T and L Byrne Excavations Pty Ltd v Robinson

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

T & L Byrne Excavations Pty Ltd & Anor v Robinson [2021] QSC 279

PARTIES:

T & L BYRNE EXCAVATIONS PTY LTD AS TRUSTEE FOR THE BYRNE FAMILY TRUST ABN 87 178 169 911

(First Plaintiff)
BYRNE CIVIL PROJECTS PTY LTD ACN 164 151 099
(Second Plaintiff)
v
LUTCHMEE ROBINSON (ALSO KNOWN AS ‘ANNIE ROBINSON’)
(First Defendant)
TROY JONATHON ROBINSON
(Second Defendant)

FILE NO/S:

BS 638 of 2020

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

DELIVERED ON:

2 November 2021

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

26 October 2021

JUDGE:

Bowskill SJA

ORDERS:

1. In relation to paragraph 1 of the first defendant’s application filed 13 August 2021, the court orders that the caveat having dealing number 720572336 over property described as Lot 130 on SP 186162 with title reference 50591910, lodged by the plaintiffs on 5 February 2021, be removed pursuant to s 127 of the Land Title Act 1994 (Qld).

2.    In relation to the plaintiffs’ application filed 12 October 2021, the Court will hear further submissions from the parties as to the appropriate order(s) to be made.

CATCHWORDS:

REAL PROPERTY – TORRENS TITLE – CAVEATS AGAINST DEALINGS – REMOVAL – PARTICULAR CASES – where the plaintiffs allege the first defendant, a former employee, misappropriated and misapplied funds belonging to them to the benefit of herself and her husband, the second defendant, also an employee, either by overpayments of wages or other unauthorised payments – where the plaintiffs lodged a caveat over the defendants’ family home, which had been purchased prior to the defendants being employed – where the defendants seek the removal of the caveat, in order to sell the property to fund their legal expenses – whether there is a serious question to be tried as to the plaintiffs’ claim to an interest in the property

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – DETENTION, INSPECTION AND PRESERVATION – FREEZING ORDERS – where the plaintiffs apply for a freezing order, preventing the defendants from disposing of their assets to the value of their home property – where there has been significant and unexplained delay in bringing the application, since the proceedings were commenced in January 2020 – whether on the evidence before the court there has been shown to be a risk of unjustifiable disposal of assets

Land Title Act 1994 (Qld), s 127

Bluepoint Property Pty Ltd v Zuri Properties Pty Ltd [2020] QSC 219
Cousins Securities Pty Ltd v CEC Group Limited [2007] 2 Qd R 520
Frigo v Culhaci [1998] NSWCA 88
Jedhar Pty Ltd v Grosse [2003] QSC 330
Palmer v Mullins Investments Pty Ltd (in liquidation) (inreported, Supreme Court of Western Australia, Murray J, 1992, 26 June 1992)
Parbery v QNI Metals Pty Ltd (2018) 358 ALR 88
Patterson v BTR Engineering (Aust) Ltd (1989) 18 NSWLR 319
Re Jorss’ Caveat [1982] Qd R 458
Wickham Developments Pty Ltd v Parker [1995] QCA 281
Wickham Developments Ltd v Parker & Anor [1994] QSC 255

COUNSEL:

P A…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read T and L Byrne Excavations Pty Ltd v Robinson and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QSC 279
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of T and L Byrne Excavations Pty Ltd v Robinson, the plaintiffs, who are the proprietors of a business, brought an action against the first and second defendants, who were employees of theirs. The plaintiffs alleged that the first defendant had misappropriated and misapplied funds belonging to them to the benefit of herself and her husband, the second defendant, either by overpayments of wages or other unauthorised payments. The plaintiffs lodged a caveat over the defendants' family home, which had been purchased prior to the defendants being employed, in order to secure their claim. The defendants sought the removal of the caveat to enable them to sell the property to fund their legal expenses.

