Rocky Point Holdings Pty Ltd v TEB Enterprises Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Rocky Point Holdings Pty Ltd v TEB Enterprises Pty Ltd [2023] QSC 20

PARTIES:

RECYCLING DEVELOPMENTS PTY LTD
ACN 132 325 314

(first plaintiff/respondent)
TEB ENTERPRISES PTY LTD
ACN 142 685 372 ATF THE PERROTT FAMILY TRUST ABN 95 197 523 153
(second plaintiff/second respondent)
v
BESPOKE RECYCLING INDUSTRIES PTY LTD
ACN 634 377 030
(first defendant/applicant)

ROCKY POINT HOLDINGS PTY LTD
ACN 645 224 755 ATF ROCKY POINT TRUST
ABN 96 370 426 600

(second defendant/applicant)

FILE NO/S:

BS No 4963 of 2022

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

17 February 2023

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

27 January 2023

JUDGE:

Davis J

ORDER:

It is ordered:

1. That Rocky Point Holdings Pty Ltd have leave pursuant to s 129 of the Land Title Act 1994 to lodge a further caveat over the real property described in the Land Title Register as Lot 10 on SP 296020, Title Reference 51250454 claiming the same interest as claimed under caveat number 721846160.

2.    That by 4.00 pm on 24 February 2023 the second defendant/applicant file and serve upon the plaintiffs/respondents any written submissions as to costs of the application.

3.    By 4.00 pm on 3 March 2023 the plaintiffs/respondents file and serve upon the second defendant/applicant any written submissions as to costs of the application.

4.    Each party shall have leave to file and serve any application for leave to make oral submissions on costs by 4.00 pm on 17 March 2023.

5.    In the absence of any application for leave to make oral submissions on costs, the question of costs will be determined upon any written submissions filed and served.

CATCHWORDS:

REAL PROPERTY – TORRENS TITLE – CAVEATS AGAINST DEALINGS – where the parties executed a call option deed – where the call option deed gave the second defendant an option to purchase land at Yatula – where the plaintiffs purported to rescind the call option deed – where the second defendant purported to exercise the option – where the second defendant lodged a caveat – where the second defendant counterclaimed in existing proceeding claiming specific performance – where the second defendant did not notify the Registrar of Titles of the counterclaim – where the caveat lapsed – where the second defendant seeks leave to lodge a second caveat based on the same interest as the first – where the plaintiffs say the second defendant is not entitled to specific performance of the contract pursuant to the call option deed – where the plaintiffs claim prejudice – whether the prejudice is loss to be suffered from the lodging of the second caveat – whether in exercise of discretion leave to lodge a second caveat should be given

TAXES AND DUTIES – STAMP DUTIES – where the second defendant claimed an interest in land through exercise of rights under a call option deed – where it lodged a caveat in support of that interest – where the caveat lapsed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rocky Point Holdings Pty Ltd v TEB Enterprises Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QSC 20
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Rocky Point Holdings Pty Ltd and TEB Enterprises Pty Ltd were involved in a legal dispute concerning the validity of a call option deed and the subsequent lodging of caveats. The call option deed gave TEB the right to purchase land at Yatula. Rocky Point attempted to rescind the deed, but TEB claimed it had exercised its option to purchase and lodged a caveat to protect its interest. However, the caveat lapsed due to errors in the notification process, and TEB sought leave to lodge a second caveat.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether TEB was entitled to lodge a second caveat based on the same interest as the first, and if so, whether it was appropriate to grant leave considering the potential prejudice to Rocky Point. Another issue was whether the unstamped call option deed could support a caveat under the Duties Act 2001. TEB had provided an undertaking to stamp the deed if required, but it was argued that the deed remained ineffective until stamped.

The court found that TEB's intention was always to maintain the caveat and enforce its claim for specific performance. The first caveat had lapsed due to errors within the office of TEB's solicitors, and there were triable issues surrounding the circumstances of the termination of the Call Option Deed. The court concluded that denying leave to lodge a second caveat would likely result in TEB selling the land, thereby depriving Rocky Point of its interest. The court granted leave to lodge the second caveat and directed the parties to exchange written submissions regarding the costs of the application.

It is ordered that Rocky Point Holdings Pty Ltd have leave to lodge a further caveat over the specified property, claiming the same interest as under the previous caveat. The parties must file written submissions regarding the costs of the application by specified dates, and the question of costs will be determined based on these submissions unless an application for oral submissions is made.

