QB4 Capital Pty Limited v Guardian Securities Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QB4 Capital Pty Limited v Guardian Securities Limited [2022] FCA 262

File numbers: NSD 470 of 2020
NSD 99 of 2021
Judgment of: LEE J
Date of judgment: 22 March 2022
Catchwords:

CORPORATIONS – registered managed investment scheme – dispute between responsible entity of registered investment scheme and investment manager – legitimacy of payments made from trust property – whether payments authorised under trust constitution – whether management fees and legal costs properly incurred – whether invoices should be paid from the trust property of the registered investment scheme – where receivers appointed – whether unit trusts ought to be wound up

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – where list of agreed issues for determination – application by applicant for leave to amend further amended originating application and fourth further amended statement of claim – where proposed amendments seek to bring new derivative claim – where application foreshadowed on final day of hearing –amendment unnecessary

EQUITY – breach of trust – equitable compensation –declaratory relief – hostile litigation concerning property held on trust – whether responsible entity breached trust – whether unitholders have standing to seek equitable compensation – whether unitholders beneficiaries of trust

EQUITY – cross-claim for declaratory relief – whether responsible entity entitled to rely on rights of indemnity – whether management fees and legal costs properly incurred

CONTRACT – payments made under deed of settlement – where Guardian defaulted under deed of settlement – where deed of settlement subsequently terminated – where Guardian sought repayment of money as a result of failure of consideration and mistake

RESTITUTION – recovery – whether total failure of consideration – whether partial performance either insubstantial or severable

COSTS – significant costs – where responsible entity intentionally defaulted under settlement deed – where settlement deed terminated – whether non-party personally liable for costs

Legislation:

Australian Securities and Investments Act 2001 (Cth)

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) Pts 5C.1, 5C.9, 7.9; ss 601FB, 601FC, 601FC(2), 601GA, 601GA(2), 601MA

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 136

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 21, 22, 37M, 37P(2), 53A, 54A

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 9.21

Trustee Act 1925 (NSW) s 59(4)

Cases cited:

Adsett v Berlouis (1992) 37 FCR 201

Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australia National University [2009] HCA 27; (2009) 239 CLR 175

Australian Financial Services and Leasing Pty Limited v Hills Industries Limited [2014] HCA 14; (2014) 253 CLR 560

Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd v Londish [2013] NSWSC 1423

AWB Limited v Honourable Terence Rhoderic Hudson Cole (No 6) [2006] FCA 1274; (2006) 235 ALR 307

Baltic Shipping Co v Dillon (1993) 176 CLR 344

Bruce & Anor v LM Investment Management Limited & Ors (No 2) [2013] QSC 347

David Securities Pty Ltd v Commonwealth Bank of Australia (1992) 175 CLR 353

DFCT v Hadidi (1994) 51 FCR 453

Dunghutti Elders Council (Aboriginal Corporation) RNTBC v Registrar of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Corporations (No 4) [2012] FCAFC 50; (2012)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read QB4 Capital Pty Limited v Guardian Securities Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCA 262
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

QB4 Capital Pty Limited, the trustee and responsible entity of the TGIF, and Guardian Securities Limited, the investment manager of the TGIF, are the parties in dispute. The main issues revolve around the legitimacy of payments made from the trust property, whether these payments were authorised under the trust constitution, if management fees and legal costs were properly incurred, and whether invoices should be paid from the trust property of the registered investment scheme. The case also considers whether the unit trusts should be wound up and if there is a liability in contract to repay amounts under the Settlement Deed. Additionally, the case examines whether Guardian is entitled to recover outstanding invoices from Fundus Trust No 1 and Fundus Trust No 2 for invoices issued before and after the appointment of receivers.

