FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Westport Insurance Corporation, in the matter of Westport Insurance Corporation (No 2) [2009] FCA 1598
INSURANCE – application for confirmation by Court of transfer of insurance business and reinsurance business of Australian branch of foreign company to Australian branches of two foreign companies – all three companies part of same group – interests of policyholders to be considered in exercise of Court’s discretion – s 17F(1A) of Insurance Act 1973 (Cth) introduced by Financial System Legislation Amendment (Financial Claims Scheme and Other Measures) Act 2008 (Cth) (No 105 2008) – whether Court required by para (a) of s 17F(1A) do have regard to the interest of overseas policyholders of foreign general insurer.
Insurance Act 1973 (Cth) ss 17B, 17C, 17F, 116, 116A
In the matter of GIO Personal Investment Services Ltd and AMP Life Ltd [2000] FCA 1871 referred to
In the matter of Reward Insurance Ltd [2004] FCA 151 referred to
Mercantile & General Reinsurance Company of Australia Ltd [2004] FCA 1773 discussed
PMI Indemnity Ltd [2005] FCA 1842 citedRe Armstrong Jones Life Assurance Limited (1997) 74 FCR 160 cited
Re Calliden Group Ltd [2007] FCA 2019 cited
Re Insurance Australia Ltd (2004) 139 FCR 450 referred to
Re MDU Australian Insurance Co Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 490 referred to
Re Royal & Sun Alliance Life Assurance Ltd (2000) 104 FCR 37 citedIN THE MATTER OF WESTPORT INSURANCE CORPORATION
(ABN 48 072 715 738)WESTPORT INSURANCE CORPORATION (ABN 48 072 715 738)
NSD 1220 of 2009
LINDGREN J
17 December 2009
SYDNEY
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
NSD 1220 of 2009
IN THE MATTER OF WESTPORT INSURANCE CORPORATION
(ABN 48 072 715 738)
The application of: WESTPORT INSURANCE CORPORATION
(ABN 48 072 715 738)
JUDGE:
LINDGREN J
DATEÂ OFÂ ORDER:
17 DECEMBER 2009
WHEREÂ MADE:
SYDNEY
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.Subject to order 2, pursuant to s 17F(1) of the Insurance Act 1973 (Cth) (the Act), the scheme for the transfer of the general insurance business of the Australian branch of the applicant (Westport) to the Australian branch of Swiss Re International SE (SRIAU and SRI respectively), in the form of Annexure A to these orders, be confirmed without modification.
2.Order 1 shall have effect only if, by 31 December 2009:
(a)the Missouri Department of Insurance, Financial Institutions & Professional Registration (the Regulator) issues a letter or other writing to the effect that it approves, or otherwise confirms that it has no objection to, the transfer of the business of issuing Insurance Contracts carried on by Westport in Australia to SRIAU, within the meaning and for the purposes of cl 2(c) of the Transfer Agreement dated 11 November 2009 between Westport and SRI; and
(b)Westport serves on the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority, with a copy to the Associate to Lindgren J, a letter or other writing issued by the Regulator satisfying para (a) above.
3.Subject to order 4, pursuant to s 17F(1) of the Act,…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Westport Insurance Corporation (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] FCA 1598
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that there were no objections to the schemes, which had been widely publicised, and that the transfer would rationalise the Swiss Re group's Australian operations. It noted that the transfer would lead to improved capital and operational efficiencies and a reduction in costs and expenses, without disadvantaging the policyholders. The court considered the actuarial reports which demonstrated that the solvency ratios of the entities involved would either remain stable or improve post-transfer, indicating no disadvantage to policyholders. The court concluded that the schemes were in the best interest of the policyholders and confirmed the schemes, subject to certain conditions being met by 31 December 2009.
The final orders of the court confirmed the schemes for the transfer of Westport's general insurance and reinsurance businesses to SRIAU and SRCAU respectively, subject to the conditions regarding approval from the Missouri Department of Insurance and notification to the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority. Westport was granted liberty to apply for further orders and was directed to pay the costs of APRA as agreed or, if necessary, as taxed.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. Subject to order 2, pursuant to s 17F(1) of the Insurance Act 1973 (Cth) (the Act), the scheme for the transfer of the general insurance business of the Australian branch of the applicant (Westport) to the Australian branch of Swiss Re International SE (SRIAU and SRI respectively), in the form of Annexure A to these orders, be confirmed without modification.
