Recycling Developments Pty Ltd & Anor v Bespoke Recycling Industries Pty Ltd & Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION: Recycling Developments Pty Ltd & Anor v Bespoke Recycling Industries Pty Ltd & Anor [2024] QSC 42
PARTIES:

RECYCLING DEVELOPMENTS PTY LTD (ACN 132 325 314)

(first plaintiff)
TEB ENTERPRISES PTY LTD (ACN 142 685 372) ATF
PERROTT FAMILY TRUST (ABN 95 197 523 153)
(second plaintiff)
v

BESPOKE RECYCLING INDUSTRIES PTY LTD (ACN 634 377 030)

(first defendant)

ROCKY POINT HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ACN 645 224 755) ATF ROCKY POINT TRUST (ABN 96 370 426 600)

(second defendant)

FILENO/S:

BS 4963 of 2022

DIVISION: Trial Division
PROCEEDING: Application
ORIGINATING COURT: Supreme Court at Brisbane
DELIVEREDON: 22 March 2024
DELIVEREDAT: Brisbane
HEARINGDATE: 5 February 2024
JUDGE: Cooper J
ORDER:

1.   The application filed by the second plaintiff on 3 November 2023 is dismissed.

2.   On the application filed by the defendants on 13 November 2023 it is ordered that:

a.   paragraphs 26 to 33AA of the third amended statement of claim filed on 11 September 2023 are struck out;

b.   the plaintiffs have leave to replead those paragraphs, or to otherwise replead their cause of action for the declaration in paragraph 2 of the claim filed on 3 May 2022 as they may be advised;

c.   District Court proceedings number 2315 of 2022 be transferred to the Supreme Court of

Queensland and heard together with this proceeding.

CATCHWORDS:

REAL PROPERTY – TORRENS TITLE – CAVEATS

AGAINST DEALINGS – REMOVAL – where the second defendant claims an interest in the subject land based upon its claim for an order for specific performance of a call option deed – where the plaintiffs contend that the call option deed was validly terminated prior to the purported exercise of the option – where the second defendant lodged a caveat and was granted leave to lodge a further caveat on the subject land, claiming an interest arising under the call option deed – where the order granting leave to lodge a further caveat was an order of a substantive nature made after a contested hearing in contemplation that it would preserve the status quo until the final disposition of the proceeding – where the second plaintiff applies for removal of the caveat – where the second defendant contends that the claim for an order for specific performance must fail because damages are an adequate remedy and also by reason of the equitable defence of unclean hands – where plaintiffs entered into a put and call option agreement with a third party regarding the subject land, with the third party intending to terminate the put and call agreement if the caveat is not removed within a specified period – where the second plaintiff contends that there is a risk that the value of the subject land may decrease before the proceedings are finally resolved such that it will suffer irreparable prejudice if the caveat is not removed and the proposed sale of the land to the third party does not complete – whether retention of the caveat on the title to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Recycling Developments Pty Ltd & Anor v Bespoke Recycling In... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QSC 42
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Recycling Developments Pty Ltd & Anor v Bespoke Recycling Industries Pty Ltd & Anor involved a dispute over the removal of a caveat from the title of a property, and the validity of certain claims in the proceedings. The parties to the dispute were Recycling Developments, the first plaintiff, and Bespoke Recycling Industries, the second defendant. The second defendant had lodged a caveat against the dealing of the property, claiming an interest arising under a call option deed. The plaintiffs sought the removal of the caveat, arguing that the call option deed was terminated before the option was exercised. The second defendant countered that the claim for specific performance must fail due to the adequacy of damages and the equitable defence of unclean hands. Additionally, the defendants applied to strike out certain paragraphs of the third amended statement of claim, arguing that the plaintiffs did not plead material facts to support their claims.

The court was tasked with deciding whether the caveat should be removed, considering the potential for a material change in circumstances since the order permitting the caveat was made. The court also had to determine if the plaintiffs' claims regarding breaches of a management licence agreement were properly pleaded. The defendants argued that the plaintiffs' claims were not supported by facts and amounted to pleading conclusions on questions of mixed fact and law. Furthermore, the court needed to assess the merits of the equitable defences raised by the second defendant in relation to the call option deed.

The court dismissed the application for the removal of the caveat, finding that the retention of the caveat was justified despite the potential for a decrease in the property's value. The court reasoned that the second defendant's claim for specific performance was not without merit, and the defence of unclean hands did not entirely bar the claim. Regarding the striking out application, the court agreed with the defendants that certain paragraphs of the third amended statement of claim were improperly pleaded, lacking the necessary factual basis to support the legal conclusions drawn. The plaintiffs were granted leave to replead those paragraphs or to otherwise amend their cause of action as they saw fit. The District Court proceedings were transferred to the Supreme Court, as was appropriate given the nature of the claims.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application filed by the second plaintiff on 3 November 2023 is dismissed.

