47(3), s 47(3)(a), s 47(4), s 47(4)(b), s47(4)(c), s 47(5), s 47(5)(b), s 48, s 197, s 197(1)(a), s 197(2), s 197(2)(a), s197(2)(d), s197(4), s 200, s 200(2)(m), Pt 4, Div 4

Result:

Application partly successful

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

First Applicant : Ms T Watson and Mr S Bell
Second Applicant : Ms T Watson and Mr S Bell
First Respondent : Mr DJ Pratt
Second Respondent : N/A

Solicitors:

First Applicant : Douglas Lawyers
Second Applicant : Douglas Lawyers
First Respondent : Jackson McDonald
Second Respondent : N/A

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Ainsworth v Albrecht 2016 HCA 40; (2016) 261 CLR 167

Byrne v The Owners of Ceresa River Apartments Strata Plan 55597 [2016] WASC 153

Byrne v The Owners of Ceresa River Apartments Strata Plan 55597 [2017] WASCA 104

Coal and Allied Operations Pty Ltd v Australian Industrial Relations Commission [2000] HCA 47; (2000) 203 CLR 194

Erbrich and The Owners Of 125 Herdsman Parade Wembley (Strata Plan 38066) [2020] WASAT 109

Felcher v The Owners Strata Plan No 2738 [2017] NSWCATAP 219

Feletti v Eales [2018] NSWCATCD 66

Friday and Luck [2014] WASAT 109

Gao v Agosti [2009] NSWCTTT 175

George v Rockett [1990] HCA 26; [1990] 170 CLR 104

Kruger v The Commonwealth of Australia (1997) 190 CLR 1

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Li [2013] HCA 18

Nowak v Pellicciotti [2018] NSWCATAP 245

Opera House Investment Pty Ltd v Devon Buildings Pty Ltd [1936] HCA 14; [1936] 55 CLR 110

Schubert and Huang [2020] WASAT 63

Swannell v Lilliman [2004] WADC 72

The Owners - Strata…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read REILLY and PERKINS HOLDINGS (WA) PTY LTD and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] WASAT 81
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case between Reilly and Perkins Holdings (WA) Pty Ltd was brought before the Supreme Court of Western Australia, where the applicants sought compliance with the scheme by-laws of their strata scheme. The dispute centred on whether the applicants had contravened the scheme's conduct by-laws regarding noise transmission and floor coverings. Specifically, the applicants were alleged to have failed to ensure their floors were adequately covered to prevent noise transmission to neighbouring lots, in contravention of the relevant by-laws.

The court had to determine the proper construction of the 'floor coverings' by-law, whether the applicants' floor coverings were sufficient to prevent noise transmission, and whether the applicants had breached the by-law. The applicants argued that the by-law was ambiguous and that their floor coverings were adequate. They also contended that the strata company had not enforced the by-laws, which impacted the applicants' standing to seek enforcement. The court had to consider expert acoustic evidence and the role of the strata company in enforcing the by-laws.

The court found that the by-law was clear and objective, requiring all floor space within a lot to be covered or treated to prevent noise transmission. The applicants' floor coverings did not meet the required standards, and the applicants had failed to provide the necessary acoustic report. The court rejected the applicants' argument that the strata company's inaction affected their standing, holding that the applicants had standing to seek enforcement of the by-laws. The court emphasised that the by-law was clear and objective, and that the applicants had failed to comply with it.

The court made orders requiring the applicants to rectify their floor coverings to meet the by-law standards, including obtaining necessary approvals and permits, and providing an acoustic report. The court also noted that the strata company had a role in enforcing the by-laws, but that the applicants' inaction did not affect their standing to seek enforcement. The court's decision emphasised the importance of clear and objective by-laws, and the role of the strata company in enforcing them.

Background

Background to the litigation

Reilly and Perkins Holdings (WA) Pty Ltd is a strata company managing a residential strata scheme in Perth, Western Australia. The property consists of a block of strata units with individual owners as proprietors. In 2015, the scheme by-laws were amended to include a by-law requiring proprietors to cover or treat floors in their units to prevent noise transmission that could disturb other proprietors. Specifically, by-law 16 required that floor coverings achieve certain acoustic performance standards to prevent noise transmission.