The court was required to decide whether Guardian Securities Limited is liable to pay equitable compensation for amounts allegedly paid or accrued in breach of trust. It also had to determine if the QB4 Parties have standing to seek equitable compensation against Guardian for the alleged breaches, and if Guardian committed a breach or breaches of trust. The court had to consider whether the expenses incurred by Guardian as trustee were properly incurred, if Guardian is entitled to rely on rights of indemnity, and whether the management fees and legal costs were properly incurred. Furthermore, the court had to decide if QB4 Capital is liable to repay the amounts it received under the Settlement Deed, if Guardian is entitled to restitutionary relief, and if the remedy of set-off is available to Guardian.

The court found that the costs of the receivers were appropriate given the tasks they were burdened with and the reports produced. The court considered it appropriate for the receivers to apply retrospectively for their remuneration and expenses to be approved. However, the court emphasized that costs should be minimized. The court proposed to make an order referring the parties to mediation to bring the long and contentious saga to an end. The court believed that if the parties could not resolve their differences sensibly, the mediation process might at least reduce the ambit of any dispute over the relief to reflect the court's findings and reasons. The court ordered that the parties file an agreed minute or competing minutes of order reflecting these reasons within seven days of the completion of the mediation.

The court found that Guardian Securities Limited is liable to pay equitable compensation for the amounts allegedly paid or accrued in breach of trust. The QB4 Parties were found to have standing to seek equitable compensation against Guardian for the pleaded breaches, and the court determined that Guardian had committed breaches of trust. The court also found that the expenses incurred by Guardian as trustee were not properly incurred, and Guardian was not entitled to rely on rights of indemnity. The court ruled that QB4 Capital is liable to repay the amounts it received under the Settlement Deed, and Guardian is not entitled to restitutionary relief or the remedy of set-off.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to s 53A of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), the whole of the proceedings be referred to mediation to be conducted by a Registrar of the Court in person and, to the extent the mediator considers it desirable, without the presence of lawyers, with such mediation to take place within 28 days.

2. In the event other orders resolving the dispute cannot be agreed at the mediation, within seven days of the conclusion of the mediation, the parties file an agreed minute or competing minutes of order to reflect these reasons.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

