Reihana v Beenleigh Show Society

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Reihana v Beenleigh Show Society [2019] QCATA 91

PARTIES:

TONI REIHANA
 (applicant)

v

BEENLEIGH SHOW SOCIETY
(respondent)

APPLICATION NO:

APL043-18

ORIGINATING APPLICATION NO/S:

MCDT749 -13 Brisbane

MATTER TYPE:

Appeals

DELIVERED ON:

14 June 2019

HEARING DATE:

6 June 2019

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Dr J R Forbes, Member

ORDERS:

The application for leave to appeal is dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL – LEAVE TO APPEAL – MINOR CIVIL DISPUTE – RESIDENTIAL TENANCY – where eviction order made – where party not in attendance at hearing – where adjournment refused – whether due process followed -– whether applicant took due care of his interests - where application to reopen made – where reopening application out of time – where extension of time for reopening application refused – where reopening application converted to application for leave to appeal – where time for seeking leave to appeal extended – where applicant appellant did not attend hearing of application for leave to appeal - where no satisfactory reason for absence established – where leave to appeal refused

Acts Interpretation Act 1954 (Qld) ss 39, 39A

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld) ss 61, 93, 138, 143

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Rules 2009 Reg 92
Residential Tenancies and Rooming Accommodation Act 2008 (Qld) ss 32, 61, 277, 291, 293
Aon  Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University (2009) 239 CLR 175
Beenleigh Show Society v Reihana 25 February 2013
Beenleigh Show Society v Reihana [2018] QCAT 97 at [58].

Brettingham-Moore v Municipality of St Leonards (1969) 121 CLR 509
Campbell v Flucker [2010] QCATA 70

Carroll v Sydney City Council (1989) 15 NSWLR 541

Cook v ASP Ship Management Pty Ltd (2008) 105 ALD 453
Herrington  v McHugh [2011] QCATA 288

Hunter Valley Developments v Cohen (1984) 3 FCR 344
John v Rees [1970] Ch 345
Lawless v The Queen (1979) 142 CLR 659
Pappas v Meikeljohn’s Accountants [2017] QCATA 60

Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Capitly (1999) 33 ALD 365
R v Brewer; Ex parte Renzella [1973] VR 375
R v Sharkey [2013] QCA 259
Reeve v Hamlyn [2015] QCATA 133
Reihana v QCAT Services Managers & Ors [2017] QCA 117
Sali v SPC Limited (1993) 67 ALJR 841

South Australia v O’Shea (1987) 163 CLR 378
Sydney City Council v Ke-Su Investments Pty Ltd (1985) 1 NSWLR 246
The Pot Man Pty Ltd v Reaoch [2011] QCATA 318
University of Ceylon v Fernando [1960] 1 WLR 223

Uren v Harcourts Broadbeach Waters [2018] QCATA 9

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

APPLICANT:     The applicant did not appear.

RESPONDENT:  Mr T Serafin of McCarthy Durie.

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. Of all Minor Civil Disputes in dire need of finality, this is one. Piles of paper, delays, obfuscation and tortuous procedural issues have been heaped upon on a claim of natural justice. Two applications to the Court of Appeal, and one to the High Court have been unsuccessful. According to the Respondent, the Beenleigh Show Society (`the Society’)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Reihana v Beenleigh Show Society and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QCATA 91
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Reihana was the tenant of a caravan on the property of the Beenleigh Show Society, which sought his eviction. The Society applied to the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) for an eviction order, which was granted. Reihana did not attend the hearing on 6 June 2019 when the Society's submissions were heard, and he did not establish a satisfactory reason for his absence. He had previously failed to attend the hearing on 25 February 2013, and he had absented himself from the country from 7 March to 18 May 2013, at a crucial time in the proceedings. He sought to reopen the primary decision on the basis of 'fresh' evidence, but his application was out of time, and an extension of time was refused. His reopening application was then converted to an application for leave to appeal, and the time for seeking leave to appeal was extended. However, Reihana did not attend the hearing of the application for leave to appeal, and he did not establish a satisfactory reason for his absence. The court held that Reihana had not taken due care of his interests and had not demonstrated that he had a reasonable excuse for his failure to attend the hearings.

The legal issues before the court were whether due process had been followed and whether Reihana had taken due care of his interests. The court held that Reihana had not taken due care of his interests and had not established a satisfactory reason for his failure to attend the hearings. The court noted that Reihana had been well aware of the proceedings since April 2013 and had been duly served with the Society's initial application. The court also noted that Reihana had been warned by the Society's solicitor that her client's time for filing an eviction case was strictly limited. The court held that Reihana's decision to absent himself from the country and go out of contact at a crucial time could only be described as a high-risk policy. The court held that Reihana's failure to attend the hearings was a significant factor in the decision not to grant leave to appeal.

The court held that Reihana had not established a satisfactory reason for his failure to attend the hearings, and it was not procedurally fair to the Society to grant an adjournment. The court noted that an order for costs would have been a doubtful remedy, given Reihana's non-compliance with orders of the Tribunal and his enjoyment of compassionate remission of tribunal fees on financial grounds. The application for leave to appeal was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

The application for leave to appeal is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute between Reihana and Beenleigh Show Society regarding a residential tenancy. The Beenleigh Show Society applied to the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) for an eviction order against Reihana. The Applicant, Reihana, was served with the initial application and attended an interim hearing in February 2013, where the Society's solicitor warned him about the strict time limits for filing an eviction case. In April 2013, Reihana was notified of the QCAT proceedings. In May 2013, the Applicant went abroad and was out of contact for an extended period. The Society applied for an eviction order, and the Adjudicator issued a warrant for eviction on 25 May 2013, despite Reihana's absence and lack of supporting evidence for his absence. The Adjudicator concluded that the application was urgent and declined to adjourn the hearing.