Orders

Orders of the court

It is ordered:

1. That Rocky Point Holdings Pty Ltd have leave pursuant to s 129 of the Land Title Act 1994 to lodge a further caveat over the real property described in the Land Title Register as Lot 10 on SP 296020, Title Reference 51250454 claiming the same interest as claimed under caveat number 721846160.

2. That by 4.00 pm on 24 February 2023 the second defendant/applicant file and serve upon the plaintiffs/respondents any written submissions as to costs of the application.

3. By 4.00 pm on 3 March 2023 the plaintiffs/respondents file and serve upon the second defendant/applicant any written submissions as to costs of the application.

4. Each party shall have leave to file and serve any application for leave to make oral submissions on costs by 4.00 pm on 17 March 2023.

5. In the absence of any application for leave to make oral submissions on costs, the question of costs will be determined upon any written submissions filed and served.

Background

Background to the litigation

Rocky Point Holdings Pty Ltd executed a call option deed with TEB Enterprises Pty Ltd, granting TEB the option to purchase land at Yatula. Subsequently, Rocky Point purported to rescind the call option deed, while TEB purported to exercise the option. TEB lodged a caveat against dealings on the land in support of its claim for specific performance, but did not notify the Registrar of Titles of the counterclaim. As a result, the caveat lapsed. TEB then sought leave to lodge a second caveat based on the same interest as the first, claiming an equitable interest in the land under the call option deed. Rocky Point opposed the application, arguing that TEB was not entitled to specific performance of the contract and that they would suffer prejudice if the second caveat was lodged. Additionally, there was an issue regarding the stamp duty on the call option deed, as it had not been stamped, although an undertaking to stamp the document had been given.

The matter came before the court as an application by TEB Enterprises Pty Ltd for leave to lodge a second caveat over the land at Yatula. This followed the lapse of the initial caveat that TEB had lodged in support of their claim for specific performance under the call option deed. The court had to determine whether to grant TEB leave to lodge the second caveat, taking into account the arguments presented by both parties regarding the merits of the claim for specific performance, potential prejudice to Rocky Point, and the admissibility of the unstamped call option deed.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Section 487 of the Duties Act 2001 provides:“487 Receipt of instruments or ELN transaction documents in evidence(1)Unless an instrument or ELN transaction document[16] is properly stamped, it—(a) is not available for use in law or equity or for any purpose; and(b) must not be received in evidence in a legal proceeding, other than a criminal proceeding.(2)However, a court may receive an instrument or ELN transaction document in evidence if—(a) after it is received in evidence, the instrument or ELN transaction document is given to the commissioner as required by arrangements approved by the court; or(b) if the person who produces the instrument or ELN transaction document is not the person liable to pay the duty, the name and address of the person so liable, and the instrument or ELN transaction document, is given to the commissioner as required by arrangements approved by the court.(3)A court may receive in evidence an unsigned copy of an instrument or ELN transaction document that is imposed with duty or effects or evidences a transaction that is imposed with duty if the court is satisfied—(a) the instrument or ELN transaction document of which it is a copy is properly stamped; or(b) the copy is properly stamped under section 494.”[16]A reference to electronic documents. Samantha Langan, a solicitor, has carriage of the proceedings for Bespoke Recycling and Rocky Point. She swore to having investigated whether stamp duty on the Call Option Deed was paid through solicitors who had earlier acted for Bespoke Recycling and Rocky Point.[17] She then swore:“15.I am instructed by Mr Murray, and believe, that he accepts that it appears likely that any applicable stamp duty has not been paid.16.I hold instructions to offer an undertaking on behalf of the Defendants to submit the Call Option Deed to the Commissioner of State Revenue (Queensland) for assessment within 14 days, and to cause any duty assessed thereon to be paid within the time required by the Commissioner, should the Court consider the giving of such an undertaking relevant to its consideration of the present Application.”[17]Her affidavit sworn 21 January 2023. Before me, the parties considered paragraph 16 of Ms Langan’s affidavit to constitute an undertaking in its terms. On behalf of Recycling Developments and TEB, it was submitted that:1.the undertaking might make the Call Option Deed admissible; but2.the document remains ineffective to found a cause of action to establish an interest in the land before it is actually stamped; and3.Rocky Point and Bespoke Recycling are therefore not ready, willing and able to perform the Call Option Deed. Those submissions are based on the judgment of Holmes J (as her Honour then was) in Hoggett v O’Rourke.[18] There, an application was made to strike out parts of a statement of claim which were reliant upon an unstamped document. There was no undertaking offered to cause the document to be stamped. The point that was taken was that the existence of the document had been admitted in the pleadings and, therefore, it was proved without producing a stamped copy.[19] [18][2002] 1 Qd R 490. [19]At [12].