As will become clear, in the process of litigating these issues, considerable fees have been spent. One question that falls for the Court to decide is who ultimately is to settle the bill. B BACKGROUND Before turning to the relevant factual background, it is useful to detail at the outset the context surrounding the confined issues that now fall for determination. As I indicated above, the procedural history of this matter is byzantine. Although the only proceedings that remain are NSD470/2020 and NSD99/2021, the matter (to use that word in its Constitutional sense) has involved the following proceedings: (1)proceeding NSD415/2020 (Pre-action Relief Application);(2)proceeding NSD470/2020 (Principal Proceeding);(3)proceeding QUD226/2020 (Judicial Advice Proceeding);(4)proceeding QLD3617/2020 (Queensland District Court Proceeding); and(5)proceeding NSD99/2021 (Legal Costs Proceeding). Upon the commencement of the hearing on 4 May 2021, I raised with the parties the difficulties with the tsunami of issues that appeared to arise from the miscellany of pleadings and written submissions, the most obvious of which was that it was unclear to me, and perhaps also to the parties, what precisely it was that the Court was being asked to determine: T2.19–26. Accordingly, I directed the parties to identify each of the issues that remained relevant and to provide an agreed list of issues for determination. I made clear that this document would replace, or at least refine, the pleadings to the extent the pleadings identified the issues to be resolved. Apart from anything else, such a course was desirable because some issues raised in the pleadings plainly relate to positions that have long since been abandoned or neglected, including, for instance, that the applicants sued in a representative capacity under r 9.21 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth). Although that initial list was provided on 5 May 2021, its relevance was fleeting. A series of procedural developments, to which I will return below, led to a significant reformation of the applicants’ case and, therefore, a new suite of issues for determination. Accordingly, it was not until 17 August 2021 that the parties provided a final agreed list of outstanding issues for determination, in respect of which the Court expressly noted, by consent, the following: The balance of the issues in proceeding NSD 470/2020 and proceeding NSD 99/2021 are reflected in the agreed list of issues for determination dated 17 August 2021 and marked as MFI18 (Agreed Issues) and represent the entirety of the balance of the matters required to be determined in both proceedings.(Emphasis in original). Those issues are as follows: Proceeding NSD 470/20201.Is Guardian Securities Limited (Guardian) liable to pay equitable compensation in respect of amounts alleged to have been paid or accrued in breach of trust?1a.Do the QB4 Parties (and in particular the Migunovs) have standing to seek equitable compensation against Guardian for the pleaded breaches? In that regard, who is / are the beneficiaries of FT1 and FT2?1b.Did Guardian relevantly commit a breach or breaches of trust?1c.If no to 1b, were the expenses properly incurred by Guardian as trustee?In respect of that issue, a relevant implied issue is whether Guardian validly terminated the Investment Management Agreement, having accepted the termination of the Responsible Entity Agreement by QB4 Capital Pty Ltd (QB4 Capital) on 16 March 2020?1d.If no to 1b and yes to 1c, are the expenses within the scope of Guardian’s right of indemnity from the PIF and ELF under cll 22, 23.7, 23.12 and/or 23.13 of the Constitution of TGIF, s 6 of the PDS of the PIF, s 7 of the PDS of the ELF and/or s 72 of the Trusts Act1973 (Qld)?1e.If there was a breach or breaches of trust, is Guardian entitled to be relieved from liability under s 76 of the Trusts Act 1973 (Qld) or entitled to a just allowance for time, energy, work, skill and judgment?2.Are the QB4 Parties entitled to declaratory relief in respect of amounts alleged to have been paid or accrued in breach of trust?3.Is QB4 Capital liable to repay the amounts it received under cl 5.1 of the Settlement Deed?3a.Is there a liability in contract to repay the amounts under cl 10.1 of the Settlement Deed?3b.If no to 3a, is Guardian entitled to restitutionary relief?3c.If repayment is required, to whom is payment to be made?4. Is the remedy of set-off available to Guardian?[5.Is QB4 Capital liable to Guardian for damages for breach of the provisions pleaded in the SCC at [17]?] 5a.Did QB4 Capital breach the provisions pleaded in the SCC at [17]?5b. Is QB4 Capital liable to Guardian for damages for breach of any of the above provisions pleaded in the SCC at [17]? If so, what damages?6.To what extent is Guardian entitled to recover outstanding invoices from Fundus Trust No 1 and Fundus Trust No 2 for invoices issued before and after the appointment … of Receivers accrued in the accounts?7.Is Fundus liable to make payment of $135,000 plus interest to VentureCrowd Property Australia Pty Ltd under the loan agreement dated 16 November 2020? If so, is Fundus precluded from having recourse to the assets of FT1 and FT2 to satisfy that liability?8.What costs orders should be made in the proceedings generally, including the costs reserved in paragraph 6 of the orders of Lee J made on 13 August 2020? In the context of costs of the proceeding, given that Guardian has accepted as valid, the termination of the [RE Agreement] by QB4 Capital, was its termination of the [IM Agreement] valid? – refer also 1c above?9.Should Mr Maarbani, as a non-party, be jointly and severally liable for the costs of QB4 from the event which led to the termination of the settlement deed?10.What orders should be made in respect of the future of Fundus Trust No 1 and Fundus Trust No 2?10a.Should QB4 Capital Asset Management Pty Ltd be appointed as replacement trustee of Fundus Trust No 1 in place of the Receivers and, if so, what consequential orders should be made?10b.If not, what orders should be made? In particular, should orders be made to cause the receivers to realise the assets of Fundus Trust No 1 and distribute the net proceeds rateably to unitholders of the ELF?10c.What form of order should be made in respect of Fundus Trust No 2?10d.Should the Receivers be required to apply to pre-fix their remuneration for the purposes of any such orders with respect to ELF and PIF?Proceeding NSD 99/20211.Is Guardian Securities Ltd entitled to the declaratory relief sought in the Second cross-claim? 2.What costs orders should be made in the proceedings?

