Kirwan v Cresvale Far East Ltd (in liq)

Link copied
Case Copied 86 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:     Kirwan v Cresvale Far East Ltd (In liq) [2002]  NSWCA 395

FILE NUMBER(S):
40188/01

HEARING DATE(S):    19, 20 August 2002

JUDGMENT DATE:      10/12/2002

PARTIES:
Nigel Peter Kirwan (Appellant/4th Cross Respondent)
Cresvale Far East Limited (1st Respondent/1st Cross Respondent)
Cresvale Securities Limited (2nd Respondent/2nd Cross Respondent)
Vanda Russell Gould (3rd Respondent/Cross Appellant)
Cresvale Capital Pty Limited (4th Respondent/3rd Cross Respondent)

JUDGMENT OF:        Meagher JA Giles JA Young CJ in Eq   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:       Supreme Court - Equity Division

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):     3672/00

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:   Austin J

COUNSEL:
D J Higgs SC and R J H Darke (Appellant)
M Cashion SC (1st Respondent)
P M Wood (2nd & 4th Respondents)
S D Rares SC and P J Dowdy (3rd Respondent)

SOLICITORS:
John A Glynn & Associates (Appellant)
Minter Ellison (1st Respondent)
Blake Dawson Waldron (2nd & 4th Respondents)
Henry Davis York (3rd Respondent)

CATCHWORDS:
CORPORATIONS- Administrator- Fiduciary duties- Duties re exercising casting votes- Standards of conduct for administrators- Liability of administrator to suffer order for costs.  CORPORATIONS- Shares- Allotment- When power to allot exceeded.  EQUITY- Equitable relief- Requirement to do equity.  MEETINGS- Casting votes- Principles governing exercise.  PROCEDURE- Costs- Administrator arguing both for the company and himself personally- How costs borne if unsuccessful. (D)

LEGISLATION CITED:
Corporations Act 2001 (Comm) s 175, Pt 5.3A (particularly ss 439A(4)(c), 443C, 443D, 447E), ss 513C, 536, 600B
Corporations Regulations 5.6.21, 5.6.23, 5.6.26
Supreme Court Act 1970, s 76

DECISION:
See paras 449, 450 and 451

JUDGMENT:

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL

CA 40188/01
SC 3672/00

MEAGHER JA
GILES JA
YOUNG CJ in EQ

Tuesday 10 December 2002

KIRWAN v CRESVALE FAR EAST LTD (IN LIQUIDATION)

Judgment

  1. MEAGHER JA:  In this matter I have had the advantage of reading in draft the judgments of both Giles JA and Young CJ in Eq.  I shall not recite once more the relevant facts, which are, perhaps more than adequately, set out in the judgments.

  2. On the central question (which has now become obsolete) of whether the issue of shares should have been set aside on the grounds of improper purpose, I respectfully agree with Young CJ in Eq.  Securities was carrying on business as a stockbroker; everyone agreed it should continue to do so; it was desperately short of capital, and was dancing on the brink of insolvency; it could not continue in business, unless there was some injection of capital; capital could have put it in liquidation, but did not do so; nobody was prepared to supply it with any capital, except Mr Kirwan; Mr Kirwan did so, in return for the issue of shares.  In these circumstances, the correct principle is that set out by his Honour:

    “Likewise, if a company has need of capital and there is only one avenue of obtaining that capital, then even though the person who is subscribing the extra capital and has a dominant purpose in obtaining control and even though that person…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kirwan v Cresvale Far East Ltd (in liq) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] NSWCA 395
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal from a decision of Austin J in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The appellant, Mr Kirwan, sought to appeal against orders made by Austin J concerning the costs of proceedings brought by the liquidator of Cresvale Far East Ltd (in liq) and Cresvale Securities Ltd (in liq). The proceedings involved allegations of breaches of fiduciary duty by Mr Hedge, who had acted as administrator of Cresvale Securities Ltd.

