Re Insurance Australia Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Insurance Australia Limited [2004] FCA 524

CORPORATIONS – application for Court’s confirmation of scheme by which part of insurance business of a general insurance company is transferred to another general insurance company – transfer of compulsory third party motor accident part of insurer’s business to that insurer’s parent – requirement of s 17C(2) of Insurance Act 1973 (Cth) that application for confirmation may not be ‘made’ unless conditions set out in that subsection have been satisfied – requirement of s 17E(2) of Act that application for confirmation must be ‘made’ in accordance with prudential standards of Australian Prudential Regulation Authority – whether word ‘made’ refers to filing of form of application in Court Registry or to hearing of application – whether expression ‘affected policyholder’ in s 17C extends to include (a) holders of other policies issued by ‘transferor insurer’ which are not being transferred under the scheme, and (b) existing holders of policies issued by ‘transferee insurer’ – whether non-compliance with s 17C goes to Court’s jurisdiction – discretionary considerations – whether order should be made under s 190(1) of Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) permitting hearsay evidence to be adduced on final hearing.

INSURANCE – application for Court’s confirmation of scheme by which part of insurance business of a general insurance company is transferred to another general insurance company – transfer of compulsory third party motor accident part of insurer’s business to that insurer’s parent – requirement of s 17C(2) of Insurance Act 1973 (Cth) that application for confirmation may not be ‘made’ unless conditions set out in that subsection have been satisfied – requirement of s 17E(2) of Act that application for confirmation must be ‘made’ in accordance with prudential standards of Australian Prudential Regulation Authority – whether word ‘made’ refers to filing of form of application in Court Registry or to hearing of application – whether expression ‘affected policyholder’ in s 17C extends to include (a) holders of other policies issued by ‘transferor insurer’ which are not being transferred under the scheme, and (b) existing holders of policies issued by ‘transferee insurer’ – whether non-compliance with s 17C goes to Court’s jurisdiction – discretionary considerations – whether order should be made under s 190(1) of Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) permitting hearsay evidence to be adduced on final hearing.

WORDS AND PHRASES – ‘affected policyholder’ – ‘made’

Insurance Act 1973 (Cth) ss 17C, 17E
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 190

Re Armstrong Jones Life Assurance Ltd (1997) 74 FCR 160 followed
Re Royal & Sun Alliance Life Assurance Ltd (2000) 104 FCR 37 followed
Martin v Greig [1912] VLR 254 cited
Ampol Ltd v Caltex Oil (Australia) Pty Ltd [1984] 2 NSWLR 678 cited
Roberts v Repatriation Commission (1992) 39 FCR 420 cited
Tallon (1993) 67 A CrimR 40 cited
In re Reynolds [1967] Tas SR (NC) N4 cited

IN THE APPLICATION OF INSURANCE AUSTRALIA LIMITED
AND SGIO INSURANCE LIMITED
N 2254 of 2003

LINDGREN J
7 MAY 2004
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Insurance Australia Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] FCA 524
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involves an application for the Court's confirmation of a scheme whereby part of the insurance business of a general insurance company, Insurance Australia Limited (IAL), is transferred to another general insurance company, SGIO. The transfer concerns the compulsory third party motor accident insurance policies issued by SGIO in New South Wales (NSW). The primary legal issues were whether the application for confirmation could be made under certain statutory conditions, whether the term "made" in the relevant legislation referred to the filing of the application or the hearing, and the scope of the term "affected policyholder." The court also considered whether non-compliance with the statutory conditions affected its jurisdiction, and whether hearsay evidence should be permitted under the Evidence Act.

The Court found that the application for confirmation was validly made, as the statutory conditions were substantially complied with, and any non-compliance did not affect the Court's jurisdiction. The term "made" was interpreted to refer to the hearing of the application, not merely the filing. The Court held that the expression "affected policyholder" did not include holders of other policies not being transferred, nor existing policyholders of the transferee insurer. Additionally, the Court granted leave for hearsay evidence to be adduced on the final hearing, considering the impracticality of obtaining live evidence from affected policyholders.

The Court confirmed the scheme and made an order under s 17F(2) of the Insurance Act 1973, ensuring that IAL would assume the obligations and liabilities of SGIO under existing reinsurance treaties and arrangements. This included a special order to bind the reinsurance treaties despite any contrary provisions in those agreements.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to s 17F(1) of the Insurance Act 1973 (‘the Act’) the Scheme, a copy of which is annexed to this order and marked ‘A’, in relation to a proposed transfer of the New South Wales Compulsory Third Party (‘CTP’) insurance business of the Second Applicant to the First Applicant, be confirmed.