The legal issues that the court had to decide included whether there was a serious question to be tried as to the plaintiffs' claim to an interest in the property and whether the plaintiffs were entitled to a freezing order preventing the defendants from disposing of their assets to the value of their home property. The court had to consider whether there was a risk of unjustifiable disposal of assets given the significant and unexplained delay in bringing the application since the proceedings were commenced in January 2020.

The court ordered the removal of the caveat over the defendants' family home pursuant to s 127 of the Land Title Act 1994 (Qld). However, the court decided to hear further submissions from the parties as to the appropriate order(s) to be made in relation to the plaintiffs' application for a freezing order. The court found that the plaintiffs had not shown that there was a serious question to be tried as to their claim to an interest in the property, and that there was insufficient evidence to grant a freezing order at that stage of the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. In relation to paragraph 1 of the first defendant’s application filed 13 August 2021, the court orders that the caveat having dealing number 720572336 over property described as Lot 130 on SP 186162 with title reference 50591910, lodged by the plaintiffs on 5 February 2021, be removed pursuant to s 127 of the Land Title Act 1994 (Qld).

2. In relation to the plaintiffs’ application filed 12 October 2021, the Court will hear further submissions from the parties as to the appropriate order(s) to be made.

Background

Background to the litigation

T and L Byrne Excavations Pty Ltd, the plaintiffs, are a company engaged in excavation works. They allege that the first defendant, who was a former employee, misappropriated and misapplied funds belonging to them to the benefit of herself and her husband, the second defendant, who was also an employee. The plaintiffs claim that this was done either through overpayments of wages or other unauthorised payments. To protect their interests, the plaintiffs lodged a caveat over the family home of the defendants, which had been purchased prior to the defendants being employed by the plaintiffs. The defendants have applied for the removal of the caveat to enable them to sell the property to fund their legal expenses.

The matter was heard in the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal. The plaintiffs commenced proceedings in January 2020. The first defendant filed an application on 13 August 2021, seeking the removal of the caveat over their family home. The plaintiffs filed an application on 12 October 2021, seeking a freezing order to prevent the defendants from disposing of their assets to the value of their home property. The application for the freezing order was made despite a significant and unexplained delay since the commencement of the proceedings.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether there is a serious question to be tried as to the plaintiffs’ claim to an interest in the property.
2. Whether on the evidence before the court there has been shown to be a risk of unjustifiable disposal of assets.

Held
1. The court held that there is a serious question to be tried as to the plaintiffs' claim to an interest in the property. Consequently, the caveat over the defendants' family home was not removed.
2. The court held that on the evidence before it, there has been shown to be a risk of unjustifiable disposal of assets. However, the court did not make a freezing order, and instead decided to hear further submissions from the parties as to the appropriate order(s) to be made.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the plaintiffs' allegations that the first defendant misappropriated and misapplied funds belonging to them, to the benefit of herself and her husband, the second defendant, either by overpayments of wages or other unauthorised payments. The plaintiffs lodged a caveat over the defendants' family home, which had been purchased prior to the defendants being employed. The defendants sought the removal of the caveat, in order to sell the property to fund their legal expenses.

The court applied the principles in relation to caveats and the removal thereof under s 127 of the Land Title Act 1994 (Qld). The court noted that the plaintiffs had established a serious question to be tried in relation to their claim to an interest in the property. The court found that it was not appropriate to remove the caveat at that stage of the proceedings. This conclusion was based on the seriousness of the allegations and the potential impact on the plaintiffs' rights.

Furthermore, the court considered the plaintiffs' application for a freezing order, preventing the defendants from disposing of their assets to the value of their home property. The court acknowledged the significant and unexplained delay in bringing the application, since the proceedings were commenced in January 2020. Nevertheless, the court recognised that there was a risk of unjustifiable disposal of assets. However, the court decided not to make a freezing order at that stage, and instead chose to hear further submissions from the parties as to the appropriate order(s) to be made.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that in cases where there is a serious question to be tried as to a party's claim to an interest in the property, the court may not remove a caveat over the property. Additionally, when there is a risk of unjustifiable disposal of assets, the court may choose to hear further submissions before making a freezing order.