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Despite the disputes over the Receivers’ costs in relation to the Receivers’ Reports, I found those costs to be appropriate given the tasks they were burdened with and the reports produced. Accordingly, I consider it appropriate that the Receivers apply retrospectively for their remuneration and expenses to be approved. But costs should be minimised.J CONCLUSION & ORDERS This long and sorry saga should be brought to an end. I propose to make an order referring the parties to mediation. It is unclear to me why this case, crying out for resolution, has not resolved. The parties should be apprised by a Registrar of the Court as to the mutually destructive nature of the ongoing disputation, which ends up resulting in unnecessary legal fees being incurred. If armed by these reasons the parties cannot belatedly resolve their differences sensibly, then the mediation process at least might serve to reduce the ambit of any dispute over the relief to reflect my findings and these reasons. Absent a commercial resolution, the parties are to file an agreed minute or competing minutes of order reflecting these reasons within seven days of the completion of the mediation.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The TGIF is a managed investment scheme registered with the Australian Securities and Investments Commission in accordance with Part 5C.1 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act). Relevantly, the TGIF constitution was contained in a “Replacement Constitution” made on 27 April 2016, and subsequently amended on 22 May 2019 (TGIF Constitution). Guardian is the trustee and responsible entity of the TGIF: see s 601FC(2) of the Corporations Act. As the trustee and the responsible entity of the TGIF, Guardian holds the assets of the scheme on trust for the members of the scheme (unitholders), subject to the standards applicable to the trust under the Corporations Act and the provisions of the TGIF Constitution itself. There are several separate classes of units within the TGIF. Those presently relevant are the two classes of units known as the Enhanced Land Fund (ELF) and the Premium Income Fund (PIF). In accordance with Pt 7.9 of the Corporations Act, the TGIF discloses any offers in terms of a Product Disclosure Statement (PDS). The PDS of the ELF is dated 9 June 2017 and the PDS of the PIF is dated 29 August 2018. The ELF was promoted as an investment in land sites suitable for property investment. The relevant projects related to the ELF include the Yamanto Property and the Lawnton Property. The PIF was promoted as a vehicle for investors to have exposure to property developments as an equity interest via preference shares. Funds were invested in special purpose vehicles that were responsible for the property development. The relevant projects related to the PIF include the Griffin Mews Project, the Wattlebird Project, and the Pimpama Project. Until 2 December 2020, the assets of the ELF and PIF were held on trust, via a custodian, by Fundus Management Pty Ltd (Fundus). Specifically, the assets ultimately referable to the ELF are held in Fundus Trust No 1 (FT1) and the assets of the PIF are held in Fundus Trust No 2 (FT2). The ELF unit class within the TGIF is the only investor in FT1 and the PIF unit class is the only investor in FT2: see ELF PDS Part 2 at [7]; PIF PDS Part 2 at [15]. In respect of the above, it is important to foreshadow that there is some dispute concerning the identities of the proper beneficiaries of FT1 and FT2. The QB4 Parties submit, on various alternative bases, that the proper beneficiaries of FT1 and FT2 are, respectively, the unitholders of the ELF and PIF. In contrast, the Guardian Parties submit that Fundus in its capacity as trustee of FT1 and FT2 holds all of the assets within those two trusts solely for the benefit of Guardian in its capacity as the responsible entity and trustee of the TGIF. It will be necessary to return to this dispute below (at Section C).The responsible entity As stated above, Guardian is the trustee and responsible entity of the TGIF. As the responsible entity of the TGIF, Guardian was required to operate the TGIF as a managed investment scheme and perform the functions conferred upon it by the Constitution and the Corporations Act.