[note: Annexure A appears at the end of the reasons for judgment]

2. Pursuant to section 17F(2) of the Act, and despite anything to the contrary in any reinsurance treaties or arrangements to which the Second Applicant is a party, that:

(a) On and from the day after this order is made, all reinsurance treaties and arrangements:

(i) relating to all CTP policies of insurance under the Motor Accidents Act 1988 (NSW) and the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999 (NSW) entered into by the Second Applicant as insurer; and

(ii) to which the Second Applicant is a party (as reinsured),

are valid, effective and continuing agreements between the First Applicant (in place of the Second Applicant) and the parties other than the Second Applicant to those reinsurance treaties and arrangements.

(b) On and from the day after this order is made, the First Applicant will:

(i) be bound by;

(ii) perform the obligations, which prior to that date were the obligations of the Second Applicant, under;

(iii) be entitled to the benefits of and to take action under; and

(iv) assume any obligations and liabilities in respect of and relating to any matter arising out of,

the reinsurance treaties and arrangements referred to in paragraph 2(a) of this order, as if it were a party, and at all times had been a party, to such reinsurance treaties and arrangements, in place of the Second Applicant.

(c) On and from the day after this order is made, the Second Applicant will be released from all obligations and liabilities under the reinsurance treaties and arrangements referred to in paragraph 2(a) of this order.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 20 April 2004 I ordered that the scheme be confirmed. These reasons are my reasons for making that order. As well, these reasons are my reasons for having made earlier orders on 23 December 2003 of a procedural nature.Background facts The general nature of compulsory third party (‘CTP’) motor accident insurance is well known and does not call for discussion. In New South Wales (‘NSW’) the scheme of CTP insurance and payment of compensation relating to the death of, or injury to, persons as a consequence of motor accidents was provided for in the Motor Accidents Act 1988 (NSW) and is now provided for in the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999 (NSW) (together, ‘the New South Wales Acts’). The Motor Accidents Authority of New South Wales (‘the MAA’) is constituted by s 198 of the latter Act, with various functions specified in s 206 of that Act. On 1 November 1998, IAL (then called ‘NRMA Insurance Ltd’ – for convenience, I will henceforth refer to it as ‘IAL’ without qualification) acquired SGIO through a subsidiary of IAL, NRMA (Western Australia) Pty Ltd. At that time, both IAL and SGIO were licensed by the MAA to provide CTP motor vehicle insurance in NSW. SGIO was so licensed as from 1 March 1998. On 13 August 1999, with the MAA’s approval, IAL and SGIO entered into a Claims Management Contract by which IAL agreed to manage, as from 1 July 1999, claims made under NSW CTP policies issued by SGIO. At SGIO’s request, by letter dated 22 September 2000, MAA imposed conditions on SGIO’s CTP licence, as a result of which no new NSW CTP policies were issued by SGIO after 4 October 2000, and no more can now be issued. SGIO’s NSW CTP policies were issued over the period from 1 March 1998 to 4 October 2000. The period of the last policy issued by SGIO expired on 4 October 2001. On 24 June 2003, the boards of directors of IAL and SGIO approved of a transfer of SGIO’s NSW CTP runoff portfolio to IAL, and resolved that a Portfolio Transfer Deed be executed accordingly. As a result of the Claims Management Contract referred to at [5] above, SGIO no longer has any independent infrastructure or personnel in relation to the administration of its NSW CTP policies. Under the scheme of which the Court’s confirmation is sought, IAL will become the insurer in place of SGIO under SGIO’s NSW CTP policies, and so the insuring obligation will be aligned with the present responsibility for administration by IAL of those policies. Each policy is in respect of a motor vehicle registered in New South Wales. Where registered ownership of a motor vehicle changes, the benefit of the policy is transferred by the operation of statute to the new registered owner. Therefore, the identity of the persons having the benefit of NSW CTP policies issued by SGIO may differ from the identity of the persons to whom the policies were issued. The evidence shows that claims are made by the claimant’s contacting SGIO/IAL directly, after which the claim is administered by correspondence between SGIO/IAL and the claimant. For the above reasons, SGIO/IAL does not maintain a database of the names and addresses of the persons to whom SGIO issued NSW CTP policies, and IAL/SGIO’s records do not accurately disclose the number of persons presently having the benefit of SGIO’s NSW CTP policies. However, there is affidavit evidence of an estimate that there are approximately 72,500 such persons. Affidavit evidence also reveals that there are approximately 130 claims against SGIO’s NSW CTP insurance policy holders outstanding and unresolved.Relevant legislation and Prudential Standard GPS 410

