Polwood Pty Ltd v Foxworth Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Polwood Pty Ltd v Foxworth Pty Ltd [2008] FCAFC 9

INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY - PATENTS – inventorship – at trial two parties claimed sole entitlement to grant of patent – primary judge found joint inventorship – appellant entitled to claims to method and process of invention and respondent entitled to claims to enabling apparatus – primary judge granted liberty to apply to permit joint inventorship to be determined on claim by claim basis – appellant continues to claim sole entitlement – respondent now argues for joint inventorship – appellant claims inventorship in totality of ‘inventive concept’ in invention – appellant claims contribution of respondent non-inventive, to do with physical working of concept – respondent claims two ‘inventive hearts’ in application with respondent inventor of one ‘heart’ being apparatus – both parties were jointly responsible for devising the inventive concept of the patent – respondent did not merely provide skill to implement appellant’s concept but contributed inventive skill to invention – claims not considered by primary judge to determine the extent or existence of joint inventorship of subject matter of individual claims

EQUITY - breach of confidence - confidential information largely conceptual in nature - authorised use involving time energy and inventive skill to produce an ‘invention’ - assertion by confidant of joint inventorship - proprietary relief in respect of confidant’s interest in the invention refused

INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY - COPYRIGHT – consideration of a claim of indirect infringement of copyright by making a version in three dimensions of an apparatus said to be a copy of an earlier apparatus embodying all of the features of a two‑dimensional drawing – consideration of whether the contended copy is a three‑dimensional version of the two‑dimensional drawings in suit – consideration of the extent of any similarities between the features embodied in the three‑dimensional apparatus and those features reflected in the drawings and the intermediate or earlier apparatus said to have been copied – consideration of the evidence going to conscious copying and substantial similarity

Patents Act (1990) (Cth), s 13, s 15(1), s 16, s 17
Copyright Act (1968) (Cth)

Foxworth Pty Ltd v Polwood Pty Ltd [2006] QSC 185, quoted
University of British Columbia v Conor Medystems Inc (2006) 155 FCR 391, cited and quoted
IDA Ltd v The University of Southampton [2006] EWCA Civ 145, cited
Kimberly-Clark Australia Pty Ltd v Arico Trading International Pty Ltd (2001) 207 CLR 1, cited and quoted
Burroughs Wellcome Co v Barr Laboratories Inc 40 F.3d 1223, cited
Stack v Davies Shephard Pty Ltd (2001) 108 FCR 422, cited
Aktiebolaget Hassle v Alphapharm Pty Ltd (2002) 212 CLR 411, cited
Lockwood Security Products Pty Ltd v Doric Products Pty Ltd (No 2) (2007) 235 ALR 202, cited
Stanelco Fibreoptics Ltd’s Applications [2005] RPC 15, cited and quoted
Markem Corp v Zipher Ltd (No 1) [2004] RPC 10, cited and quoted
Markem Corp v Zipher Ltd [2005] All ER (D) 377, cited and quoted
Yeda Research and Development…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Polwood Pty Ltd v Foxworth Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCAFC 9
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Polwood Pty Ltd and Foxworth Pty Ltd are in dispute over the patent rights for a method and apparatus for producing plant growth media using waste materials of vegetable origin. The primary judge had concluded that neither party was entitled to the grant of the patent as the sole inventor but that they were joint inventors. Polwood challenges this finding. The court had to determine the respective contributions of Polwood and Foxworth to the invention and decide whether either party was entitled to be recognised as the sole inventor of the patent. The court considered that the invention was the result of a collaborative effort, and the contributions of both parties to the invention were necessary for its final form. The court held that if Polwood and Foxworth were entitled to be recognised as joint inventors, Polwood was not entitled to registration of the patent in its sole name. The court found that the contributions of both Polwood and Foxworth to the invention were significant and that they were joint inventors. The court held that neither party was entitled to the grant of the patent as the sole inventor. The court ordered that Polwood and Foxworth were to file written submissions in relation to any orders to be made in disposition of the appeal and cross appeal, as well as the costs of the appeal and cross appeal. The costs of the appeal and cross appeal were reserved.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appellants shall within 14 days file and serve written submissions as to any Orders to be made in disposition of the appeal and cross‑appeal and written submissions in relation to the costs of the appeal and cross‑appeal together with any submissions as to the proposed Orders concerning the costs of the proceeding before the Supreme Court of Queensland, having regard to the reasons for judgment.

2. The respondents shall within a further 14 days of receipt of the appellants’ written submissions contemplated by Order 2 of these Orders, file and serve submissions in reply.

