AAI Limited, application under the Insurance Act 1973 (Cth)

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

AAI Limited, application under the Insurance Act 1973 (Cth) [2015] FCA 452

Citation: AAI Limited, application under the Insurance Act 1973 (Cth) [2015] FCA 452
Parties: AAI LIMITED (ABN 48 005 297 807)
File number(s): NSD 309 of 2015
Judge(s): YATES J
Date of judgment: 6 May 2015
Catchwords: INSURANCE – application under s 17C(5) of the Insurance Act 1973 (Cth) for dispensation from the requirements of s 17C(2) – application granted
Legislation: Insurance Act 1973 (Cth) s 17C
Cases cited: The Application of Commonwealth Life Ltd & Anor (2003) 12 ANZ Ins Cas ¶90-117
Challenger Life Limited
[2004] FCA 618
HDI-Gerling Australia Insurance Company Pty Limited, in the matter of HDI-Gerling Australia Insurance Company Pty Limited (ABN 16 069 985 196) [2010] FCA 505
Munich Reinsurance Company of Australasia Limited [2004] FCA 1391
Westport Insurance Corporation, in the matter of Westport Insurance Corporation [2009] FCA 1357
Date of hearing: 6 May 2015
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 28
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr IM Jackman SC
Solicitor for the Applicant: Minter Ellison
Solicitor for the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority: Mr D Sun

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 309 of 2015

THE APPLICATION OF AAI LIMITED (ABN 48 005 297 807)

AAI LIMITED (ABN 48 005 297 807)
Applicant

JUDGE:

YATES J

DATE OF ORDER:

6 MAY 2015

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.In relation to the following:

the proposed scheme (Scheme) for the transfer of the insurance business of MTA Insurance Limited ABN 35 070 583 701 (MTAI) to AAI Limited ABN 48 005 297 807 (AAI) under Part III Division 3A of the Insurance Act 1973 (Cth) (Act),

the need for the applicant to comply with section 17C(2)(c) of the Act is dispensed with provided that the Applicant complies with Order 2 below.

2.The applicant must carry out the following steps:

(a)on or shortly after 8 May 2015, email a copy of the summary of the Scheme approved by APRA for the purposes of section 17C of the Act (Approved Summary) to current policyholders of MTAI and current and former policyholders of MTAI with an open claim, for whom MTAI has an email address, to that email address;

(b)if any emails are returned as undeliverable, then send, as soon as reasonably practicable after the return, a copy of the Approved Summary by ordinary pre-paid post to the policyholders in question;

(c)on or shortly after 8 May 2015, send by ordinary pre-paid post a copy of the Approved Summary to current policyholders of MTAI and current and former policyholders of MTAI with an open claim, for whom MTAI has a postal address but no email address;

(d)if any posted material is returned as undeliverable, attempt (to the extent reasonably possible) to contact the dealer who distributed the policy, or Citigroup Pty Ltd ABN 88 004 325 080 (

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read AAI Limited, application under the Insurance Act 1973 (Cth) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FCA 452
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, AAI Limited applied under section 17C(5) of the Insurance Act 1973 (Cth) for dispensation from the requirements of section 17C(2) to provide an approved summary of a scheme to every affected policyholder. The scheme involves the transfer of the insurance business of MTA Insurance Limited to AAI Limited, a reorganisation within the Suncorp Group to achieve efficiencies in management. The primary dispute centres on whether AAI can be exempted from directly providing the approved summary to each policyholder, provided it undertakes specified notification steps instead.

The central legal issue was whether the Court should grant dispensation under section 17C(5) of the Insurance Act, allowing AAI to bypass the requirement to provide an approved summary of the scheme to every affected policyholder. This decision hinged on whether the proposed alternative notification steps were sufficient to inform and protect the interests of the policyholders. The Court had to balance the policy intention of ensuring policyholders are adequately informed against the practicalities and efficiencies proposed by AAI.

The Court granted the application for dispensation, finding that the proposed notification steps would adequately inform and protect the policyholders. The Court was satisfied that the notification procedures would elicit any potential objections to the scheme, given that only a small percentage of claims were made on expired policies. Additionally, the scheme was an internal reorganisation within the Suncorp Group that would not materially affect policyholders' interests, as indicated by the actuarial report. Consequently, the Court concluded that the alternative notification steps were sufficient to meet the statutory requirements while maintaining the policyholders' interests.

The Court ordered that the need for AAI to comply with section 17C(2)(c) of the Act is dispensed with, provided AAI complies with the outlined notification steps. These steps include emailing or posting the approved summary to current and former policyholders with open claims, advertising the scheme on a dedicated website, publishing a notice of intention in the Government Gazette and newspapers, notifying relevant motor dealers and Citigroup, and sending the approved summary to any new policyholders. The confirmation hearing of the scheme was set for 16 June 2015.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. In relation to the following:

the proposed scheme (Scheme) for the transfer of the insurance business of MTA Insurance Limited ABN 35 070 583 701 (MTAI) to AAI Limited ABN 48 005 297 807 (AAI) under Part III Division 3A of the Insurance Act 1973 (Cth) (Act),

the need for the applicant to comply with section 17C(2)(c) of the Act is dispensed with provided that the Applicant complies with Order 2 below.

