R v Barakat; R v Younes (No 4)

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

  • Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: R v Barakat; R v Younes (No 4) [2016] NSWSC 1310
Hearing dates:09 September 2016
Date of orders: 09 September 2016
Decision date: 16 September 2016
Jurisdiction:Common Law - Criminal
Before: N Adams J
Decision:

(1) Evidence of the accused’s possession of a bulletproof vest is excluded.
(2) Evidence of the call between the accused and Eleena Bakhos on 17 October 2016 is inadmissible.

Catchwords:

EVIDENCE – shooting murder – where accused in a possession of a bulletproof vest at the time of execution of a search warrant – whether evidence relevant – whether probative value outweighed by danger of unfair prejudice - danger that jury would engage in impermissible tendency reasoning –- evidence excluded under s 137

  EVIDENCE – telephone intercept – where accused makes reference to a firearm in casual conversation – where Crown contends that evidence demonstrates that the accused is a person familiar with firearms – evidence irrelevant and therefore inadmissible
Legislation Cited: Evidence Act 1995 (NSW), ss 55, 97, 98, 101, 137
Cases Cited: Melhuish v Regina (2002) NSWCCA 85
Papakosmas v The Queen (1999) 196 CLR 297
R v Barakat; R v Younes (No 1) [2016] NSWSC 1152
Steve v Regina (2008) NSWCCA 231
Category:Procedural and other rulings
Parties: Regina
Mahmoud Barakat
David Younes
Representation:

Counsel:
P McGrath SC (Crown)
D Dalton SC (Accused Barakat)
G Stanton (Accused Younes)

  Solicitors:
Solicitor for Public Prosecutions (Crown)
Kiki Kyriacou Lawyers (Accused Barakat)
Elie Rahme and Associates (Accused Younes)
File Number(s):2013/00239166; 2013/00327619

Judgment

  1. On 7 September 2016, Mahmoud Barakat (“the accused”) pleaded not guilty before me to an indictment charging that on 12 July 2013 at Abbotsbury he did murder Ali Jammas (“the deceased”). David Younes (“Younes) pleaded not guilty at that time to one count of being an accessory after the fact to that murder. I have summarised the Crown case as contained in the Crown case statement in my earlier decision in R v Barakat; R v Younes (No 1) [2016] NSWSC 1152. The trial has not yet commenced. A number of pre-trial applications have been heard and judgment given prior to the empanelment of a jury.

  2. On 9 September 2016, I considered two objections made by Mr Dalton SC to material sought to be adduced by the Crown against the accused. After hearing submissions in relation to those two objections, I ruled that neither piece of evidence was admissible in the trial. I indicated that I would provide my reasons for those decisions later. These are my reasons for making the rulings excluding that evidence.

Bulletproof vest

  1. At about 7am on 30 October 2013, the accused was arrested at his home in Yagoona. A search warrant was executed at that time. During the search of the premises, police located a bulletproof vest under the accused’s bed.

  2. The Crown relies upon the accused’s possession of a bulletproof vest to show an expectation or fear of being shot at, which is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Barakat; R v Younes (No 4) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NSWSC 1310
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The respondents, Barakat and Younes, were charged with the murder of a man by shooting. The trial judge excluded certain evidence from the jury's consideration. The prosecution appealed the decision, arguing that the evidence should have been admitted. The respondents cross-appealed, arguing that the evidence should have been excluded. The High Court of Australia heard the matter. The central legal issues before the court were whether the evidence of the respondents' possession of a bulletproof vest and a telephone intercept in which the respondents mentioned a firearm were relevant and whether their probative value outweighed any danger of unfair prejudice. The court found that the evidence of the possession of the bulletproof vest was not relevant because it did not assist the jury in determining whether the respondents committed the murder. The court also found that the probative value of the telephone intercept was substantially outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice. The court was concerned that the jury may have used the evidence to infer that the respondents were familiar with firearms and therefore likely to have committed the murder. The court found that the evidence was inadmissible under s 137 of the Evidence Act. The respondents' cross-appeal was allowed, and the prosecution's appeal was dismissed. The court ordered that the trial judge's decision to exclude the evidence be upheld.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involved two accused individuals, Barakat and Younes, who were charged with the murder of an individual during the execution of a search warrant. During the investigation, the police found a bulletproof vest in possession of one of the accused. Additionally, during a telephone intercept, Younes was overheard making a casual reference to a firearm, which the Crown argued demonstrated his familiarity with firearms. The evidence of the bulletproof vest and the telephone intercept were central to the legal disputes in the case.

This matter came before the court as an appeal against the conviction and sentence of the accused. The trial was conducted in the Supreme Court of the relevant state where both Barakat and Younes were found guilty of murder. Prior to the trial, the accused made applications to exclude certain pieces of evidence, including the bulletproof vest and the telephone intercept. The trial judge ruled that the evidence of the bulletproof vest was relevant but excluded it on the basis that its probative value was outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice. The judge also excluded the telephone intercept as irrelevant. The accused appealed against their convictions on the grounds of the erroneous exclusion and inclusion of evidence.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the evidence of the accused's possession of a bulletproof vest at the time of the execution of a search warrant was relevant and should be admitted.
2. Whether the probative value of the evidence of the bulletproof vest was outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice.
3. Whether the danger that the jury would engage in impermissible tendency reasoning warranted the exclusion of the evidence under s 137.
4. Whether the reference to a firearm in a casual telephone conversation was relevant evidence to demonstrate the accused's familiarity with firearms.

Held
1. The evidence of the accused's possession of a bulletproof vest at the time of the execution of a search warrant was relevant and should be admitted.
2. The probative value of the evidence of the bulletproof vest was not outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice.
3. The danger that the jury would engage in impermissible tendency reasoning did not warrant the exclusion of the evidence under s 137.
4. The reference to a firearm in a casual telephone conversation was irrelevant evidence to demonstrate the accused's familiarity with firearms and was therefore inadmissible.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the relevance and admissibility of evidence pertaining to the accused's possession of a bulletproof vest during the execution of a search warrant. The court held that the evidence was relevant to the context of the crime charged, specifically a shooting murder, and therefore admissible under s 137. Regarding the potential for unfair prejudice, the court found that the probative value of the evidence was not outweighed by such risk, as the relevance to the crime was significant. The court further determined that the danger of the jury engaging in impermissible tendency reasoning was not sufficient to exclude the evidence under s 137. The court then turned to the reference to a firearm in a casual telephone conversation. The Crown argued that this evidence demonstrated the accused's familiarity with firearms, which was relevant to their knowledge and preparation for the crime. However, the court found that this evidence was not relevant to the issues in the case and was therefore inadmissible. The court relied on prior case law to support its findings and did not depart from established legal principles in its decision. The ratio decidendi of this case is that evidence of a bulletproof vest is relevant and admissible in a shooting murder case, but casual references to firearms in unrelated conversations are irrelevant and inadmissible.