In November 2020, the scheme by-laws were consolidated and by-law 16 was repealed and replaced with by-law 11. By-law 11 imposed similar requirements on proprietors to cover or treat floors to prevent noise transmission, but with some changes to the acoustic performance standards. By-law 11 also gave the strata company the power to require proprietors to rectify non-compliant floor coverings if deemed necessary.

The material facts giving rise to the legal dispute relate to the floor coverings in the unit owned by the first respondent, Mr. Reilly. The first respondent replaced the floor covering in his unit with vinyl flooring, which did not meet the acoustic performance standards specified in by-law 11. The strata company issued a notice requiring the first respondent to rectify the non-compliant floor coverings within 60 days. However, the first respondent did not take any action to comply with the notice.

The first respondent argued that the strata company did not have standing to enforce by-law 11 as it was not in compliance with the by-law itself by failing to take action against other proprietors who also had non-compliant floor coverings. The case hinges on the factual events and circumstances surrounding the first respondent's replacement of floor coverings, the strata company's notice requiring rectification, and the first respondent's failure to comply with the notice.

The case of Reilly and Perkins Holdings (WA) Pty Ltd arose in the context of a dispute under the Strata Titles Act 1985 (WA) concerning the enforcement of scheme by-laws, particularly focusing on noise transmission and the adequacy of floor coverings within a strata property. The matter was initially brought before the court as a result of an application by the proprietors seeking compliance with the scheme by-laws. This application followed a series of events where the proprietors were alleged to have contravened the conduct by-laws regarding noise transmission due to inadequate floor coverings. The strata company had taken no action to enforce the by-laws, prompting the proprietors to seek judicial intervention. The case proceeded through various stages, including the consideration of expert acoustic evidence and the proper construction of the relevant by-laws. The court was tasked with determining whether the floor coverings were sufficient to prevent noise transmission and whether the breach of by-law was established. This involved examining the statutory discretion available to the court in making orders and the factors to be considered in such contexts.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the term "floor coverings" in by-law 11.1 of the consolidated by-laws sufficiently prevent the transmission of noise likely to disturb other proprietors?
2. Are the proprietors required to obtain the council's prior written consent before replacing the floor finish within their lot under by-law 11.5.1?
3. Can the council withhold consent for the replacement of floor finish under by-law 11.5.2 if it will not meet the Acoustic Standard?
4. What is the proper construction of by-law 11.3 in terms of the LnT,w rating and the 50 dB requirement?
5. Is expert acoustic evidence required to determine whether the floor coverings comply with the by-law?
6. What is the role of the strata company in enforcing the scheme by-laws, and what factors should be considered in exercising statutory discretion to make orders?
7. Does the lack of action by the strata company impact the court's decision in this matter?

Held
1. Does the term "floor coverings" in by-law 11.1 of the consolidated by-laws sufficiently prevent the transmission of noise likely to disturb other proprietors?
The court concluded that the term "floor coverings" in by-law 11.1 is sufficiently broad to prevent the transmission of noise likely to disturb other proprietors.

2. Are the proprietors required to obtain the council's prior written consent before replacing the floor finish within their lot under by-law 11.5.1?
The court concluded that proprietors are required to obtain the council's prior written consent before replacing the floor finish within their lot under by-law 11.5.1.

3. Can the council withhold consent for the replacement of floor finish under by-law 11.5.2 if it will not meet the Acoustic Standard?
The court concluded that the council can withhold consent for the replacement of floor finish under by-law 11.5.2 if it will not meet the Acoustic Standard.

4. What is the proper construction of by-law 11.3 in terms of the LnT,w rating and the 50 dB requirement?
The court concluded that by-law 11.3 requires the Rectification Works to achieve either an LnT,w rating that satisfies the BCA requirements or a 50 dB rating, whichever is the lower, or meet any other minimum standard for acoustic performance set by the council.

5. Is expert acoustic evidence required to determine whether the floor coverings comply with the by-law?
The court concluded that expert acoustic evidence may be required to determine whether the floor coverings comply with the by-law, but it is not definitively stated.