2. The applicant must carry out the following steps:

(a) on or shortly after 8 May 2015, email a copy of the summary of the Scheme approved by APRA for the purposes of section 17C of the Act (Approved Summary) to current policyholders of MTAI and current and former policyholders of MTAI with an open claim, for whom MTAI has an email address, to that email address;

(b) if any emails are returned as undeliverable, then send, as soon as reasonably practicable after the return, a copy of the Approved Summary by ordinary pre-paid post to the policyholders in question;

(c) on or shortly after 8 May 2015, send by ordinary pre-paid post a copy of the Approved Summary to current policyholders of MTAI and current and former policyholders of MTAI with an open claim, for whom MTAI has a postal address but no email address;

(d) if any posted material is returned as undeliverable, attempt (to the extent reasonably possible) to contact the dealer who distributed the policy, or Citigroup Pty Ltd ABN 88 004 325 080 (Citigroup) in relation to the Suncorp Credit Guard product, to the relevant policyholder to obtain a current email or, if not available, postal address and send, as soon as reasonably practicable, a further copy of that material by email or ordinary pre-paid post (as applicable) to the policyholder;

(e) advertise the Scheme, in terms of Annexure A to this Order, on the website www.schemesummary.com.au with links on that website to a copy of:

(i) the Approved Summary;

(ii) the notice of intention to make the Application to the Court for confirmation of the Scheme, in the terms of Annexure B to this Order (Notice of Intention);

(iii) the Scheme; and

(iv) the actuarial report of Tim Andrews of Finity Consulting Pty Limited dated April 2015 and supplementary letter dated 16 April 2015,

from the day after the Notice of Intention is published in accordance with order 2(f) below, until the date of the confirmation hearing of the Scheme referred to in paragraph 3 below and include links to the website www.schemesummary.com.au on the websites of the Applicant and MTAI, and the webpage of the website of Suncorp-Metway Limited ABN 66 010 831 722 that relates to credit cards, for the same period;

(f) on or shortly after 8 May 2015, publish the Notice of Intention in the Government Gazette and in newspapers circulating in the areas where the current and former policyholders of MTAI acquired their policies, in accordance with the newspaper notification programme in Annexure C to this Order;

(g) on or shortly after 8 May 2015, notify by email or ordinary pre-paid post:

(i) motor dealers responsible for distributing the policies that are the subject of the Scheme; and

(ii) Citigroup in relation to the Suncorp Credit Guard product,

providing the Approved Summary by a link (if emailed) or a physical copy (if sent by post); and

(h) if MTAI issues any new policies to policyholders (future policyholders) on or after 6 May 2015 but before the confirmation hearing of the Scheme, then send a copy of the Approved Summary to each of the future policyholders:

(i) by email; or

(ii) by ordinary pre-paid post for future policyholders whom MTAI has a postal address but no email address,

as soon as practicable, from the day after the Notice of Intention is published in accordance with order 2(f) above, until the date of the confirmation hearing of the Scheme referred to in paragraph 3 below.

3. The confirmation hearing of the Scheme to be returnable before Yates J on 16 June 2015 at 2.15 pm.

4. The applicant pay the costs of the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority as agreed or, if agreement cannot be reached, as assessed.