Reihana subsequently applied for an adjournment and later sought to reopen the case. However, these applications were denied as they were deemed out of time and without sufficient justification. The Applicant further sought an extension of time to file a reopening application, which was also refused. The reopening application was subsequently converted into an application for leave to appeal, with an extension of time granted for the Applicant to seek leave to appeal. However, the Applicant did not attend the hearing for the leave to appeal application, and the application was dismissed due to the lack of satisfactory reason for his absence.

The matter originated in the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) where the Beenleigh Show Society applied for an eviction order against Reihana. The case proceeded through various stages, including an interim hearing, issuance of a warrant for eviction, and applications for adjournment, reopening, and leave to appeal. The Applicant, Reihana, did not attend several key hearings, including the hearing for the application for leave to appeal. The Tribunal denied the adjournment and reopening applications as they were out of time and without sufficient justification. The conversion of the reopening application into an appeal leave application was granted an extension of time, but the appeal leave application was dismissed due to the Applicant's absence from the hearing without a satisfactory reason.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Applicant absented himself from the hearing on 6 June 2019, when the Respondent’s submissions were heard. If the Applicant had deigned to attend he may have been able to (a) identify the documents vaguely referred to in his adjournment application, mentioned; (b) demonstrate their relevance, if any to the natural justice issue, and (c) subject to satisfactory answers to (a) and (b), show that the documents, for whatever they may be worth, were not reasonably available earlier in the proceedings.[17] But he rejected the opportunity to do so.[17] On `fresh’, as distinct from `new’ evidence see Lawless v The Queen (1979) 142 CLR 659 at 674-676; Rv Sharkey [2013] QCA259 at [8].Should leave to appeal the primary decision be granted? The substantive appeal does not involve initiating process that is said to have gone astray. By April 2013 the Applicant was well aware that QCAT proceedings were in train. He admitted receipt of the notice to leave.[18] He was duly served with the Society’s initial application. He attended an interim hearing on 25 February 2013.[19] At that time the Society’s solicitor warned the Applicant that her client’s time for filing an eviction case was strictly limited.[20] In January 2018 the learned Member, who gave his complaints every consideration, observed:In the light of everything going on at the time, Mr Reihana’s decision to absent himself from the country [from 7 March to 18 May 2013] and go out of contact at such a crucial time ... can only be described as a high risk policy.[21][18] Email Applicant to Respondent’s solicitor 15 March 2013.[19] Beenleigh Show Society v Reihana [2018] QCAT 97 at [73].[20] Beenleigh Show Society v Reihana 25 February 2013 (Davern, Adjudicator) page 23.[21] Beenleigh Show Society v Reihana [2018] QCAT 97 at [27]. On the eve of the trial a third party informed the Tribunal that the Applicant was in New Zealand to visit a relative who was ill. This eleventh-hour communication sought an adjournment `until after 25 May’. It was not supported by medical or other independent evidence, then or later. The Society did not consent. The Adjudicator declined to adjourn, observing:[If an adjournment were granted] it appears that the application [would] be put off for at least a month and a half. It is an urgent application. I do not consider that to be procedurally fair to the applicant. If Mr Reihana sees fit to ... absent himself ... from the caravan site and remain uncontactable for [a] lengthy period of time that is his lookout. A balance must be struck here between the [Show Society] applicant and [Reihana]. There is a balance of fairness. I consider it entirely unfair that the [Show Society] ought to be put in a position of having to wait until after 25th May for Mr Reihana to return. In those circumstances I think it is procedurally fair for the warrant to issue. A mere assertion that an illness is involved need not be accepted at face value. Better evidence may be required.[22] An order for costs would have been a doubtful remedy. The Applicant is markedly non-compliant with orders of the Tribunal, and has enjoyed compassionate remission of tribunal fees on financial grounds[23], notwithstanding several visits to New Zealand during this protracted dispute.[22] Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Capitly (1999) 33 ALD 365 at 372; Cook v ASP ShipManagement Pty Ltd (2008) 105 ALD 453; [2008] FCA 1345.[23] Applicant to APN Manager 1 November 2013.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the matter of Reihana v Beenleigh Show Society, examining the issues of due process, the applicant's diligence, timeliness of reopening applications, appropriateness of time extensions, and the justification for absence from hearings. The court observed that the applicant had numerous opportunities to participate in the proceedings, including receiving notices, being served with initial applications, and attending an interim hearing. However, the applicant chose to absent himself from the country at crucial times and did not attend the hearing for the leave to appeal application. The court emphasized the importance of procedural fairness, requiring the applicant to demonstrate the relevance of any documents he claimed were not reasonably available earlier in the proceedings. The applicant's decision to leave the country during critical periods and his failure to attend the hearing for the leave to appeal application were considered high-risk policies and non-compliant behaviour. The court noted that the applicant had previously enjoyed compassionate remission of tribunal fees, despite his non-compliance and multiple visits to New Zealand during the dispute. The court ultimately dismissed the application for leave to appeal, finding that the applicant's absence from the hearing and lack of satisfactory explanation for that absence precluded a favourable outcome. The binding legal principle established by the decision is that an applicant must demonstrate due care in managing proceedings and provide satisfactory reasons for absences, particularly when seeking extensions or relief from tribunal decisions.