WJCG and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

WJCG and National Disability Insurance Agency [2023] AATA 3310 (17 October 2023)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s):2021/8539      

Re:WJCG  

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member O'Donovan

Date:17 October 2023

Place:Canberra

The parties may provide to the Tribunal for approval a statement of participant supports which includes funding for additional supports consistent with the reasons for decision. In the event that a new statement of participant supports has not been provided within 14 days of the date of this decision, the decision under review is affirmed.

……………………[sgd]…………………

Senior Member O’Donovan

CATCHWORDS

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – reasonable and necessary supports – Osteogenesis imperfecta – Hydrotherapy pool – Hydrotherapy – Reasonable and Necessary Support – purchase and installation of domestic hydrotherapy pool not value for money - NDIA is not the appropriate source of funding for provision of rehabilitation

LEGISLATION

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act (2013) s33, 34

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Support for Participants) Rules 2013 Rule 3.5, Schedule 1

CASES

Klewer v National Disability Insurance Agency [2023] FCA 630
McGarrigle v National Disability Insurance Agency (2017) 252 FCR 121
MMBX and National Disability Insurance Agency [2022] AATA 13
National Disability Insurance Agency v WRMF (2020) 276 CFR 415
Pavlakis and National Disability Insurance Agency [2023] AATA 2485

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member O'Donovan

17 October 2023

  1. The applicant is 13 years of age. She suffers from rare conditions called Osteogenesis imperfecta Type IVB and Dentinogenesis imperfecta. Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is a congenital brittle bone disorder which puts her at an increased risk of fracture and in particular compression fractures of her vertebrae. She was admitted as a participant to the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) on 17 July 2015.

  2. In 2022 her family purchased and installed a hydrotherapy pool at the family home to assist in ameliorating the effects of her condition. Two questions have arisen in relation to that purchase. The first is whether it qualifies as a reasonable and necessary support which should be included in the statement of participant supports which specifies the supports which the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) will fund. The answer to that question revolves around the criteria specified in section 34 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (NDIS Act). The second is whether the Tribunal has jurisdiction to include a re-imbursement amount in relation to the pool in any statement of participant supports which it approves as part of its review.

  3. It is convenient to deal with the issues separately and sequentially.

    Evidence

  4. The evidence before me consists of the following:

    (a)The T-Documents with pages numbered 1-182 (T-Docs);

    (b)The amended hearing bundle filed by the respondent on 4 April 2023 (Exhibit 1);

    (c)A discharge letter received by the applicant from the Canberra Hospital (Exhibit 2); and

    (d)The oral evidence of the following witnesses:

    (i)Harley Valerius (Occupational Therapist);

    (ii)Dr Nathan Hartin (Consultant Surgeon);

    (iii)The applicant’s mother; and

    (iv)Professor Frank…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read WJCG and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 3310
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, WJCG, sought reimbursement from the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) for the purchase and installation of a domestic hydrotherapy pool. The applicant suffers from Osteogenesis Imperfecta (OI), a condition causing bone fragility and frequent fractures, including spinal fractures. The NDIA had previously refused to include funding for a hydrotherapy pool in the applicant's NDIS plan. The matter came before the Tribunal for review of the NDIA's decision.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the purchase and installation of a domestic hydrotherapy pool constituted a "reasonable and necessary support" under the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013. This required the Tribunal to consider if the proposed support was value for money and the most appropriate way to fund the applicant's rehabilitation and ongoing management needs.

The Tribunal considered evidence from medical specialists, including an occupational therapist, a consultant surgeon, and a paediatric endocrinologist. It was accepted that hydrotherapy is beneficial for the applicant's rehabilitation and ongoing management, particularly in reducing the risk of re-injury and promoting function. However, the Tribunal found that while hydrotherapy itself is a valuable support, the purchase of a domestic hydrotherapy pool was not the most cost-effective or appropriate solution. The Tribunal noted that hydrotherapy is typically provided in supervised settings during rehabilitation phases and that various forms of exercise, not solely hydrotherapy, can contribute to bone strengthening and muscle support in the maintenance phase. The NDIA's role is not to fund the provision of rehabilitation facilities for general use.

