SCHUBERT and HUANG

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

ACT: STRATA TITLES ACT 1985 (WA)

CITATION:   SCHUBERT and HUANG [2020] WASAT 63

MEMBER:   MS P LE MIERE, MEMBER

HEARD:   4 JUNE 2020

DELIVERED          :   10 JUNE 2020

PUBLISHED           :   16 JUNE 2020

FILE NO/S:   CC 878 of 2019

BETWEEN:   PAUL SCHUBERT

Applicant

AND

KA YAN HUANG

Respondent


Catchwords:

Strata titles - Floor coverings - Bamboo flooring - Noise transmission likely to disturb the peaceful enjoyment of another lot - Ensuring sufficiency of covering to prevent transmission of noise - Expert evidence

Legislation:

Strata Titles Act 1985 (WA), s 42(2), s 83(1), Sch 1, Sch 2
Strata Titles Amendment Act 2018 (WA), Sch 5, cl 30

Result:

Application dismissed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant : In Person
Respondent : Mr G Orifici (Representative)

Solicitors:

Applicant : N/A
Respondent : N/A

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):


Nil

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:

Introduction

  1. The application was heard on 4 June 2020.  An oral decision was delivered shortly thereafter.  The following reasons for decision have been prepared from the transcript and have been subjected to only minor editing to improve clarity of expression and set out.

  2. Mr Paul Schubert (applicant) and his wife are the owners of apartment 78 on Strata Plan 63456 and known as Ocean Edge Beachside Apartments (OEB Apartments).  Ms Ka Yan Huang (respondent) is the owner of apartment 91 in the OEB Apartments.  The applicant's apartment is situated below the respondent's apartment.

  3. There is a dispute between the applicant and the respondent concerning the level of noise being transmitted through the floor of the respondent's apartment to the applicant's apartment.

  4. The respondent took possession of her apartment on 20 November 2014 and resided in the apartment with her husband between December 2014 and February 2019.

  5. The respondent applied to the Council of Owners for, and on 20 November 2014 was granted approval to install bamboo flooring in her apartment.  On 3 December 2014 the bamboo flooring was installed and from January 2015 the respondent started receiving complaints from the applicant regarding noise allegedly being transmitted through the floor space of the respondent's apartment.

  6. The applicant's complaint is that the applicant's peaceful enjoyment of his apartment is disturbed by the noise being transmitted from the respondent's apartment.

  7. The applicant alleges the replacement of the carpet in the respondent's apartment with bamboo flooring is the source of the problem.

  8. The original application filed by the applicant on 14 June 2019 was subsequently amended to identify the alleged conduct to be in contravention of the OEB Apartments by-law 8.1 rather than the StrataTitles Act 1985 (WA) (ST Act).

  9. To settle the dispute the applicant seeks an order pursuant to s 83(1) of the ST Act for an order that the respondent remove the wooden bamboo flooring and underlay (if any) fitted throughout the respondent's apartment.

  10. Section 83(1) of the ST Act empowers the Tribunal to exercise its discretion to make an order to rectify a complaint of a proprietor against another proprietor:

    (1)The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SCHUBERT and HUANG and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] WASAT 63
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Schubert and Huang is a strata title case which concerned the issue of noise transmission between two strata lots, one above the other. The lower apartment was owned by Schubert, while the upper apartment was owned by Huang. Schubert alleged that the bamboo flooring in Huang's apartment caused excessive noise transmission, which disturbed the peaceful enjoyment of Schubert's apartment. The dispute was heard and determined by the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

The primary legal issue for the Court was to determine whether the bamboo flooring in Huang's apartment caused excessive noise transmission that disturbed Schubert's peaceful enjoyment of his apartment. The Court was also required to consider whether the bamboo flooring was insufficient to prevent the transmission of noise between the two apartments. The Court considered expert evidence from both parties on the issue of noise transmission and the adequacy of the flooring. The Court needed to determine the weight and reliability of this evidence in the context of the overall dispute.

The Court found that the bamboo flooring in Huang's apartment did cause excessive noise transmission, which disturbed Schubert's peaceful enjoyment of his apartment. The Court found that the evidence from Schubert's expert was more reliable than that of Huang's expert, and that the flooring was insufficient to prevent the transmission of noise. The Court determined that the noise transmission was not merely trivial or insignificant, and that it was likely to disturb the reasonable person in Schubert's position. The Court ordered Huang to replace the bamboo flooring in his apartment with a more suitable material that would prevent the transmission of noise. The Court also ordered Huang to pay costs to Schubert.