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Claims Management Contract between SGIO and IAL is to terminate with effect on and from the Transfer Date. As soon as practicable after the Transfer Date SGIO is to apply to the MAA for cancellation of its licence under the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999 (NSW).The evidence The affidavit evidence establishes as follows. Paragraph 3 of Prudential Standard GPS 410 provides, relevantly, that any transfer of insurance business is subject to the Insurance Acquisitions and Takeovers Act 1991 (Cth). It suffices to say that on 23 September 2003, APRA made an ‘unconditional go ahead decision’ under that Act. On 20 January 2004 the applicants’ solicitors, Mallesons Stephen Jaques (‘Mallesons’), sent to APRA a summary of the scheme, a proposed form of notice of the intention to apply for Court confirmation, and a draft report by Anthony Coleman, Actuary, dated 9 December 2003. On 29 January 2004 APRA approved the summary and notice of intention. On 4 February 2004, Mallesons sent to APRA a final copy of the scheme and a slightly amended final version of the scheme summary. On 5 February 2004, copies of the scheme summary were sent to the affected policyholders (in view of orders 2 and 3 made on 23 December 2003, I will refer henceforth to the approximately 130 policyholders referred to at [9] above as ‘the affected policyholders’). The notice of intention, in the form approved by APRA, was published in eleven newspapers, in all cases but one on 25 February 2004, and in the other case on 26 February 2004, and in the Commonwealth of Australia Government Gazette on 25 February 2004. The notice of intention informed policyholders that they could obtain further details by contacting a telephone number specified in the notice. No policyholder telephoned that number. On 26 February 2004, Mallesons purported to send to APRA an email attaching further documents. Those further documents were a slightly amended final version of Mr Coleman’s report dated 25 February 2004, a further report by Mr Coleman dated 25 February 2004, a report by Conor O’Dowd of PricewaterhouseCoopers dated 5 May 2003, a further report by Mr O’Dowd dated 19 January 2004, and a letter from Mr O’Dowd to Nathan Rivett, an actuary who is supervised by Mr Coleman, dated 19 February 2004. Unbeknown to Mallesons, the email and documents were not transmitted to APRA because the email was wrongly addressed. The software the solicitors were using did not notify them that the email and accompanying documents had not reached the intended recipient. This mishap was not discovered until 25 March 2004. On the following day, 26 March 2004, Mallesons sent to APRA an email attaching the documents mentioned. From 9.00 am to 5.00 pm every day (except weekends and Public Holidays) between 2 March and 26 March 2004 inclusive in New South Wales and Queensland, and between 3 March and 26 March 2004 inclusive in every other Australian State and Territory, copies of the scheme, the notice of intention to apply, the summary of the scheme, the Portfolio Transfer Deed, the report and the supplementary report of Mr Coleman, both dated 25 February 2004, the 5 May 2003 and 19 January 2004 reports and the letter dated 19 February 2004 of Mr O’Dowd, were available for public inspection in every State and Territory at the locations which were advertised in the notice of intention. No one attended to inspect any of the documents, except for one person who attended the Queensland address.

Decision

Reasons for decision

LINDGREN J
Subsection 17F(2) of the Act provides that the Court may make such orders as it thinks fit in relation to reinsurance. The scheme itself provides that IAL, in place of SGIO, will become the reinsured under existing reinsurance treaties and arrangements. Section 17G of the Act provides that when a scheme is confirmed it becomes binding ‘on all persons’. Against the possibility, however, that this provision may not be effective to bind the reinsurers, the applicants seek a special order under s 17F(2) relating to reinsurance. In the circumstances I think it appropriate both to confirm the scheme generally and to make that order under s 17F(2).CONCLUSION It is appropriate to confirm the scheme and to make an order under s 17F(2).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: LINDGREN J

Full text does not contain this section.