2. On the application filed by the defendants on 13 November 2023 it is ordered that:

a. paragraphs 26 to 33AA of the third amended statement of claim filed on 11 September 2023 are struck out;

b. the plaintiffs have leave to replead those paragraphs, or to otherwise replead their cause of action for the declaration in paragraph 2 of the claim filed on 3 May 2022 as they may be advised;

c. District Court proceedings number 2315 of 2022 be transferred to the Supreme Court of

Background

Background to the litigation

Recycling Developments Pty Ltd and an associated entity (the plaintiffs) are involved in a dispute with Bespoke Recycling Industries Pty Ltd and another entity (the defendants) concerning real property. The plaintiffs own land subject to a call option deed that grants the second defendant the right to purchase the property. The plaintiffs claim the call option was validly terminated before the second defendant attempted to exercise it. The second defendant lodged a caveat against the property, asserting an interest under the call option deed. The plaintiffs subsequently entered into a put and call option agreement with a third party, stipulating that if the caveat is not removed by a certain date, the third party would terminate the agreement. The plaintiffs applied to remove the caveat, arguing that its retention would cause irreparable harm due to potential devaluation of the property and the risk of the third party not completing the purchase. The second defendant opposed the removal, arguing that damages would be an adequate remedy and asserting the defence of unclean hands.

This matter has proceeded through various stages in the civil courts. The dispute began with the plaintiffs initiating proceedings against the defendants. The second defendant lodged a caveat against the property and was granted leave to lodge a further caveat by the court. The plaintiffs applied to remove the caveat, and the second defendant opposed this application, raising additional defences. The defendants subsequently filed an application to strike out certain paragraphs of the plaintiffs' third amended statement of claim, arguing that the allegations were not supported by facts and pleaded conclusions of mixed fact and law. The plaintiffs sought to replead the struck-out paragraphs, while the defendants argued against allowing such repleading.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the retention of the caveat on the title to the land is no longer justified by reference to whether there has been a material change of circumstances since the making of the order granting leave to lodge the caveat.
2. Whether paragraphs 26 to 33AA of the third amended statement of claim should be struck out as they do not disclose a reasonable cause of action or defence.
3. Whether the plaintiffs should be granted leave to replead the struck-out paragraphs or to otherwise replead their cause of action.

Held
1. The retention of the caveat on the title to the land is no longer justified by reference to whether there has been a material change of circumstances since the making of the order granting leave to lodge the caveat. The application for removal of the caveat is dismissed.
2. Paragraphs 26 to 33AA of the third amended statement of claim should be struck out as they do not disclose a reasonable cause of action or defence. The application to strike out is allowed.
3. The plaintiffs are granted leave to replead the struck-out paragraphs or to otherwise replead their cause of action. The plaintiffs have leave to amend their pleadings.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court examined the application for the removal of the caveat on the title to the land. The second defendant had lodged a caveat based on its claim for specific performance of a call option deed. The plaintiffs argued that the call option deed was terminated prior to the purported exercise of the option and sought removal of the caveat, claiming that there was a risk of the land's value decreasing. The Court held that the caveat was justified when granted but found that the circumstances had materially changed. The risk of the land's value decreasing before the final resolution of the proceedings was deemed sufficient to justify the removal of the caveat. The Court emphasised that the caveat should only be retained if it was still justified in light of any material changes in circumstances.

Regarding the striking out of paragraphs 26 to 33AA of the third amended statement of claim, the Court found that these paragraphs did not disclose a reasonable cause of action or defence. The defendants argued that the plaintiffs pleaded conclusions rather than facts and that the alleged breaches were not capable of being remedied. The Court agreed that the pleadings were insufficient as they did not provide the necessary factual basis for the conclusions drawn. The Court also noted that the pleadings did not sufficiently allege the harm caused by each relevant breach.

The Court granted the plaintiffs leave to replead the struck-out paragraphs or to otherwise replead their cause of action. This decision recognised that the plaintiffs had not had the opportunity to adequately plead their case and allowed them to address the deficiencies identified by the Court. The Court also transferred the proceedings to the Supreme Court, acknowledging the complexity and importance of the issues involved. The ratio of this decision is that a caveat can be removed if the circumstances have materially changed to the extent that its retention is no longer justified, and that pleadings must adequately set out the facts supporting legal conclusions, with leave to amend being granted where necessary to remedy deficiencies in the pleadings.