The central legal issues before the court were whether Mr Hedge, in his capacity as administrator, had breached his fiduciary duties by exercising his casting vote in a manner that was not in the best interests of Cresvale Securities Ltd, and whether the power to allot shares had been exceeded. The court was also required to consider the principles governing the exercise of casting votes and the equitable requirement for a party seeking relief to do equity. Furthermore, the court had to determine how costs should be borne when an administrator argued both for the company and personally, and was ultimately unsuccessful.

Austin J had inferred from a report that Mr Hedge believed there was a prospect of recovering Virotec shares or their value from Mr Kirwan, but only if Cresvale Securities Ltd was first placed in voluntary liquidation, which became economically viable when the market value of Virotec shares increased. However, the report did not clearly link the sale of shares in Cresvale Securities Ltd to any preference in a prior transfer of listed investments. The court found that it was not clear why Mr Hedge was unwilling to proceed with the sale of shares, and speculation on this point was not a sound basis for criticising Mr Hedge's conduct. The court also noted a letter from the company secretary of Cresvale Securities Ltd to Mr Hedge, which indicated that the company had experienced a loss due to a reduction in active dealers and that directors were conscious of the need to increase the number of investment advisers. The letter concluded that Cresvale Securities Ltd had little or no value to outside parties and that any offer above shareholders' funds should be seriously considered, as projected shareholders' funds were minimal and any delay would likely result in no distribution to shareholders in liquidation.

The court ultimately upheld the decision of Austin J, finding that Mr Hedge had not acted in breach of his fiduciary duties. The orders made by Austin J regarding costs were confirmed.

Orders

Orders of the court

See paras 449, 450 and 451

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The report ended -“ConclusionThe priorities in the liquidation are at present to:(i) finalise the realisation of CC’s investment in CS.(ii)consider the possibility of any recoveries involving the TIN share transaction.(iii)finalise investigations into the company’s affairs and report to ASIC in accordance with the Corporations Law.I will discuss these matters in more detail at the meeting of creditors.” From the report Austin J inferred that Mr Hedge reasoned that -“ … to the extent that Securities had disposed of Virotec shares to Mr Kirwan in October 1999 there may have been some prospect of Securities recovering the shares or their value from him. Proceedings against Mr Kirwan could be taken, if Securities was first placed in voluntary liquidation. However, such proceedings became economically worthwhile only when the market value of Virotec jumped in March 2000.” The report does not obviously link the sale of the shares in Securities with any preference in the September 1999 transfer by Capital to Securities of the listed investments. In particular, it contemplates sale of the shares in Securities rather than their retention so that, through shareholder control, Securities could be put into liquidation and its liquidator could then recover the Virotec shares or their value from Mr Kirwan. There was no evidence of the discussion at the meeting of creditors. The more important issue is not so much why Mr Hedge was unwilling to proceed with sale of the shares, as whether Mr Gould was shown to have taken an unreasonable view of his unwillingness. It was certainly not clear why Mr Hedge was unwilling to proceed with sale of the shares, and speculation as to his reason or reasons is not a good basis for criticising Mr Gould. The company secretary of Securities, Mr Richard Burnett, wrote to Mr Hedge by a letter dated 1 June 2000, in response to a letter from Mr Hedge dated 24 May 2000 which was not in evidence. Austin J summarised the letter of 1 June 2000 -“39 The letter of 1 June 2000 noted that in the three-month period ending 31 March 2000, which had covered the major part of the most active trading seen by the Australian Stock Exchange for several years, Securities had been reduced to only six active dealers and, allegedly as a result of this, the company recorded a loss. It said that the directors were conscious of the need to increase substantially the number of investment advisers, but no action could be taken until the future direction of the company had been put in place. The directors did not expect profitability to return until they were able to secure the services of at least 10 more advisers. After reviewing the value of the company's assets, the letter concluded that Securities had little or no value to outside parties, and conveyed the directors' unanimous view that any offer above the level of shareholders' funds should be seriously considered.”It should be added that the letter included that projected shareholders’ funds were minimal and that any delay would undoubtedly result in no distribution to shareholders in the event of liquidation.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.