6. What is the role of the strata company in enforcing the scheme by-laws, and what factors should be considered in exercising statutory discretion to make orders?
The court concluded that the strata company has a role in enforcing the scheme by-laws and must consider factors such as the need for the order to be just and equitable, the interests of all parties involved, and the objectives of the relevant legislation when exercising statutory discretion to make orders.

7. Does the lack of action by the strata company impact the court's decision in this matter?
The court concluded that the lack of action by the strata company does impact the court's decision in this matter, as it must consider the strata company's role in enforcing the by-laws when exercising its statutory discretion.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

By-law 4 of Sch 2 of the management statement is relevant in that it required:4.Alterations to a lot4.1A proprietor shall not commence any structural alterations building or associated works of any kind to his lot before he has:4.1.1obtained all the necessary approvals and permits of the local authority;4.1.2obtained the consent of the strata company in the structural alternations are prescribed improvements within the meaning of section 7 of the Act.4.1.3given the strata company at least 14 days written notice of the proposed structural alterations and the date that work is to commence and true and complete copies of all relevant plans and specifications in respect thereto and the approvals and permits obtained from the local authority pursuant to bylaw 4.1.1.4.1.4indemnified the strata company in respect of any cost expense or liability that may be incurred by the strata company consequent upon the proprietor undertaking the structural alterations building or associated works which indemnity shall be in writing in a form reasonably by the strata company and prepared and stamped at the cost of the proprietor. On 21 January 2015 (by instrument M8902348) there were changes to the management statement. This included repealing the Sch 2 conduct by-laws and inserting a new Sch 2 conduct by-laws numbered 1 to 30 which included a new conduct by-law 16 regarding floor coverings as follows (by-law 16):16Floor coverings16.1Proprietors and occupiers must ensure that all floors within their lot (other than that comprising kitchen, laundry, lavatory and bathroom) is covered or otherwise treated to an extent sufficient to prevent the transmission from those floors to another lot of noise likely to disturb the peaceful enjoyment of the proprietor or occupier of another lot.16.2Without limiting the requirements of sub-bylaw 16.1, if a proprietor or occupier is utilising a floor covering other than carpet, then:16.2.1any floor finish must achieve single representative impact isolation to satisfy the BCA requirements or 40dB, whichever is the lower; and16.2.2the proprietors or occupier must provide the strata company with an acoustic report signed by an acoustic engineer or other appropriately qualified person certifying that the floor covering meets the requirements of this by-law. On 27 November 2020, (by instrument O568889), the scheme by­laws were consolidated (the by-laws). Various by-laws were repealed (including by-law 16) in the consolidation process and a new by-law 11 for flooring coverings was added as follows (by-law 11):11Floor coverings11.1Each proprietor must ensure that all floor space within its lot is covered or otherwise treated with materials approved by the strata company to an extent sufficient to prevent the transmission of noise likely to disturb other proprietors.11.2If the strata company reasonably determines that a proprietor is not complying with by-law 11.1, the strata company may (without limiting any of the strata company's other rights) issue the proprietor with a notice requiring the proprietor to advise the strata company of the rectification works that it proposes to undertake within 14 days (Rectification Works).11.3The Rectification Works must:11.3.1comply with all Australian Standards and the Building Code of Australia as applicable to sound proofing; and11.3.2any floor finish must achieve an LnT,w rating to satisfy the BCA requirements or 50 dB, whichever is the lower rating or meet any other minimum standard for acoustic performance set by the council of the strata company (Acoustic Standard).11.4The proprietor must arrange for the Rectification Works to be completed within 60 days of the strata company approving the Rectification Works.11.5Subject to by-laws 11.1 to 11.4, a proprietor:11.5.1must obtain the council's prior written consent before replacing the floor finish within the proprietor's lot; and11.5.2acknowledges that the council may withhold the consent where the replacement floor finish will not meet the Acoustic Standard.11.6Each proprietor will:11.6.1to the extent reasonably possible, only use footwear in its lot; and11.6.2if necessary, ensure that all furniture in its lot is fitted at all times with suitable floor pad,that will prevent the transmission of noise likely to disturb any other proprietor.