Re Westport Insurance Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Westport Insurance Corporation, in the matter of Westport Insurance Corporation [2009] FCA 1357

INSURANCE - intra-group transfer of insurance and reinsurance businesses - application for dispensation with compliance with requirement that all “affected policyholders” be notified of scheme for transfer - considerations going to exercise of discretion

Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth), s 29
Insurance Act 1973 (Cth), s 17C
Life Insurance Act 1995 (Cth), s 191

Calliden Group Limited in the matter of Calliden Group Limited [2007] FCA 2019 cited
Challenger Life Limited [2004] FCA 618 cited
The Application of Commonwealth Life Ltd& Anor [2003] FCA 501 cited
In the matter of GIO Personal Investment Services Ltdand AMP Life Ltd [2000] FCA 1871 cited
Re Insurance Australia Ltd (2004) 139 FCR 450 cited
MMIA Pty Limited and QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited [2008] FCA 1239 cited
Munich Reinsurance Company of Australasia Limited [2004] FCA 1391 cited

IN THE MATTER OF WESTPORT INSURANCE CORPORATION

(ABN 48 072 715 738)

WESTPORT INSURANCE CORPORATION (ABN 48 072 715 738)

NSD 1220 of 2009

LINDGREN J
20 NOVEMBER 2009
SYDNEY

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 1220 of 2009

IN THE MATTER OF WESTPORT INSURANCE CORPORATION
ABN 48 072 715 738)(

The application of

WESTPORT INSURANCE CORPORATION

(ABN 48 072 715 738)

JUDGE:

LINDGREN J

DATE OF ORDER:

13 NOVEMBER 2009

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1. In relation to the proposed scheme for the transfer of insurance business from Westport Insurance Corporation to Swiss Re International SE (the Insurance Scheme), the need for the applicant to comply with s 17C(2)(c) of the Insurance Act 1973 (Cth) (the Act) be, pursuant to s 17C(5) of the Act, dispensed with provided that the applicant complies with order 2 below.

2.   In relation to the Insurance Scheme, the applicant:

(a)cause a copy of the approved summary of the Insurance Scheme to be sent by pre-paid post to all policyholders of identified by the searches referred to in the affidavit of Karen Lancaster in support of the motion, and for whom Westport has an address;

(b)cause a copy of the approved summary of the Insurance Scheme to be sent by pre-paid post to MGA Insurance Brokers Pty Ltd, AssetInsure Pty Ltd, Australis Group Underwriting, Howard Insurance Australia Pty Ltd, SRS Underwriting Agency, Dexta Corporation Pty Ltd and Gallagher Broking Services.

3. In relation to the proposed scheme for the transfer of insurance business from Westport Insurance Corporation to Swiss Reinsurance Company Ltd (the Reinsurance Scheme), the need for the applicant to comply with s 17C(2)(c) of the Act be, pursuant to s 17C(5) of the Act, dispensed with provided that the applicant complies with order 4 below.

4.   In relation to the Reinsurance Scheme the applicant cause a copy of the approved summary of the Reinsurance Scheme to be sent by pre-paid post to:

(a)all policyholders of identified by the searches referred to in the affidavit of Xenia Zumbach-Hauenstein in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Westport Insurance Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 1357
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Westport Insurance Corporation, a United States-incorporated company authorised to carry on insurance business in Australia, sought a dispensation from certain statutory requirements under the Insurance Act 1973 (Cth) to facilitate the transfer of its Australian branch's direct insurance and reinsurance businesses to Swiss Re International SE and Swiss Reinsurance Company Ltd, respectively. The Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA) did not oppose the application. The primary legal issues revolved around the interpretation of "affected policyholder" under s 17C(1) of the Act and the methods for giving notice to these policyholders. The court considered whether Westport could be excused from identifying and notifying all policyholders, and if alternative methods of notification could be utilised.

