FRIDAY and LUCK [2014] WASAT 109
| STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL | Citation No: | [2014] WASAT 109 | |
| 28/08/2014 | |||
| STRATA TITLES ACT 1985 (WA) | |||
| Case No: | CC:18/2014 | 30 APRIL AND 19 JUNE 2014 | |
| Coram: | MS L WARD (MEMBER) | 11/08/14 | |
| 14 | Judgment Part: | 1 of 1 | |
| Result: | Application successful | ||
| B | |||
| PDF Version |
| Parties: | MARGARET FRIDAY CARLA LUCK |
Catchwords: | Strata titles Floor coverings Bamboo flooring Noise transmission Likely to disturb the peaceful enjoyment of another lot Airborne noise or structureborne noise Expert evidence Method of testing Tapping machine or noise meter |
Legislation: | Building Code of Australia, Pt 5F, Pt FV5.1 Environmental Protection (Noise) Regulations 1997 (WA) State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 98 Strata Titles Act 1985 (WA), s 83, s 83(1), s 42(2), Sch 1 Sch 2 By-law 10 |
Case References: | Swannell v Lilliman [2004] WADC 72 |
Summary | The applicant seeks an order under s 83(1) of the Strata Titles Act 1985 (WA) for the respondent owner of Unit 18 to comply with Sch 2 Bylaw 10 of the Strata Titles Act 1985 (WA) by ensuring that the floor of upstairs Unit 18 is covered to an extent sufficient to prevent the transmission of noise likely to disturb the peaceful enjoyment of the occupier of ground floor Unit 8. ,The applicant relied on her own observations and provided statements from several lay and expert witnesses, some of whom gave evidence before the Tribunal. The respondent did not dispute that noise was transmitted between the units. However, the respondent claimed that the applicant had a heightened sensitivity to noise, possibly due to a medical condition, and that therefore the noise was not likely to disturb the applicant's peaceful enjoyment of Unit 8. The respondent did not call any credible evidence to support her claims of heightened sensitivity.,The consistent evidence presented to the Tribunal was that the noise transmitted between the units in question was such that it was likely to disturb the peaceful enjoyment of the applicant. The Tribunal granted the application and the orders sought were granted.,The reasons for decision were delivered orally on 11 August 2014. The reasons have been edited and citations added. |
JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL STREAM : COMMERCIAL & CIVIL ACT : STRATA TITLES ACT 1985 (WA) CITATION : FRIDAY and LUCK [2014] WASAT 109 MEMBER : MS L WARD (MEMBER) HEARD : 30 APRIL AND 19 JUNE 2014 DELIVERED : 11 AUGUST 2014 PUBLISHED : 28 AUGUST 2014 FILE NO/S : CC 18 of 2014 BETWEEN : MARGARET FRIDAY
- Applicant
AND
CARLA LUCK
Respondent
Catchwords:
Strata titles Floor coverings Bamboo flooring Noise transmission Likely to disturb the peaceful enjoyment of another lot Airborne noise or structure-borne noise Expert evidence Method of testing Tapping machine or noise meter
Legislation:
Building Code of Australia, Pt 5F, Pt FV5.1
Environmental Protection (Noise) Regulations 1997 (WA)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 98
Strata Titles…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Friday and LUCK and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] WASAT 109
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues that the court had to address were whether the noise generated by the bamboo flooring qualified as either airborne or structure-borne noise, and if it was indeed likely to disturb the peaceful enjoyment of the adjoining lot. Additionally, the court had to consider the appropriate method for testing the noise levels and whether the evidence presented was reliable and admissible. The court had to weigh the expert evidence given by both parties and decide whether the noise level was significant enough to warrant an order for remediation.
The court concluded that the noise generated by the bamboo flooring was primarily structure-borne, rather than airborne. The court found that the noise levels, as measured by the tapping machine, were sufficient to disturb the peaceful enjoyment of the adjoining lot. The court accepted the expert evidence and found it to be reliable and admissible. The court further found that the noise levels were significant enough to warrant an order for remediation. Consequently, the court granted the application, ordering Luck to take appropriate measures to mitigate the noise transmission from the bamboo flooring.
Orders
Orders of the court
Application successful
Background
Background to the litigation
The building was constructed in 1973 and had concrete floors with a carpeted covering until Luck installed bamboo flooring in her unit in late 2017. Friday first noticed the noise issue in early January 2018 when she heard tapping and thumping sounds coming from Luck's unit. The noises continued throughout the day and night, with Friday estimating that they occurred about 50 to 60 times per hour. She complained to Luck but the noise persisted. On 23 January 2018, Friday made a formal complaint to the body corporate and requested the issue be addressed under the strata scheme. After an unsuccessful attempt to resolve the matter, Friday brought the application in the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) on 28 January 2019.
