Prestige Form Group NSW Pty Ltd v QBE European Operations Plc

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Prestige Form Group NSW Pty Ltd v QBE European Operations PLC [2023] FCA 749

File number(s): NSD 216 of 2023
Judgment of: JACKMAN J
Date of judgment: 5 July 2023
Catchwords: INSURANCE – separate question – indemnity sought in relation to claims arising from collapse of concrete slab at building site – construction of contract works exclusion clause in third-party liability insurance policy – natural and ordinary reading of exclusion clause does not produce an absurdity – context and natural reading favour broad construction of exclusion clause
Cases cited:

Chartbrook Ltd v Persimmon Homes Ltd [2009] UKHL 38; [2009] 1 AC 1101

Ecosse Property Holdings Pty Ltd v Gee Dee Nominees Pty Ltd [2017] HCA 12; (2017) 261 CLR 544

Electricity Generation Corporation v Woodside Energy Ltd [2014] HCA 7; (2014) 251 CLR 640

Hakea Holdings Pty Ltd v Neon Underwriting Ltd [2023] FCAFC 34; (2023) 164 ACSR 591

Halford v Price (1960) 105 CLR 23

HDI Global Speciality SE v Wonkana No. 3 Pty Ltd [2020] NSWCA 296; (2020) 104 NSWLR 634

LCA Marrickville Pty Ltd v Swiss Re International SE [2022] FCAFC 17; 290 FCR 435

McMurray v AIG Insurance Australia Ltd (No 5) [2021] WASC 300

Star Entertainment Group Ltd v Chubb Insurance Australia Ltd [2022] FCAFC 16; (2022) 400 ALR 25

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Commercial Contracts, Banking, Finance and Insurance
Number of paragraphs: 33
Date of hearing: 28 June 2023
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr J E Sexton SC
Solicitor for the Applicant: HBA Legal
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr E C Muston SC and Mr N J Olson
Solicitor for the Respondent: Clyde & Co

ORDERS

NSD 216 of 2023
BETWEEN:

PRESTIGE FORM GROUP NSW PTY LTD

Applicant

AND:

QBE EUROPEAN OPERATIONS PLC

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

JACKMAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

5 JULY 2023

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The separate question be answered as follows:

Question: Are the works identified in the definition of Contract Works for the purposes of the Contract Works Exclusion limited to those owned by or in the possession of the Insured which makes the claim under the Policy?

Answer: No.

2.The respondent file and serve any submissions together with any affidavit(s) in support relating to costs and consequential orders by 12 July 2023.

3.The applicant file and served any submissions together with any affidavit(s) in support relating to costs and consequential orders by 19 July 2023.

4.The respondent file and serve any submissions in reply, together with any affidavit(s) in reply, on the question of costs and consequential orders by 26 July 2023.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

JACKMAN J

Introduction

  1. These proceedings concern a claim by the applicant (Prestige) to be entitled to be indemnified by the respondent (QBE) under an insurance policy (the Policy) for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Prestige Form Group NSW Pty Ltd v QBE European Operations Pl... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 749
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Prestige Form Group NSW Pty Ltd sought to recover indemnity from QBE European Operations Plc in relation to claims arising from the collapse of a concrete slab at a building site. The dispute was heard in the Federal Court of Australia. The primary legal issue was the interpretation of the contract works exclusion clause in a third-party liability insurance policy. Prestige argued for a narrow construction of the exclusion clause, contending that it did not cover claims arising from damage to property not owned or in the possession of the insured making the claim. Conversely, QBE contended for a broader construction, arguing that the exclusion clause covered all contract works, regardless of ownership.

The court found that the ordinary and natural meaning of the exclusion clause did not support Prestige's narrow construction. The language used in the exclusion clause did not provide any textual support for such a distinction, and the broader construction was consistent with other exclusions in the policy that explicitly referred to possession or control. The court also noted that the policy provided substantial cover for property damage outside the contract works, and there was nothing inherently unbusinesslike about the broader interpretation. Therefore, the court ruled that the exclusion clause covered all contract works, regardless of who owned or possessed them.

The court answered the separate question in the negative, holding that the works identified in the definition of contract works for the purposes of the exclusion clause were not limited to those owned by or in the possession of the insured making the claim under the policy. The court directed that QBE file and serve submissions on costs and consequential orders within seven days, with Prestige to respond in a further seven days, and QBE to reply within another seven days. The court anticipated deciding the remaining questions on the papers.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The separate question be answered as follows:

Question: Are the works identified in the definition of Contract Works for the purposes of the Contract Works Exclusion limited to those owned by or in the possession of the Insured which makes the claim under the Policy?