3. The costs of the appeal and cross‑appeal are reserved.

Background

Background to the litigation

The first appellant (‘Polwood’) and the first respondent (‘Foxworth’), each claim entitlement to the grant of a patent on a patent application. The field of the invention as described in the patent application is a method and an apparatus for producing plant growth media (potting mix) using waste materials primarily of vegetable origin. The primary judge concluded that neither Polwood nor Foxworth was entitled to the grant of the patent as sole inventor but that they were joint inventors (Foxworth Pty Ltd v Polwood Pty Ltd [2006] QSC 185 at [262]). Polwood challenges that finding.Relevant background In order to understand the claims to inventorship, it is necessary to have some understanding of the subject of the relevant patents and their history. The invention the subject of the appeal originated in the ‘steaming tube dual auger concept’ (‘the concept’). Briefly, the concept involves a preferable method of producing plant growth media to increase their properties such as water retention. The concept involves transporting plant material (bark) through processing equipment (two augers) which leads to the plant material being submerged in treated water. The resulting plant growth medium is then 'de-watered' so that its moisture content is reduced. This subject matter was first discussed between and developed by Mr Rampton (‘Rampton’) and his neighbour Mr Connick (‘Connick’). We shall refer to their interests generally as those of Polwood (comprising the interests of all appellants and, in addition, the general position of Connick). Subsequently, in the context of a Deed of Licence (‘the licence’), the information regarding the concept was communicated to Mr Power (‘Power’) and Mr Kemp (‘Kemp’). We shall refer to their interests generally as those of Foxworth (comprising the interests of all of the respondents to the appeal). After the information regarding the concept was communicated to Foxworth, it commenced to develop the concept by building prototypes and ultimately an apparatus to implement the concept.The earlier Polwood patents On 25 August 1989 Polwood obtained a patent in respect of a process developed by it for the production of orchid bark (‘the orchid bark patent’). In about 1993, Rampton reached the conclusion that the potential for sales and profit from the manufacture and sale of peat products exceeded that from the production and sale of orchid bark. Polwood filed a patent for the process for the production of peat products on 20 July 1994 (‘the peat patent’). The publication date of the peat patent was 20 February 1995. The claims are to a method for the manufacture of a peat moss alternative. The named inventor was Rampton. The patent was part of the published prior art available to be read, as it was by Kemp. The patent applications the subject of this appeal were filed on 22 July 2002 and 22 July 2003 respectively (relevantly a provisional patent application and an international application under the Patent Cooperation Treaty (‘PCT’), together ‘the patent application’).The machines (the apparatus)

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

FINN, BENNETT AND GREENWOOD JJ

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FINN, BENNETT AND GREENWOOD JJ

Polwood submits that the primary judge erred in emphasising the conceptual nature of its contribution and points out that many complete inventions are conceptual and have not matured into a practical application. Polwood says that, in this case, the experimentation that gave rise to the three prototypes was to get a preferred working embodiment and not to research a problem with the concept itself. ConsiderationIndications of joint inventorship in United Kingdom and United States authorities The entitlement to the grant of a patent as the inventor is not determined by quantitative contribution. The role of joint inventors does not have to have been equal; it is qualitative rather than quantitative. It may involve joint contribution or independent contributions. The issue is whether the contribution was to the invention. What constitutes the invention can be determined from the particular patent specification which includes the claims. In some cases, evidence can assist. In some cases, the reduction of a concept to a working apparatus by a person may not be part of the invention, in other cases it may be. For example, the construction of an apparatus may involve no more than carrying out the instructions in the specification. This would not normally entitle that person to joint inventorship. On the other hand joint inventorship may arise where the invention is in the apparatus itself, or where the person constructing the apparatus contributed to a different or better working of it which is then described and claimed. One criterion for inventorship may be to determine whether the person’s contribution had a material effect on the final invention. It may be that an invention is made as part of a collaborative effort. In those circumstances, it would ordinarily follow that the collaborators are joint inventors of the product of the collaboration. In the present case, the subject of the patent application was not part of a continuing collaboration recognised as such by the parties. To ascertain the inventor for the purposes of entitlement to the grant of the patent it is therefore necessary to determine the contributions to the invention described in the patent application. The claims may assist in that determination, bearing in mind that the claims may be to less than the totality of the invention. It may also be appropriate to investigate the contributions to the inventive steps giving rise to the invention. In the United States the principle has developed that a patent to a claimed invention that is the subject of contribution from more than one person cannot be granted to one only of the contributors. While care must be taken in applying United States law on inventorship where entitlement is determined on a ‘first to invent’ not on a ‘first to file’ basis, that principle is of general application. This was acknowledged in Stack v Davies Shephard Pty Ltd (2001) 108 FCR 422 (at [21]) and is consistent with s 15 of the Act. As was said in Chisum on Patents (1978) and adopted in Stack at [24], ‘if the invention was joint, the defendant’s patent in his sole name was invalid’. That led the Full Court in Stack to conclude at [28] that one person was not solely entitled to a patent for the joint invention of himself and another. It follows that, if Polwood and Foxworth are entitled to be recognised as joint inventors, Polwood is not entitled to registration of the patent in its sole name.