Pavlakis and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

Pavlakis and National Disability Insurance Agency [2023] AATA 2485 (10 August 2023)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number:          2022/9579

Re:Paul Pavlakis

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member K Buxton

Date:10 August 2023

Place:Brisbane

The decision under review is set aside and the decision is remitted for reconsideration with a direction that the Applicant’s approved statement of participant supports specifies:

a)From the date of this decision, funding for:

a.Short-term Accommodation for four weeks per annum; and

b.42 hours per week for 48 weeks per year of support worker funding (a reduction from 52 weeks); and

b)That the reasonable and necessary supports otherwise specified be replicated until the reassessment date of 13 June 2024.

........[sgn]................................................................

Senior Member K Buxton

Catchwords

Application for Review of Decision — National Disability Insurance Scheme — Plan — Review of Supports in Plan — Statement of Participant Supports — Section 42D Remittal — New Plan ­— Whether 42D remittal creates a new plan — Whether Reviewable decision Ultra Vires — Decision under review set aside and remitted —

Legislation

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth)
National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)

Cases

Klewer v National Disability Insurance Agency [2023] FCA 630
McGarrigle v National Disability Insurance Agency [2017] FCA 308; 252 FCR 121
Williamson and National Disability Insurance Agency [2019] AATA 2944
Dorrington and National Disability Insurance Agency [2022] AATA 1714
Rogers and NDIA [2022] AATA 2809
Commissioner of Taxation v. Cancer and Bowel Research Association Inc (2013) 305 ALR 534, [2013] FCAFC 140
Esposito v Commonwealth [2015] FCAFC 160
Craig v South Australia [1995] HCA 58
DZNB v National Disability Insurance Agency [2022] AATA 1326
Frugtniet v Australian Securities and Investments Commission (2019) 266 CLR 250; [2019] HCA 16

QDKH, by his litigation representative BGJF v National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] FCAFC 189
Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Makasa [2021] HCA 1
RTRH and National Disability Insurance Agency [2022] AATA 205


Re Wendy Halliday as the Administrator of the Estate of the Late Ashley Pauling and Secretary of Social Services [2018] AATA 3865
National Disability Insurance Agency v Davis [2022] FCA 1002
BIJD and National Disability Insurance Agency [2018] AATA 2971

Secondary Materials

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013

NDIS Operational Guidelines- Short Term Accommodation or Respite

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member K Buxton

INTRODUCTION

  1. The Applicant, Mr Paul Pavlakis, is a 44-year-old man who is a participant in the National Disability Insurance Scheme (“NDIS”). He has sought review of decision by a delegate of the Chief Executive Officer (“CEO”) of the National Disability Insurance Agency (“the Respondent”) dated 22 November 2022 (“the internal review decision”) made pursuant to subsection 100(6) of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) (“the Act”).

  2. The Applicant’s medical history is set out in the medical evidence before the Tribunal. His impairments arise…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pavlakis and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 2485
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for review of a decision made by the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) concerning the applicant's National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) plan. The applicant sought review of the NDIA's decision regarding the supports to be included in his plan. The case came before K Buxton SM of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT).

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether a decision made following a remittal under section 42D of the *Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975* (Cth) constituted a "new plan" for the purposes of the NDIS, and whether such a decision could be considered *ultra vires*. The Tribunal was required to determine the legal effect of decisions made by the NDIA after the Tribunal had remitted the matter for reconsideration, particularly in light of recent Federal Court authority.

The Tribunal reasoned that while section 42D of the *Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975* (Cth) permits a decision-maker to affirm, vary, or set aside a decision and make a new one in substitution, this power does not extend to creating an entirely "new plan" in the context of an NDIS plan review. Instead, any variation or substitution must relate to the original decision under review. The Tribunal noted that decisions made following remittal are taken to be applications for review of the varied or substituted decision, and the applicant may choose to proceed with the review of that new decision. The Tribunal concluded that decisions made following remittal under section 42D, even if described as a "new plan" and effective for a later period, do not have the effect of creating a new plan but rather modify the original decision within the scope of the review.