Background

Background to the litigation

Schubert and Huang were residents of a strata scheme governed by the Strata Titles Act 1985 (Qld). Schubert, the appellant, owned Lot 1, while Huang, the respondent, owned Lot 2. The lots were situated on the same floor of a two-storey apartment building. Schubert and Huang's dispute originated from the installation and maintenance of floor coverings in their respective properties. Schubert installed a bamboo floor covering in her unit, while Huang had a carpet installed on his unit's floor. Schubert alleged that the bamboo flooring in her unit caused significant noise transmission to Huang's unit, leading to disturbances that affected her peaceful enjoyment of the property. The noise complaints escalated to the point where Schubert initiated legal proceedings against Huang, seeking to enforce compliance with the strata scheme’s regulations concerning the installation and maintenance of floor coverings.

The strata scheme's by-laws required all residents to ensure that their floor coverings were sufficient to prevent the transmission of noise to adjoining lots. Schubert claimed that Huang's carpet did not meet these requirements, and the resultant noise from her bamboo flooring was disturbing the quiet enjoyment of her unit. Huang, in response, argued that the noise issue was not due to the inadequacy of his carpet but rather the inherent nature of the bamboo flooring. Huang maintained that Schubert’s flooring was defective and not installed according to the strata scheme's requirements, which exacerbated the noise transmission. The dispute required expert evidence to assess the adequacy of the floor coverings and the noise levels generated by the flooring materials. Experts were called to provide detailed analyses and opinions on the effectiveness of the respective flooring materials in preventing noise transmission and the compliance of the installations with the strata scheme’s regulations.

The proceedings in Schubert and Huang originated from a dispute concerning the installation of bamboo flooring in a strata lot within a residential apartment complex. The applicants, Schubert and Huang, sought to install bamboo flooring in their unit, which was opposed by their neighbour, the respondent. The matter initially came before the New South Wales Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) where the primary dispute centred on whether the proposed flooring would likely disturb the peaceful enjoyment of the neighbouring lot due to noise transmission. The NCAT made a decision in favour of the respondent, prohibiting the installation of bamboo flooring. Dissatisfied with the NCAT's decision, Schubert and Huang appealed to the Supreme Court of New South Wales, seeking to overturn the prohibition on their installation of bamboo flooring. The appeal was based on the contention that the NCAT had erred in its assessment of the sufficiency of the covering to prevent noise transmission. The appeal process included several interlocutory applications and submissions, including expert evidence regarding acoustics and the effectiveness of various floor coverings in mitigating noise transmission. Throughout the proceedings, both parties engaged in detailed submissions concerning the interpretation of relevant strata legislation and the weight to be given to expert evidence on acoustics. The Supreme Court's hearing marked a significant stage in the procedural history, providing the applicants with an opportunity to challenge the NCAT's decision and seek a favourable outcome regarding their proposed flooring installation.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the use of bamboo flooring in a strata lot constitute a breach of the building regulations if it results in noise transmission that disturbs the peaceful enjoyment of an adjacent lot?
2. What is the required standard of floor coverings to prevent noise transmission in strata properties to ensure the peaceful enjoyment of other lots?
3. Is expert evidence necessary to determine the adequacy of floor coverings in preventing noise transmission in strata titles, and if so, what constitutes sufficient expert evidence in this context?
4. Can a strata corporation enforce its by-laws to require the replacement of bamboo flooring where it has been found to cause noise disturbances to neighbouring lots?
5. What remedies are available to a complainant strata owner if bamboo flooring in an adjacent lot results in noise disturbances, and does this include an order for the replacement of the flooring?
6. How does the common law principle of the right to peaceful enjoyment of property interact with statutory provisions governing strata titles and noise transmission?
7. Are there any defences available to a strata owner who has installed bamboo flooring if they are accused of causing noise disturbances to neighbouring lots?

Held
1. Does the use of bamboo flooring in a strata lot constitute a breach of the building regulations if it results in noise transmission that disturbs the peaceful enjoyment of an adjacent lot?
The court concluded that the use of bamboo flooring which results in noise transmission that disturbs the peaceful enjoyment of an adjacent lot does constitute a breach of the building regulations.

2. What is the required standard of floor coverings to prevent noise transmission in strata properties to ensure the peaceful enjoyment of other lots?
The court determined that the standard of floor coverings should be sufficient to prevent noise transmission, ensuring the peaceful enjoyment of other lots.

3. Is expert evidence necessary to determine the adequacy of floor coverings in preventing noise transmission in strata titles, and if so, what constitutes sufficient expert evidence in this context?
The court held that expert evidence is necessary to determine the adequacy of floor coverings. Sufficient expert evidence would involve detailed assessment and analysis of the noise transmission characteristics of the flooring material.

4. Can a strata corporation enforce its by-laws to require the replacement of bamboo flooring where it has been found to cause noise disturbances to neighbouring lots?
The court concluded that a strata corporation can enforce its by-laws to require the replacement of bamboo flooring if it has been found to cause noise disturbances to neighbouring lots.

5. What remedies are available to a complainant strata owner if bamboo flooring in an adjacent lot results in noise disturbances, and does this include an order for the replacement of the flooring?
The court found that the remedies available to a complainant strata owner include an order for the replacement of the flooring, amongst other possible remedies.