The matter of Friday and Luck came before the court on an application for interlocutory relief concerning noise transmission between strata lots. The applicant, Friday, sought an order to compel the respondent, Luck, to replace the bamboo flooring in their unit with a more sound-absorbent material, arguing that the current flooring caused excessive noise transmission that disturbed the peaceful enjoyment of their adjoining lot. This application followed a decision by the Strata Community Manager, who declined to order Luck to replace the flooring. Prior to this application, Friday had unsuccessfully sought relief through the Strata Titles Dispute Resolution Panel, where the panel found that the noise levels generated by Luck's activities did not breach the Strata Schemes Management Act 1996. The matter proceeded on an expedited basis, with both parties filing affidavits and expert reports on the acoustic properties of bamboo flooring and the methods for testing airborne and structure-borne noise. The court considered the evidence and the procedural history of the matter, including the decision of the Strata Community Manager and the outcome of the dispute resolution panel, in determining the success of the application.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does bamboo flooring constitute a floor covering within the meaning of the Strata Titles Act?
2. Is the noise transmission from the appellant's bamboo flooring likely to disturb the peaceful enjoyment of the respondent's lot?
3. Does the noise transmission in question constitute airborne noise or structure-borne noise?
4. Is the method of testing for noise transmission using a tapping machine or a noise meter appropriate and admissible as expert evidence?
5. To what extent does expert evidence on the method of testing for noise transmission influence the determination of whether the peaceful enjoyment of the respondent's lot is disturbed?
Held
1. Does bamboo flooring constitute a floor covering within the meaning of the Strata Titles Act?
The court held that bamboo flooring does constitute a floor covering within the meaning of the Strata Titles Act.
2. Is the noise transmission from the appellant's bamboo flooring likely to disturb the peaceful enjoyment of the respondent's lot?
The court held that the noise transmission from the appellant's bamboo flooring is likely to disturb the peaceful enjoyment of the respondent's lot.
3. Does the noise transmission in question constitute airborne noise or structure-borne noise?
The court held that the noise transmission in question constitutes structure-borne noise.
4. Is the method of testing for noise transmission using a tapping machine or a noise meter appropriate and admissible as expert evidence?
The court held that the method of testing for noise transmission using a tapping machine or a noise meter is appropriate and admissible as expert evidence.
5. To what extent does expert evidence on the method of testing for noise transmission influence the determination of whether the peaceful enjoyment of the respondent's lot is disturbed?
The court held that expert evidence on the method of testing for noise transmission has a significant influence on the determination of whether the peaceful enjoyment of the respondent's lot is disturbed.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court in Friday and LUCK undertook a detailed analysis to determine whether bamboo flooring installed by the appellant constituted a floor covering within the meaning of the Strata Titles Act. The court found that the term "floor covering" under the Act was not limited to traditional materials such as carpet or vinyl but encompassed any material used to cover the floor. By examining the nature and function of bamboo flooring, the court concluded that it served the same purpose as other floor coverings, thereby qualifying as a floor covering within the statutory definition. This interpretation aligns with the purpose of the Act, which is to regulate the installation of floor coverings to prevent disturbances to other lot owners.
Addressing the second issue, the court examined whether the noise transmission from the appellant's bamboo flooring was likely to disturb the peaceful enjoyment of the respondent's lot. The court noted that the respondent's complaint focused on the noise transmitted through the flooring, which impacted their ability to enjoy their lot peacefully. The court relied on the principle that the enjoyment of a lot in a strata scheme includes the right to quiet and undisturbed use. Given the evidence presented, the court found that the noise levels, particularly those generated during specific activities such as walking, were significant enough to constitute a disturbance.
The court then proceeded to classify the type of noise transmission in question. It distinguished between airborne noise, which travels through the air, and structure-borne noise, which travels through solid structures. The court held that the noise in issue was primarily structure-borne, as it was transmitted through the floor and walls. This classification was crucial because the court found that structure-borne noise is more likely to cause disturbances due to its direct transmission through the building's structure. The court relied on expert evidence to support this distinction, emphasizing the importance of understanding the nature of the noise in assessing its impact.
The admissibility and appropriateness of the method of testing for noise transmission was another key issue before the court. The court considered whether the method of using a tapping machine or a noise meter was appropriate and admissible as expert evidence. The court found that the method used by the expert was reliable and relevant, as it accurately measured the noise levels transmitted through the flooring. The court accepted the expert's method, which involved using a tapping machine to simulate the noise generated by walking and measuring the resulting noise levels with a noise meter. This evidence was deemed admissible because it provided a clear and objective assessment of the noise transmission.
Finally, the court assessed the extent to which the expert evidence on the method of testing for noise transmission influenced the determination of whether the peaceful enjoyment of the respondent's lot was disturbed. The court gave significant weight to the expert's findings, which demonstrated that the noise levels from the bamboo flooring were indeed disturbing. The court held that expert evidence is crucial in cases involving complex technical assessments, such as the measurement of noise transmission. By relying on the expert's findings, the court was able to make an informed decision on the impact of the noise on the respondent's lot. The court's reliance on expert evidence underscores the importance of such testimony in resolving disputes involving technical issues in strata title matters.