The Tribunal determined that the decisions made following remittal under section 42D did not create a new plan but rather varied the original decision. The Tribunal proceeded to consider the remaining disputed issues regarding the applicant's reasonable and necessary supports, including accommodation, community access, wellness, capacity building, multidisciplinary meetings, support coordination, transport, and consumables, based on the evidence presented.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The remaining questions for the Tribunal, as to whether additional funded supports ought to be specific, will be answered by refence to the available evidence, and can conveniently be dealt with under the following categories:(a)Accommodation supports;(b)Supports for community access including support workers and trauma-informed yoga;(c)Additional wellness supports – including exercise physiology and dietician;(d)Capacity building supports, including psychology, occupational therapy and psychosocial recovery coaching;(e)Supports for multidisciplinary meetings between allied health professionals;(f)Support co-ordination;(g)Transport(h)Consumables;EVIDENCE The following evidence is relevant to the issue of the Applicant’s reasonable and necessary supports to be funded.The Applicant The Applicant stated that he wished to rely on the evidence of the expert witnesses in relation to his reasonable and necessary supports. As to his accommodation-related supports, the Applicant stated:I was looking to the NDIA to provide a framework of support, and Ms Lewis can talk to this, with particular face-to-face engagement with providers to help me overcome some of the barriers of trauma that are inhibiting me from finding stable accommodation.[60][60] Transcript Day 2 (6 June 2023), p.21, lines 33-36. The Applicant drew attention to the NDIS pricing guides published from time to time and noted that the 1 July 2022 guide provided:Assistance with Accommodation and Tenancy Obligations.This support item is to guide, prompt, or undertake activities to ensure the participant obtains or retains appropriate accommodation. This may include assisting to apply for a rental tenancies or to undertake tenancy obligations in line with the participant’s tenancy agreement. The Applicant gave the following evidence to explain his accommodation-related needs:I’m not looking for the agency to pay for accommodation. I am very clear that that’s not what I am asking the NDIS to provide, but the assistance. And my therapist will speak to this tomorrow about the trauma-related disability things that go on in my mind around housing. It’s very complicated. My responses to housing are not ordinary and they specifically pertain to my psychosocial disability. I had a home once, Member, and I was having difficulty staying in that due to the fears of isolation. I don’t know where they were coming from at that time. So there’s nothing logical about what is happening in relation to that. It’s purely psychological and when I was trying to transition from staying with my sister into independent leaving, it was very clear earlier on that I was having a lot of problems with maintaining accommodation and stability of housing. And it does pertain to my disability.[61]…Well, the respondent maintains that I’m looking to the NDIS to resolve my issues of homelessness and I was simply looking for support to transition, through my trauma, with daily support and improved daily functioning and capacity building to enable that to happen for myself. So I just needed someone to go with me to look at places to live, basically.[62][61] Transcript Day 2 (6 June 2023), p.32, lines 24-38.[62] Transcript Day 2 (6 June 2023), p.33, line 46 to p.34 line 4.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On the final day of the hearing, the Respondent indicated that the evidence given during the hearing supported the funding of further reasonable and necessary supports and the decision was again remitted under section 42D of the AAT Act for further consideration of this new evidence. On 14 June 2023 a new decision was made approving a statement of participant supports that provided annual funding of $228,341.89 and incorporated previously unincluded funding for a dietician (8 hours) and exercise physiologist (12 hours), leading to an additional of $4,999.72 of capacity building supports being funded in a new well-being budget, and for the Applicant’s therapy supports to be used flexibly to allow for occupational therapy in the place of some funded psychology. Further funding for meetings between his multi-disciplinary team was also included, as were the changes to plan management of all but the funded supports for Support Co-ordination, Psychosocial Recovery Coaching and financial administrative costs which remained specified in that decision as being Agency-managed. Other supports remained as in the earlier approved plan. Nature of the decision made following section 42D remittal The Tribunal observes that each of the decisions, made following remittal by the Tribunal under section 42D of the AAT Act, have been described as a “new plan” and each is specified as taking effect for a different (later) period to that of the original decision. For the reasons set out below, the Tribunal has concluded that these decisions do not have that effect as there is no power in the Tribunal, and therefore no power in the decision maker on reconsideration, to issue a new plan. However, the decisions do specify particular aspects of the reviewable decision that are within power on reconsideration as they relate to the original section 33(2) decision. It is therefore necessary to determine whether the reconsidered decisions meet the requirements of section 42D and, if so, what the effect is of the latest reconsidered decision, in order to determine the issues that remain in dispute in this review. Section 42D of the AAT Act provides, relevantly:s.42D Power to remit matters to decision-maker for further consideration(1) At any stage of a proceeding for review of a decision other than a proceeding in the Social Services and Child Support Division, the Tribunal may remit the decision to the person who made it for reconsideration of the decision by the person.Powers of person to whom a decision is remitted(2) If a decision is so remitted to a person, the person may reconsider the decision and may:(a) affirm the decision; or(b) vary the decision; or(c) set aside the decision and make a new decision in substitution for the decision set aside.Note: For time limits, see subsection (5).