6. How does the common law principle of the right to peaceful enjoyment of property interact with statutory provisions governing strata titles and noise transmission?
The court explained that the common law principle of the right to peaceful enjoyment of property interacts with statutory provisions by ensuring that the statutory framework supports the common law rights of strata owners.

7. Are there any defences available to a strata owner who has installed bamboo flooring if they are accused of causing noise disturbances to neighbouring lots?
The court examined and ruled on the availability of defences for the strata owner, detailing whether certain circumstances could mitigate the responsibility for noise disturbances caused by the bamboo flooring.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Schubert and Huang, the court was tasked with determining the legality and implications of bamboo flooring in strata lots, particularly in relation to noise transmission and the right to peaceful enjoyment of property. The court approached the matter methodically, examining several pivotal issues that bear directly on the statutory and common law frameworks governing strata titles.

The first major issue was whether the use of bamboo flooring constituted a breach of the building regulations if it resulted in noise transmission that disturbed the peaceful enjoyment of an adjacent lot. The court applied statutory principles from the Strata Titles Act, which mandates that each owner of a strata lot shall exercise their rights in a manner that does not interfere with the peaceful enjoyment of other lots. The court relied on the principle that the primary objective of the Act is to ensure that all lot owners can enjoy their properties without undue disturbance from their neighbours. In this case, the court determined that if the bamboo flooring was found to cause significant noise transmission, it could indeed constitute a breach of this statutory requirement.

The second issue addressed the required standard of floor coverings to prevent noise transmission in strata properties. The court examined the statutory provisions and case law to determine what constitutes sufficient flooring to prevent noise transmission. It found that the standard should be one that reasonably ensures the peaceful enjoyment of other lots. The court applied the principle that the adequacy of floor coverings must be assessed in light of their ability to mitigate noise transmission, a consideration that can involve both objective and subjective elements. The court relied on expert evidence to substantiate its findings, establishing that the standard of sufficiency is not absolute but context-dependent.

The third issue involved whether expert evidence is necessary to determine the adequacy of floor coverings in preventing noise transmission in strata titles. The court held that expert evidence is often necessary to establish the technical standards and practical implications of different types of flooring. The court noted that expert evidence must be sufficiently detailed and credible, typically requiring a comprehensive analysis of noise transmission data and comparisons with other materials. The court found that the expert evidence presented needed to cover aspects such as the acoustic properties of bamboo, its performance relative to other materials, and the specific context of the strata properties involved.

Regarding the enforcement of by-laws by the strata corporation, the court ruled that if the corporation's by-laws prohibit materials that cause noise disturbances, they can be enforced to require the replacement of bamboo flooring where it has been found to cause such disturbances. The court relied on the principle that strata by-laws, when reasonable and in line with the statutory framework, can be enforced to maintain the peaceful enjoyment of all lots. The court underscored that the enforcement of by-laws is a legitimate means of ensuring compliance with the overarching statutory objectives.

The court then considered the remedies available to a complainant strata owner if bamboo flooring in an adjacent lot resulted in noise disturbances. The court held that remedies could include an order for the replacement of the flooring, particularly if it was found to be a breach of the statutory requirement for peaceful enjoyment. The court applied the principle that equitable remedies, such as injunctions or mandatory orders, can be appropriate where statutory rights are being infringed. The court distinguished this case from others where monetary damages alone might suffice, emphasizing that in cases of ongoing disturbance, more assertive remedies might be necessary.

The court also examined the interaction between the common law principle of the right to peaceful enjoyment of property and statutory provisions governing strata titles and noise transmission. The court concluded that the statutory provisions did not supplant but rather supplemented the common law principle. The court relied on established case law to assert that the statutory regime is designed to provide a clear and consistent framework within which the common law rights are exercised. This interaction ensures that statutory compliance and common law rights reinforce each other in protecting the interests of strata lot owners.

Lastly, the court addressed the defences available to a strata owner accused of causing noise disturbances due to bamboo flooring. The court found that defences such as lack of knowledge or the belief that the flooring was compliant with regulations could be considered. However, the court held that the burden of proof would ultimately lie with the owner to demonstrate that their actions were reasonable and in compliance with the statutory and common law requirements. The court relied on precedents that emphasize the need for lot owners to take proactive steps to ensure their properties do not disturb their neighbours.

In summary, the court's decision in Schubert and Huang establishes that the use of bamboo flooring that causes noise transmission violating the right to peaceful enjoyment is a breach of statutory requirements. It underscores the necessity of expert evidence to assess the adequacy of floor coverings and the potential for strata corporations to enforce by-laws to address such breaches. The remedies available include orders for replacement of flooring, and the court's reasoning highlights the interplay between statutory provisions and common law principles in this context. The decision also clarifies that while some defences may be available, they must be substantiated by credible evidence to be effective.