The court held that all of Westport’s policyholders were indeed "affected policyholders" as defined in s 17C(1) of the Act, as all of their policies were to be transferred under the proposed schemes. However, the court also acknowledged the difficulty Westport faced in identifying all policyholders and providing them with the required notices. It found that the statutory requirement to "give" a document to a foreign corporate body was ambiguous and impractical. Consequently, the court granted the dispensation sought by Westport, allowing alternative means of notification, such as sending copies of the approved summaries by prepaid post to identified policyholders and specified brokers and underwriters.

The court further ordered that Westport must notify any new policyholders issued between the date of the order and 31 December 2009 about the insurance scheme. The final orders included dispensing with the requirement to identify all policyholders and specifying the methods and recipients for the approved summaries of the schemes. The proceeding was set for a final hearing on 17 December 2009.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. In relation to the proposed scheme for the transfer of insurance business from Westport Insurance Corporation to Swiss Re International SE (the Insurance Scheme), the need for the applicant to comply with s 17C(2)(c) of the Insurance Act 1973 (Cth) (the Act) be, pursuant to s 17C(5) of the Act, dispensed with provided that the applicant complies with order 2 below.

2. In relation to the Insurance Scheme, the applicant:

(a) cause a copy of the approved summary of the Insurance Scheme to be sent by pre-paid post to all policyholders of identified by the searches referred to in the affidavit of Karen Lancaster in support of the motion, and for whom Westport has an address;

(b) cause a copy of the approved summary of the Insurance Scheme to be sent by pre-paid post to MGA Insurance Brokers Pty Ltd, AssetInsure Pty Ltd, Australis Group Underwriting, Howard Insurance Australia Pty Ltd, SRS Underwriting Agency, Dexta Corporation Pty Ltd and Gallagher Broking Services.

3. In relation to the proposed scheme for the transfer of insurance business from Westport Insurance Corporation to Swiss Reinsurance Company Ltd (the Reinsurance Scheme), the need for the applicant to comply with s 17C(2)(c) of the Act be, pursuant to s 17C(5) of the Act, dispensed with provided that the applicant complies with order 4 below.

4. In relation to the Reinsurance Scheme the applicant cause a copy of the approved summary of the Reinsurance Scheme to be sent by pre-paid post to:

(a) all policyholders of identified by the searches referred to in the affidavit of Xenia Zumbach-Hauenstein in support of the motion, and for whom Westport has an address; and

(b) all insurers authorised with the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority listed in the “List of Authorised Insurers” maintained by the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority as at today’s date.

5. The proceeding be fixed for final hearing on 17 December 2009 at 10.15am.

THE COURT NOTES THE UNDERTAKING OF THE APPLICANT, BY ITS COUNSEL, THAT:

6. Any person to whom a policy of direct insurance is issued by or on behalf of the applicant between today’s date and 31 December 2009 will be notified of the Insurance Scheme.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

On the hearing the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA) appeared and was heard: see s 17E(3) of the Act. APRA raised no objection to the making of the orders.BACKGROUND There two schemes are:(a)the “Insurance Scheme”, under which the direct insurance business of Westport’s Australian branch will be transferred to the Australian branch of Swiss Re International SE (SRI); and(b)the “Reinsurance Scheme”, under which the reinsurance business of Westport’s Australian branch will be transferred to the Australian branch of Swiss Reinsurance Company Ltd (I will refer to this company as SRC, and to its Australian branch as SRCAU). Westport is a subsidiary of SRC. Both proposed transfers are “intra-group” transfers. Westport is incorporated in the United States of America. It is authorised under the Act to carry on insurance business in Australia, as are SRC and SRI. Each of Westport, SRC and SRI carries on its insurance business in Australia through an Australian branch. Westport (formerly known as “Employers Reinsurance Corporation”) has operated its branch in Australia from 1996, writing both direct insurance and reinsurance. As at 31 December 2008, Westport’s liabilities were approximately 18% direct insurance liabilities and 82% reinsurance liabilities. Westport’s direct insurance business and reinsurance business were written by Westport itself or through brokers and underwriting agents on its behalf. SRC acquired Westport in 2006. From October 2006, Westport ceased to write or renew any reinsurance. The nature of the direct insurance written by Westport is varied, but it is principally (about 90%) “short-tail” in nature, which means that reliable estimates as to claims can be made within two years of the conclusion of the period of insurance. The “long-tail” part of the direct insurance portfolio is principally casualty insurance. According to the affidavit evidence, most of the holders of policies of direct insurance are located in Australia and New Zealand. Westport’s reinsurance business comprises all structures of reinsurance (proportional, non-proportional, treaty and facultative), and many classes of insurance business. Most of the holders of policies of reinsurance are also located in Australia and New Zealand. Claims made on Westport are currently handled by its parent, SRC.CONSIDERATIONWho is an “affected policyholder”? The term “affected policyholder” is defined in s 17C(1) of the Act as “the holder of a policy affected by the scheme”. In Re Insurance Australia Ltd (2004) 139 FCR 450 (Re Insurance Australia Ltd) at [19]-[20], I held:·that the expression “affected policyholder” referred to a policy that was affected by the scheme, not to a holder who was affected by the scheme; and ·that the holders of policies that had been issued by the transferee company, or that had been issued by the transferor company but were not to be transferred under the schemewere not “affected policyholders”.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