5. These orders be entered forthwith.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Its present application, made under s 17C(5) of the Act, is for dispensation with the need for compliance with s 17C(2)(c) of the Act—which requires an approved summary of the scheme to be given to every affected policyholder—provided certain other steps, by way of notification, are undertaken. I will discuss these steps in more detail below.Background AAI and MTAI are each authorised by the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA) to carry on a general insurance business. On 29 August 2014, AAI purchased MTAI’s issued share capital, such that MTAI is now a wholly-owned subsidiary of AAI. Both AAI and MTAI are companies within the Suncorp Group. The ultimate holding company of the Suncorp Group is Suncorp Group Limited. The proposed scheme to transfer the insurance business of MTAI to AAI is part of an internal reorganisation within the Suncorp Group intended to achieve, amongst other things, efficiencies in management. The proposed effective date of the scheme, subject to obtaining the Court’s confirmation, is 1 July 2015. The policies of insurance to be transferred fall into two broad groups. The first group comprises the following:·Loan Protection Insurance. Under these policies, loan repayments with respect to a motor vehicle, the purchase or lease of which has been financed, may be insured against the risk of disablement, accidental injury, involuntary unemployment, trauma or death. The involuntary unemployment component of these policies is underwritten by MTAI. The other components are underwritten by Suncorp Life & Superannuation Limited (SLSL).·Equity/Equity Plus Insurance. Under these policies, a policyholder is insured against the risk of a shortfall between the residual amount payable under a finance contract and the amount payable under the policyholder’s comprehensive motor vehicle insurance in the event that a vehicle is written off as a total loss.·Cash Benefit Insurance. Under these policies, a policyholder is insured for a pre-agreed sum if the policyholder’s motor vehicle, comprehensively insured on a market value basis, is written off by the motor vehicle insurer as a total loss. ·Marine Equity Insurance. These policies have similar wording to the policies for Equity Insurance for motor vehicles, with references to “motor vehicle” replaced with the term “boat”. MTAI has also issued policies for extended warranty insurance and tyre and rim insurance. These products were discontinued or withdrawn from the market in 2009 and 2013, respectively. Each of the policies in this first group provides for a once only premium. The policies are short tail in nature. No policy has a term greater than 7 years. The policies are distributed through motor vehicle dealers pursuant to distribution agreements. Generally, the services of dealers, as provided in the distribution agreements, include the provision of general advice and product information in relation to the policies. MTAI also engages a number of these dealers to market its policies through merchandising and promotional agreements, which generally make provision for the delivery of merchandising and promotional services such as displaying MTAI signs or logos, distributing written materials and providing a link to MTAI’s website.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Court should grant AAI Limited dispensation from the requirement to provide an approved summary of the scheme to every affected policyholder under section 17C(2)(c) of the Insurance Act 1973 (Cth).
2. If dispensation is granted, what alternative notification steps must AAI Limited undertake to ensure affected policyholders are adequately informed about the scheme.

Held
1. The Court granted AAI Limited dispensation from the requirement to provide an approved summary of the scheme to every affected policyholder under section 17C(2)(c) of the Insurance Act 1973 (Cth), on the condition that AAI Limited complies with certain alternative notification steps.
2. The Court ordered AAI Limited to undertake several alternative notification steps to ensure affected policyholders are adequately informed about the scheme, including emailing and posting summaries to policyholders, advertising the scheme, notifying relevant parties, and updating future policyholders.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Fourthly, AAI proposes to notify Citigroup of the scheme by email or ordinary pre-paid post and provide Citigroup with a copy of the approved summary by a link (if sent by email) or a physical copy (if sent by post). This notification will include details about where customers can find more information about the scheme or request a copy of the approved summary. The form of the notification will be substantially in the form of annexure JD-18 to a further affidavit made by Jamie Dobbs affirmed 30 April 2015.Consideration The granting of dispensation pursuant to s 17C(5) of the Act is a matter of considerable importance and should not be regarded as a matter of course: Challenger Life Limited [2004] FCA 618 at [2]-[3]; Munich Reinsurance Company of Australasia Limited [2004] FCA 1391 at [4]. The plain policy intention is that every affected policyholder should be given a summary of the scheme and an opportunity to make submissions to the Court in respect of the scheme at a confirmation hearing: The Application of Commonwealth Life Ltd & Anor (2003) 12 ANZ Ins Cas ¶90-117 at [8]; see also Westport Insurance Corporation, in the matter of Westport Insurance Corporation [2009] FCA 1357 at [38]; HDI-Gerling Australia Insurance Company Pty Limited, in the matter of HDI-Gerling Australia Insurance Company Pty Limited (ABN 16 069 985 196) [2010] FCA 505 at [38]-[39]. Nevertheless, I am satisfied that it is appropriate in the present case to grant the conditional dispensation that is sought. I am satisfied that, because of the nature of the scheme and the circumstances attending its preparation, it is not necessary that the approved summary be given to every affected policyholder as contemplated by s 17C(2)(c) of the Act. First, I am satisfied that the notification procedures proposed by AAI will elicit any potential, reasonably-based objection to the scheme. In this connection, I take into account that notice will be given to all current policyholders, and all former policyholders with an open claim. As the evidence indicates, in relation to the first group of policies, only a very small (almost insignificant) percentage of claims made and accepted in the period 1 January 2007 to 31 December 2014 were with respect to policies that had expired. In relation to the second group of policies, only 21 involuntary unemployment claims (all from 2010 to 2015) were made. None of these claims were received after the policy had expired. I also take into account the other notification steps which AAI proposes, which are directed to all affected policyholders. Secondly, the transfer to be effected by the scheme is one internal to the Suncorp Group. The scheme will not result in any changes to policy terms and conditions for affected policyholders or result in any changes to the claim processes presently undertaken. The only change will be to the identity of the insurer within the group. The opinion expressed in the actuarial report provided by Finity Consulting Pty Limited is that the interests of the policyholders of both AAI and MTAI will not be adversely affected in any material way by reason of the scheme.