Answer: No.

2. The respondent file and serve any submissions together with any affidavit(s) in support relating to costs and consequential orders by 12 July 2023.

3. The applicant file and served any submissions together with any affidavit(s) in support relating to costs and consequential orders by 19 July 2023.

4. The respondent file and serve any submissions in reply, together with any affidavit(s) in reply, on the question of costs and consequential orders by 26 July 2023.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

For completeness, I am not persuaded by QBE’s argument based on the allegedly unbusinesslike result of Prestige’s construction in the context of a third-party liability policy. In the context of Condition 4 dealing with Cross Liabilities, as Prestige submits, one of the Insured can make a claim against another Insured (as here) within the scope of the insuring clause. On Prestige’s narrow construction, a claim by RCC against Prestige may fall within the insuring clause and not be excluded by the Contract Works Exclusion, if the claim relates to damage to RCC’s property, and not property owned or in the possession of Prestige. There is no absurdity in contemplating that cover may extend to damage to the property of other people (that is, other than the particular Insured claiming on this Policy) who may be working on the building site. However, as I have indicated above, I am unable to discern any textual support for Prestige’s narrow construction and the language used elsewhere in the Policy points strongly against such a construction.Conclusion Accordingly, the separate question should be answered: No. Both parties expressed a preference for dealing with the question of costs and consequential orders after reading my reasons. QBE may seek orders finally disposing of the proceedings as the logical corollary of my answer to the separate question. In those circumstances, it seems to be appropriate that QBE should go first in filing and serving its submissions on costs and consequential orders, together with any affidavit in support, and I will give QBE 7 days to do so. Prestige will have a further 7 days to respond, and QBE will have a further 7 days to reply. I anticipate that I will then decide those remaining questions on the papers.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

QBE submits that it is Prestige’s construction which produces an unbusinesslike result. QBE draws attention to the nature of the Policy as a third-party liability policy, providing cover for third-party claims made against the insured. The Policy does not provide first party cover. If Prestige’s own property, including any formwork it might have erected in connection with a project, were to be damaged, the only party which would logically suffer loss is Prestige, and Prestige could not bring a third-party claim against itself. QBE thus submits that, viewed in the context of the insuring clause, Prestige’s construction of the Contract Works Exclusion deprives it of any meaningful operation, as it would be confined in its operation to liabilities that could never arise.Consideration In my view, the ordinary and natural meaning of the language used in the Contract Works Exclusion does not favour Prestige’s narrow construction. I am unable to discern any textual support for that construction. The use of the definite article “the” is too slender a hook to bear the weight of the proposed distinction between Contract Works which are owned by, or in the possession of, the Insured which makes the claim under the Policy, and those which are not. While I accept that use of the definite article “the” ordinarily suggests a reference to Contract Works which are known to, or ascertainable by, the parties, that is much too broad and general a concept to have the effect of confining the exclusion in the way suggested. Further, Prestige’s construction stands in stark contrast to the express language used in other exclusions. The exclusion for Damage to Insured’s Products picks up the definition of Insured’s Products, which in turn depends upon whether the thing in question has “ceased to be in the possession or control of the Insured”. That exclusion therefore turns on whether something is in the Insured’s possession or control, i.e. the very distinction which Prestige seeks to introduce to the Contract Works Exclusion. Similarly, the exclusion pertaining to Faulty Workmanship depends on whether the relevant work has been “done or undertaken by the Insured”. Further, the exclusion relating to Property in Physical or Legal Control uses the concept of whether the property in question is “property in the physical or legal control of the Insured”. The language of these exclusions demonstrates that the parties had express language readily available for making the kind of distinction which Prestige contends is implicit in the Contract Works Exclusion. In those circumstances, the fact that such language has not been used in the Contract Works Exclusion should be regarded as intentional. I am not persuaded that there is anything unbusinesslike (or absurd) in adopting the ordinary and natural meaning of the exclusion. The Policy still provides substantial cover for Property Damage in relation to property other than that comprised in the Contract Works. QBE’s examples of claims by adjacent owners or by the owners of vehicles nearby are well made. Moreover, the Contract Works Exclusion would not qualify the cover available for Personal Injury or Advertising Liability.