The Tribunal concluded that the NDIA was not the appropriate source of funding for the provision of a domestic hydrotherapy pool. The applicant's claim for reimbursement was therefore dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

It is convenient to deal with the issues separately and sequentially.Evidence The evidence before me consists of the following:(a)The T-Documents with pages numbered 1-182 (T-Docs);(b)The amended hearing bundle filed by the respondent on 4 April 2023 (Exhibit 1);(c)A discharge letter received by the applicant from the Canberra Hospital (Exhibit 2); and(d)The oral evidence of the following witnesses:(i)Harley Valerius (Occupational Therapist);(ii)Dr Nathan Hartin (Consultant Surgeon);(iii)The applicant’s mother; and(iv)Professor Frank Munns (Paediatric Endocrinologist).Reasonable and Necessary SupportBackground As a result of her OI, the applicant is prone to suffering serious fractures. She has suffered multiple serious fractures since July 2017, a number of which have been spinal fractures. The applicant has on multiple occasions been taken to Westmead Hospital in Sydney (including by airlift) for treatment of those fractures. That treatment has involved surgery plus the fitting of a spine brace. Following these fracture events, hydrotherapy has been included as part of the applicant’s rehabilitation programs which follow her recovery from the fracture. Further, hydrotherapy is recommended for the ongoing management of her condition. The applicant sought to have allowance for the purchase of a hydrotherapy pool included in her statement of participant supports (Statement). The respondent has made 3 decisions refusing to include hydrotherapy in the applicant’s Statement. The decision the subject of the original review application was the decision of 20 October 2021. The matter has been in the Tribunal since 12 November 2021. In January 2022, after the application was commenced in the Tribunal but before the matter came on for hearing, the applicant’s parents purchased a hydrotherapy spa which was delivered and installed in the family home in May 2022.[1] .[1] Transcript, page 5. The applicant now seeks re-imbursement for the installation of the hydrotherapy pool. If her application is granted, the applicant intends to use her existing Capacity Building Budget included in her Statement to employ a hydrotherapist to conduct a bi-annual review of her home-based hydrotherapy program.[2][2] Applicant’s Closing Submissions at [11]. For funding to be provided for the hydrotherapy pool it is necessary for the applicant to establish that the support sought is a ‘reasonable and necessary support’. If it is, then (subject to the question of the Tribunal’s jurisdiction discussed further below), the hydrotherapy pool can be included in the Statement approved by the Tribunal. Inclusion of a support in the Statement means it can be funded by the NDIA.Framework for including supports The decision which the Tribunal is called upon to review is best described as a decision by the CEO’s delegate to approve a Statement which did not include all of the supports which the applicant contends should be included. The approval was given in accordance with subsection 33(2) of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (NDIS Act). The Statement which was approved forms part of the applicant’s NDIS Plan, which is a document which the respondent must prepare once a person becomes a participant in the NDIS. Plans need to be reviewed regularly as required by the NDIS Act.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

My reasons for these conclusions are set out below.Consideration The applicant suffers from OI. OI is a rare disease and the applicant’s is a moderately severe case. Her bones are weak and can break spontaneously. Her condition has already caused multiple fractures including vertebral compression fractures. In addition, the applicant suffers from muscle weakness and joint hypermobility. The applicant is seeking reimbursement for the purchase and installation of a hydrotherapy swim spa. The total cost was $44,181.62 including $35,490 for the spa itself and around $8500 in installation, electrical and fencing costs. The applicant’s family installed the hydrotherapy pool so that the applicant could undertake hydrotherapy in a safe and convenient environment. Hydrotherapy involves undertaking exercises in water which are low impact and pose minimal risk of a fracture. All of the medical specialists engaged with the applicant’s care agree that undertaking exercise in a safe environment will reduce the applicant’s risk of re-injury. Hydrotherapy at the applicant’s home provides a safe and convenient form of exercise which, if performed consistently, reduces the applicant’s risk of re-injury and will assist the applicant to undertake a larger range of activities safely and is likely to promote the applicant’s social and economic participation. At the hearing the Tribunal had the benefit of evidence from the applicant’s occupational therapist, treating surgeon and treating endocrinologist. Based on that evidence there appear to be three phases through which the applicant passes when she suffers a fracture. In the first phase her treating professionals are focussed on ensuring that the fracture heals safely. With a spinal fracture this requires significant medical intervention and often surgical intervention. It also usually requires the applicant to use a spinal brace which immobilises the applicant for around 12 weeks. In this phase, rehabilitation and exercise of any sort are not appropriate.[6][6] Transcript, page 41. Once the acute phase has passed the applicant must undergo rehabilitation to overcome the deconditioning which the immobilisation in the acute phase produces. There is no doubt that in this phase hydrotherapy is a valuable tool in restoring function to the applicant in a safe environment.[7] Hydrotherapy in this phase is supervised but the hope is that the supervised phase ‘doesn’t last very long’.[7] Transcript, page 42. The third phase, which can be described as a maintenance phase, is when the applicant’s function has been restored. At this point, the applicant’s fracture resistance is likely to benefit from 3 things in combination – medication, growth and exercise. In this phase there appear to be a range of options which will improve the applicant’s function and reduce her risk of injury, including hydrotherapy. Professor Munns, the applicant’s endocrinologist, gave evidence that when the applicant is not in the acute phase, working of the applicant’s core muscles will be particularly beneficial for strengthening her bones and providing muscle support. It is however clear many forms of exercise will be beneficial, and that hydrotherapy should not be seen as the only activity which has these benefits.