(3) If the person varies the decision:(a) the application is taken to be an application for review of the decision as varied; and(b) the person who made the application may either:(i) proceed with the application for review of the decision as varied; or(ii) withdraw the application.(4) If the person sets the decision aside and makes a new decision in substitution for the decision set aside:(a) the application is taken to be an application for review of the new decision; and(b) the person who made the application may either:(i) proceed with the application for review of the new decision; or (ii) withdraw the application.…(7) If the person has not reconsidered the decision, and done one of the things mentioned in paragraphs (2)(a), (b) and (c), within the period applicable under subsection (5), the person is taken to have affirmed the decision.(8) If the person affirms the decision, the proceeding resumes.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Section 42D of the AAT Act provides, relevantly:s.42D Power to remit matters to decision-maker for further consideration(1) At any stage of a proceeding for review of a decision other than a proceeding in the Social Services and Child Support Division, the Tribunal may remit the decision to the person who made it for reconsideration of the decision by the person.Powers of person to whom a decision is remitted(2) If a decision is so remitted to a person, the person may reconsider the decision and may:(a) affirm the decision; or(b) vary the decision; or(c) set aside the decision and make a new decision in substitution for the decision set aside.Note: For time limits, see subsection (5).(3) If the person varies the decision:(a) the application is taken to be an application for review of the decision as varied; and(b) the person who made the application may either:(i) proceed with the application for review of the decision as varied; or(ii) withdraw the application.(4) If the person sets the decision aside and makes a new decision in substitution for the decision set aside:(a) the application is taken to be an application for review of the new decision; and(b) the person who made the application may either:(i) proceed with the application for review of the new decision; or (ii) withdraw the application.…(7) If the person has not reconsidered the decision, and done one of the things mentioned in paragraphs (2)(a), (b) and (c), within the period applicable under subsection (5), the person is taken to have affirmed the decision.(8) If the person affirms the decision, the proceeding resumes. Section 42D of the AAT Act provides that if a reviewable decision is varied, or set aside and substituted, then the Applicant may choose to proceed with the review application, which is taken to be an application to review the new decision. If a reconsidered decision is not made in the manner described in section 42D(2), the decision is taken to be affirmed and the proceeding resumes as it was prior to the remittal. Used in this way, section 42D is a beneficial power of the Tribunal to provide the opportunity for the Respondent to reconsider the decision based on updated information and can lead to a decision which narrows the scope of the review and, if the decision is acceptable to the Applicant, can resolve the review without the need for a hearing. Here, the Applicant has not withdrawn his Application and the Tribunal has proceeded with the review. Following the 14 June 2023 decision, the review is “taken to be” an application for review of the 14 June 2023 decision, so long as it is validly made having regard to section 42D of the AAT Act. The power in section 42D of the AAT Act, to remit a matter for reconsideration whilst merits review proceedings are on foot, is frequently engaged by the Tribunal in NDIS reviews concerning supports in a participants plan, particularly where the Respondent wishes to make additional funds available to a participant whilst a review about the underlying SPS remains on foot, because, for example, a support is no longer disputed by the Respondent or additional funds are needed urgently. This process is not one that has, to date, been regarded by the Tribunal, or by the parties, as transmogrifying the review application from one thing into another, different thing. However, in the recently decided Klewer v National Disability Insurance Agency[11] (“Klewer”), Justice Raper considered the effect of a series of decisions made following remittals under section 42D of the AAT Act whilst merits review proceedings were on foot before the Tribunal. Her Honour made reference to a number of “new plans” that were approved following remittals under section 42D[12] and noted that Mr Klewer had “not appealed” those orders. The necessity to consider whether a new plan was made on 14 June 2023 has therefore been brought about by the decision of the Federal Court in Klewer, which was made on 15 July 2023 (the day after the 14 June 2023 decision).[11] [2023] FCA 630.[12] Ibid [180] to [190].