R v Melhuish

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEAL

CITATION:      Regina v William John Melhuish [2002]  NSWCCA 85

FILE NUMBER(S):
60217/2001

HEARING DATE(S):               8 March 2002

JUDGMENT DATE: 08/03/2002

PARTIES:
Regina
William John Melhuish

JUDGMENT OF:       Stein JA O'Keefe J Buddin J   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: District Court

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):          00/11/0806

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:     Shillington DCJ

COUNSEL:
GI Rowling (Crown)
DN Stewart (Applicant)

SOLICITORS:
SE O'Connor (Crown)
Ross Hill & Associates (Applicant)

CATCHWORDS:
Possession of firearms - denied knowledge of same - alleged error in failure to exclude finding of gun holster - Rule 4 - affidavit from trial counsel - proviso considered - application for leave to appeal against severity of sentence - cumulative sentence

LEGISLATION CITED:
Criminal Appeal Act 1912 (NSW)
Drugs Misuse and Trafficking Act 1985
Evidence Act
Firearms Act 1996

DECISION:
Appeal against conviction dismissed.  Leave to appeal granted.  Appeal against sentence dismissed.

JUDGMENT:

IN THE COURT OF
CRIMINAL APPEAL

60217/01

STEIN JA
O’KEEFE J
BUDDIN J

Friday 8 March 2002

REGINA v WILLIAM MELHUISH

Judgment

  1. BUDDIN J:  The appellant faced trial upon an indictment containing the following six counts:

    1On 4 May 2000 at Brookvale in the State of New South Wales, did supply a prohibited drug, namely methylamphetamine, in that he did have in his possession an amount of the prohibited drug which was not less than the trafficable quantity.

    2On 4 May 2000 at Brookvale in the State of New South Wales, did possess a firearm, namely a .38 calibre Smith & Wesson revolver, serial number J197863, without being authorised to do so by a licence or permit.

    3On 4 May 2000 at Brookvale in the State of New South Wales, did possess a firearm, namely a .38 calibre Astra revolver, serial number R280859, without being authorised to do so by a licence or permit.

    4On 4 May 2000 at Brookvale in the State of New South Wales, did possess a firearm, namely a Fabrique Nationale pistol, serial number unknown, without being authorised to do so by a licence or permit.

    5On 4 May 2000 at Brookvale in the State of New South Wales, did possess a firearm, namely a Belgian manufacture revolver, serial number unknown, without being authorised to do so by a licence or permit.

    6On 4 May 2000 at Brookvale in the State of New South Wales, did possess a firearm, namely a .22 calibre pen pistol, without being authorised to do so by a licence or permit.

  2. In the absence of the jury panel the appellant pleaded guilty to the first count in the indictment. He was then convicted by a jury in respect of the remaining five counts. Each of those charges carries a maximum penalty pursuant to s 7 of the Firearms Act 1996, of 10 years’ imprisonment. 

  3. The quantity of methyl amphetamine was 20.29 grams. Pursuant to s 32(1) of the Drug Misuse and Trafficking Act 1985 that offence exposes  an offender to a maximum penalty of 2000 penalty units and/or 15 years’ imprisonment. The appellant…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Melhuish and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] NSWCCA 85
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of R v Melhuish involved the appellant who was convicted of various firearm offences. The appellant sought to appeal against the severity of his sentence, arguing that the trial judge had erred in failing to exclude evidence of a shoulder holster found in his bedroom. The appellant contended that the holster was not capable of carrying the firearms in question, and that its admission had unfairly prejudiced the jury against him. The appeal was heard in the New South Wales Court of Criminal Appeal.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the trial judge had erred in admitting evidence of the shoulder holster. The appellant argued that the trial judge should have excluded this evidence under the discretionary powers available to him. The Crown maintained that the trial judge's decision was correct and that the evidence was properly admitted as it was relevant to the appellant's possession of firearms.

The court considered the affidavit from the appellant's trial counsel, which stated that the counsel had examined a similar holster prior to the trial and found it capable of carrying the firearms in question. The court held that the trial counsel had turned his mind to the issue and had a reasonable basis for not objecting to the evidence. The court further noted that the appellant's counsel had not objected to the evidence at any stage of the trial, and therefore, the rule barring objections not raised at trial applied. The court concluded that the trial judge had not erred in admitting the evidence of the shoulder holster.

The court dismissed the appeal against the severity of the sentence, finding that the trial judge's decision to admit the evidence of the shoulder holster was not an error. The court observed that the evidence was relevant and did not unfairly prejudice the appellant. Consequently, the cumulative sentence imposed on the appellant was upheld.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

At the outset of the trial, counsel then appearing for the appellant submitted that the first count in the indictment should be severed upon the basis that the appellant intended to plead guilty to it. The Crown nonetheless sought to rely upon the evidence relating to the discovery of the drugs in support of its case upon the various firearm charges. In those circumstances counsel for the appellant sought a ruling, pursuant to s 137 of the Evidence Act, from the trial judge that the evidence concerning the drugs, and associated paraphernalia such as scales, plastic bags and money associated with drugs, all of which were located in his bedroom, should be excluded. After hearing full argument upon the matter his Honour ruled in the appellant’s favour. The transcript records what then occurred: CROWN PROSECUTOR: Sorry your Honour, there’s another matter. Police found a shoulder-holster in his bedroom. Is your Honour allowing that evidence?HIS HONOUR: I would think so, yes.BAKER: I didn’t make any application on that so --.HIS HONOUR: I think you can take it that other items which have relevance to the guns would be not subject to objection. It is quite clear in the circumstances that counsel, then appearing for the appellant, raised no objection to the reception of the evidence which is now sought to be challenged. It can be readily inferred that counsel, who is a very experienced and capable practitioner in the field, had turned his mind to the question and had concluded that there was no proper basis upon which he could object to the evidence. Nor did counsel, it might be observed, see fit to object to the evidence at any subsequent stage of the trial. Prima facie rule 4 applies. Counsel who appeared for the appellant in this Court, sought to rely upon an affidavit sworn by Robert Anthony Baker, dated 5 March 2002, who was counsel at the trial. The Court received the affidavit. Set out below are the relevant parts of that affidavit:2. In the preparation and conduct of his defence, I was of the opinion that the evidence of the finding by the Police of a shoulder holster in Mr Melhuish's bedroom was relevant to the issue of his alleged possession of the firearms found in a camera case in that room and, therefore, admissible.3. The discretionary exclusion of such evidence depended, in my opinion, on the resolution of the question as to whether the shoulder holster was capable of carrying any of the firearms found in the camera case, subject of the respective counts in the indictment.4. In the week prior to the commencement of the trial Mr Melhuish, as requested, purchased an apparently identical shoulder holster from the party-hire shop from which he had originally bought the shoulder holster located by the Police.5. On the morning of 26 March 2001 before the trial commenced, my instructing Solicitor, Mr Ronald Jenkins and I, in the presence of Mr Melhuish, examined the more recently purchased shoulder holster in an interview room at the Downing Centre Court Complex.6. As a result of our examination, I was of the opinion that, although the shoulder holster was apparently a cheap, vinyl item for fancy dress party wear and was not a sturdy and well-manufactured article, nonetheless, it was capable of carrying a firearm of the types found in the camera case. Mr Jenkins was of the same opinion.7. I, therefore, concluded that there were no grounds to object to the tender of the shoulder holster found by the Police and, accordingly, I did not do so.