LINDGREN J
Fifth, APRA does not oppose the making of the order. The fact that APRA, which is charged with the responsibility of protecting the interests of policyholders, has raised no objection has been said to be a matter in favour of a dispensation: see, eg Commonwealth Life Ltd at [6] and [10], Challenger Life Limited at [5]; Calliden Group Limited at [62].CONCLUSION It was for the reasons expressed above that I made the orders on 13 November 2009.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: LINDGREN J

Claims made on Westport are currently handled by its parent, SRC.CONSIDERATIONWho is an “affected policyholder”? The term “affected policyholder” is defined in s 17C(1) of the Act as “the holder of a policy affected by the scheme”. In Re Insurance Australia Ltd (2004) 139 FCR 450 (Re Insurance Australia Ltd) at [19]-[20], I held:·that the expression “affected policyholder” referred to a policy that was affected by the scheme, not to a holder who was affected by the scheme; and ·that the holders of policies that had been issued by the transferee company, or that had been issued by the transferor company but were not to be transferred under the schemewere not “affected policyholders”. In the present case, all of the direct insurance policies and all of the reinsurance policies of Westport are sought to be transferred to either SRI or SRCAU. It follows that all of Westport’s policyholders are “affected policyholders”. The policyholders of SRI and SRCAU, however, are not, and are therefore not required by s 17C(2)(c) to be provided with an approved summary of either scheme.The need for the dispensation Westport seeks a dispensation because it is not able to identify all of its policyholders, and is therefore unable to comply with s 17C(2)(c). There is an additional reason why a dispensation is sought. This additional reason applies to certain policyholders that Westport has been able to identify. Section 17C(2)(c) requires that the approved summary be “given” to affected policyholders. Section 121 of the Act provides various ways in which a document may be “given” to a person for the purposes of the Act. In the case of a body corporate other than Lloyd’s (being the society of that name incorporated by Lloyd’s Act 1871 (UK)) that is not incorporated in Australia, s 121 provides that the document may be given by being left at, or by being sent by registered post to, the body corporate at its address for service notified to APRA. Where no such address has been notified to APRA, the Act appears to require that the document simply be “given” to the body corporate, as distinct from being posted to it at its last known address, without explanation as to how it is to be “given” to the foreign body corporate. Section 29 of the Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth) does not assist because it is enlivened only where an Act authorises or requires a document to be served by post. Westport therefore asks that the Court permit an alternative means of service. The issues affecting each scheme are dealt with in turn.The Insurance Scheme In relation to the Insurance Scheme, Westport relies on an affidavit of Karen Lancaster, the Technical Accounting Consultant of SRI. Ms Lancaster performed a search of Westport’s computer systems to identify the holders of policies of insurance written by it. Having identified a policyholder by name, Ms Lancaster undertook various searches (both of Westport’s records and of publicly available sources of information) to determine a current address for that policyholder. Ms Lancaster created a spreadsheet that contained the information that her searches elicited.