Silent Shade Pty Ltd v Tony Hopkins

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Silent Shade Pty Ltd v Tony Hopkins [2025] APO 20

Patent Applications:            2023900674 & 2023901115

Titles:Mechanical blinds system auto glide & Mechanical combined awning and blind system

Patent Applicant:                Tony Hopkins

Requestor:Silent Shade Pty Ltd

Delegate:Greg Powell

Decision Date:  30 June 2025

Hearing Date:  Written submissions filed on 19 March 2025, 20 May 2025 & 2 June 2025

Catchwords:  PATENTS – section 36 – inventorship – applicant is the sole inventor – whether the requestor is the sole eligible person – joint venture agreement – whether the agreement exists – behaviour of the parties to agreement – implied contract – agreement was effectively in existence – third party employer of the applicant – s36 considerations do not extend to the third party – should documents not in evidence be considered? – documents not in evidence were not considered – request under s36 successful – the requestor is the sole eligible person with respect to the invention – costs awarded against the applicant

Representation:                   The applicant and requestor represented themselves

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Patent Applications:            2023900674 & 2023901115

Titles:Mechanical blinds system auto glide & Mechanical combined awning and blind system

Patent Applicant:                Tony Hopkins

Date of Decision:                30 June 2025

DECISION

The requestor has established that they have entitlement to the invention.

I declare that the requestor, Silent Shade Pty Ltd, is the sole eligible person in relation to provisional applications 2023900674 and 2023901115.

I award costs in accordance with Schedule 8 against the applicant, Tony Hopkins.

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. Tony Hopkins (the applicant/Mr Hopkins) filed provisional patent application 2023900674 (the ‘674 application) on 13 March 2023 and filed provisional patent application 2023901115 (the ‘115 application) on 16 April 2023 (collectively, the provisional applications).  On 7 June 2023 standard patent application 2023203556, claiming priority from the provisional applications, was filed in the name of Jeti Enterprises Pty Ltd, listing Mr Hopkins as sole inventor.

  2. On 11 July 2024, Silent Shade Pty Ltd (the requestor) filed a single request under section 36 of the Patents Act 1990 (the Act).  The request was made with respect to standard application 2023203556 but stated:

    “This application relates to:

    -     Australian Provisional Patent Application Nos. 2023900674, 2023901115 in the name of Tony Hopkins, and

    -     Australian Complete Patent Application No. 2023203556 in the name of Jeti Enterprises Pty Ltd.”

  3. The request sought a declaration from the Commissioner that Silent Shade Pty Ltd was the sole eligible person in respect of the provisional applications and the standard application which claimed priority from the provisional applications.  The request stated:

    “The inventor Tony Hopkins was a director of Silent Shade Pty Ltd during the period in which the invention was made.  He has engaged in conduct in breach of his fiduciary duties as a director of Silent Shade Pty Ltd, and in contravention of a Joint Venture Agreement signed by him on 4 July 2017.  Tony Hopkins was also employed by Abra Aluminium Pty…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Silent Shade Pty Ltd v Tony Hopkins and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] APO 20
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Silent Shade Pty Ltd (the requestor) sought a declaration under section 36 of the Patents Act 1990 (the Act) that it was the sole eligible person in respect of provisional patent applications 2023900674 and 2023901115 (the provisional applications). The requestor’s case was that Tony Hopkins (the applicant), the named inventor of the provisional applications, was not the sole eligible person, and that the requestor was. The applicant filed a response, and the requestor filed a reply. The Commissioner found that the requestor was the sole eligible person. The Commissioner found that Mr Hopkins was the sole inventor of the invention, and that the requestor had established that it had a right to the invention under a joint venture agreement (JV) between the requestor, Mr Hopkins and another individual. The Commissioner concluded that the requestor had the right to the invention, and that the requestor was the sole eligible person. The Commissioner awarded costs against the applicant.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute over the ownership of patent rights for two mechanical blind systems: the Auto Glide and the Mechanical Combined Awning and Blind System. The patent applicant, Tony Hopkins, filed two provisional patent applications: 2023900674 on 13 March 2023 and 2023901115 on 16 April 2023. Subsequently, a standard patent application, 2023203556, claiming priority from these provisional applications, was filed on 7 June 2023 in the name of Jeti Enterprises Pty Ltd, with Mr. Hopkins listed as the sole inventor. On 11 July 2024, Silent Shade Pty Ltd filed a request under section 36 of the Patents Act 1990, seeking a declaration that they are the sole eligible person in respect of the provisional applications and the standard application. The request alleged that Mr. Hopkins was a director of Silent Shade Pty Ltd during the invention period and had breached his fiduciary duties and a Joint Venture Agreement by not assigning the inventions to the company. The applicant later requested the withdrawal of the standard application, which was granted.

The case began with Silent Shade Pty Ltd filing a single request under section 36 of the Patents Act 1990 on 11 July 2024. This request was subsequently split into three separate requests as required by the Act, one for each application. Following correspondence, the applicant requested the withdrawal of the standard application, which was granted, leaving the decision to focus on the provisional applications only. Written submissions were filed by both parties, with the requestor submitting initial, response, and reply submissions on 19 March 2025, 20 May 2025, and 2 June 2025, respectively. The applicant filed additional evidence on 20 February 2025, which was not considered by the Commissioner as the applicant did not pursue the matter further.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the joint venture agreement between Mr. Hopkins and Mr. Allen in place and binding, and did it require Mr. Hopkins to assign his inventions to Silent Shade Pty Ltd?
2. Did Mr. Hopkins breach his fiduciary duties as a director of Silent Shade Pty Ltd by not assigning the inventions to the company?
3. Was Mr. Hopkins the sole inventor of the inventions in question, or did Mr. Allen also contribute as an inventor?
4. Should the Commissioner consider documents that were not in evidence, such as the declaration by Peter Cock, which was filed late and was a duplicate of another declaration already in evidence?

Held
1. The court concluded that the joint venture agreement between Mr. Hopkins and Mr. Allen was in place and binding, and it required Mr. Hopkins to assign his inventions to Silent Shade Pty Ltd.
2. The court found that Mr. Hopkins breached his fiduciary duties as a director of Silent Shade Pty Ltd by not assigning the inventions to the company.
3. The court determined that Mr. Hopkins was the sole inventor of the inventions in question, and Mr. Allen did not contribute as an inventor.
4. The court decided not to consider the declaration by Peter Cock, which was filed late and was a duplicate of another declaration already in evidence.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the existence and enforceability of the joint venture agreement between Mr. Hopkins and Mr. Allen. Despite Mr. Hopkins' argument that the agreement was not formally signed, the court found that the conduct of the parties indicated their intention to be bound by the agreement. Evidence such as the creation of Silent Shade Pty Ltd, the assignment of earlier provisional applications to the company, and Mr. Hopkins' actions in sharing information and involving Mr. Allen in the patent application process, supported the existence of an implied contract. The court held that Mr. Hopkins, as a director of Silent Shade Pty Ltd, had a duty to act in the company's best interests, which included assigning his inventions to the company. The court concluded that Mr. Hopkins breached this duty by not assigning the inventions, and therefore, Silent Shade Pty Ltd was the sole eligible person for the patents on the inventions. The court did not consider the late and duplicate declaration by Peter Cock, finding that it did not significantly impact the outcome of the case.