Decision

Reasons for decision

From those facts I draw the inferences that:1.the counterclaim was intended to support the caveat;2.some error has occurred within the offices of Francom Legal which has led to the notification not being given to the Registrar;3.Mr Murray acted by giving Francom Legal instructions to lodge a second caveat as soon as he saw the threat of TEB disposing of the land to a third party;4.altogether, those facts demonstrate that the intention was always to maintain the first caveat and press the claim for specific performance in the counterclaim.Conclusions The Call Option Deed gives Rocky Point an equitable interest in the land. It is conceded by Recycling Developments and TEB that there are triable issues surrounding the circumstances of their termination of the Call Option Deed and they cannot assert on an application such as this that Rocky Point has no arguable case. In my view, Recycling Developments and TEB have not established that specific performance would not be ordered if Rocky Point established that TEB was not entitled to terminate the Call Option Deed. Denial of leave to lodge a second caveat is likely to result in TEB selling the land and Rocky Point’s interest being lost. Any loss suffered by Recycling Developments and TEB is referrable more to alleged breaches of contract than any inability to deal with the land pending trial of the claim. The evidence of the circumstances which resulted in the first caveat lapsing is less than satisfactory, as is the evidence as to why this application was not made until about six weeks after the first caveat lapsed. However, the evidence is sufficient for me to find as I do, on the balance of probabilities, that Rocky Point always intended to maintain the caveat and enforce its claim for specific performance and the first caveat only lapsed because errors, the specifics of which cannot be identified, occurred within the office of its solicitors and those errors resulted in the Registrar of Titles not being notified of the counterclaim. In all the circumstances, I consider it appropriate to maintain the status quo by giving Rocky Point leave to lodge a second caveat claiming the same interest as claimed in the first caveat. Rocky Point has been successful in the application but the application was only necessary because Rocky Point, through its solicitors, allowed the first caveat to lapse. Costs questions could be difficult. At the hearing before me, the parties were content for me to make directions for the exchange of written submissions on costs. That is appropriate. It is ordered:1.That Rocky Point Holdings Pty Ltd have leave pursuant to s 129 of the Land Title Act 1994 to lodge a further caveat over the real property described in the Land Title Register as Lot 10 on SP 296020, Title Reference 51250454 claiming the same interest as claimed under caveat number 721846160.2.That by 4.00 pm on 24 February 2023 the second defendant/applicant file and serve upon the plaintiffs/respondents any written submissions as to costs of the application.3.By 4.00 pm on 3 March 2023 the plaintiffs/respondents file and serve upon the second defendant/applicant any written submissions as to costs of the application.4.Each party shall have leave to file and serve any application for leave to make oral submissions on costs by 4.00 pm on 17 March 2023.5.In the absence of any application for leave to make oral submissions on costs, the question of costs will be determined upon any written submissions filed and served.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by considering whether the prejudice to Rocky Point from the lodging of the second caveat is the loss to be suffered from the lodging of the second caveat. The court noted that the primary prejudice to Rocky Point would result from TEB disposing of the land to a third party before the matter was resolved. The court concluded that the prejudice to Rocky Point from the lodging of the second caveat was not the loss to be suffered from the lodging of the second caveat.

Next, the court considered whether, in the exercise of discretion, leave to lodge a second caveat should be given. The court recognised that the Call Option Deed gave Rocky Point an equitable interest in the land, and that there were triable issues surrounding the circumstances of the termination of the Call Option Deed. The court was satisfied that Rocky Point always intended to maintain the first caveat and press the claim for specific performance in the counterclaim. The court found that the first caveat only lapsed because errors occurred within the office of Rocky Point's solicitors, which resulted in the Registrar of Titles not being notified of the counterclaim. The court concluded that it was appropriate to maintain the status quo by giving Rocky Point leave to lodge a second caveat.

Lastly, the court considered whether, on a proper construction of s 487 of the Duties Act 2001, the unstamped document can found an interest to support a caveat. The court noted that an undertaking to submit the Call Option Deed to the Commissioner of State Revenue for assessment and to pay any duty assessed was given. The court found that the existence of the unstamped document had been admitted in the pleadings, but that the document remains ineffective to found a cause of action to establish an interest in the land before it is actually stamped. The court held that, on a proper construction of s 487 of the Duties Act 2001, the unstamped document cannot found an interest to support a caveat.