R v Taylor & Napatali; ex parte A-G (Qld)

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL [1999] QCA 323
SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
Brisbane
[R v Taylor & Napatali; Ex Parte A-G]

T H E Q U E E N

v

BEAU LINCOLN TAYLOR

- and -

RUBEN JOSEPH NAPATALI

Respondents

EX PARTE ATTORNEY-GENERAL OF QUEENSLAND

Appellant

McMurdo P
McPherson JA

Thomas JA

Judgment delivered 20 August 1999

Separate reasons for judgment of each member of the Court; each concurring as to the order made.

ATTORNEY-GENERAL'S APPEAL AGAINST SENTENCE DISMISSED.

CATCHWORDS: CRIMINAL LAW - Jurisdiction, Practice and Procedure - Pleas -

Robbery - Aggravation - Sentencing - Whether young offenders with no prior convictions should be sentenced to mandatory imprisonment

Criminal Code (Qld), s409

Penalties and Sentences Act (Qld) 1992, S9

Bainbridge, Cullen & Ludwicki (1993) 74 A Crim R 265
House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499
Lahey v Sanderson [1959] Tas SR 17
R v del Arco (CA 289/1993, 25 March 1994)
R v Fitzgerald (Indictment No 2500/ 1992, Trafford-Walker DCJ, 11
Dec 1992)
R v Lovell [1999] 2 Qd R 79

Counsel:  Mr P Keane QC, with him P Rutledge, for the appellant
Mr M Shanahan for the respondent Taylor
Mr P Leask for the respondent Napatali
Solicitors:  Director of Public Prosecutions (Queensland) for the appellant
Legal Aid Queensland for the respondents
Hearing Date:  9 July 1999

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - McMURDO P

Judgment delivered 20 August 1999

  1. I have read the reasons for judgment of McPherson JA, who has set out the

    relevant facts.

  2. The courts have long recognised the desirability of not sending youthful offenders without prior convictions to prison because of the chances of favourable reformation.[1] The schedule of sentences imposed in armed robbery cases on 17 year olds between 1988 and 1992 referred to in R v Bainbridge, Cullen & Ludwicki[2] shows that at that time where the offender had no relevant previous convictions only seven of the 24 matters included in the schedule involved custodial sentences and three of these were for six months or less. The Court there noted that s 9(4) of the Penalties & Sentences Act 1992 gave legislative support for the view that youthful first offenders should not be incarcerated unless no other sentence was appropriate in all the circumstances.

    [1]            R v Price [1978] QdR 68

    [2] (1993) 74 A Crim R 265

  3. That section was repealed in 1997 when substantial amendments were made to the Penalties & Sentences Act 1992.

  4. Sentencing guidelines are set out for the Court in s 9 and include:

"(b) to provide conditions in the court's order that the court
considers will help the offender to be rehabilitated."

Section 9(2) provides:

"In sentencing an offender, a court must have regard to -

(a) principles that -

(i)

a sentence of imprisonment should only be imposed as a last resort; and

(ii)

a sentence that allows the offender to stay in the community is preferable."

Section 9(3) provides:

"... the principles mentioned in subsection (2)(a) do not apply to the

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Taylor & Napatali; ex parte A-G (Qld) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] QCA 323
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involves an appeal by the Attorney-General against sentences imposed on Beau Lincoln Taylor and Ruben Joseph Napatali by the District Court at Beenleigh, arguing that the sentences are inadequate. The respondents were convicted for robbing a service station at gunpoint, during which Napatali held a rifle to the head of a customer while Taylor demanded the money and threatened the cashier. The appeal was brought on the grounds that the sentences were not sufficiently severe given the nature of the offence.

The legal issue before the court was whether the sentences imposed by the District Court were adequate in the circumstances of the case. The appeal hinged on whether the court had given appropriate weight to the severity of the armed robbery and the impact on the victims.

The court found that the sentences were indeed inadequate and were below the minimum sentences required by statute for such an offence. The appeal was allowed, and the case was remitted to the District Court for re-sentencing. The court emphasised the need for sentences that reflect the seriousness of the offence and its impact on the victims, as well as the need for general deterrence.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I agree that the appeal should be dismissed. REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - McPHERSON JA Judgment delivered 20 August 1999 [4] See R v Melano ex parte Attorney-General [1995] 2 QdR 186 This is an appeal by the Attorney-General against sentences imposed in the District Court at Beenleigh on the ground that they are inadequate. At about 8 pm on 27 October 1998 Ms Sonja White, aged 28, was on duty in the course of her employment at the Ampol 24-hour Service Station at Kingston. She was busy serving a customer Adam Walsh, aged 18, when the two respondents to this appeal came into the service station shop. They were holding guns. One, who was the respondent Ruben Joseph Napatali, was holding a single barrelled rifle. He was wearing a baseball cap, but his face was uncovered and Ms White recognised him as a regular customer of the shop. The other was the respondent Beau Lincoln Taylor. He was holding what appeared to be a pistol. He had a bandanna on his head, but his face was also uncovered. Napatali first pointed the rifle in the direction of Ms White. He then jammed it at the back of Adam Walsh's head. Taylor said "give us your fucking money". He held out a white shopping bag, telling Ms White to hurry up and put the money there. She did what she was told. She suspected that the pistol held by Taylor was a replica (as indeed it was) but she was afraid to take any preventive action while the other respondent Napatali had his gun at Walsh's head. She put the money in the bag, and the two respondents ran out of the shop. They apparently escaped on foot. Once they had gone, she locked the doors and called the police. The amount of money taken was about $600. The reason why there was so much in the cash register at the time was that the service station shop had been too busy to enable Ms White to carry out a periodic clearance of the register before the respondents came in. That was on 27 October 1998. Two days later Ms White was again on duty in the shop when a young woman with a child came in to purchase some confectionery. Accompanying her was a man whom Ms White recognised as one of the respondents who had been involved in the offence only two days before. She ascertained he was called Joey. After he left the shop, she engaged in conversation with the young woman, who told her that his surname was Napatali. The police were advised and conducted a search of Napatali's house in Woodridge. He gave them the name of his co-offender Taylor, who was located at home. A search conducted there uncovered a rifle buried in the yard. It lacked a firing pin, and so was incapable of being fired; but Ms White and Adam Walsh had, of course, no means of knowing that at the time it was used to menace them. The police interviewed the respondents, each of whom made full and frank confessions of having committed the offence. Napatali said they had been drinking together when they formed the idea of robbing a service station. They obtained the weapons, including the replica pistol, from Taylor's place. Napatali remembered placing the muzzle of the rifle against the back of the customer's head. Afterwards they went to Taylor's place where they divided the proceeds. Napatali spent his share of the money on cigarettes and food. Taylor confirmed Napatali's account of events. He spent his share on marijuana. He buried the rifle in the back yard to prevent its being found and threw the replica pistol into the creek.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.