2. Order 1 shall have effect only if, by 31 December 2009:
(a) the Missouri Department of Insurance, Financial Institutions & Professional Registration (the Regulator) issues a letter or other writing to the effect that it approves, or otherwise confirms that it has no objection to, the transfer of the business of issuing Insurance Contracts carried on by Westport in Australia to SRIAU, within the meaning and for the purposes of cl 2(c) of the Transfer Agreement dated 11 November 2009 between Westport and SRI; and
(b) Westport serves on the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority, with a copy to the Associate to Lindgren J, a letter or other writing issued by the Regulator satisfying para (a) above.
3. Subject to order 4, pursuant to s 17F(1) of the Act, the scheme for the transfer of the reinsurance business of the Australian branch of Westport to the Australian branch of Swiss Reinsurance Company Limited (SRCAU and SRC respectively), in the form of Annexure B to these orders, be confirmed without modification.
4. Order 3 shall have effect only if, by 31 December 2009:
(a) the Regulator issues a letter or other writing to the effect that it approves, or otherwise confirms that it has no objection to, the transfer of the business of issuing Reinsurance Contracts carried on by Westport in Australia to SRCAU, within the meaning and for the purposes of cl 2(c) of the Transfer Agreement dated 11 November 2009 between Westport and SRC; and
(b) Westport serves on the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority, with a copy to the Associate to Lindgren J, a letter or other writing issued by the Regulator satisfying para (a) above.
5. Westport have liberty to apply on three hours’ notice.
6. Westport pay the costs of APRA as agreed or, if agreement cannot be reached, as taxed.
Note:
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: LINDGREN J
There is to be no change to the terms of any of Westport’s insurance or reinsurance policies other than the substitution of SRI or SRC as the insurer liable.The Schemes’ rationale The Schemes are part of a rationalisation or consolidation of the Swiss Re group’s Australian operations. The Australian policyholders of one Swiss Re group company (Westport) are transferred to other members of the group (SRI and SRC). In the result, the Swiss Re group’s insurance and reinsurance businesses in Australia will be carried on through separate entities. Several benefits are intended to be achieved through the transfer. It is expected that the legal structure of the group’s business in Australia will be simplified, and that there will be improved capital and operational efficiencies and a corresponding savings in costs and expenses. The Schemes will also permit the more efficient use of capital within the Swiss Re group of companies by facilitating the release of surplus capital currently held in Westport. It is intended that that capital will be repatriated and applied for the corporate purposes of the group. Westport intends, following the transfers under the Schemes, to apply to APRA to have its insurance authorisation under the Act revoked. It is planned that the capital remaining in Westport will be repatriated.Solvency The financial condition of Westport, SRCAU and SRIAU is set out in the actuarial reports. The following is a brief summary account of their effect.The Insurance Scheme(a) The current position is as follows:i.SRI does not currently carry on business in Australia, so no financial information exists in relation to SRIAU;ii. Westport had a solvency ratio of 232.9% as at 31 December 2008;iii. Westport had a pre-scheme solvency ratio of 252% as at 30 June 2009;iv.In the September quarter of 2009, with APRA approval, Westport repatriated A$70 million. If this reduction in capital is taken into account in the 30 June 2009 calculation of solvency, Westport’s solvency ratio would have been 158% as at that date.(b) It is calculated that following the transfer SRIAU will have a solvency ratio of 191%.(c)It follows that Westport’s direct insurance policyholders are expected to enjoy a higher solvency ratio (191%) following the transfer than they did previously (158%).The Reinsurance Scheme(a) The current position is as follows:i. SRCAU had a solvency ratio of 167.3% as at 31 December 2008;ii. SRCAU had a solvency ratio of 182% as at 30 June 2009;iii. Westport had a solvency ratio of 232.9% as at 31 December 2008;iv.Westport had a solvency ratio (once the A$70m repatriation is taken into account, as described above) of 158% as at 30 June 2009.(b)It is calculated that following the transfer SRCAU will have a solvency ratio of 160%.(c)It follows that Westport’s reinsurance policyholders are expected to enjoy an approximately equivalent (but probably slightly higher) solvency coverage ratio following the transfer (160% as against 158%). On the evidence, there is no disadvantage to the affected policyholders as a result of either Scheme.